← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/7721/2018allowed

Sharwan Singh And ORS. v. Ut Of Chandigarh And ANR.

2018-11-29Mr. Justice Anupinder Singh Grewal7 pages

       

  

!

"#$#% & '

 

  

       

     

  &  ()  *

   *+ 

 !

"#$ % & '(   ')

#" '

'  (  + (   

*+ ,  -).

'

  (   ,  %   -.+  &  '     &    %,'

0& "& 1, '

* &  23 +44-+453 *   ,  %   -+4    5+467     "

%     %   53 '

'  ""% 1,

"( % * *'& /# '  &% /( /   $ 0     +84-+45.#'(   %  (( 0& '" 

" ,9""

  #& * *'  / % :  '*,  &'% /( / % /("

%' &# (  &'

&),

"  #'

' 5-4;+45.#'

0 % $# ' # '

0  %'

'( '

$"'

(, 0"!

' , !,, &",%#% %  (,

 '," 

/# 0<% $ * " & "* "!/  % % "' %

"% &"

%=

1,  "! ,'

( ("  '

$ & *'

' %' '<, ( %'  *' ( (!# *'  "

& "

0!  ' *'%, '/0!'"* "!/ ' $ " (, '% &"

%0  ( #'

$ *" $  & ' %

" # %

"'

/ ! ' % ! ,%'% 0 ", & / * $ '(  "'  (,0!% /( / # & % ,#% / * 

'%

"* "% 1,% "" $# ' % " (,  % "! %'/"$  "! (   ' (, / &' % (#% 1,% &&% '%

% % ' &&% % 1,%$,( ' % ! * '& #'"

(% 0(, '/#$(, '/ '>/(, '/# %", * '( "!& % " %  $#/  &' '% $ " (,  6 % &"

%  &    (    & /  '/"$    % "  (%

'& #'"* "!/("

!/(   "$'% &"

%0 

( :

''  ? &, *'

' $ /( % & (, 1,  % ! "

* / @7, ""'%    "$' % &"

%0   0!(, *   '& #$'%

1,  * $,*  '

' &'(   (, % * @ *'

( % (" "!#'

"* "!/ " ( $ & 

% * @ *  ' % /( /   0        &   % "  (, % A+4 >(( $ '

*  '

%   "!( $ & % /( , *, *'

"#0,(/ % /( , * $  ((""

 $ " * $0! $! , % (# % A+4%  0' "(   !: ' '% *   % /( / 0 '

$:% "!: 0% &  '

% "

 "! ' &&%(% 0,'

 " 

'  " /  &&%(% 0 ,  $ ' &&% >  * ' /   & / /  /#/ ?

*' >  * &&% 0"

*'  * $ /  &( & & &&% 0 *% *  $  &%' " * " $ %/

'

%  1, '& " ?

*0! % A+4  % * '% /( / 0   (,7,



' % ! &'( %,(% 0& % "

":'

 ,%  0(/   $"0! '% ((% 0,'

( %,%'&  $ ?

*% -.+0!' *'

 , 7,#    0$  0 $#  '

'  & "! (     ' % " (, ," 

!0,&&  /  % "

$  &'( #"

 ,0"&&%:' % ,% ,"'

$"& 1, ' % ! "

* '& ' &&%% // 0!( 

$ "$ * $ %   &  %1, * &&

"(  

'

">% * && %( %  0(/  0% /( /  = ?

#  $  '  &&%  $ "$ *  "!    ( $   ( #  0, &"% *( $ ! &%'

%  $ "$ *% , *  ""  &"

& % , *  ""  &( (!0!> * // '  &"  &  "

&:  %    0  (/     0  % /( /   >%(  '  0 $6 / * $ &&%#' $!  '

 "" ' &&% ' ,"0(/  0% /( / 0!' , %'( & & &&%0& ' ,#

," $ "$'% ,% &'( 

(,#'&  &' ,  (/ ' / 0% /( /  ''(  ," ("

! %?,( ' , ,'

%1,  " & %%,0!,0$ *'   &% "<, %   $ '  &   &% "<, % & % '% @ "    (' %? * 0("

!,(  ,  ,0$'<, %!/   ,"

!0 '  &<, %

"&:'

'% /( / 0  % * @ '% @ /

  /     % //     '  

"  &  '  !/  &

  &<, %# " #1, '  &&%# '

%''  &  % !  (/  0% /( /   B0"',(/ ,'

/("!%"

& '"* "(    % * @ *% /( / * '%  &

 



   

  !" '

 0$ ,6 

      



  

       

             !      "

 

 #





                      $

%&'  

   

   

 

 

 (





 

  "

   

  

     )*+ ,

   #

 +

,        

 (

                        !("

         

    

     

     

 

       (    - "



  -  

 

    

(      

 

   

(   

.- -

(-  



 (    

 

/ 

(   

 

$

 

      

    

 ($ 

 (-(   

  



  

       

  

. 0

 



1      

( 

 



 .

    

( *

      (  

             



       2            

   (   

 (

  

 

  

   

    - 

  (

  

    -   -

-

-     

.  

    



     ( 

  (-   

(

   





(     

      

 

  



 

   (      -    

  (       

       

  -            

    

- 



(  





 . 



          

 # "



#

              (  

            

  

        

     



 

 

  -  

 

 

 

     (  

 

 #

  



         



             

    

  

 

    

   

         #

-



          

  

        

+ ,

   

-      

  

   

 

 

#

          3

'(%   & "" !  &'>%( $ *

0 $  %#    $  &  '  (   &  '

&  ),

"    # '

'    5-4;+45.#   /     (,, %  &  '     +84-+45.( 0!'

 ,#' ,&"'

 ,&,"(,( 



,"0$0!?( *'( % * $

""0 '  &<, %# &'"/ %'0  %%( %%  *"!#'(( ""

 23  +44-+453 *   , %   -+4   5+467     "

%   % 53'

'  ""% 1,

"( % * *'& /# '0  &% /( /   $ 0  '0!

1, '1, '((  -  *+ .

 ' $ ''( ?

*9  C ''(  0"C