High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12085/2013dismissed

Polly Shera v. Presiding Officer And Others

2019-12-16Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih9 pages

" !

# $$ % &''(

)*)

!"# $% &'()$ % *( !+

((,-./0(*-.,1% *(+(& (2,/3(*-.,2

44"+ $% &'()$ % *( !+

((2,/3(*-.,2% *(+(& (-$&1(,-./0(*-.,1

6 !(&% +(+( (&)& 7(7 +

(( ,-./0(*-.,1

&$++, -./ '/$$ ##$/1 34/ 4/ 45 4/$ + /$34

+1 .

$0 /.

./$&(2,/3(* -.,2

&$ $

4 $+ #/ .$+ +# / ''

.1 .

$0 /.

' ++, -./

./%7!)!$ 8!$9:$&

7$&&$ &,0.,-.,1;

<"=1>+$&96 $ 9"$ = )":=$9("(" %!$&8$!%9( !96 !7(#:$$7 $

!7(#:$$88'&(* !(&7!)!8$ !:

":+=":)(:+$ ((* ,%?.%...

= "(* : $! #8 *(* : $ (87 !*" 9$)#7$8$&)( "

6(* ')$& +$68*(@) !*)( )(')% !*$) $98 $#*(:(,-./0(*-.,1 '

* 6% !*$) $ !+

(=7(#:$7$$++( & $$ **)(,/.,,A/?96 !+(& = $* $ '7! &(.2.,,A/?$&!7$8$ !8" $+$6)$ 7*.,.2,AA.!$&'& !+(& *(:( !$-.6$ !("

$6)(:+ $ (7'%!')!$'9 &'& (&&$ &1..,-..?( !8("& !!$97(#8$8$ $ (=< +( $&7 !("

!$++('$ (*$6)(:+ 6

(!$9:$&96!: +(@"( (!:!$'9 $&')$&*!$++( 7$ (:$&*( (*

$ $* ! ((!(7)$"( )7$'& "+(!:(B"67$! &(7$$6 )!: )(:+$ ( 8'98'( $ !+)+ (*$ "$ @" )$&) (-0= (* %7!)!"" $$9 $7!$+$6& *( : $&)( "

6')

!( !!$&% ! $&(* 7(#:$ 7$ ( $++( & $8$ ! $) (& +( ( 7$ ! $++( $++('&96 6' !<)"

' (::

) & (* ! () 6 &( ( *" *

B"$ *)$ (*( **)$!7$( 6$(:

$&"$ $&&&( !$' !B" <+) $ ! $ &

!7$$++( &$$ **)($+" 6 :+($6+( ( $ )(( &$ & $ $6 (* ,-..

= + :( ! ! B"$ *)$ ( *( $++( $ (:$&06$<+) )'

8$& ! $ $++( (* ! +

( )()&% $ !7$$++( &7 !)(

4!"8! *("8 !(

6)!:( !$9 ( ! & ;$6$>7*,/.,,A/?$&!$++( 7$$++('&$ ! ' (*

!$ ) $6(* !(") 7!)!( 6 !(

6)!:&&):9%,A//9"

!7(#:$)( "& $ **) 8$ 67 $+ !&) ((*

!(($6) $6$&$ (8( $8" $+$6)$ (*,?..=-??.7 !

$ (7$)).,.2,AA.!+( **)&(( <

$& !$&+( !$$ (( 9$++('&96 $)+$ *( !')(* !+

(%( $7 +

(98* &96((* !)(=7(#%$"9=(::

(* )(") 7$)(

( ((# !$++( !7(#:$7! &)+$)7 !8$& (!$++( $&!)( "$ ($$

**)7*("&

(7$"&$!(7)$"( )

! 8!

(* ! $9(' *$) $& $* )(&8 ! + 6% ! 7$

&968'8!:(:( !$ $6 "(*( )!8("&*(

( 7$ ! +()&"% $ +)9& *( $++( (* +:$

8" $:+ (6 %!$( 9*( (7& $&% !*(% 7$)() "&& ! 6 (')7$9$)#&(( 6$($&' : 7$"&($6$:)$ &*(*(:

:+ (6: <)!$8+)$ 67! **)&& ( < (7$ !$++( (+( $++('&96

6 '

!9$(* !+ $&8(* !+$ %*( (78" 7*$:&96 !$9("(" % !$:$&$*( (7 = C;,> ! ! !+(& $&" 6$&*&"& ) (-;@>(* D

;-> ! ! !) $:$ $(#:$D

;1> ! ! !*)( :$ $$9 D

;2> ! !')(* !(#:$7 &96

!:$$8: 8$ 6%*(% (7!$ * !(#:$

(%*$6D

;0> ! ! ! ( $ + ! : (* $++(

%*(% **) D

;?> *E &'

8$& "(,%!$&8$!(") *(! & *$ 7$&) $&$$F 6F 8$& "(-%( 6!$7$ *("& (9$F(#:$F "(1 (07&)&& (8 !*$'(" (* !7(#:$ 96!( &8 !*)7$:$ $$9 $&

( (* ! ') (* ! 7(#:$ 7$ *("& ( 9 8$ (7'%9)$"(* !(=< )(* !$) (&+( **)% $&(* 8 !7(#:$%)(:+$ ((* ,%?.%...

= 7$$&%7!)!7$(&& (9+$& !7(#:$7 !$+(& (* 7(:( !*(: !&$ (*+"9 )$ 7$&(7 ! ! :( !(* !&$ (* 7$&7!)!'$ %*$ 87!)!!7(" &9

( G,-H+$": !$ I$ !$:!

7$&&$ &,0.,-.,1!$9)!$ 8&96 !7(#:$$7 $

!)( ! $&)(" *( !7(#:$

!$9("(" !$'8)(: ($)() "( ')(* !7(#:$7$( $))(&$)7 !+('((*

$&!!$'8'& !+(& *(:( !$ -.6$!(" &!$'8$ ! *(* : ')7 !

)( "

6 !(*7 !*" 9$)#7$8 $&(*8$ 8!: ":+=":

)(:+$ ((*,%?.%...

=%7!)!( $))+ $9 )( & *&8%$!$9)(&&96 $ 9"$ 7 !8$& ! 98(8" $+( $'$ $9 (* **)%)$( 9$))+ &$ !** "<(* :% !) 6$& !"

6(* !$9 +('&96(&&("9 $&:*(:$ $++('$ !$'8( 9)'& *(: 6 !<)"

'(::

(* !() 6%)$( (79 $#$$8("&$* -.6$

!')(* !7(#:$

$:$ $=*&$) ( !+$

(!$' !')(* !7(#:$$ !9 $ & $8% !*(%+$6*( : !+

(')7 !

$ )(B" $ 9* '

!( !!$&%)(" *( !$$ &

!(" 9 (7!$7(8 6+()&& (!( &( 6!$ (9$ 7(#:$ !8$&%!!$*& !:$*") ($& $ & < ?=,

$ !7$+*(:8 $#7!)!7 :$$8$ $&"+'(6)$+$) 6 &"

7 (++$ 9"&8 :$ (*$ !+(8$::%)!)#8(*)$!9((#%$))(" : %+()8$&

8$"& (9@) ($& ("+&6

& **) &+($ (*7(#96 $ 7$$ (B"& ( &$ 7 !:+( $ $&)(:+ )$ &)$$& (7$ )!*( ($$& $&'$)$& !)('6$+ :)!&" 7$ ()!)#$& +$$ <+& "9 $&( !9 ))(&8 6%!$ ) $:$ 7$ ( $7(#:$ (!$ $ ( 9:$& $++( (*( 6!$ !6$,A/?7$+:$ 6*( !+"+( (*(

6)!:$&!7$$ (+*(:8(:) )$ $))(" 7(# (

6 )!: 7$ $ (8 ! &)( "& ):9% ,A// 9"

!$* %!7$)( "&')96 !(($6) $6(* () 6$ ! (7 ' ($++('$ !$ 9("8! *(*(: )(:+ 6$&!)( "&$")!' !8" $+$6)$ % 7!)!7$8$ !) $:$ %7$7 !("

$++('$ (*

6$&$ ! ' (* !(($6) $6$ (%7!)!$8$7$ ( " $$9 (7$ )(($)7 ") ($++ )$9 !8$& ($++( ! $** !() 6 !$++(

98( )(($)7 !B": $+ ") ((

!98$8" $+( **)$'$ $9 % !) $:$ )(" & ( !$'9)( "&( 7!)!&&( < ('

8$& !)(:+$ (%7!)!!$98$ &% $ &96 !)(" *( !$++( ) $:$ 98( )(($)7 ! "

(6 " $& 98 8$ % !7$(B" ((*8$ 8!: !9* (*) (-0=(*

+)$ 67!(+( **) < &( !( (* !() 6*" !)( &7 !*)

:($&":(* ()$ ( !$:$&(9@) (* !() 67! !$ "(*$ *$() 6 $ !)(:+$ (%$

* 8$ &%!(" &( !$'98$ &$& !*)!(" &!$'9 @) &$6!$% !"%9:$&*(

8$& 7$&:+"8& '

!$')(&& !"9:(:$&96 ! $&)(" *( !+$ $&7 !$ $)%!$'8( !("8! !+ $&8 $& !)(&(* !)$9"

&(( *&:6 *$8: 7 !$6(*

!)( (%7!)!!$'9$&969( !)(" *( !+$ % 9"

$87 7$&+$&96 $ 9"$ =)":=$9(" (" %!$&8$! '

$++$ ( !9$(* !*$) $ 6( 6!$ 7$$++( & !6$,A/?+:$ 6*( !(

6)!:7!)!7$ &)( "&):9%,A//!$++( ( **)%$:$&%7$*($ :+($6+"+(

( &+"

! 7$($) (&+( **) !$9)(*$$) (& +( %( 6!$)(" &( !$'98$ !8" $+$6)$ (* $&+( 7!)!$) "$ 6&&( < !'&)%7!)!!$)(:( )(&%) $ 6&)$ ! ! $ $++( (*( 6!$= ) $:$ 7$$++('&96 6(7$ (*

**)8( $++('&96 6 !<)"

' (::

)& !() 6!$++( % !"%(*( 6 !$( **))$( 9$& (9$))(&$) !8" $ ($++ )$9 *($++( !:+ (6(* () 6 '

! $&(* !) $:$ 7$( $ 7(#:$$&7$+*(:8 !:$$8$ "+'(6*") ()$(

9$))+ &#+8'7 !$ "(*7(#$& !&"

+*(:&96 !:!)() "(% !*(%$&$796 $ 9"$ =)":=

$9(" (" % !$&8$!% )$( 9 $& ( 9 8$ ! 7(# +*(:&96( 6!$=) $:$ +:$ 67$) )$ $ "$&%

!*(%!!$8!

69$& (97 ! !)(+(* !&* ((* F7(#:$F$+('&&"&) (-;>(* '

" ! 7(#:$=) $:$ !$ 9 '8

*(: ! 6$ ,A/? ! &$ (* ! ( ( 1..,-..?$ :( -.6$9"

)!$++( 7$(+" 6

:+($69$$&!!$&9)( "87 7 !("

!$++('$ (* 6$&7 !($) (&+( %

7$&+$&96 !$9("(" &68!: : $& $& 8$ 8!: ":+=":)(:+$ (%)$( 9*$"

&7 ! ' $:(" (*)(:+$ (%$8$ &%@" *&#+8'7 !*$)

&$(") *(! & *$$7 *$() 6!( '( $ !+('((*) (-0=(* $ $* !) $:$ %(*!$++( !$9:$&$ $ **) ! $++( % * $6% !$ 9 :$& $ $

$ )'

7(" &( 9("

(*7$6 (: (! ( ( 67$

!$++( !) $:$ :+($6%7 !98($) (& +( $&7 !("

!$++('$ (* 69"

!$:7$ $ ( ( +((& 96 $6 :+ (6: <)!$8 ( 7$ ! +(

$&' & !:&$*()"

$+ !8" $ ((* !(") *($++( (* $**!*(%!)(" &( !$'9(&& (9 &') '

'7(* !$9('%*&8(: $6(* ! 7(7

(% !$:$&:&$& !$7$&(* $ 9"$ =

( )":=$9("(" %!$&8$!&$ &,0.,-.,1;

<"=1>% !96%"+! & !53/ &1

( 6- 7-8

! ! !+$#8 $(&

( ! ! +( $9 (