High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3273/2019allowed

Hardeep Singh v. Joginder Singh And Another

2020-02-12Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal6 pages

"#$$%&'&()

) *+ +, + !"

# $$$ +, +-

##& #

# ! ' (" ) (

## # # (" "# # #' # *+ ,- *,,.

) # & ./&# 0 1''$''&( 23 4"3 '1$%&&% 1$005"(%$ "60$$5$(##'$778"#$8

:#;$7"(85$"'/0&(69 "%0$' &6;"'! 2$"0&(6 ,$4"#<,;"#"/(& :<:- <-<:- <-2$"0&(6,;"'0"=<-= - 9- 9- 9<- =- =<- 9 "(8 > ';"0$ &( ,;"'0" ( =<=: "' 1$0 ?"5"2"(8& '&#/"#$8 "# $0'$;"(&- $;'&7 $0" "''&- &'#0&%# ;"7& /(?"2!

8&0$%#&(6#;$8$$(8"(#'#$@$%/#$#;$'"7$8$$8#;$7"(8 &("A/0#;$17"&(#&(1"35$(##;$2"7"(%$'"7$ %('&8$0"#&(/###"7'"7$%('&8$0"#&('

BB 01$05"($(#&(?/(%#&(0$'#0"&(&(6#;$8$$(8"(#'05 "7&$("#&(6- 50#6"6&(6- $(%/52$0&(6 /1(- A$0 #;$ '/&# 101$0#3#"(3#;$01$0'($@%$1##;$17"&(#&"(805 8"5"6&(6#;$7"(8238&66&(6#;$$"0#;0230"&'&(6"(3 '0#%('#0/%#&(&("(35"(($04;"#'$A$0"8A$0'$# #;$&(#$0$'##;$17"&(#&#;0/6;#;$5'$7A$'0#;0/6; "(3283$7'$023#;$;$71#;$"(3#;$0"6$(%3/(8$0

08$0/7$ C / )

# ## "# *- ,, ,,,1&

2.3

# (" ' "

,5 ,6 *,*, * ) ##' "7 #(

6 # ! # ' #

6, ,6 *,*,

& .&8"A&#0$'1(8$(#';"'2$$(&7$8&(#;$ /0# #8"3"(8#;$'"5$&'#"D$((0$%08"'5"0D* * 7"&(#&B"11$77"(#&'&(0$6/7"0'$%(8"11$"7"6"&('# ?/865$(#'1"''$823#;$ /0#'2$748$%&8&(6#;$'/&#0 1''$''&(234"3'1$%&&%1$005"(%$"60$$5$(## '$778"#$8

: +$"0($8#0&"7 /0#60"(#$88$%0$$00$%A$03 $"0($'# 5($3 "7(6 4&#; &(#$0$'# "# #;$ 0"#$ :E 4;$0$"'7$"0($8&0'#11$77"#$ /0#;"''$#"'&8$#;$ "0$'"&8 8$%0$$ 1"''$8 23 #;$ #0&"7 /0# 0$'/7#&(6 &( 8&'5&''"7#;$'/&#&7$823#;$17"&(#&

BB #&%$ 5#&( 4"' &''/$8 ; "08&1 &(6;- 8A%"#$ ;"' 1/# &( "11$"0"(%$ ( 2$;"7 #;$ 0$'1(8$(#'

( -774&(6 08$04"' 1"''$8( #;$ '#"#$5$(#7$"0($8%/('$70#;$0$'1(8$(#'-&(#;$ 10$'$(%$0$'1(8$(#)B .$'1(8$(#"7(64&#;;&'%/('$7 &'10$'$(#&(#;$ /0#;$3;"A$?&(#73'#"#$8 #;"##;$3"0$0$"83#$@$%/#$#;$'"7$8$$8"' 10"3$80&(#;$'/&#01''$''&(234"3 '1$%&&%1$005"(%$"60$$5$(##'$778"#$8

: ( 0$%$&1# 2"7"(%$ '"7$ %('&8$0"#&( +$"0($8%/('$70#;$"11$77"(#;"'( 2?$%#&( &(%$0$'1(8$(#&'(#10$'$(#-7$# 2#; #;$ 0$'1(8$(#' &7$ "&8"A&# # #;$ "0$'"&8$$%#(#;$($@#8"#$;$"0&(6 8?/0($8# +&'#&(/06$(#C &8"A&#2#;#;$0$'1(8$(#';"'2$$(&7$8"(8 0$'1(8$(#'"0$8/73&8$(#&&$823#;$%/('$70$10$'$(#&(6 #;$5 $'1(8$(# &' "7' 10$'$(# &( /0# ;$ "&8"A&#&'##;$774&(6$$%#)B . ;"##;$"11$77"(#B17"&(#&&7$8"'/&#0 1''$''&(234"3'1$%&&%1$005"(%$ 60$$5$(# $77 8"#$8

: 7"(8 5$"'/0&(6 9 %0$' &6;"'! "6"&('# #;$ 8$1($(#'B0$'1(8$(#'B8$$(8"(#' 4;&%; 4"' 8$%0$$8 23 7$"0($8 #0&"7 /0# 0 "7#$0("#$ 0$7&$0$%A$03'9-

<B"7(64&#;

&(#$0$'#F:E1$0"((/5A&8$?/865$(#"(8 8$%0$$8"#$8

9"(8"11$"7"6"&('##;$

B=B '"&8 ?/865$(# "(8 8$%0$$ &7$8 23 #;$ 8$1($(#'B0$'1(8$(#'B8$$(8"(#'4"'"774$8 23 #;$ 7$"0($8 +4$0 11$77"#$ /0#- "6"0 "774$8 #;$ "11$"7 "(8 '$# "'&8$ #;$ &51/6($8?/865$(#"(88$%0$$A&8$?/865$(# "(8 8$%0$$ 8"#$8 : "(8 #;$ "2A$ #&#7$8"11$"7;"'2$$(&7$823#;$"11$77"(#B 17"&(#& 4;&%; &' (4 &@$8 0 ;$"0&(6 ( 2$0$#;&'(*27$ /0# ;"# #;$ 8$1($(#'B0$'1(8$(#'

B8$$(8"(#'"0$0$"83#$@$%/#$#;$'"7$8$$8 "'10"3$80&(#;$'/&#01''$''&(234"3 '1$%&&%1$005"(%$60$$5$(##$77 8"#$8

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

/(?"2!C

B9B $'/25&#'#;"#7$'##;$0$&'"(38&'1/#$-7$##;&'"%# 2$%7"0&&$8

( #;$ #;$0 ;"(8- 7$"0($8 %/('$7 0 #;$ 0$'1(8$(#';"''/25&##$8#;"#&(#;$"&8"A&#-8$$(8"(#' ;"A$ "70$"83 '1$%&&$8 #;"# #;$3 ;"A$ ( 2?$%#&( # 1"''&(6#;$8$%0$$"'10"3$8023#;$17"&(#&'&(#;$ '/&# (A&$4#;$%('$('/'"00&A$8"#-#;$8$%0$$1"''$8 23#;$ /0#'2$74&''/2'#&#/#$823#;$8$%0$$0'1$%&&% 1$005"(%$ "60$$5$(# # '$77 "' 10"3$8 0 ;$ 17"&(#& ';"77 2$ 7&"27$ # 8$1'&# #;$ 2"7"(%$ '"7$ %('&8$0"#&('9%00$'97"D;'4&#;&(/05(#;' # #;&' '#"6$- 7$"0($8 %/('$7 0 #;$ 0$'1(8$(#' 10"3'0#&5$(#;$60/(8#;"#'5$1"0##;$7"(8- "%%08&(6 # ;&' &(05"#&(-;"' 2$$( "%G/&0$8 23 #;$ "#&("7&6;4"3/#;0&#3(8&""(8;$4"(#'#6$# %517$#$&(05"#&( 8?/0($8#= +&'#&(/06$(#C ' '" 8

#' # ("'

5( ("( "

'( / # ! "

# 8

5 ( 7 7

- 9*,:

;

(' (

## ##& / # ##&

# #

B:B / # (' #'

0 '( 6, ,6 *,*, '

- ( ' ( # # #' # *,:

9- ;# '

'( ' ( (! !' #5( # 0 (" # # ## ( (# )

< ' (" # ## 4 # ' # ' ( 7 ## ## =# '# ## ( 7

) ' 8

' (

(# ) ,6 ,5 *,*,

' # "

# # ( ! ' +, +!

6* ,* *,*,

> 0

1 ? > (