High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1233/2017disposed of

Kulwinder Singh v. State Of Punjab

2017-05-01Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan4 pages

!!"#$#%&' ()*+#%,!-.#%/0 ! # #%!- 2!-$)$ . ! )%34% 0!- !$5%,!% $

*3# .#%/0% 0!- ! # #%!-$ 2!-$)$ . ! )%34%,% 0!- !$5%,!% $

-!$!% &1

-67#-%.#%/0%, -6- %.#%/0 ,6" !$- 0!5! # #%!-$

-2-)%.0-899 )%34

- )$05#%,!-()$0*9,6" !- 0!"85*#%% :::

()*+#%,!-.#%/02$. ! )%34

*3# .#%/0% 0!-2$. ! )%34 % 0!- -!4!#%/ 7!%)5 /! 0!--,#$5$*$4 0 0!$!-!6#$#% 5! # #%$-#$!-8 0!3),/!8!% , !,;95$$!,4< 0!*!-%!, ,,# #%*.!$$#%$),/!9../-9 0*#%,#% !-8$+0#"0 0!

"%6#" #% 0!5! # #%!-$#% 0!$! +-!6#$#%5! # #%$)%,!-$!" #%$ => %,1 -!"-,!,4< 0!-#*)- 90$4!!%#-8!, -#!" $ 0 8<4!% #"!,-! 0 0!5-"!$$*++$ $! #%8 #%% 0!$ !8!% 8%5-!! .#%/09+0+$$ ),!%

%34 %#6!-$# <90%,#/-0%,+0**!/!, 0 0!0,4!!%,)5!, $)8 $*"$4< 0!"")$!,5- <#! *+#%,!-.#%/09*3# .#%/09

/04#-.#%/0%,,6!%,!-.#%/0% 0!5-! !? /#6#%/0%,$8! -! )-%$ 5%"85*! #%#%6!$ #/ #%%, !-$)48#$$#%"0**%9

11 "0-/!$+!-!-8!,/#%$ 0!-!1% #"!,"")$!,-!%"!)%,!- $!" #%$ =>9 = %, $!" #% 1 -#* )- -!"-,!, 3),/!8!% "%6#" #%, !,'0*,#%/!"0%! 0!"")$!, /)#* <-!%"!5)%#$04*! )%,!-$!" #%$ => %, 1 %, $!% !%"!, )%,!-/ - <!-$ #% !"0 !%"! %, 5< "85!%$ #% 0! )%! $*"$#% * !"0 $'*"$ 0!

"85*#%% 0!"")$!,+!-!90+!6!-9"@)# !, 0!"0-/!-8!, )%,!-$!" #%= 0!$!% !%"!$+!-!,#-!" !, -)%"%")--!% *<

)-55!*$-$!) 0!3),/!8!% "%6#" #%%,** )-06!4!!%,!"#,!,6#,!"88%3),/!8!% , !,;95$$!,4< 0!*!-%!,,,# #%*.!$$#%$),/!9../-9 0*##-8#%/ 0!

3),/!8!% "%6#" #%%,-,!-$!% !%"! /#%$ 0! 3),/!8!% , !, ;9 5$$!, 4< 0! 55!** !)- 0!5-!$!% +-!6#$#%5! # #%$06!-#$!%#!

06#%/4!!%#*!,4<()*+#%,!-.#%/0%,

5-!!--!,4<*3# .#%/0%, /04#-.#%/0 )-#%/ 0! 5!%,!%"< 0!$! + -!6#$#% 5! # #%$9 % 55*#" #%0$4!!%86!,-"85)%,#%/ 0!!%"!)%,!-$!" #%$ =>91 % 0!/-)%, 0 "85-8#$!, !,=0$4!!% !!" !, 4< 0! 5! # #%!-$ #% 0!$! + -!6#$#% 5! # #%$ +# 0 0! "85*#%% #!8%5-!! .#%/00!"85-8#$!,!!,, !,= +$*$5*"!,%-!"-, %%!?)-!1 0!"85*#%% 8%5-!! .#%/0+$*$5!-8# !, 4! #85*!,!,$5- <A-!$5%,!% %#%4 0 0!$!-!6#$#%5! # #%$%,0! +$,)*<$!-6!,

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

+$$!#D!,"$!9+0!-!

0!"")$!,+$"%6#" !,)%,!-$!" #%$%,= %6#" #% 0,4!!%)50!*,4< 0!#/0)- 0!5- #!$+!-!-!* !, !"0 0!- %,!% !-!,#% "85-8#$!4!-! 0!%C4*!5!?)- 0!%C4*! .)5-!8!)- 0,**+!, 0!"85)%,#%/ 0!!%"!%,0,$! $#,! 0!"%6#" #% 55*<#%/ 0!,#" )8*#,,+%4< 0!%C4*!5!?)- #%

!"$! $)59 0#$)- #$ 0!"%$#,!-!,6#!+ 0 0! !%"! 0!5-!$!% "$!4!#%/"85)%,4*!%,"85-8#$!

1=1 ,8# !,*<06#%/4!!%!!" !,4! +!!% 0!5- #!$9 0!5-<!-8,!% 4!0* 0!5! # #%!-$0!-!#%8!-# $""!5 %"! 0!**!/ #%$-!* !4"7 0!<!-;0!"85*#%% 0$6*)% !!-!, "85)%,!%"!+# 0 0! 0-!!5! # #%!-$0!-!#%#% 0!$! +"%%!" !,5! # #%$#% 0!*#/0 $5!"##" !-8$%,"%,# #%$ "% #%!,#% 0!"85-8#$!,!!,, !,= %%!?)-!1 0!

!%"!)%,!-$!" #%$=>%,1 -!"85)%,4*!#% !-8$ $)4$!" #%$!" #%- %6#!+ 0!46!9 0!!%"!)%,!-$!" #%$=>%,1 @) 0! 5-!$!% 5! # #%!-$ #% 4 0 0!$! -!6#$#% 5! # #%$ -! "85)%,!,%, 0!"%6#" #%%,$!% !%"! 0!5! # #%!-$#$$! $#,!

!6#$#%5! # #%$-!,#$5$!,""-,#%/*< 0!5! # #%!-$-!,#-!" !, 4!-!*!$!,- 0+# 0

*)"7< E0! 0!-$5!7#%/A-!$%!,& !$ E0! 0!- !5- 4*!&