Lakha Singh And ORS. v. State Of Haryana
!"# "$ % &'(
)&%!%! "&'( *&'(+( % %& , '- "
&(. "$&"%
! '
/0!1$2 3 %&
'% &.&%!%! "&'(
"
#"
"$%$ & )'&(&"%'&2!(! ".&%!%! "!($!'&3%&$ # !"(%% &5+$#/&"%
3 "2!3%! "$ %&$6
"$ '$&' (&"%&"3&$ %&$
.
((&$ 7- 0& '"&$ +7 !2!(! "
0 8+$!3!
0 #!(%'
%&1
!$ "1 9 &'&7- % & .&%!%! "&'(9&'&3 "2!3%&$ "$(&"%&"3&$ (+"$&'
(!)* !
(
'
+$,-!
&3%! " : '& $ 9!% &3%! " ; "$!
"
)&"
0 $& ' ( '%1 <)= +"$&'# !# ' +( /.'!( "/&"% ' .&'! $
"&-& '&
+'% &' +"$&'# !/.0& /.'!( "/&"%
' "&/ "% &
&3%! " '& $ 9!% &3%! " ; )
+"$&'# !# ' +( /.'!( "/&"% ' .&'! $
%9 -& '( "$% .
- !"&
>
?&
&3%! " '& $ 9!% &3%! " ; )
+"$&'# !# ' +( /.'!( "/&"% ' .&'! $
"&-& '&
&3%! " '& $ 9!% &3%! " ; )
+"$&'# !# ' +( /.'!( "/&"% ' .&'! $
%9 -& '( "$% .
- !"&
>
?&
&3%! " 6 '& $ 9!% &3%! " ; )
+"$&'# !# ' +( /.'!( "/&"% ' .&'! $
%9 -& '(&
&3%! " '& $ 9!% &3%! " ; )
+"$&'# !# ' +( /.'!( "/&"% ' .&'! $
%9 -& '(&
00% &(&"%&"3&(9&'& '$&'&$% '+"3 "3+''&"%0-
..& 0 !0&$ 7- % & .&%!%! "&'( 9 ( $!(/!((&$ 7- 0& '"&$ $$!%! "
0&((! "(8+$#&18!"$2!$&5+$#/&"%$ %&$
&0&2 "%
3%( '% &.+'. (& $&3!(! " % !(.&%!%! "@% %
3 /.0 !"%9 ( !0&$+"$&'&3%! "> '
) 9!% % & 00&# %! "(% ( " "!1#'
"$
% &' % &3 /.0 "%(1 $.+'3 (&$0 "$ /& (+'!"#: "
0/ '0 ' /)' 2!"3!
0A 2&'"/&"%!"% &-& ':
>
"$/+% %! "
:$ %&$>
:
9 (&"%&'&$!"% &'&2&"+&'&3 '$(
!$!( '&/ !"&$!". ((&((! " % &( !$0 "$ "$ $!&$!"% & !'(% 9&& -1:6 "% &-& '
613 /.0 "%( ..'
3 &$) %9 '!
% & '& '#&%%!"#3 .- '&2&"+&'&3 '$ %% %%!/&1% &-3 /&% " 9% % "% &7 5+$#/&"% "$$&3'&& % &!2!0 +'%$ %&$
:61/+% %! " $7&&"3 "#&$ "$% &3 /.0 "%(3 /&% " 9 % +$ $7&&".0 -&$+. "% &/7- 7% !"!"#5+$#/&"% "$$&3'&& "
!"3 ''&3%
3%( +$+0 "%0-
& '"&$3 +"(&0 '% &.&%!%! "&'(3 "%&"$&$% %1!"
3%1% & .&%!%! "&'( $.' $+3&$ #'&&/&"%B 9 &'&7-!( $&"%&'&$!"%
" #'&&/&"% ( 0& $% &"% &&"%!'&/ "&- "$&2&"A&"&'
) 9&' %% '"&- $7&&"#!2&"!"
2 +' % &
% &' % &.&%!%! "&'(
((+3 1% &'&9 (" C+&(%! " 3 & %!"# "-7 $- &.&%!%! "&'( 0(
!0&$&#+0 '&3 "$..& 019 !3 !(.&"$!"#7& '&% !( +'% ; % % & +'%(7&0 9 2&" %3 "(!$&'&$% %% &'&9 (" 3 & %!"# "% &.
'%
% &.&%!%! "&'(7&3 +(&% &&"%!'& / +"% $ 0'& $-7&&".
!$% !(
"$ . ((&((! " % & 0 "$ 9 ( $&0!2&'&$ % % & .&%!%! "&'( "$ % & .&%!%! "&'( 9&'& !" 3 "%!"+ +( . ((&((! " % & 0 "$ !" 2!&9 % &
#'&&/&"%B 19 !3 9 ($+0-% +/7/ ' &$7-!( "$% &( /& ( $+0- .' 2&$1 " +$ 9 ( 3 //!%%&$ '& ( 1 " / +"%
( >1>
? $ 0'& $-7&&"'&3&!2&$ (!(&2!$&"% ' / % &$ 3+/&"% B 17+%7 % % & +'%(7&0 9 2&" %3 "(!$&'&$% &(&
3%(
>
& '#+/&"%('
!(&$7-0& '"&$3 +"(&0 '% &.&%!%! "&'(
2&7&&"$+0-3 "(!$&'&$ "$&2&"7 % % &(&. !"%(9&'&'
!(&$7& '& 7 % % & +'%(7&0 9 ; % % & +'%(7&0 9 2& 0'& $- ..'&3!
%&$% & &"%!'&&2!$&"3&!"30+$!"#B "$B 2&'&3 '$&$ !"$!"#( "
% &7 . (!%!2&&2!$&"3& !0 70& "% & !0&% %1!"
3%1!( $!&$ !"% & !'(%9&& -1:6 "$% &
3%'&# '$!"# !($& % 9 ($+0- &"%&'&$!"% &'&3 '$(/ !"% !"&$!"% &
!3& $$!%! "
0&#!(%'
'1;!'%
"$& % ( "
> :6 !$!( $%9 ( "(1"
/&0-1"$&'!"#
"$D!0&!"# !$D!0&!"# 9 ( .'&$&3& (&$
%&' % & $& %
1% &0 &00 % % &( '&( "$&'!"# "$0&# 0 &!'( D!0& !"# %&'% &$& % "$&'!"# 1 !( ( '& $# "&% !(0&# &!'( "$ "% %7 (!(1 % & 3 /.0 "%( % !(3 (& '&5 !"% 9"&'(!"
. ((&((! " % &0 "$!"&C+ 0( '&( (.&'% &3 /.0 "%(1% &- $
..'
3 &$) %9 '! % & '& ' 7% !"!"#3 .!&( % &'&2&"+&'&3 '$( !"% & !'(%9&& &7'+ '-1
6 %% %%!/&1% &-3 /&% " 9% ( /&7 #+(&"%'- "% &7 5+$#/&"% "$$&3'&&$ %&$
::9 ( / $&
; % % & +'%(7&0 9 $.0 3&$'&0!
"3&+. "% &%&(%!/ "-
)E61 2!"$&'F+/ '1% %!(%!3 00&' 1
!3& &#!(%'
'1;!'% ( "$ & % (19 / $&% &(% %&/&"% "% &7 '&3 '$% %% &$& %
9 ($+0-'&3 '$&$!"% &( !$
!3& .
'% ' /% %10& '"&$%'!
8+$#&.0 3&$'&0!
"3&+. "% &%&(%!/ "- )E1;
0'
/ !"!1$2 3 %&G )E1 /!"# @ )E1 &( 0/ $!"% & +'% 8 1
!$ @)E1 5 '!"# 3 /.0 "% "$)E>1 %& !"#
"% &7 . (!%!2&&2!$&"3&17 % % & +'%(7&0 9 2&
0'& $-'&3 '$&$% & !"$!"#% %!( $$!&$!" -1:6 "$'&0&2 "% &"%'-9 ($+0-/ $&!"% &'&3 '$(/ !"% !"&$7-% &
!3& &#!(%'
;!'% ( "$ & % ( ((+3 % &'&9 (" C+&(%! " 0&# 00-2 0!$ 5+$#/&"% "$$&3'&& 2!"#7&&".
((&$ " :6 '% &'&7-3 "
&''!"#
"-%!%0& 0 "$!"
2 +' % &.'&(&"%.&%!%! "&'(
&(+0% "%0-1% &.'&(&"%.&%!%! "!( 7( 0+%&0-9!% +% "-/&'!%
"$% &( /&(% "$($!(/!((&$
. / 012312 ( / E &% &'(.& !"#?'& ( "&$ H&( E &% &''&. '% 70&