High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1253/2017disposed of

Krishna Kumar And Others v. Navneet Alias Seema And Others

2018-02-21Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi17 pages

!"# $% & '( '#) * ( + ,# - .) * ( /* 0.) + ,# .

*/'#) * ( /*

+ -1( $2* %-*

(/ *

(/* (# 3 %-*

(/ *

(/* 44444444

5( " / * 3) "6*/* "$ ))*/ ( * 6

)) * " (( 6 ( )**

* &

/*6 6#

)/ * #* ( + 7) ) ) ,- ( 8 ,- 8 9* #*

* (" 3 (/ % 3"

1 ) %3((( "/ * "$/ '( '#)

( 3%/ ( ) ) ( 3 * / .

*/ '#) (#"

)/ /* .) * (5(/ 3#*" * (*% ( " *

)/ :/* 3 ( );*

) 6

<3 (/ (%# 3((3*1

) (* 3 " =

.( 3 #* # ( )

) ()% # ((#"

* *(/ "6

*3 ( (*3$6> # $% / #*.

,- 63 ( )*#*. %&%=% % * ,- 3 ( (/ ) *6( * 6*( *(#(*

3 / * 5( # *)* (

* ( ( * (#(*% ( 6#*

( * (# "6*?#$

( 3 *6 *)

:/) ( ) (*

(*5( **3

*%3((3 ( 6* // "$ " ( -**. 2#*6%'

% 3( 3* // * )* * (* # % (?

36* )/ :/* 3 ( ( * (#(* @#

<&% A % A *( % '

* ( * ) # <

:/) (%3( 36 ) "/ */ * )*

6 % *

)

6 (*/ *"$ # %6 6) )

(*9 ( *)/#6** 6*3 #* / )

6 ( (# B# -66* ( **% *

( "/ * "$

( 3% ) ( 3 * (#"

* ( )/ 3( % * ( "/ *"$ 9 % (/ 16 ( 6 (C#*6)

/ * // % 366( * ((#"66$

( 3 * ( 6*%3( % (/ )/ ( 6

( * C#*6) % ( 6#*

( ) ** *B#

%(( (/" $ "66#/ )(* *

) ((#"

* #* %

: *

(( 6 1( 66 6*"# ("

1 -1( $2* % *# // 6"( / * ()/#6*C#*6)

* &

/ *"$ (-**.2#*6%'

// %

366( * #

"% ((#B# "6$

( 3 / '( '#) % 3((

" 6* 9 6#*

-//

# ( 6* (* #) **3"$ (.#/)#

!" !#$% &' (!

) **+, (- %)% #( '%'./ 3( ( "(*

(#"66 ) ( 3 "$ $ ( ) 6

"**

8( *(#(*8%/ (#"

* *6

( *(# *

%*6.

C % 959(31%

D )# 9 #")

)/)( * " *

" 3 ( / / (#"

* * )/ * /

))*

1 @ 11

3(%" ( (/ ** 6 ( /*

*( ) (9 *#6 (/*

@ 11

# 6

3 # * (/ * #

() $% 3#*")/" * (# "66 (

(% 3* "$ ( -//

# % (* 36) ) (*

"% 6 ()6 3($% ( *) (#*"/ * ) (*

% * ) (*

(*9 **

(-//

# ( / *C# % 6/

( 3

)

6 ((#3 (# ( % 3(( #

" + % (# 3 % *# // 6 "( 6#

( ) 3($ *B#

%/ (#"

*316 -

6 @ ! E 1% D )# * 6 #)

:/) ( * ( (/" $

"66#/ )* #6( %3( # # * (F * # #")

#3@6(#

!"! "# $ $%( * 3* (

6( * (( *(#(*%"66 (

( 3% ( 3 ( (#

( *

( ) 6 * #* * ( (*/# " 3 (/ 9

6#*

(*/ *"$/ (#"

*/*6% 3(( / (#"

* ( " * * / $ #)

: ) #*.

@*# 6- % ) (*

%3((( #*

)# %3(( 6

6#* ,- * * )# 3#*#" $*#6 (/*$ (/ #* . @*# 6- 9 "#6( ( #

/ (#"

* *6D )# % ( *

(**"* @# <&%A %A *( %'

3 * * (

) 9 # ( 6#*

((# / (3 > ! ( / >?+

)

) 6 * (

% 3)%

()3 # * (/ (3 -E>! ( / >?+%3 ( ()$ "# * "$ ( / % "$ 6 ( "#

:%3((3 6 3 *# ;

( # % *

( %(( 6( * ( *(#9 6#*

)/ ( # #$" "

( )

< *) * * ) % /**#* , - < 9( ( * *# (/ *3 ( (

%( /#* (/ *6

-*)

*$% ) *3 (/ .

*/'#) *# 3((3*1% )(* )$+ $ 3 "5()/ 3 " /*) (#6( 3 *#)

$*(F/*6#*

, - % 3(( # * ( / "6 3* "$ ( 2#* 6

"$ **

* . )/ 3 " / $ (66 *6) ($ $ ((#"

*/ % )#

:/) (3

3*%

16 () " B# * "#% / " 6 %

: %

:/) (-

) 6( * (( *(#(*3 *% ( )3 * 3*%

(3 (6 (*6 *6 (3(/ ((#5( -//

# 3* // "$ ()/#6*C#*6) "$$6 #/ % 3( ( 6 ) # <

:/) ( ) (*

E* (% (3 3* (( * (#(* * (/ (3* *

((# B# % (3 ( / & 5(/) $B#

3#*"G 7( ( ( )/ * 6(

* ((#

* "6 ((#"

7( ( * ( )

() )# = 5(+ 7) ) ) ,- ) "

* ($

3( *3

*B#

/ 3 "66 3)%*/ / / /** #*. =&- 9* + * 5(6

#3 /

( "# *)

(/%3(()6( "

# *3$ (3 *3)3 "

**/

(/ 5( )8 "#83 6 *

%3(( #*"?# "#%"

*) "# *) "#% "* (/($ "#. ,- * ) I'$ %"$#('%$#0"J #*G & &

! !

. ,- % * ) 1"#)%'23 %0 2#!'$2-4 #*G #'%

! !

! . ,- /* 6( *

( *(#(*%3(( * #*G ()!* #

$ %

!# (%. = ,-

#*G ($!'+ # &

(#)! #$ *

! !

- !

! !

" . 5( -//

# % )/#6* C#*6) *

% 3( $6 #/ C#*6) # 3 @6( #

(5$ '$ !" !#$% &' $2& !2'(- )* * (*/ *"$

(2#* 6

9 *( "* #*/ G

0 0 1

! !

' 9 (5$ '$ !" !#$% &' $2& !2'(- %#3@6( # "* #*G

"# $ $

% $

$%$ $

% $ $!'( $

(

)

% % !

(

)

!) (

%$%

$ % % % ,%!'

, % !'

$%&

$ % $%

!- $

% $ (

)

! ' + +

!/ 5( 32#*6E( .#/)#

!#$% &' (!

'(- ( * 3 ( (* I'$ %"

$#('%$#0"J*

%"* ( (/ ,- -) B# 3( ( (#%3((?#$"6* ) ( 3 3(($*3 (((#"

* )

) (/

() 6%)3 ( )" I( * (#(*J#*. ,- 5(.#/)# 3(

36 // ( (*

" '

'! 2 0

2 + 3

* 0 #456

! '

' '

'7 F * # ( /* .) 5 # E

* ( * (#(* #* (#(* 3( ( /

66*

6( ** *)

(/@ **

*$ (/* ( ** (// $ B# (/ %( ( *// $(( *(#(*5( .#/)# ( # ("* #*G $8 &

$5 2! !

! 7

$6 2

$: ;

! % 3 #4(#)(!)!

' $4 #6(#)!

3 +

! !

! $ ! 3 0

7 => !

$( )!

=# !

! 0 1

! 1 ?

!% 3

* *3 ! ,& ' #/ ( #"B# $" 3*

C#*6) #@6( # "$ (' @6(# '$2 &' $2)

*6,

2)2!

0.7,%"$ ( * @6( # 8!( "$ &'

(9 !$ !"#$% '% ) < %"$ (@6(#

2'$$ !" !"#!&' - ! !"#! !"#$% '

*66, 2 < 9 ( *% (

(/ / (#"

* )/ ** #% 3(( # * #)"

" 3 (/ #6 (/*$ % 3 )/) *

" 3 (/ %" ( 3 * / (#"

* 1 /

))*

@ 11

% '

9 3 *#6 (

( /

))*

% 6 )/ 6 *

/ (#"

* *(3 % ( %( *#*.

: +9 (

% "

*" 3"

( (#"

* * 3 .#"B# ( % / (#"

**/*6 * (

% )/ 6 !9

*= %6 *#*

. % <% < 9* + * *. : : = -) -

5( 6#) *

/ *6

3#*"*

*#/()

** * ( * * (

6#) 3(( #

"#/ ((#"

* **'

1 " /

(*6 (% (/ / ( 6

(/)

**# %#&% $%'

:'02- %02%"(-#!'$#;'-%22#!% !#,#5% ;# <2!9 )(!

9 ( *% ( ((#"

(3 *6 ((#B# %3(("6* /

( 3?#$9

='3 '%'(- % ( " $(*"$ (.#/)#

((#"6*

( ) ( 3% " )* I'$ %"$#('%$#0"4)$" # )/ *((#"

** 6 ( (/ (#"

* * 3 (9 ( " # ("*"$ (.#/)#

3 $ * ) 6( * ( *(#(* *

( *(#(*3#*) ((#"66

1 "$

((#"

*% ((#3(("6 (C

)$ 3(( (#"

* ))"5( %* (# % * 6#( " * // " /#

*#)

(/ $ #

? *)

(/" 3 (3 * (

((#"

*% 3#* ) 1# 3 )*

(#%3((?#$"6* (

((#"

*-( *

(#(*)# " * ) (#"66

1 "$

((#"

*% ((#3(("6 (C

)$% 3(( (#"

* ))" & 93 66*# *

3(*"$ .#/)#

='3 '%'(- B# )*"$

(# 3* 5((#B# % "6?#"66 /

( 3% "

* I'$ %"$#('%$#0"J3 ( )" . , - B# $% ()/#6*C#*6) *

* &

/ *"$ -//

# " " * (?

)/ 6( )6( * ((#B# %3(( "6* (

( 3 * # (

( 3

" * )

6 ((#B# %"6

( *(#(*9 *% (* * )

))*

/ $) # ( = 5(*B# 3(( *

3( (

( )/ * ( ) ( )

)# H9 *" # % )* () )# <

:/) (@3%

" $ *#)

$ *% # "$ * *

* (* * ) 0

: /) (%3(( )# 3 ( * <

:/) ( // "$ (-//

# "$ **

* &

9 (* /*6

*"$/ (#"

*% //

* #*. (@*# 6% ((#"

*( "* *

< / $ #) =

:/) ( ) %#*6 )# )/ 6

6#* ,- @3 (#

( **/ *#*. @*# 6- %( ) #" %$*#6 (/*$ */*69 (

) % 16 () )# * )6 %

: /) ( ( %"* #) %

:/) ( () 6(*5()/ )*

/ $ ((#"

* %

:/) ( *(* #6( + $ 3 #*$6 9, 9

.(%E#

% '

%3((

(#* "

1 *

%3(( 6 () )# 9 % C6

/ (#"

* -

6( "/*#**%3((

$ / .

*/'#) % =%=& :/ #)% /

) @-

: / #)% $ =<

: / #)% *

:/ #)%F#(-3 %= :/ #)% + + $&%

:/ #)% (-3 =&% :/

#)9 ("

$ 3 / / $ * ( 3

*% ) % <% :/ #)5( *C6

* ( % %3(( ) ($ *3((3#*( * (/* ) # ) * ( .% (

$ /

1 " %

:/ #)% ( () ($ $) %

:/ ) ('/63

6 6 3

(B#) () ) (*%3()

% (# (**3

C# 3#*") % %

:/) ( ** ) #

3 * ))*

3(((( "(* * # *

( 38(# ( ) 3 (#/"66 () ) (* 93 66*#% (*B#

# 5()/ (* * ) 0 %

:/) ( ) (*

(* ) 5( )# %

: 3#*"#"C *C# ) 3 ( () )# %3(( )/ 6

6 $ (/*6- 6#) ( " *

()/#6**6 6) 0<

:/ ) ( ) (*

* ) (*

3*"$ (29% #

"% 6 ( " 6"$ (-//

# ( )5( 6#) #

" / (#"

*( "

*3 ( ( " $ / $6 ) 0=

:/) (#*. @*# 6 - %3((#"

$) )# %

( " ** E ( (/

*/ $ 3* *6$

%5 ( : *7

7( (/ 16: * D: 7( (/

" D: