Rana @ Randhir Singh & ORS v. State Of Punjab

  

         

!"#$#%&'&()



!($+&,-&(.+!($"+#,'

#"&"&(#,'

/#,'0'

-"!"#0(1!2  #'3($#("

)  45  - 6 5-  ,#'#(")7 ,&8,!91&",,!:$;%!"#:,"+#3#"&"&(#,' ,'+&'+-!(.+&:#30"< 0(1!2  =+#"+#,"+# #3,"#,'*%!*(#>'3!3#,9!<2#!**>#$" '##"+#10$.9#("?

 2#,##,,#$""+# #3,"#,,("  =+#"+#,"+#10$.9#("'+0*$2#,#3,"#$&("+#$&.#'"? 77 77 5- 

5 +&',#;&'&(&'&*#$2<"+#3,#'#("3#"&"&(#,':(!9#*<: !(!

!*&!' !($+&,-&(.+:!220!*&!'!'2&,-(.+:&9*!!*&!'60*>!("6!0, !($!,"!3-&(.+!.!&('""+#10$.9#("$!"#$

 :3!''#$2<"+# *#!,(#$$$&"&(!*-#''&('0$.#:!,(!,!(:;&$#>+&%+"+#10$.9#(" %(;&%"&(!($,$#,'#("#(%#$!"#$@

:3!''#$2<"+#*#!,(#$

+&#0$&%&!*!.&'",!"#:!,(!,!(:>!'03+#*$:;&$#>+&%+"+#3,#'#(" 3#"&"&(#,'>#,#%(;&%"#$0($#,-#%"&('
:
A:
 '3#,"+#3,'#%0"&(%!'#:(

 :%93*!&(!("60*$&3 -&(.+>!'%9&(."+&'+0'#!"#,3!<&(.2#&'!(%#&(6+!$,-!+&2 0,0$>!,!"!20"):>+#(+#,#!%+#$(#!,+&'+0'#:!%%0'#$ !,"!3-&(.+!($ !(!:!,9#$>&"+'>,$:!220:!,9#$>&"+$!(.:&9*! #93"<  +!($#$  %(,("#$  +&9  &(  ,("    +&'  +0'#   &9*!  ,!&'#$ #B+,"!"&("%!"%++*$"+#%93*!&(!("!,"!3-&(.+.!;#!'>,$ 2*>:>+&%++&"("+#"+092,&.+"+!($"+#%93*!&(!("

7
7

!(!!*'.!;#'>,$2*>:>+&%++&"("+#&(.#,*#"+!($"+# %93*!&(!("  93*!&(!("60*$&3-&(.+#**$>( !,"!3-&(.+.!;# !("+#,'>,$2*>:>+&%++&"("+#*#"8(##1&("*#"*#."+# %93*!&(!("!220!($!,"!3"+#,#!"#,.!;#2*>'>&"+"+#&,,#'3#%"&;# >#!3('("+#*#"8(##1&("*#"*#."+#%93*!&(!("92!($ -&9,:9"+#,!($'&'"#,7&(7*!>"+#%93*!&(!(",#'3#%"&;#*<&("#,;#(#$ "'!;#"+#%93*!&(!("+#(: !(!.!;#!'>,$2*>">&%#"92:

>+&%++&"(+#,,&.+"!,9!($(#!,+#,%+&(%%0'#$!220.!;#!$!(. 2*>"92:>+&%++&"2#*>"+#8(##1&("+#,*#"*#. %%0'#$ !,"!3-&(.+.!;#!'>,$2*>,9&"',#;#,'#'&$#"-&9, '&'"#,7&(7 *!> :>+&%++&"(+#,,#+#!$ **"+#3#"&"&(#,'>#,#!%%,$&(.*< %(;&%"#$,'02'"!("&;##(%#'0($#,-#%"&('
:
A:
("+# !33#!*:"+#10$.9#("%(;&%"&(!($,$#,'#("#(%#$!"#$@

: 3!''#$2<"+#*#!,(#$ +&#0$&%&!*!.&'",!"#:!,(!,!(:>!'03+#*$ ""+#9"&('"!.#:"+#("&%#>!'&''0#$""+#-"!"#(*<C0! "+#,*#&9*!!*&!'60*>!("6!0, 3#"&"&(#,+#,#&( !($"+# *&!2&*&"<"+#,#9!&(&(."+,##3#"&"&(#,':(!9#*<: !($+&, -&(.+:!220!*&!'!'2&,-&(.+!($!,"!3-&(.+0($#,-#%"&(A !($ !*'("+#C0!("09'#("#(%# +!;#+#!,$"+#*#!

,(#$%0('#*,"+#3#"&"&(#,':"+#*#!,(#$ -"!"#%0('#*!($+!;#!*'%!,#0**<.(#"+,0.+"+#&*# "%9#'0""+!"&9*!!*&!'60*>!("6!0,>!''"!"#$"2# #93"<  +!($#$  !($  '+#  >!'  !"",&20"#$  #B+,"!"&(  (*<   -+#  $&$  (" 3!,"&%&3!"#&("+#%,&9#=+#("+#"+#,!%%0'#$%!9#!,9#$>&"+'>,$' !($$!(.':"+!">0*$9#!("+!""+#<+!$%9#,#!$<"%99&""+#%,&9# +#,#,#:3''&2&*&"<&9*!!*&!'60*>!("6!0,2#&(.!*'#*<&93*&%!"

77 %!(("2#,0*#$0"+#,#,#:"+#2#(#&"$02"&'.&;#("&9*!!*&!' 60*>!("6!0,!($'+#&'!%C0&""#$"+#%+!,.#',!9#$!.!&('"+#,0($#, -#%"&('
:
A:
 >:%9&(.""+#,#9!&(&(.C0#'"&(!"",!%"&(-#%"&( A !($"+#C0!("09'#("#(%#:!9"+#;&#>"+!"'3#%&&%&(10,< 0($#,-#%"&(
 &'!"",&20"#$"!%%0'#$!220!*&!'!'2&,-&(.+: "+!">0*$9#!("+!"!%%0'#$!220!*&!'!'2&,-&(.+&'"2#%(;&%"#$ 0($#,-#%"&(
 :>+#,#!'!%%0'#$ !($+&,-&(.+!($ !,"!3-&(.+!,#!*'"2#%(;&%"#$,#(%#'0($#,-#%"&(


,#!$>&"+-#%"&(A  +#'3#%&&%&(10,<0($#,-#%"&(
A &'

!"",&20"#$  "  !%%0'#$  !(!  !*&!'  !($+&,  -&(.+  !($  !,"!3  -&(.+ +#,#,#:  "+#<  !,#  ,&.+"*<  %(;&%"#$  0($#,  -#%"&(  
A   :  >+#,#!'

!%%0'#$!220!*&!'!'2&,-&(.+&'"2#%(;&%"#$0($#,-#%"&(
A

>&"+"+#!&$-#%"&(A +#'3#%&&%&(10,<0($#,-#%"&(
&'

!"",&20"#$  "  !%%0'#$  !(!  !*&!'  !($+&,  -&(.+  !($  !,"!3  -&(.+ +#,#,#:"+#&,%(;&%"&(0($#,-#%"&(
&'"2#9!&("!&(#$:

>+#,#!'!%%0'#$!220!*&!'!'2&,-&(.+&'"2#%(;&%"#$0($#,-#%"&( 
,#!$>&"+-#%"&(A +#10$.9#("'2"+"+# 0,"'2#*> '"!($'9$&&#$""+#'!&$#B"#(" >: %9&(. " "+#  C0!("09 '#("#(%#: "+# '#("#(%# ,&.,0'&93,&'(9#(", A9("+'!($D9("+'+!;#2##(!>!,$#$ 0($#,-#%"&('
!($
A ,#!$>&"+-#%"&(A ,#'3#%"&;#*<:&( >+&%+(&("#,#,#(%#&'%!**#$,-!,!'"+##(%#0($#,-#%"&(

 &'%(%#,(#$:"+#&(10,&#''+>"+!""+#,#>!'3!,"&!*!930"!"&( ,&.+""+093%93*!&(!("60*$&3-&(.+:>+&%+&'!"",&20"#$"!%%0'#$ !,"!3-&(.+(10,<
&'%9B
%9>&"+&("#,$&.&"!*90'%*#'%0"

7A7 *#"+!($&,'"$&.&" "+092 :%9'8&(("+#$,'!*!'3#%">!' &("!%"+#,#,#:8##3&(.&(;&#>"+#(!"0,#&(10,&#':!9"+#;&#>"+!" "+#'#("#(%#,&.,0'&93,&'(9#(","><#!,'0($#,-#%"&(

&'!$#C0!"#&('0%+%&,%09'"!(%#'"2#&(.':"+#,#;&'&(C0!&9*!!*&!' 60*>!("6!0, 3#"&"&(#, &'!**>#$!($'+#'"!($'!%C0&""#$"+# %+!,.#',!9#$!.!&('"+#,-+#2#,#*#!'#$,"+>&"+:&(",#C0&,#$&(!(< "+#,%!'#:>+#,#!'"+#3,#'#(",#;&'&(C0!!%%0'#$ !($+&, -&(.+:!220!*&!'!'2&,-&(.+!($!,"!3-&(.+'"!($$&'9&''#$>&"+"+# !2;#("#$9$&&%!"&(,#.!,$&(.%(;&%"&(

5-    



'18'