Kapur Singh And ORS. v. Financial Commissioner, Haryana And ORS.



 
        
  



 !"!

#$ %& & '



                  

 
($  )* (& +
 ( +



* * !

   "  # $  %

 & '( #"    & )!

  %

 

 #    * &  + ,-
. -

    ,%    $ *-/   ,-  0 -

 

 1 2 3


   4  $ # "  -''56''7   "4 "

  '58)'8 ) - 9: ' #

 1  :          ."" "  ""       #   

  


 '58;  ( " " 1   <

  : :   "     1 3    8    * %

 1 2:.

  1 5:

= 

  "   "     1 7    *   

 "      "

 "  

  2 3 "  %# (  -  337  "  '58;      ;

$1  2;

 1 '8;1 26' ): < 566'<6'

7:< '23:8  56626 <:8 '>6''5:  )'66 76'<:8 '<3:8 '23:

8 ))6 3:8 '3:8 )3:8 <3:8 23:8 53:8 73:8 >3:8  83:

8  3:8  '3:8  )3:8 ))6 <3:8  23:8  53:8  73:8  >3:

8 '83:8 ' 3:8 ')3:8 '<3:8 ))6'23:8 )<66 87:3  6 ):

<4      "  $    
 
 

 $ 8'85 >7>-"'   "   "  "  "



  

 8'85 >7>- 9:<( 

 $  '38''885- 9:7 -  9 " '38''885- 9:7  +

   

 

 

  
    
    
  
  


  ! 
 "#
 

 $ # %

&
'( 

) $


*  ++

,

-
".  


" '#

 #


 $/0 !12-

44443$
 + - 

 


  '

 


 ''

' 5  '-




'

  ' #

#  

    '


'
-


 

'

    
 
    
 

'   



    
 '



  '

      '


#
'

 
 

'

1



'



'
6   



 

   1 2    3  "   #"

    $

     885'883- 9:3-  9  885'883  + 7


'

 

 

   



 



  !


# "#
$ # 



)$1 ++ ,

%$0 !(3

44443 $
 + -0




   '

 
 
'
 8''

'7
7

  






 
 

 
#



'

 7

 
-



  #


'
 




 


 
'

 # 

5

 



  !  
  #  
  "#
 $ #    

 )$*

++ ,

%$0

!(3

44443$
 + -




 
   '

    
'


 
 '
       

''

'  
  0


 

  
    '

 

'
    ''

' 
7

 
-

  



 
 
 
  9  +  
  #  



  '

  



'
 
 

  
    

'
 

 #
'

 
 

'

1

6 -       

   1 2    3  "     #"

      * 

$

'582'88> - 9:> %     

 -     

      #$ "!:3<>':'8 8 $  $   " '8 ''8 8$ #  

           4   "  '8 ''8 8 #      

   "     #"

            $

 '58)'8 ) - 9: '   #"

-:4/ #

   #"

    

%  "             #   -     9  "    '58)'8 )  + 2 7


  '





# 
 
.5

: -

'

 





 , 2 ,2 

#



'

 
 
 
 '
 

+2 ,2.5 ;

& -

'

 

 
.0# .

-<<05 
.




  +2 ,2.5

;

& -

'



'
   #


  




 


'



5



'




'



 


8
 


- 



'




 
  '
 




 '

 =
 







  ;

  

 #



 
#







 



 


  
 

 +, > -

51?
 

  



 

'

 








 
 


 '
-


 
 

 

  

 

=
  '
 

-

  '
 
  

    

    

  
 '

   

 #

    


   



 
 '
  -  
  

 






 #
 


 


   51  ?
-     )   


#


-
 '
 51?
- -  


# 




'



'
''

   ! 5
  '

 


'

-



 '



 '
#

'

 

 
 ,,%2($/0222'

 # 

  
 '

 

#
 



'

  '

 
'

'

  
 

#
#
0
  

 '



-


'
 
'


''

    



  '

  '

 '

'

6

  $  4       "

     -  

 8'85 >7>- 9


:<$ #-:4/   "

  
 
 8'85 >7>$" "  #  "'

4 $   #  #-:4 /  

 $ 

 "  "

     #$ 



 "     !

  

- 9:2"

  

 8'85 >7> $" #"

-:4/ #  

  -:4/ $?   "    #  ""    "

 

 

(    "    "

   

 1      

  '58)'8 )- 9: ' 4 " $

#    '58)'8 ) -:4/  ?

  $    $



   "

        



8'85 >7>#"

 $   "      $ $ (   "    

    4"

 -:4/      $   $      #"

    - 9:2"

   
 
 8'85 >7>(    $##  6 #%    "




 

 8'85 >7>#"

-   :4 /  * $ "

 #   %& & '