Parkash & ANR v. State Of Haryana & ORS


 

      
 

      

 

         



 
 
  

   ! 



  



    



!" 

 

  

 #

  

$%&%&'($)*+),+*-+(. +.-+$/&0&.'0'1&*-+(2&(34)$.
5'678+&(+(%9  -+/$  1&8$.  %-$  7)$*$(%  )$/&*&'(  7$%&%&'(  5-+88$(:&(:  %-$ 34.:6$(%7+**$.;<%-$..8 $**&'(*4.:$+80+8.+%$.  = 0-$)$;<%-$+77$88+%$5'4)%0-&8$47-'8.&(:%-$5'(/&5%&'('1+554*$.
)$*7'(.$(%*'

%'#)$8$+*$.%-$6'(7)';+%&'(+(.14)%-$).&)$5%$.%-$6 %'7+<+*46'1
>
$+5-+*5'67$(*+%$%'&(34)$.&*-+(&(:-+(. +),+*-'4%'10-&5-
=>
0+*%';$7+&.%'&*-+(&(:-+(.=>
%'&(34)$.+),+*-

-$5+*$'1%-$7)'*$54%&'(0+*;+*$.'(%-$*%+%$6$(%'1 &*-+(&(:-)$5').$.'( = 0-$)$&(+;'4%?
.+<*7)&')%'%-$ .+%$'1'554))$(5$+6&(')/$);+8+8%$)5+%&'(%'',78+5$;$%0$$(-&6+(. %-$+554*$.

 (@ # +%+;'4% + 0-$(-$)$+5-$.&(1)'(%'1 %-$-'4*$'1+554*$.7$)*'(*0-&8$)$%4)(&(:%'-&*-'4*$+1%$):$%%&(:


;'+).$.-&*5-&8.)$(&(%-$*5-''8;4*-<+64*4..$(8<5+6$'4%'1-&* -'4*$+(.:+/$++)*+;8'0%'-&60-&5-8+(.$.'(-&*-$+. 554*$.

+)&-&%-&60&%-+(&)'()'.'(-&**-'48.$)+(.+554*$.+)+ -+(.:+/$ 8+%-& ;8'0*'(-&*8$1%-+(.+(.0+&*%  "-$(+),+*-;)'%-$)'1%-$ 5'678+&(+(%
&*-+(&(:-%)&$.%'*+/$&*-+(&(:- &)+("+%&0&1$'1 +<+!+8:)+778$.-&61)'6;$-&(.+(.+554*$. +84+:+/$8+%-&;8'0'( -&*8$1%-+(.

"-$(%-$5'678+&(+(%+(.+),+*-)+&*$.('&*$0&1$'1%-$ 5'678+&(+(% +.-++(.'($4:+8 &*-')$5+6$%'%-$*7'%+(.*+/$.%-$6

-$+554*$.0-&8$;+5,&(:'4%&**4$.%-)$+%*%',&88%-$5'678+&(+(%

(  %-$  ;+*&*  '1  +;'/$    '

#?  .+%$.   =   0+* )$:&*%$)$.4(.$)$5%&'(*@@@#=A)$+.0&%-$5%&'(@# +%'8&5$ %+%&'('.+8 -$+554*$.0$)$+))$*%$.

(/$*%&:+%&'(0+*5+))&$.'4%+(.

+  1&(+8  )$7')%  4(.$)  $5%&'(  ?@  ) 

 +:+&(*%  %-$  -<+64  +84+ +)+5-+(.  +(.  +)&  0+*  *4;6&%%$.  ;$1')$  %-$  '4)%  +(.  +55').&(:8< 5-+):$.0$)$1)+6$.+:+&(*%%-$6

%+%$6$(%*'1%-$+554*$.0$)$)$5').$.4(.$)$5%&'(@@

) 

0-$)$&(%-$<.$(&$.+88%-$+88$:+%&'(*+(.78$+*$.&(('5$(5$

-$  %)&+8  '4)%  +1%$)  )$8<&(:  47'(  *%+%$6$(%  6+.$  ;<  %-$ 5'678+&(+(%5'))';')+%$.;<%-$%$*%&6'(<'1%-$'5%')"=5'(/&5%$. %-$+554*$.4(.$)$5%&'(@@@#+(.=A

 -$%)&+8 '4)%+1%$) 5'(*&.$)&(:%-$7-<*&5+85'(.&%&'('1+554*$.-<+64;$&(:4(+;8$%'0+8, )$8$+*$.  '(  7)';+%&'(  '0$/$)  %-$  '%-$)  +554*$.  0$)$  *$(%$(5$.  %' 4(.$):' 1')A6'(%-*+(.%'7+<+1&($'1
>
$+5-4(.$)$5%&'( @@ B%'4(.$):' 1')A6'(%-*+(.%'7+<+1&($'1
>
$+5-

@
4(.$)$5%&'(@# B+(.%'4(.$):' 1')A6'(%-*+(.%'7+<+1&($'1 >
$+5-4(.$)$5%&'(=A

88%-$*$(%$(5$*0$)$').$)$.%')4( 5'(54))$(%8<

-$+1')$*+&.34.:$6$(%'15'(/&5%&'(+(.').$)'1*$(%$(5$ 0+*5-+88$(:$.&(+77$+8;<+554*$.
)$*7'(.$(%*' %'#0-$)$;<%-$ +77$88+%$  '4)%  0-&8$  47-'8.&(:  %-$&)  5'(/&5%&'(  )$8$+*$.  %-$6  '( 7)';+%&'(1')A6'(%-*+(.+8*'.&)$5%$.%-$6%'7+< 
>
$+5-+* 5'67$(*+%&'(%'&(34)$.&*-+(&(:-+(.+),+*-

%&*+:+&(*%%-&*6'.&1&5+%&'(&(%-$').$)'1*$(%$(5$7+**$.;< %-$+77$88+%$ '4)%%-+%%-$&(34)$.
7$%&%&'($)*-+/$5'6$1')0+).0&%-%-$ 7)$*$(%)$/&*&'(7$%&%&'(

!$+)($.5'4(*$81')%-$7$%&%&'($)*5'(%$(.$.%-+%%-$+77$88+%$

'4)%+1%$)-+/&(:%'%+88<5'(/&(5$.0&%-%-$').$)'15'(/&5%&'(7+**$.;< %-$%)&+8 '4)%-+*0)'(:8<6'.&1&$.%-$*$(%$(5$+0+).$.%')$*7'(.$(%* '

%'#  %0+*14)%-$)5'(%$(.$.%-+%)$*7'(.$(%*' %'#0$)$%-$ +::)$**')*+(.+%%+5,$.7$%&%&'($)'

+(.&*-+(2.$5$+*$.91')(')$+*'( +(.-+/$;$$(5'(/&5%$.+(.*$(%$(5$.;<%-$%)&+8 '4)%,$$7&(:&(/&$0 %-$*$(%$(5$7)'/&.$.1')%-$'11$(5$*5'66&%%$.

!$+)($.  %+%$  5'4(*$8  -+*  +8*'  *4;6&%%$.  %-+%  &%  -+*  ;$$( 7)'/$. '( )$5').  %-+% )$*7'(.$(%*  '

  %' #  0$)$ %-$+::)$**')*  +(.

+%%+5,$.7$%&%&'($)+),+*-+(.&*-+(&(:-2.$5$+*$.9

!$+)($.5'4(*$81'))$*7'(.$(%*'

%'#*4;6&%*%-+%%-$ '554))$(5$7$)%+&(*%'%-$<$+)+(.6')$%-+(<$+)*-+/$$8+7*$. *&(5$%-$)$*7'(.$(%*+)$1+5&(:%-$+:'(<'17)'%)+5%$.%)&+8+(.+77$+8 %

#
-+*;$$(14)%-$)*4;6&%%$.%-+%%-$&(34)&$*0$)$('%8&1$%-)$+%$(&(:+(. )$*7'(.$(%*'

%'#-+/$+8*'7$+5$1488<58$+)$.%-$&)7)';+%&'(7$)&'.

!$+)($.5'4(*$814)%-$)*4;6&%*%-+%)$*7'(.$(%*' %'#+)$)$+.<+(.

0&88&(:%'5'67$(*+%$%-$7$%&%&'($)*'/$)+(.+;'/$%-$5'67$(*+%&'(7+&. +0+).$.%'%-$6;<%-$+77$88+%$ '4)%%':&/$+0&*$;4)&+8%'%-$6+%%$)

!$+)($.5'4(*$81')%-$7$%&%&'($)*-+*+55$7%$.%-$7)'7'*+8 6+.$;<8$+)($.5'4(*$81')%-$)$*7'(.$(%*' %'#  -&* '4)%+8*'

1$$8*%-+%%-$6+%%$)&*-+(:&(:1&)$*&(5$%-$<$+)+(.$(.*'134*%&5$ 0'48.;$6$%&1%-$7$%&%&'($)*+)$*4&%+;8<5'67$(*+%$.1')%-$+5%'1%-$ )$*7'(.$(%*

(/&$0'1%-$+;'/$0-&8$+11&)6&(:%-$34.:6$(%7+**$.;< %-$+77$88+%$  '4)%&% &* ').$)$.  %-+%  )$*7'(.$(%* '   %' # 0&88 7+<
@>
$+5-%'%-$7$%&%&'($)*2&(%'%+8
>
9+*5'67$(*+%&'('/$) +(.+;'/$%-$5'67$(*+%&'(+0+).$.;<%-$+77$88+%$ '4)%0-&5-0&88;$ .&/&.$.;$%0$$(%-$7$%&%&'($)*&(%0'$C4+8*-+)$*

$%&%&'(*%+(.*.&*7'*$.'11

 +(4+)<



48+%&   "-$%-$) $7')%+;8$  $*>'

"-$%-$)7$+,&(:> $+*'($.

 $*>'