M/S Floral Electricals Pvt. Ltd. v. Haryana Vidyut Prasaran Nigam Ltd. And Another
!
"#$%& & #$#'$( "#$%
&
)% *+) ,,
, -
*+) ,.-,,
! "#$ %&%#'%(%)* +,%-( %-) '%* +,% %&% (%-)%* +,% .(%-% (%/* +,% (' %!* +,% 0( /%)* +,% '(%) '%%,(% %* +,% ,(%%'%* +,% % (%""%* +,%% %%+!)%* +,% 0 1 ,
, -
/ 1
(!((%- *( (3 )0 1# 211 (3 4(21 4!23 +4543 "* %#0(4%(!0( ) % 56785756 9 : ;57<* -("#* ( ;
= %# ")%,/) "% 0= ! %# " -( 1; 0#%* + %))#-(%#(
# %( ()+%,0 :;57",= :%, (%0
% ? )%) ),,%)+ 9% %< 9?%< 1>1*.%)"% *(% 55@*A'% * = (;516;7B ;;
5>1);
C
9< %$;56785756 ,'67 (3% 54$234#$#8(#$3 2(38# #$ 3 '(34#$#89!,,0,3$/2$ 4 21#$:;43<3 54$234#$2 2$:
$3#8-.4 ('43 2:24$ 3 #
0 =0> $0 ?
@"23 " 2$""
62 4$:8# #$ A 2 ;7BD ;;5>1 D C 9< % 71755751 0 ,,01@5/%%)!-(=%%%!=01@5' ,,-%%-% % *(% ?)%) ),,%)* /#"%-(,= ) 018=( 717E5755
(,%,-%! 757@5751 (=)0( &,%% $;
%00 71755751 %0!!0,%, 757@5751
= ) 18=(
%,+%)0-/ 1F57
%,%)% % 757@5751
%,%),= ) % 717E5755
%,%),= ) %%0=: @77>5755 5
( ,%,%) % 0 ,= ) -% @77>5755 9%0 = = :<-+*)) %*=%&),,%)% ,+)%,+%)) ! ,) !,==!05 1E57 1@511/ 9 ) "# < % 1 5758 1@5@@/ 9 ) "# < ,(*,)%(% (-/)%!!!0%"( (,( )% #0=-) "%") ,= )(-/0" "%*%,(%) %, @
(% %,(0#0=-%)(%!,,"!!*-!( +%0#0=0=-%,)# % "#0) %-)) %(% 00,00,0,= )0-/%(%)-+*+%0 )% 0,%,%) *( !0-/%-%%0%,#% ((% "%)%,/0 ,%00=:,!( &, 6
+-0%"+% %)% ,)%6610
*%,-%+ #0=7F11575@=%/! ( 0,,#( !0-/ -(18 %#0=( %0, 0(, 8
% 0 !+! ( , % 7F11575@ (-! !:,,= )0-/*#0=+ == % 1F11575@ 4 %))-=0-/ (,%"0 =!
-%,( ) "# 5511575@!%! ##0=,)%0# -%4 "##0= !(=!5511575@%))-
#17= %#%#0%,%) % %%!(0 0 ,= )0-/ , (4% !% #0=17 %# + ) % 5611575@%#0%,%) % %/! 0 :,0-/ E
% 0"=!(%, )%0,= )0-/*#0=+ ) % 7115575@%!%4 + =(%! ((%!
-%%!%!% "# !%=% %=!-%() 7615575@ )"%( %, )%0,= )0"%)%,-/-+*,( )%-%"= "##0= !(=!*+%0!%!=%# F (%0*%,018 %# ,)%6650
+ #0= 7>15575@*(-,%%-(#%,=%0,%,*00 0 "%/ !%%* ,%#! "%)%, -/ % / D , 0 # 0=* ")%,/)! "%!0#0=0#%,=%#"%/%!%# 0="# % =D, 0(,%, >
( =% !% ! % %) ,)%= 0 , +%% 0 - D 4 =,%,,0
(% "% "##0=+% ,,%%=!( ( ,0 = - 00,(!% * (% %)% #"=% #0=1578575@-("#-%() (%( =% 0(!( ,+%%00=&0 -(,%0% %) ,)%=0 ,+%%0-D4 =, !"0) "% B (% ),%0#0= ) "%*+ % 1115 575@(% !% %#=%, % 7>15575@ "# ) "%+%,% (%#+ % 7F7@5756 17
%)*#0=+ ) % 11755756 (%-/0 ,,01@5'"%%-% )%# =%#%=%)#
+ % =,* , 0)%*,)0=!"#
D% +0 %* )%#=%%)+0,%*0),%)%%* )%#0)) %#=0 ,+%%* %,#0-/!0 ,% 4 0(%+=%))# % %%") )= (* # 0= + ) % 7>7@5756 % 0))- "# %( ) % 1B765756 (% 4 + )% #0 %)(%!(%#0=,%0%))# ( )% ( %0 % 0=%))=%)!-((4 -%0 0%")0%,, %,D(,&, +-00=G0%) ((,%,%)")!% 0=) ) 11 )%) ),,%)9?%<+ ) % 117@5756*157@5756 % 58765756(% ,%% 4 %/%#% =%+ %,%!%(=% %))-(= %)(%!(=%*(-+*%= -%% %%)) %%&)#% +%))# ")0:, 0,%, 15
=%#/ )#" (%=,0,%, %",0 ,= )0-/%-% #* -+%,% ")% (0 (: , %,% %=)0 !%= )%#,= )0 &,)% ,(,%)D,==,%)) % + !%) "),(%+4%)#+,0 !%= 1@ ( !% * %--% ,)%667 0
0(
%,;
*, +
#34( #8 82'13
0(,%,:,!(-/%,, %,-((,%, !),! 0= ( ")!% ( % )# %00, ( !%==0,%#!0(-/*( = )#=%#!+,( ,%,4!(==%/! ,(0%)!),
23'
#8#$3 2(3# * 82'13
0(,%,;
%< (%0%) ,= )#-(%%%"))=-(%,";,)%661* "< %!(,%,",%,(-()0(-/-((
= )#G-,* ,< ",="%/ )+*(%%,+! =% %!%(= ,= -((, *,%" %,+* =%%!0("00(, !)4 %
( = )#=%#*%0!+!18 %#,(,%,*=%( ,%,% : )(,%,0=( #,(: )% =%(%))"-( & ,%#(!( -0( = )#*(,%, (,%,
( = )#=%# ,(=%,= )(-/(=)0"#%# (,%, %%))#%) ! (4=%(/% ,0(,%, ( = )#,((,%,=%#0,( ,= )%#,%,G4 =-(,( (%((#=%# (/ *% ( = )#(%))%))-(,%,%0% ,0,(
(= )#=%#%/% =%+%,,(% "%!*")%,/)!%)! -(00!0"%/!%%, 16 + 0=%"+*#0=(%0%) :,(,%,-/ -( ,0 =)% 0(=) ): ,(%,# )% * )0%% + 0=("004%)# - )# %,,0#0%):,( &,-( ,0 =* (% 00 "%,/*% (%%)00 %=%!% ) (#0=(% ,== "%,(0,%,% %,, !)#$;
%, ;7B ;;5>1C 9< % 71755751%-% % * (% ? )%) ),,%)* ("# =% .%)%,-/ ;7B ;;5>1C 9< % 71755751(%)) "!:, %=%))#%(/D,0 % (% ?)%) ),,%)* 0=%, .%/ %% "= %!% ;7B ;;
5>1C 9< % 71755751 %,, 0 ; 0=%, ("# 00 ,%( + +%,.%/ %%"= %!%;7B ;;5>1C 9< % 71755751*0%#*("#00 ,% 0,+#0% +%,% ,+#0(00=( 0(0= + %,,0 )%#,= )0-/*#0=)%") %#0 ,(%!04 % %=%!9<% ,)%1670
0(,%, + % *(% ?)%) ),,%)*("# "% 0( 01#%-(== %00,0 !0(" -(
5
( 0( / , 0 =+! )!(")%,/)! "%!%(,
2(3'212(9" #B#83< (2 @ 1; 0( 0,,!
1@5'"%%%*+ ;
17B@(%+!()% %0"=%7@7@5757 6
( )+% ,)% 0 ( ;
% :%, (%0
!"
#
"
$
%
"
&
'( (
&
"
)
"
*
*
&
*
+
+
, -.
+
*
/
( 0
0(
0
$
1 1
" 1 "
1 1
2.345
8 5 %0 ! % & + != % 757@5757 -( ( (* )# %, % (%0% " ! ,% ("#"= ( " %)!-( ,,( )* %%4=* %#==% -/,( )-( 1 E ( %!=* ( % - &)# % +%))#)%") 0=(,%,% %))(")!%,% ( ()+%,)%*%,,(%!=9 %<% :%, (%0 7
8 9
.
" 3
9
.
/:, ;
6
8
7
+
5 3
( 9
.
"
(
7
7
" 8
"
(
1
1 8 "
6
8
3
3
( !!!!
7
"
9
.
1
8
8
! < 7
3
"
9
.
7
8
6
F
(.% 0,0( = %#+ ) % 177E57579 :;@<*)+ (%(,= %# (%)) %, %%%& %-( % *(-+* %))(0%,%)% ,%,%)")!%= ),%(%))",= ,=" % > 1; -/ 9 : ;8<0%+0 % 9)% %<% )%)
),,%)+ 9?%<,= )( &,-(1>
" =(0=(!!0(,%, (%0*-/,%, %!= 9 : ;E< -% :, "- ( ; ,= %#% 5 B
)%670(A/ %, !=9 :;
E<",=:%, (%0 = ,
>
' ? ;
7 7
6 7 "!??@
3 1 7 +
A 17 0(%-% !0(-/,%,*(
5%0"=!(0=%,.%/ %%*"!%( :,0(%)) -/,%,*")%,% % "- 1; % 5* !% !(%0%,#:,0(-/,%,*(-( (=,( )= (,%, 11 13 + ) % 7@7>575@ 9 :;B<% (&+"(( %* ( (%=0 "%*-(=%#"% * % & ,% ( %%"-(?= % ( (%0*%,==,%-%,+ 0=
% 0% ! (&%*,% ? !*9 <%% "%
15 (,)%= 9 :;11<-%0) "#
% "0() "%%=0 0,-% 0) "# *-("#*% ,0,"&,-%%/(%%) ,)%=% =%%! ( ,)%=* -(%* ( ,%, ",= %-% %&+ 1@ %= =% ),%-%=+ "#(,)%=%0 ,(%!! ( ,)%=%G %= ( %%# 0 % 0= %
% ? )%) ),,%)+ 9? <(!()% %(*%= =-%!(4% (=G) ( G",=! ) % (=G? G"- % % )%) ),,%)+ G* "! )%, 4%G) ( G 16
()% "%&, (% % ),%+ % 7F7@57569 :;1>< ( %+ %0(% :%, (%0 =
?
73
"
1
+
9
.
&
> 9.
*
/:08 3
5
73
6
73
"
%
0 "6
!!
!
%
'
!
%
?
7
18 !%(%0% * .@705756(%" "0( ")-*-(,( !% & ,% #$3 $34#$ #83< 1 2 $ "(#'$ 18# 3< B2 34 1E
( ((%,(%))! ( -("# (,%,%-% (&+(%"=% *" -("#( 0=%,!%%",%=00 +*( (% %) ,(%))! ( * -("#* ( ,= %#(%" "% 0= !%#"-(
1; *(0#% 1F ( =%#,0( (*(%* ( -%%)% %%&+% %))( %%,-"! "# % *(0* ,%"() )%")0%#==% "# % 1> (((% *()% ,)0 1 "= (% ( , 9 %< =,,+ % =; , *%(=% , 0(" ,=*(-(% -%"= %%? !=*% *%)(-/ *(-(%,(,%,%-% %&+* ( * %)) % % &)# % +%))# )%") 0 ( 0=%,0(,%,%)")!%
$8
$( #83<4 #' 3 1B (*((%0:%, & ,%) , ,+!("&,=%%4 "%)) # $%% & ' ()*
+ ,+ - ./..&.-!01%$.
&7 &
> * 3
5 C
D1 /
7
C)
64,7E'?
1 2 7
!
+
" 1
&
1
" % & 7
"
1
"
1
'
" 7
1 ++++ ++++ % 3 "
1
"
"
"
%E F "
"
1
1
" "
1 & $
+
+
& "
"
"
"
" 1
# $%% & '% #(# )*"
" -.2 345$#&# $./ 6 1, % %7.
!
&
I
"
7
%
!@"
J
6"
J #
1
7
8 8
C7 5 ,
I
C
(!?BE!,77B " 7 =
1
;
&
1
K A
% / , 9(
" 7 = !
KI
1
"
"
6
& " "
I
1
+
I
"
"
"
A(8
++++
++++
@ "
+
" 1 :
>
*
& 1
"
8 "
"
++++ %
"
1 :
&
&
7
1
I
( : )% 0 )%-* % ) ( % + ,%)%%(%$ 1< A( "%,( % ,,) ,%, ",= "%0 )# : )% " -(%"%0 % "#( # ,, * %!% ( )# =! 0= ,%,%) ")!%* ( * ( % )# =% %)# 0 ")%,/)! "%=*(!(" 5<
( %)#0 "%!")%,/)!%",== % %#"(% %,,4,*%("#*
% +)#%00,("0( (#,, " =%%))# & ,( = )#=0 ( -( = )#= (= @<
( ),, ,(=0( ( #,, *" %) %")#%"(*%&0#( +,%0( %,= #0")%,/)! "%= 6
(% % ) ( % ( =%% %,(* ( = ( %, %)#0 "%=")%,/)!%(" %+ * % ( %= =%# " %* ( (- )+%") (!((+,%0%%"%= #* -( * %) ( % = =%# ",= )=%)# , 51
- ( 0( )+% ! 0 ( % & !=* ( ,,, ( 0 ( : )% 0 )%-* %=,(%*(%4=0,% (,",=! =% ( , ) 0 %%) &,* (* %)) (!( ( % )# %/ , ! 55
-0!-((%))( %: )%0)%- ",=,= ))#%0 " %) =(%(, , 0( *-%%"(*-("#*(= 0 %)#0")%,/)! *"-%%,%#4)(0* )+%"%= (0))-!$ %<
(:!%%"%,)%(,%, :, "-( % (
"<
( ,%,%))# %! ) =,(%=* %=,( %* 0 %"% ",=! "# ( ,%,! % 5@
-% )#!(%"+: )%0)%-( % + 0%,*"%%))#"!0(%0,*(%("# )#%"%0 : )%%* " ",%= %= ",=%00 "#( +;%;+(%"0 =, ,4%*-(0%!!+%,#()+% : )%%*( %(%+ (0(%"%=,(%= )%)# ("#* ) ( ,,) 0 ( %"% , !* ( = 0 ( (%( %)# 0 ")%,/)! "%=* * ( * " -% " %+ +* -( ( ,)=% 0 ( %"% , !*-%%=%")0( *%) ( % ))0= =%%(,,) *(%:, !
(= 0((%( %)#0")%,/)! ( *( -%(= %"))+# ( ("# ( ,) ,,) * (% ( , , 0 ( -% %"(* % %!(-%#* ( % )# -(%-%!0(,,)0(%"% , !* 0( ,,=%)# 0 4% )# ( %)# 0 ")%,/)! "%!
,%* ( # +%) % ( = 0 ( %)#0")%,/)! "%! ( * (
) =,(%= 0 %"%* ( ",=! ,%))# %/ "# "( ( %* ("#* ( % %/ ) =,(%= %( -) ",= "(=%!)%-))% % 58
(% (%"%+ *%(,,)0(% %"% , !*=%#=%%-((()+%= %%" ( -%"%0 -(((-% %#%) )"%0%)( %0%#,, 0* ( %)# 0 ")%,/)! "%!* % = ( *% =%)#= %)#*" %(%!* "((%(% %*(#: ),%")=, ,*% %" ( 5E
+(-*(+ ,, !!+ (% ( +,% 0 ( )+% ,)% "# ( ,! * -( ( %)# 0 ")%,/)! "%= % *(*(,! ( /,( , !* -("#* ,= ) ,= )%, -% =% ( , )0%%)&, (%",0(% =%%)"! (=%0,*(%(+,%0()+%,)%*%( %, 0 ( * (% " = ,% ,)# % %"%)#*% *("#*(= ! 4 "4%( % %
4$21 "
#83<4 #' 3 5F
%0=%(*( 0 =(- % -(("+%%"+*(%=%))- 5>
(= ! )9 :;57<% % "#( (#,, 4%( % % " ( ,, , =+ ) ( 0 &+0& (, 4%( ,= %#*%=% ("% 0(= ! )9 :;57< 5B ,(=%,%)0(%" , *(*%))( !% ),%9<*0%#*% 0%,( ?,
, -
@ ?.-,,
@
& /%+!( < 3< B 294$:0 2 #$ "
% 0# < 3< B# 3261
% 0#