Sukhbai And Others v. Ram Avtar And Others










 
 

















 



!"#$
 
#%

&&''  (%! )*
+%
 
#%

)&   
 
 
 
  
  ,%


#-.
+
 
%
)"#
/!*%.
+
%
#
&&''  %
0%1
#
#%*.
+
%
%&  
2

%
)
 3#'.
+
%
4 !% 
5*&   
 

  

8#
&% 
&&'
#
$
&%%%
3 
#
-%


 


&

#
'*
&
'
!

%



#
% (#'
.
9
$6
#
'% 
%
 
5'*
8%$!

'.
 & %
#%.
:#
8%$!

';
%
 # * 

*& 
3% 

# '* 

#
!



) .. <
' 3
-#
 %
=
>
&%


!*.

!



#

8'"
)1


%
(#!'%
 .
!%%





'
!
%
%* 

#
&% 
&&'

   
?! !*

*& 
-%
$6
#
'% 
8%$!

'.

'

%%

#


#



%?!%

$
%&%!
%
#
" 
$%+6

  

 
 


 @

8#
'% 
!

'
%
#
'* &&'' 
  
#

#
*!



$6
#
'% 
8%$!

'


#
'-%

  %+

$
 # 
8#%%.
#
&%6
#
#
&% 
&&'
$ ''-
 
*& 
$
 # 

&%
'
'-

,%
 %.
'% 
!

'
%
#
%&  
2 @4 !%  5*& 6
+#* '6
%3!
#
#
'% 
8%$!

'
#
%%

3%  *& 

#
'* <&&'' 
8#%%.
#
&%6
%
*'


#
&&'

B% 
!

'
%
%&  
2 - %

#
  +#'
  
#
#
'% 
8%$!

'
#
%%

'-

3%  3
# *& 

#
'* <&&'' 
8#%%.
#
'
&%6
% *'

#
&&'

 4
#+
#%
'% 
!

'
%
#
&%
 
&%!
# -#'
%%

#





    C ;$'
#
!&%*
5!%

#


Sarla Verma Vs.

Delhi Transport Corporation and Another   
!
"#$%&%
'"$( )*%*
+ +,.
'
-
#
'-

* 

*& 
 
# %'+ 
&%

#
*
%

!

% D30
 

    

    

      

      

 



 

    
        





 

           

            

    



  

@  !"#$      



%#  !"&$      

 &'   !"($      

 


31
)

        

                   
 *       (+,         









        


-  



  

        

        $   

    
.  /

 



         

           

    
*  

 



                  

    



 

             

        
32
       

           

                        (+,          

    (+,      
         

   



  

             

                    



 

      

    
* * * * * 42.)     

 

    &$      

    0

   1           $        !2  

 !(%+ %!%(

$ 

   



 3!4%'#+

3!'#! #(

3!(#'&+

3!&&!&(

  3!#&'(+

  

   



 3!!(!((

35(''+

34'!'(

 3(''4+

C ;$'
!&%*
5!%

#


'

National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors.  +-
+!

!.,
# '%
#
'-
%' 3

 
.
@
 


#
% (#'
.
9.

#
''- 3
&  !

&% '
 
'+ 3
E& 

%* *!'&' F 0 '

*!'&'%
&  3

3

F 5 3



$
%
&&'6 3
*!'&'%F  ) $'
3!%

 +  '
#.
*'6.
' 
.
'

 %!*
 
!

%'
E& .
-# '

G !!%
&%&
%
''
3%

&% 
 
% % 
3
-#
&%* 
1$F
'*&'6
%
E '%6 8#
%'+ 
&%

#
1!3* 

%&%!

!

% D52. 6  conventional heads 

    

   

 7/

8
 *        7
%(+++     



7 !+++++ 

   7

!+++++ 

  

  


    

    

 

   
7/

  0       

  

     

 

              



   

   

  



         

  
 : 

     

            

  
6         

 
          

     



 

    


   

  

  

  


; 

  

    

  

 

  

      





  

 

                    

  
    

  



 * 

           

 

         

  

  

   

 

    

 7
!(+++
&++++ 7
!(+++


          

  
<       

   

 )              

 



   

  

 

  !+,   

 ) 

 

 



  

 



  = = = = 59.3
)   

  (+,    





 



 /     &+

       #+,  

  

&+(+

* 



 

 (+'+

   

!(,
6        


59.4
* 







 $ 

            &+,    

 

  



   &+

6  %(,

  

 &+(+

 !+, 

  

 (+'+

   






  

    
59.5
 .             

       

  

       #+#%0 > ?    

    59.6.

            0> @ &% /


59.7
  

        
59.8
7   

        

 



 

     

    7  !(+++  7  &++++     7  !(+++


 

    

  !+,  

A C ;$'
!&%*
5!%


'

)/&)
%0%$)1 0*"$)02%
'&#)03
4&4(%5
6*
)0"
)&
)14)*
7"7$"
)&
8 (7%$*

+.+.

+9,
%
 % 3

)$1)
6%$&)
*"#$)


$)0)3
%(74
"#$)
#
'
#
'-
%3% 3
 %!*

)'+ 
&%

#
*
%
%&%!

!

% B21
6  <

  C  0 8        

 

    

;



  




 *     

  D  D    

      



 D  

 D  D    D     D

 D
    

          

  

   

 

  

  
)

 

 

   

 

%!
!
Spousal consortium  

   

                      

    



      

  

    /  D
%!
%
Parental consortium     



     

D  

   

     

   

     D
%!
#
Filial consortium             

  

 

   
6 

      

 

        



  

   

     

     

 

          
22
       

  

  

      

       3  /     

 



  E   

   

   

   
3 /      

 

   

   

 
    

    

        

     

  

 
 23
 3> 

6  

    

     

  

 

  

* 

     

         

   

         
 C          

 

    



      6 
 6           

    
      



  

  

      

  24
        

         

     

 



   D

  D   C  0 8
*  







           

   7 &++++ 

  


&%!'

#
%%
%+'
#
,H !"#$

#% * 

#

#6*
B'
-
9
6%

3

#
*
 #
#
C-+%.

!* %6
+ 
!&&% 3
#
*
- &'
$%
#
B
8%$!

'

!%#%.
&
*%*
%&%
GE ,
%+' #
#
3

#

-
@
6%

#
*

#
#
4

' &%&

'-

#'
$6
C ;$'
#
!&%*
5!%

Sunita Vs.

Vinod Singh 2025 INSC 366 -#%
#
C ;$'
&E
5!%
#'
#


$ 

*%'
  3

#
 %%6.
#%


 #$

& #
3



&%
&
*%*
%&%
8#
%'+ 
E%

# *

%&%!

!

% B!!
      

    7
(2!5"  7

 .      -        F

$            7
!++++"  7

 

  $          

   

 

 

  



7
(!#4" 7

.   ;

    $    



           

  7
%(++" 7

  .

  $
        

  

   7
4'#4"

7

0   0     $ 

  7
4+++" 7

0   $

           

    

  &(

 C 3

7   





 


  



        

   

        
!   #+

 

!(

 

             

        

  



  

   

 %( #+

  

  !54+
Moreover, in the absence of material indicating to the contrary, there is no inhibition to accept the age of the deceased as per the Post2Mortem Report
       

   !&   &(

)  

   

  Pranay Sethi $  7
&++++" 7

.

  $  

 !+, 

 

    

    Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v Nanu Ram, (2018) 18 SCC 130  

           
          

      G7
&2+++"(H 


%&++++"  7

   I     .    $   

    

  


A 

+-

#
$+.
%%%

1!3* .
#
3

 #6*
B'

% 

@
6%

#
*



&%!'

# -%
!%#%
 
#
#

-


$
-%" 3



 $6
&%
 
#
* #'6
 *
-
%

$
) 

<

C-+%.

!* %6
+ 
?!
#
*
-
&%!
$%
# B
8%$!

'

5 ?! '6.
#
8%$!

'
#
%3#'6

#
 *
 #


)

<
&%
* #

%

#
*!'&'%

 % .

#
'% 
8%$!

'
%%

'-

&&'6 3
#
*!'&'%

A
 
 
8#
8%$!

'
#
'

-%
 6
*!


%
!!%
&%&
  '


%+%.
#
*!


-%
%
!

%'
E& 
 
' 
 %!*


#
'-%

 
%+

$
 # 
8#%%.

#
-%
%?!%
 !'3 

#
5!%

    

+-

#
'-
'
-
$6
#
C ;$'
!&%*
5!%


#
$+
%%%

1!3* .
#
&% 
&&'

''-
8#
-% 
 



*
% 3'6
8#
&&'' '* 
%
#' '

 # 
*& 

&%
#
'!' 
*
#%!

% Sr. No.

Heads Compensation Awarded   #'6
4 *

)

< !!%
&%&
=
A > )

<
A >


 @ !
-%
&% '

E& !%
<A#


) 

<


I
<A#

8'
4 *
)





 !'&'%
 

!'
&  6
)  .

.

<
I I  B

G ) .

< !

%'
GE&  ) .

<

@ B

5 %!* ) .A .

< &!'

)
A.

<E ,% '

)
A.

<EA '()1
'&#%0*)(4'0

*+ .:;< 

%5"2(4'0
*!


-%
$6
#
8%$!

'

*=!=++ ;<  07)02%5
)&'"0(

*-+....;<
+ .:< =!=++  @


%

#
 %
&%

 % .

#'
$6
C ;$' !&%*
5!%

Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma

+

9+-!
 
R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nandu State Transport Corporation



=
"#$%&%
'"$(
)*%*
+-
#
&&'' '*  %
3% 
 %
=
9>
&%


!*

#
 # 
*!


%*
#
 
' 3

'*
&
''
#



%'J

A


&%
-%
&
$6
B
8%$!

'

 

.
#
B

8%$!

'

#
'*
&

+!%

#
'* 
 
3  %&  
2 
 


%+%
 
- %

#
+#'
%&+'6

)&  
2 
 

-%
#'
1 '6
 
+%'6
'$'

&6
# *& 

)&  
2 @4 !% 
5*& 6
-
%

&6
# *& 

#
%
  
 
'$%6
-
3% 

%&  
2 @ 
%+%
#
*
%*
%&  
2 
 

5 ?! '6.
%&  2 @4 !% 
5*& 6

%

&
#
*!



 #  *& 

#
%
  
-#
#
'$%6

%+%
#
*
%* %&  
2
- %

#
  3
+#' 

8#
4 !% 
5*& 6%&  
2
@

%

& #
 # 
*!



*& 
' 3
-#
 %
-#
#
8%$!

'

A -#

&%

-
* #
%*
#
%&

&6

#
1!3*
8# 8%$!

'

%

$!%
#
 # 
*!



*& 
' -#
 %

#
!



#
'* <&&'' 

?!'
#%
8# '* <&&'' 
%
%

!% #
#%
$ "
!


'

# 8%$!

'



!%#%
4 !% 
5*& 6

%

$!%
#
!%% #!'


%
)
 3#'.
+.
&!%! 

%%
 

A
&


2 


$6
#
5!%.

-#

&% 
- 6
6
%*
#


%&

&6

#
1!3*



,  3
&&'
.

 6.
'
 
&


.-

=   
  J















 

7%(7%$
*#%)>40/;$%)*'0%5< %*;'

7%(7%$
$%#'$()?1%< %*;'