Mani Ram v. Chief Manager & ANR
!" #"$%&%'( )
( * +, -
!"
$% !"
- . & '&
(&
) &
'
*+
# ,***
- (
.//0
# ,*
./12 #
&
"
&(
*
/./31003
4( '
(
!*100512316)1005+.375
' '
#
8"##& (
9
8 (
9
#
#&
#
'
# ' # 1//.1005(
'
#
&
(&
(#
#
&
# #
(&(&
(#
#
&
#
"##&(
#
& #
(
#
# # # (
'
'& #
(
& "## (&
#
#
(&
#
& # (
(# '#
"##&
(
#
'
(
##
' :
"## "#
##
#
&
(&
#
& #
#
#
#
'
"# '
, #
&
, '
; (&
'
# < *
!*100=77>6)1005+==>7 *
?#
/./31003
# "
& "
131.1003 ?#
# (&'&
"# *
< .//=)7+@105
;
#
#
# ( :
* #
" *
& '
# # '# &
A
,# ,
/3/310>1$ '
# ! $
#
?#
,!
"
/1/1100>
211..///
#
#
'# ' (
!
*
&
15B
( "
#
#
#
" (
&
(#
#
?#
,!
(
./12
&# (
#
'
#
#
##
.//
' (
,! #
#
&' (& 3. '
# ( #
'
(&1/122 &
##
1000* .///
*
33
#
@ ,*
,!
#
#
!##
&
"
15B
#
#
&
'
(
.///
100> #
#
'>3
,!
# #
# ) + # #
"C
#
#
##
& '
"
'
"##&(
'#'
@
(
10>. ).+ D 2/3
C #
@'
( E -
10>0 )7+ D .53
&
'! @
(
!* 100= 11>06 @ 100= ).+ 3.3 )! ,1+ ! @
(
)1000+3./0)! ,.+#
& ##
'
## (& ##
&
# # #
'
& ' 1000
'3.
#
&33 .///
,!#
(# '# &
#
#
#
(
@
# ,* ' ( (&
# ( #
:
&'
;
" ''#
& (&
(&
#&
#
#
*
# '
#
(&
,*** " & # # ( #
#
#(
1000.///'
# #
&
#
# #
"#
# '"
##
(
' F
( *
#
& ;
&
"##& ( ( &
, G # "##&(
&
.//"##
,!
@ ,*#
"##& (
#
#
' ( 2/ )15B .//+
& #
' ( 15 )35B .//+
H #
#
#
# (
(
#
&
# # &
./17
.//"##
, !
@ ,*# "
&
@ ,* # #
,!7//
'# #
7/ #
75
(
.// "## '(
#
5/)15B =//I 0/ (
#
0/,7/+
#
%)35B =//I 75 (
#
75,75+J #
# "
11/>./11
#
#
?#
" 1000./// *
'
)! ; ,3+
' #
# &
# '#
# >
'
& 1000
'
=. (
,!
@ ,* 21 ' #
,
21 )
#
&+'
* (
'
"
*
.2/1100> 21 '
# ;
;
# .///* .///
.3 "##
#
&=
# ( #
&
@ ,*
,!
&' (&33 # '
K ''
'
#L*
(
" #
!
# 1=7! 1=7
&
# %
&
#
(
& #
(
!#(
# #
1000 ./// '
(&
K
% 75>0 ./1. 2//2./1.
'
(
,
#
#
&
# #'
"
(
#
(
(
& 1.& '#
#
# ;
& &
"'&
% !* 1037 ..31
#
*'
( &
#
&(
&
"
##
(
:
&& #"
&
(
(
)
/ - 0