← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14071/2020disposed of

Jagbir Singh v. Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd.

2024-09-03Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj6 pages



       

#$%&'(%

  



  

   !"#

$

$

$

  2!2!

%)*+*&,%-$%./%0!12!2  

      

 

/%!(!"

      %&'!( %),

(&%-*"

*+) *!*,

(&%-*" "'"'%!

*0'!( '!1+,

(&%-*"

/%!(!"

=====

 



+* *))!1 /!"

/"'"'%!

'

22 3

!6* *4

3

!!9 :

;

;+45,

'( *;*( .*&%

/"'"'%! %!0

(/'" "+ 4'

'!1 -+*))!1 9"!"

*)*(5

/"'"'%!-%!0 0

!- *)*( (5

( *) .*&% "'"'%! *)"( +'

/6('-

* !( -%!) *//*'!1 -%!"!(

0*!(*" -"

"'%!

87:

/%&'( "*""%5

0(5 ( *) 9*0'!'!1

' /"*'!'!1

*/-" )*"'!1

 )* 9- 4'))'!1 "-

/"'"'%!, *11'

&( (0*!( 4'!1 *'( /%!(!" , /.(

/"'"

"'%!

-"'%!

 87:

'&* *!-

* *'( /"'"'%!

  (-'(   >, ;+'!

-) )*'0 /*")5

*))%;(

%/ /*"'& /*"

/*

*( !(#

?@ -''%!#

A/'!1 / /"'"'%!, /)5, %*) ('-'%!, ,

*." +*'!1 4%"+ /*"', /*) -%(

/%(-( "+0

%4&*"'%! <%0,

(-'( "+*"#

8*:

*0%!"

-+*1

('"

*"5 &'( $ $

    !6"'.'(

-%&*4)

84:

*(('"'%!

*4% %&, *0%!"

 7

2 

/"*'!'!1 '!" "

(.*)"'!1 *0%!"

0%!"+  >  2 >

!6"'.'( -%&*4)

8-:

"

C %& &+*)(

-%!!-"'%!

' >    /)*-0!"

0" $

 2 D

 D  D

-

0" (i.е. 06.10.2017 to 29.01.2018 for 115 days worked o out as Reading 34609 kWh on n 29.01.2018 minus Initial reading on n 06.10.2017=34608 uni its)  7 8(:

C 

>  

D> D27

8(:

C %&+ *)(

/0*!!

!"

('-%!!-"'%!

 > 

*-"*) ) -%(( 3>

(i.e. Final reading g 27830 as on 24.08.2017 minus s Initial reading 12 as on n 13.06.2017).

8:

C  0" ;+'-+ 1%! (.-"'&

3  > %&+*)

/0*!!"

('-%!!

!-"'%!

 



 2 7  

  >:

7

'%( 0"

(i.e. 06.10.2017 to 29.0 01.2018 for 115 days worked out t as Reading 34609 kW Wh on 29.01.2018 minus Initial l reading 1 on. 06.10 0.2017 34608 units)

 7 8-:

,

!( C

3   

-%!0/"'% 7

D> 727 7

= 1 1)*"'%!

 !6*4 "*"

1)*"% 5

%00''%!

8<%0

04(0*!:

1)*"'% %!, D -%0/)'*!-

(-''%!

+*)) 0*(

;'"+'!

-'/"

=.

%"

*"'.'( (-''%!

<, )'4"5 .') /!"*"'%!

*//%'!

!"( ('1!*"( !6*4

"*"

1 )*"%5 %00''%!

;'"+'!

 -'/"

<%0, ,

3 *( +

7 > !6*4 "*"

1)*"% 5

%00''%!

8<%0

04(0*!:

1)*"'% %!, D@ H

'!- - *"'.' *4%& *'(

.)"

!"'

' %1+"

+*& 4!

+'0, /.( *!

*//*)

)-"'-'"5, !6 6*4 -"'%!

8:

/*5 * (0*!( E/'!1

)%*( %"+ .*-"% % 0!"'%!( *//%&(

"*""%5 1)*"'

'%!

'!1 -% +* '!1 *'(

% 7

3 (-'((  3,

*'( (-''%!

%!0 < %0

%/*"'& /*"

!(# #

?@@ 7 %!-)'%!

<%0 *4%& *!*)5'

', )1'"'0*-5 %&+*)'!1



"'"'%!, .%)) )%;'!1 ("*'), /%& 45%!(

(%4"#

8':



)* -%!!-"'% >  

/)*-0!"

! 15 $"

$

 2 D

 D 

D

'%(,

!15 $"

D    7 (*5:

*('!

!1

,D3 E+

0'! !'"'*) *('!1

E+ D  F ,D>

E+

 7 8(:

>  

,3 E+

,D> D2 7F ,3 E+

8'':

%  G G'(

/0*!!"

('-%!!-"'%!

  >  *-"*) )

-%((

,3> E+ <'!*) )

*('!1 ,3 E+  >  0'! !'"'*) )

*('!1 E+

8''':

"'"'%!,

  , 8(

!15 $" 1""'!1 (.-"'&

3  >:

G G'(

/0*!!"

('-%!!-"'%!

 



%  2 7

    >:

7

-%!

!0/"'%!

/'%(,

!15 $" D  

7 *('!1

,D3 E+ 3   > 0'! !'"'*) *('!1 E+ D  F

,D> E+:

 7 8-:

%(

!(

3   

-%!0/"'% 7, E+ +

,D> 72 7F7, E+

-''%!#

G G) *4%& ('-'%!,

  > *    /+)(

('/% ( *--%('!1)5

-*,  "'"'%! % /%!(!"

8'"'4"'%!

'-!:

*"'.'( *4%&

(-''%!, '"

)'4 "5 E *//%/'*" 0(5

*1*'!"

.% %0 *//%/'*" %('

*--%(*!- 

!6*4

"*"

1) )*"%5 %00''%!

8<%0

04(0*!:

1)*"'% %! D H

"

-%!"!(( %'1'

'!*))5 '&*!- ( *) +* .*-"

!

*..'0(

'

'"  3, &!

"+%1+ /** !% D *'(

;*(, (-' '%!

-* 

%  > +* 4!

/+)(

* !( -%!) *//*'!1 4+*) /%!(!"

(%

('/"

*4!- *!5 -+*))!1 1 *;*(

('"'4"'%!

)'-!

! -%0/"!"

%",

-%)(

+*& "*E!

*;

;*5 4!.'" *)*(5 4!

9"!(( .*&%

-%!0

(* *)

 "+ .*')5 40'"

-+ 9"!

!"

;'"

0*5 *))%;(

& *.%*'( -%!"!"'%!

! .*' "*!( *(%/"(

-%!) /%!(!", /!"

;'"

"'"'%!

*))%;(

 3 /

04( (0*!

*'(

%!0

*..'0( .*&%

/"'"'%!% %!0

%-$%./%0!12 '"

+"+ +"+   2!2        + /*E'!12*%!(

+ /%"*4)#

I2%

I2%