High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1476/2017dismissed

Ishwar Singh v. State Of Haryana

2017-09-19Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul7 pages

!"#$ %%%&'' ("

) #'!' *!"+!!

%%% , '

- - !./).!"

%%%&'' ("

) #'!' *!"+!!

%%% , '

-- .&!"0!

%%%&'' ("

) #'!' *!"+!!

%%% , '

11111 &" ' "

# # !",)"234 !' "','' "

5!6 "#$!!6234 !' "','' "

- -

!,# )66234 !' "','' "

! 5! !62,)'+34 !'7"!62*!"+!! "'" , '#'!'

8 "" !66 ,

' ! ".' '" ".!6 "4 ,'' !

' !.!4!" "

.! ..

!' :)"#' -2 :2

!5 "! '#' &"$ '"!'& 6#'!' '+ !" !!2 '"' ; 4"2 !66 ' ,'' !4 < 6 !$! ' =)$.' !' :

<+ 6!" 3' !6 #

;)$2 ; "<+ !,,!6 6 <+ ' ,'' !$! ' ' =)$.' 4' !' ! "" '!'- ,!

<+6!"#)< 4 !6;)!6!$ '"!'2 !" !!2 !

'!.

'!' 4' ,'' "!./).!")"#' & !

* 4"2 " 4!6!"'+2''!6 "" <$ ,!

''6 !

!"# $%& '#( )")' "#*"%"

5"6+ '!'2 .,6!!'!./).!"

5 <!6!6 ! .,6!'< "' 66!>!!$ '"!' ''!4".'

" ,

?-' !" ' !$")6')"!6 6! .!

)"$ /!!6 .," /66!

??? ! ?? ')!' !' @06!! !2 !" !!

*!!6"!+

6 !"'

!A!62!=/).!"2!$<"

4 ! (+! 4 >)!6 !" 4 !6

: ! '"!'"2 ! " ' ' !. * 4"2 !)

!" #$2 !. /).!" A!.<"!" ! #!' /).!" 4! '! '"!

. '","

2 '!4 '

!.!$ ",)'!' ! " ' ,)",

!'$2 ! .,"

. '"

,6! ! "!))6'6+ $ 'B)' !6

!' : '"$!"'

' !6!!4 )" !)

!"#$ * 4"2' .,6!!'!4"$ '"$ '"' )< >)' !6 <+ ,)''$ !,,!"! < " #)<$ '"!"2 !" !!

3) !. /).!" <$ A!.<!"!" ! '!0 )) <' ,

' ! "

$6+ '' !.,

'"!

' .,6!!'

3) #!' !6

$6+ '' .,6!!'!,6!+"!)), .

'<!

! ! !6

!' :2 !)

!" #$2 <+ $''$ '

.)'!' !' 2 ! .! ! !''.,''

'!0 "<6,

"$!6 !.6+2

! A!6! '"

.' .,6!!'!!6"!+

6'6!'+!" ::

' <!

! ! .,6!'2 6!" 66!>! !$ '"!'2 6 B" $ ' , "

)" #' - "

& $ ' ' 9 >) ' "$ '"!$! ''!) #'!'.'

' '

"" "!!'" .,6'

4 '$!' 2 !66! )" #' "

& !

," ' ' )"'

, !66!2 !

4 !$ )" #' "

& 2 "

),,6'

'!) "

9$ ! ,".!! !

!$! ' ' !) 2 '+ " !"$ ' "' ..

,) !<6)"#'

"! ' ' 5 &<+'6!"'"!6 )"' 4 "" !' :

'+ ' ,6! $)6'+ ! 6!.'"!6 * 4"2)"$''"!62!) #!' !6'

!,,!"< "

''"!6 )"'! !

)6'.!'6+6!"!

6!. "<+' '"!6 )"'4 ""!' 3'" "$'4!!"$',!"' 2''"!6 )"'2 4 =)$.' !' 2 6 ' ,'' $)6'+ ! 4' " ..

)"#' !

"! ' #' 5 & 5 ' 2 ,'' "!) !. /).!" !

6$)6'+! 4' " ..

)"#'

"! ' #' 5 & ( ,!"!' "" !' - ,!

<+''"!6 )"'2','' " '!

)" #' #'

& 4' !. /).!"

6+ $ "

) .,"

.' " '" +!"

! '

,!+ !

2? ! !)6''" 2'

)"'")"$ "

#' ?5 & $ "

) .,"

.' " +!"! ,!+ !

-? ! ! !)6''" 2'

)"'")"$ "

'! #' ?5 & $ "

) .,"

.' " '" +!"

,!+!

2?!! !)6''" 2'

)"'")"$ " B.

! #' ?5 & $ "

) .,"

.' " +!"! ,!+ !

-? ! ! !)6''" 2'

)"'")"$ "

'! #'

?5 & $ "

) .,"

.' " +!"! ,!+ !

-? ! ! !)6''" 2'

)"'")"$ "

'! * 4"2' !

""'!'!66' )< '!'4 ' !66 ") )""'6+

3$$"4 !$! ' ' ! ".' =)$.' ! "" ,!

<+6!"'"!6 )"'2','' !,"""!!,,!6< " ' )"' #

2<)'' !. !

<+6!"3' !6 #

;)$2;4=)$.'!':

'!.

'!' 4' ,'' "!./).!")"#' & !

' ' ").

'! ','' !4!,,"

!' )"'<+6$'," '"4 ,''

3' ' )'

'2 6!" ) 6 " ' ,'' !4 ' !66$ 4' ' ,'' ! !4 '" " ,'4 !"$).'

>)!'>)!'). ' 6+ '!

< )<.'''!'!

!$! ' ' ! !" ' '" +!"

2 ,'' "

!" #$ !

!6"!+ )"$ .,"

.' " .

! !+ 6)$ ".

' ! !+

#.6!"6+2 ,'' " !. /).!" !

)"$ .,"

.' " .

!!+ 6)$".

!+ 2 "!

,'' " . &!"0!

)"$ .,"

.' " .

!!+ 6)$".

A!" ) 6 "','' !4)"'" ''!' !66','' !""

''. "

!'" '"!

,$ !$! ' '.

8+ !" ,

" ,"

! '+ !4 '

0 !'" '" ,'4 !.6 <$ '

6 <"! !""

8 ,'' !4 <

)"$ ' !$ + ".!6 ,"

$ :2 ' !' '9 >) ' !

"$ '"!$! ''.

8) 2'+!4,"!+ "")' ' ' ,'' '

'," !6"!+)"$ <+ '.

A!"#'!' ) 62 ' '"!2!

6') + "'!' ','' ' )"''

!+2 !"'!0 " " *!

' ,)'') + ','' 2<)' ,,

',6! '!0$6<"!64 2!

"! <+6!" ) 6 "',''

!4!"6!" ) 6 "',!"'

,") !6 '=)$.'

< '' )"'

<6 2' )"' ' " 4 '!' ' '"!6 )"' !

"$'6+ !,,"!' ' 4 " " 6 6$ ' ,'' $)6'+ " ..

)"#' !

"! '#' 5 & 8 !,,66!' )"' !

"$'6+

'" !,,!6 ' ! .

'!' 4' ,'' "!./).!")"#' & !

8" 66$!6'+ ","4"

'+'$ $4<+< ' ' )"'

<6 .!+ !""!''"" ' )"'<+4 0$ "4 !6 =)" ' C4 '" 2 6!" ) 6 " ' ,'' !4 '!

!6'=)$.'

4' !!42"!'"2" '"''" ,'4!"$).'

>)!'>)!'). ' 6+ 8 4' ' ,'' 2'" "2!". # !"!

) >)!'). ' "2!

," ' ) + "'!' 2 ,'' "

!" #$ !

!6"!+ )"$ .,"

.' " .

!!+ 6)$".

'! !+

#.6!"6+2,'' "!./).!"!

)"$ .,"

.' " .

! !+ 6)$ ".

!+ 2 "!

,'' " . &!"0!

)"$ .,"

.' " .

! !+ 6)$ ".

8,'' !4< )"$'!$ + ".!6

$ " ' 6!

' .

" '! +!"

' 9 >) ' !

"$ '"!$! ''. :

8" "2'!0$'

! )'',"

'"!''"!62!''

','' !'," ) + ','' 2' )"'6 '!' ' =) ' )6 < .'2 ' ' ! !" '

' ,'' ") '

' ," !6"!+ )"$ <+ '. )<=' '

,!+.'

2?!!

!' '

'!6"!+.,

), <+''"!6 )"'

""! "$6+ &") !6 ' "" ' !' - ,!

<+ 6!" '"!6 )"' "4!6 '!' ' !

<+ ' '"!6 )"' !

!6"!+<,!<+',''

8" "2'+<"6!

"' '2 ' ">)" !+ '" !

2 '" ,

'$ ! ".'

2?!2!

<+' )"'

' .!6!"'!'!

','' !6'

2?!2!

<+' )"'2'+ !66<6!<6'

)"$ '".!$,!"' '"" ,'4 ' D' ' ! ! .

' "" '2 ' ," '"4 ,'' '!

& ,+ ' ""<,6! '6 '" ' !

!"#$ % E!$)'' D'" ,!0$?"!

E D'", "'!<6