Mohinder Kaur And Another v. State Of Punjab
! "#$ %&% "#"'#( ! "#$ %%
")*#!
+,' ,#! ,#"-)
%%%%%% -*-*"#
'
.-,- "/ '#0,1 %%%%%%
2"#!
#- $ 34 % .+
!!!!
+ 5 %
,6 "" " ## $% &$#' ( ) * " ) ( )" " &
,-. #$#'
$& &$&##+" ) %$/#&$01-2" 2 ) ) 3 ) - + " ( ( 2 ) "+ 21) #4 $& &$&##+ + +"
"% 5) 67 " 8 + ) ( )
-))" """ "+ + . #0 1
++ ""++ ) + "
)(+ ) %$/:#&$01-2 1 +$9()"+ 6$$:0 -+ )( ( )) " - $6(
%
* " #6 #& &$#6 + ) ( ))2 + ) "
%$/-2 %$4-2 " 0 ;<<<<<<<< 9% + )): ) + ) " ) (+ ( ) ) ) %$/-2 + ( )) ) :%$4-2 )+ ) - ) =%$4-2 ) :%$/-2 8 ( &&&>&?2 "+ + ( ) "
"+ 8 " ))+"
"" ( @= ) 2 A@ ) B 8
A- &$$$ &/'A" B A>#//'?% &#%
@)" "
)())2 ))+0
.
. 3 : - )
" -
#
%$4-2 8+( - 6$$:0 ,( 00 #&$01-2 8+( -
&
D %$4-2 8+( - 6$$:0 ,( 00 #&$01-2 8+( -
2 ) 2 )+"" %$4:%$/ -2 ))" ( =) = @ ( +( %$6-2"
@ : (+ E ( ()"" 8 " + (+ ( (
) "
)( 8 " ( 2 )+ )" "
)() @ () ) F< 2 " )0" ",- 8 " 8
" )"
( - + + ) ) ( @ ))"
(+ + . #0 )+ "
+ ) + ))""
@ ))") 0 ) ) ) &6 F '
) 2 )+ )( "
)() F + ( )"
F< 2 @ ( " . # ) ( ) )( : " +
@ + + +) (") "
- ) " "
/
1" %$6%$4 -20 89% *:*#,6 1 ,() "/ - '
- GH "( + (+ ( ( )( + ( )( ( ) ( )+ " + " ( )") <
)+ " " +) ))( ( ;) C #IF<) &I#J G ")(9I 0 ) + < #' F)(K , )) #/6& >#/ #/6&?
F)(K- #/%7>9% #/%7? )) + ( ) ( , ) )) )( ) )+ J-)) >? "< +)) )( ( )++
" +)) + )
> ? + 0 L "" ( )) ( ) + )( )) " )
>? " 2) " L " ) 8 < ) +L )) (L )) ( " LK L )
+ 2(K )( ( )( ( + 0 )
>? 1 ) )) )( " )" +)) LK" ) 1 1") (LK ( 1 1") L ("
2(K "
L ) ) ) ) ")" )( " )( )
>? 0 + ) ( ()+ ( <)+ ( ()) )(+
) )( ( )
>? (L+ ( ( ) ( + )( ( ) 8% '#* ):
#- /" ( *:*#,6 1 ,() "/ - '
-
) )) + + (< (+ + #$
%$6 )" "
) #
F "(+ (+ ( (
&
0 >?
)( " " + ( >?
)( " ( +) ))( " ( ) >?
( )+ " + " > ?
( )") " " ##
<2 =
+ ))"
+ "%$6 ) 0 "xx xx xx The basic requirement to bring home the accusations under Section 405 are the requirements to prove conjointly (1) entrustment and (2) whether the accused was actuated by the dishonest intention or not misappropriated it or converted it to his own use to the detriment of the persons who entrusted it. As the question of intention is not a matter of direct proof, certain broad tests are envisaged which would generally
& afford useful guidance in deciding whether in a particular case the accused had mens rea for the crime."
#&
<2 ! " # $
% ) 0 ;<< << << In a prosecution for offence of criminal breach of trust if there is absence of legal and independent evidence with regard to the entrustment, then it would be improper either to put a question with regard to the entrustment to the accused and if put and an answer is obtained, partially admitting entrustment, the same does not establish the case of entrustment."
#9
" 2 )+ F< 2 + F< 2 0 ;3 2 ) ) 3 )
) 8 @38)+ . 97&& $& &$## 0 H "+ )(""+2 1) - ( " + " "+ 2 1) 8 ))+" "+ + ))+" + 0 . H H "+H " )+ # &5 '6 "#4'
6$$ " #$' "6$$"
& &5 '6 "#&9 66% "
#6# "6$$" #%
+) ") F< F
) + +E "+2
;
( " 0 . # )( : ))2 )" ) 0 ;<< << &%
-+ )): "++ (+(F< ) + +"
F< 2 ))"+
)):
) ( ( F< F 8 -( "
( ) )):
&6 - + " "
( ) ) )):
))"( " F< 2 <) C #6
- 2 2 )+))( ,))+" H0&-1)+"
-""3 0 -#40$&0&$##+ ) 8)+ 2 3
"
2
))"1) H " ""++ - )"+ )(
8 + ( "+) )
)"+ "
%E )67 ) "++ " + + ) ( #$&2 F<
+ . @2 "
+ 3#'
$& &$## ) + ( @3 8)+ 2 2 ) )3 )
+ - ( " ( F< H&: ,-F<H&:1 -)"+ )( + F< H&:2 8 +++
3&/0$&0&$## "
+ + + 2 F<H&:
3#090&$## +F<H&:F + + 2 8 + ++ 3) " ))+ (-:@3
)+"
" - ( - ( 2 + F<#F<&F<9 - F<%+ - )+ )(+1 8 ) + @ "
<<<<<< ( + . #
- ++ - + )"+ 2)( ")( + + . # -("+ +E + +) "+2
1)"
+ - + (
- + ( ) ) ))"
) + )(" ) 8 + +)(" H
+"
+ . 0# )%E )67 ) H +"
+ +"
" + + ))") ++ ("" " +"
"
+ 71> "?+ +
) "
( " H " " + F< +( ") 2 3 + - ) "+ () 8 (+ () ""( " ) ""
(+ ( ")) )+ 8 )+) ) ) - +" "
(+ . #
-+" " . # )"
) ( +" ) ( "2 3 ) <<<<< ( "
2 ) . &
+ . &( "+
"" + " ""( 8 "+" ) "
))" . & -+" -"
" )+
#4
, - ) ) 2 ) )3+
F< 2 )+ "#$' "6$$" ))(
D #6# "%%4" 8) &6/
" 8 + ))" %67 " 8 " ) ))"D%67 " + &6/ "+ + " , ) "
" F< 2+ && $& &$##",- ) + " -+
"F< 2 " - " + H 2 ) ) 30 )H04 <)(" ;- + @3 8)+ " " ) ( 2 -
2 "
-( DD)+
-+ ))2 F< F
@+ ) F< 2 F ) )("E ( (-""3 2 )+ ) #'
))( DD) (
7 (%E) 67 "+ ))" ) + )"""+2))(+ F< 2 +)+ &E) 6/ ")( ( D ) (
" ( : ) ))(++
)( ))"+ +
D(+) #7
-+ 2 )+ )" +"
)( "
" %$6-2+ #/
E ) " " ( )2 ( ))2 )" ="
)( )
%$4-2+ #&$01-2 (
E )) ")))" ,-. #$#'
$& &$&##+" )
%$/ #&$01 -2 ) 8)+
&$
2E )( ))+
+ %%
": M ) M