Sanjiv Tayal v. State Bank Of India & ORS.





   
 
  

 
  

    !"#$  % &%' () *++ ,% -.
  // 
 0%1,+ ,%  % &%' () *++ ,% -.
  

   
 %!2'3%+ ,%  % &%' () *++ ,% -.
  45  
 )+%2'3%  % &%' () *++ ,% -.

      
 
%

%-27% %87+!

 %,. %
  

 8// +45   %*,9%:$87+!

 %,. %  

    %-2, .%8 %7+!

9, %2.$2))%87+!

+ %;'%!,%387+!

 % ,%.

+() 

 8 // 8

   +45   %22,,$87+!

 %%.

+ 5  

   


 

 (#, %+%8< !'3<%+9%. ,$$<+.

+

, % !%#!

$!+$$,+$= %<%!#8 %<1>%+% 3 

  *  ,    9%  . 8  . %  ,  ?' +  , %'$%++ +'%,% %+%.+<#9,,,. %@ %!%+ ,!<%3+ () *+ %.

+,!!

$!+,3 %, .'%.

 3

,1,.%  $ 1%++% !%#<# ..

1?'$+.% +,#,!<3+A>  % ()1%!B('=$ %'%' ,.

$#+  ,() *+8. %+ ,!<..

+ 4 5
7>'%  '%' 7>'% 8%.

+ () ,!%+ 1%3<9, ,('=$ % 9, 9%..

+ ",%.

()

)+ %$1

 %!9    ' 1    ('  =$ %@  + '   113 +!+'$('=$ %%3  +!+'$ ('=$ % >.%# 1%3  <#3  33'   ,,1%-'%$ %$
7>'% / (#!%' ', 33' 8%.

+.% ++ + ', %!    ('  =$ %  9, '  .1  %  '1  %+%  + ' ('=$ %",'8,.%.  :%+ '$ %,. %'<3+,.% ,%'$%++ 9,,%+'+%

     !" !# $# !% !!% & # '( ('()*#' +%'( !%*'

'+ ,-'+,&#'( , !%) '.% #'!$'

#      %   ,#  $'  +'(  +"

, '!# (  '()*#-'  & ,#'! &'+!''( # ,

'  '#!&+!'#  '  ' &,('(  '  +!

'  '(

+!+#/ ",  < !  +       1%$  +  !%#  !1'    , . %@%!%+ '+('=$ %9,%%   %'$%  ++   8    ,  13        +#  ,3 ..

3$9,%*9'%,%'<3+,.%,1%3 %+ <9,%.

+ ()+. %8!+% .%5C"%3"%3  ,$'%$ %31, 1%3<9,.%<#1!13 ,@ 9%1 ,

,%.%#%?'%+ < 3.$+*,.%8%.

+,! 3%$#%$+ , 33' ++ !+7>'% / +  .% ++    + '  ,  . %@ %! % 3 ,  .

  ('=$ %  %$<#,%.!%$ ",'8,%

  ! $     1%3    + '1  ,  . %    (' =$ %<#,%.

() % %$%+ '$ %,%.

+'<3+, .

$#+ ,<)<#,%.

() %!9, ' 1 ('=$ %++ '('=$ % ,#,!%!+ 3.$%1%+1('=$ %
+!+'$ ' 1.%,$++ 9%' ++'$11% 9% 1  .%     ",'8  %.

+  .% ++    + '  , 113 %,+!+'$('=$ %%3+>1 ('=$ % >.%# ,%1%3:%+ '$ % ,%.

+%$+ ,+ .+:7 

 / .+<#,01, '% D'+'%=% 3, '+139 .

+%. %+ 9,,%+'+%

 '!%!%% '

, ' +&'#,  !%) '.#&$"!! !% !!%'( ("'! !%)&#'## * +,!

!# #'+'! +!$ ## ' !% #' "

,0  '  "

,0  , !'#%   1%  )&#'## * +,!

!#'( ( '+""##'$ ## ' !% !

!# ,+0 +#' #!%!%!%) '.&, ,. ! +'!'&! '( ( )&#'## * +,!

!# !% !% $2+! % '( '

'+ ,'+,&#''!3'+!%

'!"'! !%

,, '!# #+'! +!& , &,0 '+""##'$ ## ' !%

+!!% !!%

,, '!# % 2' !%)&#'##* +,!

!#.''(,,!% !"#  '  +' !'#  !%  + ''!  $  '0  ,  

"##0#!

, #'' #"

 ! '0#!

(1% '( ("'! # &,0+'! +!& ,'+""##'$ ##

'

!%&# +&, $!"'

!  ! '0 '! !"'

!"#   !% ("'! '! & '1%   !%

,, '!#% '2&#!

 + &#!'.!%4! 

5  '

02&# +!' !%#
&!6, '+# , + & '2& ("'!# !%'7$,3& "
&!'!% + ## 3!

!  ' !%# '

,8 # ,

9:

 3

5

;3!

! ## #<= '

!% > #    #   5    3

 95;  '  ?#  ) ' &#!

'@! <33% @ ,A'! ##@! #    3



  1%B&#!'!$4 "' #% !# !%  '

!&    !%  "

,0"'!C  1%  +##  

'!"'! )&#'##* +,!

!# #'!

! '!% $ ## !%
+&,  !%6#) '. -'

!

5!%8 '& 0  1% & # #!'#&( !

'+ ,  '+,&#'  '  !  '+ #  &! +%    !% ) '.'(  3+!  1% 
+&,   !#,  +'!"

, ! '( ("'!    )&#'##  * +,!

!#  ' 

0"'!  

 #'

$,  +""##'  -!  #  !%

!  !%  ) '.

++&, !  3+%"'  D ,  1%3+%"

,#+'!"

, ! 

0"'! +""##', !'(! .  " -'!% !#"'!##& !%#'

"#!% !!%)&#'##* +,!

!##% ,,$+'

 #!

!&# (&, "

,0# ! '0#!

(D !#,+!'

!% ("'!4+&!  ( '#%#!% !!# +'! +!

 ,"! !"%+%+ '$4!'   "!"! !" 1%#   # + ++' !' !% ! !% )&#'## * +,!

!##% ,, +! # ''  ' '!#+  

' #% ,,'!$ " !$ ' ('! !%) '.

4+ !'# +! ! '# +!'#?#+#%+%( #!'+

,D('!, !'#% $0"

,+ !'!% #&+%  +' !'#  '  !%  ,+0  ++&, #  '  '  !%

("'!

!%#+# !%

,, '!# '!%'($&!

&,0  +'! +!& ,    4    '  ' 

+""##'+# ' '(!.  " -'!"#  !%+' !'#'!% ("'!

!%

,, '!# '!

'!% ('!# !%) '. '  '  ' '!#+

 

 1%  !%

,, '!#+ ''!+, "!% 

'0(%! "

,0"'! ( '#!!%) '.!%'$ ##   +!' "##0#!

,'!"# !% +'! +!/ *9$ '<3+,9 $# %'$1%3 <9,. %+,%.

()",% %8. %, %1,  ',3 ('=$ %
+!+'$ %, .'%.

 +,%11,+'%$1 $ 3% 0%+$%+ '$ %,.% %'$ 7>'% /8!+,%$  33' <9,,;%$1% -'%$('+ ,,;%$1% %$(+ , 33' ++  
7>'% / %+%.

+,)+ 

+ ',. %('=$ %
+!+'$7.%, 1%3%+ <9,. %+,().%'$%$# .%5C"%3"%3 9,,%+'+%

 

:  1%  ("'!  #% ,,  $   ,   

  '0  "!% ! !#4+&!' '

"

0$'  #&+% &!%  # #"

0$ "&!& ,,0 ( $!'!%

!# : 1%) '. #,, #3#% ,,% (%!

!!"'

!!% ("'!$0('( "'!%'!+'

!'(!!%!%

!0-'!%'! !"'

!'

!% ("'!$03 ,,+ '

"

!''+,& '( +&"'!#!+#% ,,$!&' $03!!%) '. #

'#!&+!'# !%) '. :  1%  ) '.  #% ,,  %    (%!  ! !"'

!!% ("'!"" !,0$0('( '!+ '!'(!3'!% ,,'('!& ,!#

  444 4444 : -'!%'! !%!"'

!' !%

("'!  $0  !%  ) '.  &#& '!  !  +, &#  : %'

$ 3#% ,,$, $, ' # '#$,!!&'

,,  + #  '  '

"

!'  '  !#  ####'  # '# ( &' +, &#:  $/ ", %+1%3.'$,9$$< %,.% +

 #%+'%,%9 '$+<%9+ 3''$1%3<9 ,.%+,! %3  1%383 ,@  %?'%+ <1!9%1<#,% ,.%#+$ ()%%! ,%%1, %3,1%333+$#<#1!13 ,@     ,  ('  =$ %    ,  !'$  =%$#8  , %.

+  ()  ,     +  '.

   33'   ++   
7>'% / ,> + '1,. %@%!<# '1+!+'$ %+%<#, 3.', %# * ,%9 %+8 . %  ,  <  + '+  %$$#  % 3 ,  ('  =$ %  +$#8,%.

+,!! $+.%5 ,1%3='%,% .%'$ .% , 33' ++ ,13 ,%.

(),!%!+ 3.$%1%+1(' =$ %
+!+'$ ' 1.%$++ 9%'  +  +'$11    %  9% 1  .%   ",   33'   ++  ,<..$+ $$,('=$ %
+!+'$ %. 9,,% 3.$,!<%!+1$). % % * ,%9 %+,% $ ..$  3+",% %8,  33' ++ 9,,,<)  +% %,.'%.

 + '1,. %('=$ % ,1,$#%<%%#+9, '..$  3++$<$ <+

: + %+1$#8+ ",%.

+@'<3 ,+$'9 +%+ <#,01, '% D'+'%:7 

 /%'$

.%+ 8 9,%, '%,>3+%. 9,,% ,% ,.%,!'+  % ()9,,%%!, %1, %3,1%3<#1!1 ,< 3.$+9, '< 3%+9$  +'+9,,%"%3+"%3 %+ <9,%.

()+('=$ % '$+ <1 %+* ,%9 %+.%5 1%39 ,'< 3% +9$   +%++% +",% %8,++ +

#3%%. ,.%7 %+1$#8, < !   ,%.

(),%<#% +  +$$ 9+ ",%.

+%,%<#+%+

)..% .%+ 9%1+ 33'<# $$ 91.%5

,1%3,#+ + ',%! ,. % '%1,%!1.% +8. %%$+ %3 %#< ",3,$$<$'$+++<'%+ ,. %9,.% +

 3 , 7,18$%+ '$ %,%.

+'<3+, . %9%..

+  33 < ",% %8?'  >+1#%%%<+  % *,!8. %% $+ %  ,.  -.

+%,%<#+%+ .#
/8B  , ,. %9,.% +  3 ,% 3 +# =$19,,. %%$+ %E5F.%'3% 3, + $1, 7,18$%+ '$ %,. %'<3+,

9 %%%%%%?'%+ <$+<#,%.

()*, %1%+8 %+(%,1%,% 33++,+' .+#

$1 8  ,<)<#,%.

+", %+ %.

+%,%<#+%+ ) %. %%%9,, + <+' ,. %*,%1%+8 %+%.

+ ,%<#+%+ >+3 %#<,. %% ,%9 $1<$ % ..)1 %+%+ 33',3 , . %9,.% +  3 ,% 3 +#  

   !"#$"%  & '())* ,,%.)1B% +

GB

,,%-.

%<$

GB