High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/597/2022disposed of

Ram Kumar Garg v. Jatinder Singh

2025-07-22Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul4 pages

!"#$!%&'&"()*+,

($-

./0&12*1003 4444455+&%( 6!0'*' ./0& &($!0.&(3/ 44444!'5"($!( ) ) ) ) 78.4.28 78.4.28 78.4.28 78.4.28 0!'!( ) 04'/(3309+-$:"% ! #"0 /!55+&%( 4 28-4 28-4 28-4 28-4 4 /! 55+&%( /' #&+!$ /! 50!'!( 55+&% &"( '!!;&(3 30( "#+!:! "55!+3&(' /!<*$31!( "#%=*& +5''!$&( %"15+&( %'! &(' & * !$ *($!0 .!% &"( >? "# /! !3" &@+! (' 0*1!( '% -?? /!0!&(# !00!#!00!$ "'-A% B-9/!0!@, /! %"15+&( #&+!$ @, /! 55+&%( 9' $&'1&''!$ ($ /! %%*'!$ 9' %=*& !$4

4 /! +&1& !$ =*!' &"( 0&'&(3 #"0 %"('&$!0 &"( &( /! 50!'!( 50"%!!$&(3'&'9/! /!0(55!+3&(' ("0$!0"#%=*& + 5''!$ &( %"15+&( %'! *($!0 .!% &"( >? "# /! % %( @! !( !0 &(!$ *($!0 /! 50":&'" " .!% &"( > "# /! 0444 /! &(' (%!"# /!%"15+&(( C >4 /! &''*! &' (" +"(3!0 0!' &( !304 ( AD' !+!' &*1 AD' !+!' &*1 AD' !+!' &*1 AD' !+!' &*1 &((%&+ 6'4 4 (('!;0( %4

. ?

> &((%&+ 6'4 4 (('!;0( %4

. ?

> &((%&+ 6'4 4 (('!;0( %4

. ?

> &((%&+ 6'4 4 (('!;0( %4

. ?

0&1&(+

?B- /!"(7@+!.*50!1!"*0 * /"0& &:!+,/!+$ /

%"15+&(( &(50"'!%* &"(*($!0.!% &"(>?"# /!% -=*+&#&!' 'A:&% &1B*($!0.!% &"(

9"# /!0444-@!&(3 /!5!0'"(9/" '*##!0'#&((%&++"''$*! " /!$&'/"("*0"#%/!=*!4"('!=*!( +,- '*%/ %"15+&(( &' !( & +!$ " 5*0'*! ( 55!+ 3&(' %=*& + *($!0 /!50":&'" ".!% &"(> "# /!0444-9& /"* /!0!=*&0!1!( "#'!!;&(3'5!%&++!:!*($!0.!% &"(> ?

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

( /!%"( 00,-'3&(' ("0$!0"#%=*& +- /!. !- /0"*3/ /!*@+&%0"'!%* "0%(50!#!0(55!+!:!(&# /!%"15+&(( $"!'(" 50!#!0'*%/(55!+- /"*3/"# %"*0'! '*%/ ( 55!+ &' 9& / /! +!:! "# /! %"*0 4 "9!:!0- & &' (" +9,' (!%!''0, #"0 /! . ! "0 %"15+&(( " 50!#!0 ( 55!+4 * 9/!( & %"1!' " :&% &17'0&3/ "50!#!0(55!+- /!&('&' !(%!"('!!;&(3 '5!%&++!:! "55!+#0"1 /!&3/"*0 *($!0.!% &"( > ?

E "# /! 0 9"*+$ @! %"( 00, " 9/ /' @!!( &( !($!$ @, /! 0+&1!( @, &('!0 &"( "# /! 50":&'" " .!% &"(> "# /!0444 "*0 /+,- /! 0+&1!( /' (" 1!($!$ .!% &"( > ? " %&0%*1'%0&@! /!:&% &17'0&3/ "50!#!0(55!+<*' '& /' 9& / 0!30$ " %"15+&(( "0 /! . ! #&+&(3 (

> 55!+4 ( /!" /!0/($- /!0+&1!( /'&('!0 !$ /! 50":&'" ".!% &"(> '"' "!(:&'3!'*5!0&"00&3/ #"0 /!:&% &1"#("##!(%! "50!#!0(55!+"( /!30"*($' 1!( &"(!$ /!0!&('%"150!$ "%"15+&(( 4 &# /+,- /! &(:"+:!1!( "# /! . ! &( 0!'5!% "# ( "##!(%!*($!0.!% &"(>?"# /!% &'%"('5&%*"*'@,& ' @'!(%!4 /&' &' @!%*'! /! %"15+&( #&+!$ *($!0 / 50":&'&"( &' &( /! ( *0! "# 50&: ! %"15+&( ' 5!0 .!% &"(

"# /!0444($.!% &"(E>"# /!% @,( !F50!''&( !( &"(&(%"05"0 !' /!50":&'&"('"# /!0444 &( /!1 !0"# 0&+"#'*%/$!!1!$"##!(%! 0&!$' %0&1&(+ "##!(%!4 /!0!#"0!- /! %"15+&(( - 9/" &' /! :&% &1"#$&'/"("*0"#%/!=*!1*' @!%"(' 0*!$ "@! :&% &1&( !01'"# /!50":&'" ".!% &"(> 0!$9& / /! $!#&(& &"("#:&% &1*($!0.!% &"(

9"# /!0444 FFFFFFFFF 4 ' +0!$, (" !$- /! 50":&'" " .!% &"( > "# /! 0444 9' &('!0 !$ &( /! ' * ! @""; "(+, 9& / !##!% #0"1>4

4/!"@<!% ($0!'"(#"0'*%/&('!0 &"( 1*' @!0!+&'!$($1*' @!3&:!(& '#*++!##!% "@, %"*0 4(:&!9"# /!#"0!'&$$&'%*''&"(-9!/"+$ / /! :&% &1"#("##!(%!/' /!0&3/ "50!#!0(55!+*($!0 /! 50":&'" " .!% &"( > "# /! 0444- &00!'5!% &:! "# 9/! /!0/!&'%"15+&(( "0(" 4:!(&# /!:&% &1"#( "##!(%! &' %"15+&(( - /! %( ' &++ 50"%!!$ *($!0 /! 50":&'" ".!% &"(> ($(!!$(" $:!0 "'*@'!% &"(

E"#.!% &"(> ?"# /!0444H 4 /*'-9/ #+"9'#0"1 /!@":!"@'!0: &"('&' / /! "(7@+!.*50!1!"*0 -# !0(!F/*' &:!!F1&( &"("# /!' * "0, #01!9"0; ($ 50!:&"*' <*$&%&+ 50"("*(%!1!( ' &(%+*$&(3 A++&;0<*(2"$3+&6'4. !"#20( ;" /!0'B

. A++&;0<*(2"$3+&6'4. !"#20( ;" /!0'B

-%+0&#&!$ / /!0&3/ "#55!+%"(#!00!$*5"( /!A:&% &1B*($!0 /!50":&'" ".!% &"(> "# /!0444&'&($!5!($!( ($'*@' ( &:! &( ( *0!- (" %"( 0"++!$ @, /! 50"%!$*0+ 0!3&' 0 &"( *($!0 .!% &"( > ?

E"# /!0444

4 $"5 &(3 5031 &% ($ <*' &%!"0&!( !$ 550"%/ ($

E 3*&$!$@, /!50&(%&5+! / 50"%!$*0+0*+!1*' '!0:!($(" "@' 0*% /!%"*0'!"#<*' &%!- /&'"*0 $!!1'& 550"50& ! "$&0!% / /! 50!'!( 55!+ @! 0! !$ ' "(! * /"0& &:!+, &(' & * !$ *($!0 /! 50":&'" ".!% &"(> "# /!0444 4 ( :&!9 "# /! * /"0& &:! 50"("*(%!1!( &( D'!+!' &*1&((%&+7'%'! '*50 D'!+!' &*1&((%&+7'%'! '*50 D'!+!' &*1&((%&+7'%'! '*50 D'!+!' &*1&((%&+7'%'! '*50($ /!:&!9 ;!(@, /&'"*0 +'"&(. 5+.&(3/:4. !"#*(<@(04 >>

$&'5"'!$"##"( 4

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

*+,

($ ($ ($ ($-

28 28 28 28 *(!! I/! /!0'5!;&(3D0!'"(!$ )

!'D" I/! /!00!5"0 @+! )

!'D"