High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1427/2019allowed

Swati Kataria v. State Of Haryana And Others

2025-07-04Ms. Justice Kirti Singh10 pages

!" #

!"# $"

% &'%( () ( % $ &'(()*+&,* ! )*&"-. $" /0*1 22222 ) (* 3" .#((4 # - $ # " "" * #5! # $$(. " . 6

''4#$- $" ""(..

" "

"5! #("&""(

7 "4*(. 5489/0 "" 0* ". 66*6:*6 *6:": 09*4 " (.&

"#*( ;#5. ('<#. ## 89 4 " $ .'$(

5'" 5! # $ 0 0* ((44 # # # $ " # '(! #" 5 .4 . #

' # #"

# ..

" $ # #$ # 4.

( ( (" " 5! #' 0##$(4##'# #"45.) (

$- 4##- #.$ $("#4.

( ( ("* #! $$#"" # #! 54 ((" " # #!

"#"5.)"

#-((4*#-#.(''"#

.#4.;#$4".#.)#"'4" #.*# # # '5$(#"4.#')

() 4 9 # # $"# '.#"4"

#'.4*# #" #.9

5'"# # ((4"(! =5 ="5#4# 4# (4 # /" 4#* , "( 4#* 9"> 4# (4 # # # $ $ ((" # $ #." "

(4# 4# *#'# #$

#" '#. .

#* $#.# "$ 4#* "$ 4#* 9"> 4#* ""* , "$ 4# " # $ (4#" ' # .* # "$ 4# " ?() )(( # '# # $* # # .)" # " .) " -5!#.#(#$ ( '( "5!#..

"*#! $ $4(4#.'4' " -#.( ;#$ #'" . .(( # 5#* " # $'#-""#$(4## '# ) (.( # $( ' # #! .-( # $(*(&'5 (.+ #..(."#'# #$* # ",9*5 #$.# 4# "'" 8 $(* #(* ' # #

@ (! '-" ?"') $( 9((! # - 44 4.! 6 .. . (" 4 # ' # '# # $ ."" # #" 5 ".(" # $ $ 5! # ". #(*#("44#89*.#(( $ "(!4 # ..

" "$ 4# #( (( # # ..

" $ <"5!#- 444.!;#$#$$.#" # * )4 # - 4* $

#.# #

6 - 4#. "5!#+.,((. # ' = * ! ! "4 # - 44 $ ' # = * #.# (!

5'" : 6 * # $ #" '-" $$(. " . 6 )4

''4 # $- $" ""( ..

"* #.# "

"-"'$ 4"""" &44-"5!# ' #$# ("#$ $ 6 9 #

#$##$$(.("5! #$ ".6 # 54(!"

"5!# (";( 9

5'"## '#$ ( # '# # > "

# " ..

. .""5!#(";( *"#!(

5>."# .

<'*#.##!# ""

$$"#. # $ .

A*#$$(.

''4$- $" # ""( ..

" "

" 5! 5 -4 # #" 5 ((!'-""(!" 4#$(4#(9

5'"##(";( ("). "# .##$$(. ("# 4(!# # # - 4@ #$ 89#"5$"4## $.(.' =.#*"#$ *(( $ *<$.4"'$( - 4 " .$4 # # $$ " ..

" (" 5 " (!#.' #!.''"4 #$"#'#* #.# (! "" #$$ B # # 5 - # (" ;( 4"4 # 54 '( '$-' # - $ "5!#$*

5'"#89"5 .!.($"- *" "5 "(" #"$

'"5# 9# . *.5 5. "# #'". #. #89"# '! # $ " # '# # $ . * #.# . (" #- 5 #'

(! . " " " 9 #

5'" # # 5 -#(";( ##..

"'" #89*.( 5( "'5"4#899 #

5'"##$"#'##".4.((!'"((# ..

" $ " " 4" $.. ( #'* " # #

( "

$$"5!'".(-".#'? #$"#'#;#$

5' ##$ $

''4""(..

"*(!< .'#$'. . "

5 *#.# .((!$ # . .*(". ($$45#(#$- $"

5' ##(";( #"4#(!"

"# $$(.'-"5!#$

''4#$- $" (!#"5("5(" 4##".-". 54"-."*5 ( ..(!5 -"#'$ 4""#

)4#

''4 #45 # 4#* .# 4(4 . . " '( '$-' # - # $ 9 #

5'" # # $$ " ..

" <"5!#$(.)4.. ((#-".*.( "4 # .(( "( " '5( (. '((!* - # ( $

5'"5! #'= *#$- $" ".*..(

#.# -"')4"$"

>- 4"<'4#

( #$(!4$#

: #.## $" #"((4(! "4;#*#$ $" - 5"

" : ?" . ( #( (!4 $ # . # $(! ""

5' # (( # ..

" $ >" - 4"-#$(!4$# ."

."54 . *## "5$ -" # ( (! ..

""$4# $'. "4 (!"# " #*.(("( "(.#$$ "..

"5"" .'$"#..

""$4#*# "#.(( '" 5! #'* # '5( $# # ..

" "$ 4# # # (. ( # # $(. # ((4" ..

.9 #

#((#$- $" #".(" . " # - # (" ;( "

" # $$(. #

''4 ""( ..

" -" # '$ 4" """ 0 "#

'""$

"#> ".(((4 ##."#( = $."4 #* $ " .

# 5 - '" 5! # C5( $' ' . > "4' + .

4 # .$ . 6 * # =.# C5( $'

"## (""#% D : ".6 " .!" <"!$9 5<. " $4(!"(! # . ##..

. #. 9 5<. "5.

#4 #

7 "4 #$# '#$ '!( 54 (!.''4 #. (!# 4".4-"...

0 $ ' # -". (" 5 # . #

.# $

# ("5<. "".

(".-(' 0;#

*#("## 4#(!$'.. 5 5( #" ' # -". (" 5 # * .

(! " # -( .

<'* @ '

.# 4-".#'$55(!# .'$(.!;# ## 5$$(" #.# '#$'.. <. " # ' '4 .#4* 5 #

.<##-".*4 5 "* (" (" .-. 9 # 5 .

.# .* #

# ("'<. 4$ ".6 9 .6 #$ $ $-"4D$$ '# -".#!$ 54#..

"# .''"! .D .('#"

D#.#

.#$ . ("5 "4###..

"D;#"

"D#.#

.#$ . ("5.-."D;# *#* .$ # .4 ".6 '!$ #4 (#..

"E 1 ;# C5( $' +,+-.//-. #0$1

2+2.-(-23+(+456 -75)!,-- 25*#(" "% F B .(!* ." =.# # 7"/# #-3" # &#* $ . "4 "$ 4#

$* #" # .. 5 - (( % G . 6 * #.# - 4 " .! $* '$ # . #("4 ( $." 4 ! $ #'" ..

"$$ '# -".#

.#$ # .''".'#.## 4# 5"4###..

"# .4( .#$ .5<. "5!#. @ $ # '"# 89*'"#895 # ..

"#.#4

# ;#* #

( <. # $

". 6 # # -". ." '

# #-(-'$ #.''

.'"#

# "$ *## 54" ..

"* # (" .(4###..

"("!4" -*# . #("4 (* "

<. $ ." 5!. 6 * '

. '.#.((! '(! # 4 " # ' -". # .' ." '$(.4 # $ 4#5

''"H .$."4#" # "'

5'#$'. '"# 4 .#454'"" # .<## -".* 5 "* ("(".-.E

;#$.$( (#.<. > ".

" 6 (( (" & # 5 $" $(# > "4' * .(##5>.--)#$ ". 6 * ((#($$ .4!

$ #";#(4 (-5#"#.(

# $- $-#' .4>

.5!

4#(("-"

( #'4# #-(#.5 4#5#. <'*#

4#. .$'#.( $( '$(!5.

#! ((!"" ..

" 9# . *@ #. '#$(!4$# $ 54- #$$ "..

"*4 (..5'" #.> "4'$

"5!"=.## $

" +$) - !* 66 * "."" 6 : * ##$("

''4""(..

" " . 6 (("5!')4#((45 - % G6& 4"

#(.$(."5!#;( #

( #$(!4$# " ."#$* # ' #((!' ..-"(9(-C .

$*# =.## C5( $' #-(! #(" #

( "'

5( -". " #- $5- -(

(

"$"(! .5" 5! "'

5( '(&!(. $

.#"'

5('(

1 ""- .4 $ .

' (!

<<< <<< <<< :;#4 '## '! $-(.)

$..5 # '& ''" # .

- .#.* " # . .! 5 # 89 " "$ (! #. # ."5(!

8 # " $(!*# 4"."4$$(. " . 6 * # . @ " "> ". $# # (

#- *5 (! ## # '( ."* 5 "* (">

!( 0 ;# (. $(." 5! # ;( "'

5( $(!4$#

( " 5 # -.! # '! # $ (! (4((!

5( 5 ( - # <. > ".

" . 6 7 ".( "' '

5(-"." !$' * - 4!( (.)4-"! .!E #* $..((4 "( #-5

4"# $$ "..

"5!#$*#.#"#5!#" #'##($$45#( I"I0;#

- " (4#! .

<' 5 " 5! # - ;# 4 " "

4 # $$(. (" 5! # $

" .6 )5!#( *##'( '$-' # - # $ .

* ( 5(* ...

$.$

(# ' ." #(* 5 * . 5 ' - .((. "

.*#-4'(54#*$$ ##( # $(." 4. (. # '! +I* # " # ." 5 " .." & # 4* # ' . $ "( #-"!-( "$ I"I0* (

" "4#""

4#($$; !#

''4 "

. 6 * < . ' # $' . . 4(! ".4"

#$55(4 (

.8 #* ("(# 89 " 5 .!.($" - * " # # # "( '44"

4#"$ "*$ *"# '! '9 #4 ""(!(4#$$(. .."* # ' ( .(!>

"5!#$* 4## $$(. (" ( .$ # $ # - 4#.# 54."

."5!# $.(.'=.#;#

! $- ( " $ .5 ! (' '-4 $$(. " .6 *.# '5'"#5 "

4# '#.4".-.44 "

'" $4"

#$55(4 (#$$ "..

"9# . *.

(-"4# ' ."') 4 $' . . 4 # $- $" * .

4 #

''4$-#' .4>

. -*# 4* (!#

''4#$- $" .(#.#*# *. "4#. #. ..

$.* .-."#54'#$' .. -*4 # !4##-.!((4 (-("4 #$- $" !5$-""

4#. ( 6 8 # 44 * # '$ 4" " "" $

"5!#("&""(

7 "4*(* " ;#$ .."4(!*((" /#4 " #5- #(( 5 . " 5 <$

$#'#.

: ;#("&""(

7 "4*( . 4") #( (4.(..(

*..".#(* <$"

(! $

5( 0 "4 ' .((

$$(.

* !* ( "

" $ "*.."4(! 8) (9 !.: #* $ ! I## $)4J " A J/ I##$5( A J/