Santosh Devi v. State Of Haryana And Others
!"!
#$ %
&
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TRIBHUVAN DAHIYA
!
" #$%% &&'# #
%% () * TRIBHUVAN DAHIYA
#$%% # +"%( ,%- .% "/0 #%- #
.#+*56- #(*"% ! 0 # * ' $ % ! # $ "
! ) $( *0( 23378" # 9#23370(:;
# + % #$%% < "0# .% "
# + 0-# %!%-#$ - #$%% #(*"%
!" .( * $#0( 2 $"
! #$%% :#0+
+ 31371=73 .
$$ % !%! % # !# ( 0!
% $ 27111=>?0" 0 (* % .#%(% %! 3=37233@ ( %- +#% #$%% A.% . . % < # % #.
$
) %-#!# ( ) #% B C% $0 )00- "#% # $%% /0 # $ " 56- !
! $ $$ % # #0( .# .
+ 14311==1 B" * !%% #/0! 0( + , #) %"%
#23370(" -% %-"% ! # $ " !
$( * C! #$%% :!
" ! $ $$ % #- 0 #0( $ % " %#.
#" ,
0+% $ " % "#23370(" "% ! "
₹2@( ! 21 %! #% " ## ! .
+ #%*6"% * (# " *6%-#* " - #$%% +!
%( !% #(*"% !% "0(@81;8+; "#2337 0(" .( * /0 ( # #(*$ * # (( .
!# . 0( # + . +* # ! $( * . # $ % A(- ( %!%# - .
C!
% %$0-
#- 0 "% !.
%%+(
##
(
*+-%-"
%(*$% ?
#% "
!0 ( $ %% ( ! 0( " # $%% ! # #C!% %
%((- #$%% %%( #(*"% !% "#23370(.#%!#$ % #
(($ %-!
"56- ! #% " %"%!
% "# 0(.%((+! #0 !! %-(* #!( %! 0( # +C! #- 0 #$%% .
.%-"
%(*$%
4 ( ! 0(! # #!( %# +%-#(*C! % "!( %$0( % %0(@82; "#2337 0(# "
%(*# ((+(%-%+( !% "
%(*$% (* "# $% 0%-.#%!#%%!% %-"% ! -! $( #% # ( +!( %"% +*#) 1731233=# %# !
.# %
* A) 0%*
* 8
A) ; # +%0 $% 313>2337 % #
.#%!##23370(.
+( # 0( .%(( $$(* # $%% 06 %$0 (*#
+ !% "
%(*$% $% 313>2337 @ 0+%%
+*( ! 0(" #$ %# + ! % 7 # $%% : #0+
% (* % % # 3=37233@ .##.
+.#%*6"% " *6%-#* " - # !! 0 #$%% #
+ !% "
%(*$% .
+" #/0" 56- ! ! $ $$ % # % 0 # 233@ 0( ! 0( + "% ((* !%
# ) %"% #23370(.%#""!" 313>2337 !
" ! $ $$ % ( " #(*"% ! 0 #.0( .
C! %#.%# #- 0 # #
(
*+ !% "
%(*$% $% %"%!
% "# 0( #(%-# "#"
! #%0 %%-" ! % % %
9
& 71 !% #%0 %% $ " 0(@ 7 "# 23370( .#%!# 0 @ 81; # # " * ) $( * # "
%(* "#$( *. 0( ! %0 !% "%
! 0/0 ( #$ * # (( .
!# .
.+*# ! $( *%# (! 0 .%# 0 %%- $!%"%!!( %6 ;" $% ""%"* " #
" # "
#$( * %"#$( * #% "#% ##
% # - "#%*6"% * < 8+; " $% " .( * %(( #
# $( *. 0( # % " ) %! %%-# - "0$ 0 % .#%!# %(
%"#$( * #% "#% ##
%
- "#%*6"% * +0#
% # - "
" *6%-#* < 8!; " $% " * %(( #
# $( *. 0( # % " ) %! %%-# - "0$ 0 % .#%!# %(
%"#$( *#
% # - "" *6%-#* 82;#"
%(*# ((+(%-%+( !% "
%(*$%
$# (0( (* "#$% 0%-.#%!## !% #"% ! + %! $( 8?; 8@;555 555555 7 (($ %-!
"56- !# ((+!
0 #.0(#!
(!0( % "#$% $ * # ((+
0!#!
" #
" %"%!
% "
#0( . #"
%(%.%((# # $% $ " #(0$056- $ % %#0( 233? 233@ #!
*+ %(%0 "# #(*"%
! $ % 0 # * ' $
% ! #$ "#! ) $( *0( 2337 72 + $0 ( " # 0( # . # # "
- $( * #%A#"
%(*.%((! %0 !% # $ *
(( .
!# .( .+*# !
"% ! $0+6!( 08 ; 0+60(81; 0(@ %!
#% " # #$( *#
% # - "#%*6"% * #%"
%(*. 0(
+%( "% !" "%"* < $0+6!( 08+;
% !
$( * #% " #.
+ #%*6"% * ( # " *6%-#* " - #"
%(*. 0( -"% !"
$% ".( * %((#$( *. 0( # % %%- # - "0$ 0 % .#%!# .
( "% !"
$% " * %((#% " ! $( * .#%!# .
( . 0( +
%%+(%!
$( *#
% # - "
" *6%-#* #% " #0+60(2$ % # #"
%(* . 0( +%( !% "
%(*$% $ (0( (* " ! $(% "#$% ""% ! 0# 0(7$ % # (($ %-!
"(0$056- 0 #233? 233@ 0( # (( + ! 0 #23370( " $ * " #(* "% !#0 . %.%((+$ * +(" #
"
%"%!
% " # 2337 0(< # % # "
%(* # + $ % $% $" (0$056- $ % 0 # 0( "233? 233@ " #(*"% !0 #2337 0(
7? %$0 (* #% " %"%!
% "#23370( 313>2337 # $%% : !
" $ * " (0$ 0 56-
!A- " ₹2@ ( ! .
$ %-! % % 0 # # 5%%-233@0(0( (* $0(7#$ .
/0%
! % %" #(*"% !0 #.0(6#2337 0( .#%!# #
+
+( # $ %- !
,%- 6%"% (- 0 # ( 0( %#.%# +" ! % %- #.
/0% +-% $% .###.
$" (0$056-
" %- #$ .#%( C!%- # !
" ! $ $$ % %-#.
*
%! # 0+% $ " " "% ! "₹2@( !#% % % ( % " #
" # 2337 0( ! /0(* 00 % +(#
.
! % #!
" #+"%0 #.0( $ % ##
!# !( %+"%0 # (
0(<%
#$ #% . .%# 0-% %- $% # $%% ! % #!
0 # ( 0(+* %!%-# 0+%
!0" ( " 6%(0$0- .#%!#"((" 0( "0(7 "#23370(D###("/0 !% # #(* "% !0 #.0( %.
( !(% % # %$0-
% - % "#23370( 74 0# # %- " C!%-#$%% :!
" #+"% " #(*"% !0 #23370(% ""
%(*$% #$% %"%!
% "#0(#%% ( 0 % +( - ""
%(*$% ! *+ 0$ #
' - #(*"% ! 0 # 23370( 0(@82; (* %$0( # .# # + ( #(* "%
!.%((+(%-%+( -"
%(*$% (* "! $(% "# $% ""% !% "#23370( . "% !.
-% #$%% $%#%(0 0( @ %!0 #% + # "
%(* $% #
+ !% # $% %"%!
% " # 2337 0( %# # %$0- #.% " *$ %% %# 0($ %-( " #(*"% ! .# # +-% "
%(*$% $% %"%!
% "#0( #% %0 % :%-# -"
%(*$% 0 $% 0( .(( "% !0 # 2337 0( +*#%
# % 0(*! 0 !! %-(* %%#( %!
.# %-%-"
%(*$% $% %"%!
% "#23370( $ - #(*"% !0 #23370( #A#.%(( + %( "
%(*$% " # 0 % ""% ! % .%(( %0$ 0%-0+%! ""% ! (* + # " " # % ( $% " %( #
$% .%((+ #
%%+( #
" % .%# % (+"%" #$% "#% 0#%. 0( -% ""! # $ %% "0(@82;
.%#0(7 "#23370( 7@ !! %-(* # $%% .# .%# +$ #(* "% !0 #23370( %#( %( #
0+C! # -%- "
%(* $% " # 0 % " "%
(
!#$% .%((+ (*" #% ($% "
%( "#$% ""% !- E
%. " # %!0% # $%% % (( . # %$0-
% % #$ %!
! % #(*"% ! #$%% %#
" % $%( ( # # "
#!
*+ .%#% # "%5$!$
0" # 0
%((#
" !0 ($ *# %!% +!
% 0.%#%" 0., "!% %- !%"% ! $* "#% E1
% ( !( %"% #$%% % %( - "
%(*$% 0%-#$% " #(*"% ! # 0
(
*$ #+*.
* ""
%(*$% # ((+ 0!
C0
- %# #(*"% ! +$ % "#% E2
#"
! !%!0 ! "#!
## ((+ ! >
%- %!(( 0 % 8;
%" * ( 8;
%$ " )TRIBHUVAN DAHIYA* 12122324
!
" !# " !#