G 4 S Security Services India Pvt. Ltd. v. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner
-1-
!"
#$ %"&'('#)* ++ ,
, - -
-.-
.+ / +
0+
.(+
/ .
--
+++-
* 1/ + - -/
!
-/3
/
"
! #$$%&$$' ( ! ! )* )'
$)"" + ,-". / # 0 1 ## #23 4# , 0 # # 1 3 !##3
$
5
3 !! ! # # ( !! 3 3 # 6 0
1 "77% 3!# ##!##
!3! # 3 8 9: ##3 ##3; ! ##3 !
3! #
;! "7*<+ 6"7*< 0.3 3!
-2- # !3 "7*< 3 # ! / # 0 1 ## "7=$+ 6"7=$ 0. # !9:
##3; ! ##3+## # 6 ##3> . 3!3 ### !/ # &/ # ? - 0"77%"77< @"
)= "777 # ! 1 A
3! 3 # ! #
8 ;!9:
; ! ##3 @
# ## 3 )"
)= $)))#@"
)= "777 !
9 ; 4# 9 !3 ##3 $) )7 $)""
4# 9 !- ! ## (
#3
") ") $)$@ *
# 0 "77% "77< ! '
"7=$ 2 0 "77< 0 "777 ! $@ )= $))$ ! # ! # # 1 ##3 9:
##3 ; ! ##3 3 #
# =
4 0$))" # 0$))= ! ! '
"7=$ "@ )* $))%# # # #9:
##3 3! 1
-3-
3 ! # # # ## # 3 ##3 "= )% $))7 ## # ##3 # 8 ## 1 # ; 3
)"
)$ $)""
( # 3
8 $) )'
$)""
3 !
$) )'
$)"" 3 3 )< )7 $)""
3##4# 9 !# ! 4 8 "'
)< $)$@# 4 8
# %
A !0 $))= ?0$))'! ! '
"7=$ 3 #
@) )'
$))< ! # ##3 8 ;! 1 # ## 3 ## ##3 # #9:
8 ;! 3 ###3 8 ;! 1 '
#
! # # #
# ! 90#
! #
-4- <
!
##
#
3!
8 9:
##3 ; ! ##3 3 3##33
# ## # # # 8 90# 6
.(+
! "#$ ## #
##3 ## # # 8 1
( ! 3 # ## ")
"@ )* $))% #
##3 8 1
3 3## 3
3! 3 8 9:
; !
##3 ##3 !! - %
!
"#$ """
% &
'()*+,*"-".*"". .#/##
!0123%
01
+,!3 4 444 444 444
-5-
+,!
4 )
5
(01 60 !
!01
444 444 444
. !
3 ( 7
8 -#"##/
6* % & 9
0
:
3 (01 60!
3
!
3
3
)
5 3+,!
01
+8(01! ! !
;6! < ! 012 31 =! !'/"">= ->### $ 13##/> 444 444 444
? 3
+8 (01 !
6* ;6! <! 012 31 +8+
2 @ A
,0123 @ A < 6* % & 9
% 0
:
3
( 7
3+,
-60
1 0
1
> ""
## # "= )% $))7 # ##33 8 ;!
8 ;! $+. "7=$ ## # # # 3## 3 3## 3 #
3! 3 #3 $ B
3
3
A C+,!
3
9 @ , 0 ! D 2 3 %
01
9
$! !
> "$
#
## - #
##3 8 ;! 1 "= )% $))7 #3- B% 7 3
-7- 01
3
01
C !
+,! 3
! E
3 )
5
9
=> !
! 01
3 .#&##-
, !
2
> "@
- 8 )"
)$ $)""
( ") )$ $)"" 3
## # ##3 # 8 ;! 1 #, )"
)$ $)"" #3- B
8
A
1 !
A
A
-81
3
6 5 !
A
3
,
&'
(
""?= >::;3"$"+
2 , ) * ( + ! * , !,
"""92&/" 7 3
!
4
6 5 !
( 0
1 6 0
!
!
:
0
1 !
6 5 !
:
3
6 5 !
(0
1 !
-9-
:
444 444 444 +
3
4 +, ! 3
> ,,, ,,, ,,, "*
( # 3 3
$) )'
$)""
"=
## 3 "'
)< $)$@
# #2 7$<* $)"@
# "'
)< $)$@ #3- B ) 9 ; 3
/ ;3 ##"3 !
( 0
1 6 0
!
3 "/3
6
9
$! (01 !
3
3
A
-10- ! 9 ; F
) +
2 . 6 < A )3 !
9
%
(01!
3
4 G E 9
& 6 5 !
3 "&?
-
G
E
G E
6 5 !
3 "&? & 3 (01 !
G
E= 9
>3
4
2 6 5 !
3 "&?3
4
3
23
/
. 63##3 !012 9
$! (01!
3
A -
3
> "%
!
' + .
#
! # - ,
A
-113 !##3## # 3 # ,
!# !
' + .3# $< )$ $)"7 3 #
# "'
)< $)$@ #
# # # "'
( 3
# # ") 3 # #!
# 3 #
- 84 8 3## "<
( ##3 !# ##3 ( ! )* )'
$)"" + , -". - "7
!
## # +.
## #
$"
""
$)$*
4 -/5
; !& C&2 ;# C&2