High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3776/2006allowed

Sunita Devi And ORS. v. Kamal Kumar And ORS.

2024-11-05Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma12 pages

"# $ $$ $

!"# $%# & ' ($"

)# $% & * %%% $ $ & #

'(" %+'&&' ( %,- '"" , "".'- /001+('( " %+'&& ( %,-

$"(-$"

2304/0/5" 213/&/004# '"( ' -"( "

%"' ( %,"'"' $#-&'"

, %(&" #'( )( 6( '%(, )"'' ( %,"#)'" "' ( ""', ( ' #'%% ( %,")

% "+( '%(

%' ( &'%(.. +-'" ( & ""."', '".&'( # ($"

)# $%%% "%+'&& *7 ( %,-

%(& ''' $ %-&' 7+.)"' $ %

' %(&

*7 ( %,- $")&'

2304/0/5 " 213/& /004#' ( %,-" "

% "+( '%(

%' ( & ($"

)# $%#'%(.. +-'"( "' % 2 ' '+ &

."')

2805/001 "'%",""&" ( %"211&'

'"%%#2833+-' %%"

", "+(#,+9&

' # :' "+(:; & '%, & %,"# .

' %",< $ $ / '+ "&&%&'% ' 34/005= " ".'

% ;) $"., %-%+ ". >70478401+".

"$ +-,"'+-+ $".' &&"% ( , ?' '- %' ,+&:

: $')#,+"-#'" + ". ." " 72278515#)'"%')+".

"$+-,(,

2"$ - ' ."., #%,& ,'"

%" '"."', %-% (&)'"%'+' "

&' , %-%& ),"'(" ," " ( "#')$ #= "

".'(" "(" ( ""%( "." ( -"'"' "$ &' & %(".'%%"

)-)"'' ',",'

".'&

".' %' ' = " ".')

"$">"#,+"->)$ #)-''"#'(%%(,+ '" ( " ) ." ." 2 *

"% & ' %", ""#

% '%","" " '&%(,&'%%"

5 , ' ". & ' "# ' "+( & , ' &)"."(

!"!#$ %&

' ( $

( ) *(

(* (%&

+ * (

) ,

%& - + !- @ & "."%"

"' ". '$"

# ' "+( )

%," ' ( & 20#24#@00<7.)"'" A4@B (,>%'%",< &" ' & '%,&%,")

+-' "+( $ $$$$#$$ 1 ' %(& '%",7% '' %," +-' "+("') "

>&( '

% '' "+(') .- '"%,& % 3#500<7 ,'>&( ' % ',().

&(( % $ #'% '',(.

& & #&( C &% "(,") "

' & #

' - ' ' + ) %," '( + '% ) 4

% # %( & ' # ')$ # $',- .('"&')

% '',(& %," +-' "+(' ".'-+.

3 '$'

%(& ' " ( ')'

&'"% 8 (&')

" "%'' "+(' ".'- ' ,'- "%, & % 3#500<7# & ". " %"

"' - "&"%C ! ( ' #' "( '

)'"-".,("" &2@" &25( ' #,(.

& &#&% "(, & &( C") "

$ #,().

& &(( %' & #" 6("

" & %&'"( $# #' $ 20 >D+ ( ,( "'%&

(

$)*+,-,.)+/01,12# "

)'),&%," ' $ &' , (

E. ( #( * / #

. 0 , $ 1 #2

0 ,*

* * * ( , * /

, #

34+ *(#

($((#

' +,

34!*(#

($ ((#! ",

345*(#

($((#/ / * # ( ,

) # , ( $,567 /,# ( # * ( ( 8 *, #$

( (,* # 3 #$ # $9,# $,

$ * ( * # ( * # ) #

$, # * # , # $ * # , ( , #

. #$ #, $ ( * # #

, 567* # /

# 567 #

($1 *,*

(

, * * * ( (#

$ # , /( $# #

($*# *

( # # ( 0 ( 3!

# # 3 #$

$ (( . ( :, . 0 0 , * * (

5 '6 ' '5$ , #$

$ $ , < =

'" +6$ ,< "

+5$ ,< 5

+" !6$ ,< !

! !5$ , < +

!" 56$ , #$*

$ , ,<

5 55$ ,<

5" "6 $ ,< =

" "5$ < 5

"" =6$ 22 >D+ ( , ( " ' % & ! "

#$ ( $3 2'% "&" ' )( %"211#21*7 213&' '"%%#2833#' &)".% 3> ?

/ ( ( @ 3A

(

@ 30 >

$(@ 3? - # , ($,

( /,* @ 38 9

B*( #@

( $ / $ .

( B

C% >

& ,*

**/ - D) -'5,666 * /, - ,66,666 *

( -,66,666 *

( .

( /. - ?, (

* (. , $, # ( # # * #

# (

(, #2 >$2 (

. #

# ,

( $ # . (

# (. # (#

&*, * # /(

$ (

( (# , *#(( $

*, #$#

$ # .

,* ($ / #()( #

, ($,

( / # -5,666, -!6,666 -5,666 $ .

#A #

2 ( * # ( * 2 # # $ $ ( #

$ # *# $

( (,

567

$ (

,* ( # * # *

!6$ , #( . #+67,

* #*!6 56$ ) * #*

56 "6$ ,

#57> $ # $ / %'

) *

( $ 3 / $,

!67

# ( # * * * # *

!6$ >

'57* * #*

!6 56$ 67* * #*

56 "6$ # $ (

( . # ( ( (( / ( %'

%9 (

( ,

/,# # #$ +6 +'

( F** #

( .

( # .

# ( G * !'

( %'

$ ( %'

*- # , ($,

( / #- 5,666,-!6,666 -5,666$.

( #

67$ $ H 2/ >D+ ( ,( "'%& 04-0,5,+06 51)+057,.-*058#9-9/,:;1 05)0-06901<)<+)0-

/<,+1( 3 3 $ 2& %"

".$0+60;,+-0 1)*+0

+0508 $,/<9 $)*+0 ' ' ) .

". % "(, $ &', (% (

C>0 A

0 $ D * * ( # * &

() , I (I ( ( * ( I (I, I (I, I (I .

(* ( $, ,, (

, ,

,* / * '

# * * * (

I ( $, $,

$ I ''"

(

, ,

, $, ,

I '++

(

. $

, (

($ 0 ( ( ( # *

< *

J (

/ (

(

( # * (

(

. ( *

(

, (

.< > #

( (

() *

( , (

, # *

(

( * * ( > > *10 * ( 1 *,* $* * ( #

( . (

( # * ( * # #$

* ( I

(I * $) ,* ( *

, (

-!6,666

( #$ 2* $")&')"

)+-'>D+ ( ,( "' +$ &

( .,#' ") ')

2805/001 ", "&" %%

".-'7%", " '% %," '%%(", ' 7(

, - '- %, 3#500<7 / (( %A*0B /@/0<79*0B&3500;

* (%" )

C "( 2<5' /4*0<7920#8/0<7F2<5;

5 %, 3280<79208/07/4*0;

("" @ ( %- 2*#4@#8/0<793280F2/F25;

& 23#000<7 ( C 23#000<7 &% "(,

53#000C*

( 53#000C2 2#8/#000<7 ./06.-*,510/9.5 1 & & = -.)5/>0+:,:?8/<, +9?)506 1 && = 5<057,:0-.)5/ 1 &3&! = 25

& ' " " %% # ' +- >D+

( ,( " .

01 .

2 $ $)*+,-,.)+/01,1 &'7%", .

'" A8B (,''% ,(& ,' & &"".&%","""' &" "G" 2@ ' ( %,-7 *" "

% "' '% ,(&%,".)"'" )"'' "+()"'" " &),'& , -' "+("&( ' "

% "+( ''% ,(&%,".)"'" "'%%(&' %",<# ' " +-' "+("")

2805/001'%",< "

% &( "''"

+%%(

"' "+( 21 !& ". )"' ' ( .,# '" ( C " %"" ($"

)# $%#& '"+"%'( "' , 24 " &&%%

".- 23

"."%"#"&-# " & !

$ $ -0-/0 ?'' ".<

H< ?'' + H<