High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/527/2007allowed

Naresh Kumar v. Sham Lal And Others

2025-02-10Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma12 pages

!"

#$%$!&'

( (

'

)*

+( + + +

!"# $

%

&&&& + + (

*

'

(

) * '!

'+ ,++- '--

'.//)%

$ () $* 0 1() 23

*

4 !

5+ +++4"

* -6

7 )%

+/ +8 ,++,

,

9

)%() :

: ) %

+ +++ *

+*+ + !

(

4

)%() ;

:*) ** !5++4" ; "

3 (

% )% <586 )% 0=< "-/3

)% % ) *%*

% ( )% )'++6 #

7 * ;2) $ > ,-.

&/ !

+ 1.

2( * &

0-$ 5,

6 +# .

7(

3 ; () % * * * * ( %

)

) ?

!"# $

% %*

)% () *% )*

4 ( %

#

-

() *% !+++4"

):*) @

< A", B 7

) C

% )%586 )% ; )% =< "-/

*)% )C @

*

4 ** ) < 7 D * 586 )%D

)

*

% ***%*

!&% 8- &.9:

,$% "-&#$!& .

5$% 1$.$9 %,!-.5 0 %% %% 5

% ;((

))%;2) $ > ,-.

&/ !

+

1. 7 %-/0

< $ *E )% %

*** % *

% )% ) * *

% %

( < "

'?

>

<

! " " " " #

$ ! F /

@ ;2)

<$ -05 2 +$&=, >%( .$ &# & 0 .

&%-0 &# !4/ &9 *5(

% & " '(!

"

"

)* + ,)*

"

" ' -

. - / ( $ " .

" 0

"

1

.2" " "

#

, 3 ( '(!

. 0

(

'(!

" $ ! 4

$ !" "

!

5 $ !

& " " #

7 88888888888888888888888888888888 .

() % *

* * * ( 9 * $

+*

*?

+ '+

;2) $ ***

)% (

<$ @ A-4 >%( @ A-4

&5 &!, 0

+-/0 4 !-0 % %

<

"

'9

("#6

:;(; < "

" = " >

"

"

>

= " >" ( "

"

"

:/! ? /

& ?

@ "(&A#63 /!03"A .

$ !:& <2 "#66:#</!!# - 5 "#63 (!*3<

+

:

< B= " C " "

"

" = :

<2 : <

" + : <2 D :< 2 :

<E = @4 :F . < :

<. "

>

:<2 : 1 < : <2 =

: < & " :

<":

<: < :

< &

"

" :

<:<":

<":< : < " =" : 1 < =

=== === === ===

! :

<( : <" :

<

"

" := "

" < :

<

4 =

> =

=

:

<

"

" " "

"#$

%

%%

&

%

% '

()(+

" " 0 A 0

14 ( .; " >

> >

0

#

" " ! + <( +A 0"

14 <2 :# <+ A *

14 <' +#3 <2 +:*

=#3<+ A 6#"

14 '

(*(+

0 " A 0

14 $

$

$

"

3 ! + <( +A 0"

14 <2 :3 < +A )3

14 <' +#3 <2 +:)3

=#3<+A *"6"

14 '

(+( +

)

B ( "

"

3

(

>

"

3

+ <'

B +A "

14 <2 :3

= < +A *)

14 <' :) < +# <2 +:*)

=# < +A 3""

14 G@ +

:(< :-<

& :!< ( ? '

: <H ''

;2) $ , ' +- .

/0 C B + BD E '-- '-!"

'-/

'.// * "

B *<

G 0C3 ** G 0$3

* )

%* G 0B3 )* % < G 0=3 @ * * 7)G"

%<% ( 7 * "

>

"

= &

"

" " = A #"

" A * "

A #"

- 4 > 4 5

>

#

5 7 ',

;2) $ 1 .

1&

$+- "#"#)+2"34 "

%3

> = +

% %(5(

%(6(D

)0 @ & ! 2 /

I "

) #3 (!J )3

:/!< & * " ! -

/ 9 :/< I .

! ( ")

6(!J #)6 :/!< & #4) " ;# ; =

/ ! " " ;# ; ;#3; -

%

%

%78 & "

J ' KI ") # (!J# ##:/!< / ?

(. K( ") #3(!J636:/!< 5= J : < +

, & (

"

+ :

< "

D :

< 2 D :

<

D :

< ' = > D :< 2 =

, G H

C " / ?

: < >

& "

=

" 1 C

#L ( ) ##J ) #0

+ ,, % + :

<

:

<

:

< :

<

0"* K :< : <

:

<

5 = " / ! - "

= E " #0

/ ?

: <

"

5 " "> 0# #

>

@ & ! 2 : <"

#:

<"

"

$

"8 & " 6 J M : < I

" "

6

! +0,+-9'0,

" "

" + :

) 2 :A #*"* =#)=0# #1#

A 6"

#"63 E :

< A *"6 "6 ' = "

" A # "*"

*14 2 A "

"

2 "

A #"

"

A )"

"

A *#"6"

0#14

" " A *#"6"

0#14 6

* '!

# )%;2) $ ) 7 *

'!

'+ ,++-

*% (

"

" "

+0( !( 5% !4/ &% $!& F 05 5 '

%# !+++4" ,

@ ?+6 ',++4"0?+6!+++3 !

# 5+ ?++4"0?,++<',3 ?

*

)% 5+ ?++4"

'/ -

*

.

+8 ,++4"05+ ?++H'/3

< ,8 -!?4"

/

* , 5+ +++4"

.

* , ++ +++4"

'+

( * ,+ +++4"

''

$* , ++ +++4"

',

, ++ +++4"

'!

5+ +++4"

'?

!

.

!4/ &% $!& %(B:<:D <G ( 4!-& F 05 5 ,

0$1-& .

!

5+ +++4"

'-

&, &# 5

4!-& %( : <:D <G

B:<:D < : : '?

)% ;2) $

; *.

. 6

B <. 0

.$ , $

+

+-/0 4 !-0 % % :

"

*I.6 * E '5

( "# $

%

*() %7 * ( () )

*

4

(

4

):

() ()%# $

% 7 )% () '!

'+ ,++- '-

(# $

%)% ) ,+%

%7 * '/ +8 ,+,? @ J '-/,,++8 )%$ '8

*

%

+ +

( ( 4 A :*4" :* :* A ) K4