Vimla Mehta And ORS. v. Mohan Lal And ORS.

   

     

  


!  "

"

# $%     &'()!'* ,-.-+&"/ 
 12 '3&  (&3'4  5555566'22 0'4+-+ (3 7 2 !(&3'4+ 55555'+6(

,  87 95 9 79 77 4'+'

&, 45595 12 /!:(* &')(4&3' 66'22 &+5 455 5 -6& /!:(* &')(44'+6( &(55 ;;; 79 77/5  3 +1 &&'4 +<'

.& ='

-6)(43' 4

.&34(-.3:

!'(*( )'4'

*

. !-'&((-&<4' =()&3'6 !'1 */

0
5



4 >'4

&3' 662 +)(42 +&

.&3 + 66' 2)(43' 4

. +&3'

++-'+

:(2:'! +& ! *4>+& 2 +'! <> : 4 (-+ ?-!.1'

&+ () &3' ( @<2' 9-4'1'

(-4&5 (& *'()&3' 662 5 45 5 5 -6& / !:(* &' **'6&+ (& *' (  <'3 2) () 4'+6( (5 !!('+ (&4 +' >+'4 (-+(<?'*& &(&3'2 +&

.()&3 + 66' 25 &4'A-'+& !B &3*( +'

&()2' 4 +'2)(4&3'6 4& '+/ 66' 2

+& ='

-6)(43' 4

.&(! > &+'2)5 662 +!

+6(+'!()5

 

4'+'

& 66' 2 3 + <''

 ) 2'! <> &3' *2 &+ )(4 '

*'1'

& () *(16'

 B 4!'!<>&3'2' 4 '!(&(4** 1+4 2/ 1-  . 4 & . !34 #3'4'

)&'44')'44'!&( +&3'84 28%( &()!' &3() ? >3-+3 '3& :

!' B 4!! &'! 5 5

5

4 ') ) *&+ '*'++ 4> )(4 !?-!

 () &3' * +' 4' &3 & &3' 66'22 &+*2 5'56 4'

&+()&3'!'*' +'!) 2'! 6'& - !'49'*& 
 () &3' (&(4 0'3 *2'+ *& +''=

. *(16'

 (  **(- & () !' &3 () 0 ? > 3-+3 '3& ( 
5 5

/

 1(&(4:'3 *2' ** &/* -+'!!-'&(4 +3

'.2 .'

&!4

.()&3'())'

.:'3 *2'/ 5'5&4-*=<' 4

.4'.

+&4 & (5  CC"<>4'+6( &(5
5 7' 4 '! 4 2 (  *( !'4

. &3' ':

*' (  4'*(4!/ ) *&+ * 4*-1+& *'+ *( *2-!'! &3 & 0 ? > 3-+3  '3&  !

'!

 &3' ** & B3 *3 &((=62 *'( 
5 5

!-'&(4 +3 '.2 .'

&!4

.()&3'())'

.&4-*= <' 4

. 4'.

+&4 &  (5  CC" <> 4'+6( & (5
5 7' 4 '! 4 2 B3 2' **'6&

.&3 &.4(+++ 2 4>()!'*' +'!B ++5
/ /3'2!

*(1'()&3' !'*' +'!&(<'+5
/

6'41( &3/ )&'4!'!-*&

.&3' 1(- &&(B 4!+ 9/

'&*5 ! B 4!'! +-1()+5/"/

B &3

&'4'+& &&3'4 &'()5D6'4

-1)4(1&3'! &'())

.()&3'*2 16'& & 22! &'() *&- 24' 2 () &3' B 4!5 '!-*&  ()
4! B + '))'*&'!5 -2& '4 () C B + 662 '!5 !!

22>/  +-1 () +5
  B + B 4!'! (  **(- & () &4 +6(4& & *3 4.'+5  ..4 ':'! () &3' A- &-1 () *(16'

/ *2 &+ 3 :' ) 2'! &3 66' 25 7' 4 +'2)(4&3' 66'22 &++-<1 &+&3 & 66'22 &(53 +

*'6 ++'! B > ++-4:

:'!<> 66'22 &(5
5 7' 4 '! *(- +'2 )(4 &3' 66'22 &+ +-<1 &+ &3 &

*(1' () &3' !'*' +'! 3 + <''

 B4( .2> ++'++'! + +5
/

 6'4 1( &3 <> &3' 2' 4 '! 4 25'!-*& +( : 4 (-+*(- &+ ++3(B

&3'+ 2 4>+2 6()&3'!'*' +'! 3 :' &( <'

*2-!'!

 3

*(1'5  -4&3'41(4'/

 &'41+ () ?-!.1'

& () &3' ( 8<2'9-64'1'

 



   #

$ %

(
(

/

*4'1'

& (  **(- & () )-&-4' 64(+6'*&+ &&3'4 &'() D+3(-2!<' ))(4!'!5 (16'

( &()2(++

() *( +(4& -1 '&*5 + 2+( +(-.3& &( <' '

*'!5 & +/ &3-+/ 64 >'! &3 & *(16'

 B 4!'!&(&3'*2 &+<'4'B(4='! **(4!

.2>5 7' 4 '! *(- +'2 )(4 &3' 4'+6( & 

+-4 *' *(16 > B3 2' 4')-&

. &3' 4.-1'

&+ 4 +'! <> 2' 4 +'2 )(4&3' 66'22 &++-<1 &+&3 & !'A- &'*(16'

3 +<''

 B 4!'!<>&3'2' 4 '!4 2B3 *3* 22+)(4

( )-4&3'4 '

*'1'

&5 & + +-<1 &&'! &3 & *(16'

 3 + <''

 4 .3&2> ++'++'!/&3-+/ 16-.

'! B 4!! &'! 5 5

<'-63'2!5 3 :'3' 4!2' 4 +'2)(4&3' 66'22 !3 :'.( '&34(-.3 &3' :

2 <2') 2'5 3'4' ( !

+6-&' &3 & 0 ? > 3-+3  '3&  2(+& 3 + 2 )' !-' &(

?-4 '+ 4'*'

:'! <> 3 1

  1(&(4 :'3 *2' ** &/ B3 *3 &((= 62 *' (
5 5

!-'&(&3'4 +3 '.2 .'

&!4

.()&4-*=<' 4

.4'.

+&4 & (5  CC"/<>4'+6( &(5
5

.()&3'2' 4 '!4 2( &3 ++-' 3 + &&

'!)

&>5& + 2+( (&!

+6-&'!&3 &&3'!'*' +'!B +">' 4+(2! &&3' 1'()&3' ** &/3 +! &'()< 4&3<'

.
"5

5
 5 *(1'()&3'!'*' +'!3 +/3(B':'4/<''

*(44'*&2> ++'++'!<>&3' 2' 4 '! 4 2 + +5
/

 6'4 1( &35 7' 4 '! 4 2 3 + B4( .2> !'!-*&'! +-1()+5/ "( &()3(-+'4'

&/ 9 5'& 2+() &3'!'!-*&  +6'4+ 2 4>*'4& ) * &' E5/B &3&3'&(& 2+ 2 4>()+5
/  4' +5"

 &(B 4!+ / +5
  &(B 4!+ 9/ +5
" &(B 4!+ 3(-+' 4'

!+5C

&(B 4!+

*(1'& E5& +( 2>&3'+-1()+5C

&(B 4!+

*(1' & EB3 *33 +&(<'!'!-*&'!)4(1&3'+ 2 4>()&3'!'*' +'!&( ++'++3

*(1'5 '!-*& + 1 !'

 &3' + 2 4> (  **(- & () 9/ /  '&*5 3 :' &( <' *(- &'!&(B 4!+

*(1'()&3'!'*' +'!5&3 +<''

3'2!<>&3'( @<2'9-64'1'

$% ) $%  *

$+%

$

  &3 & > !'!-*& + +3(B

 &3' + 2 4> *'4& ) * &' + !'!-*& +&(B 4!+ /2 )'

+-4 *'64'1 -1/4'6 >1'

&+()2( +'&*5/+3(-2!

(& <' 'E*2-!'! )4(1 &3'

*(1'5 3-+/

*(1' () &3' !'*' +'! + ++'++'! + +5
"/C 6'41( &3#
/ C

% 5'5+5
/C/C 6'4

-15 :

'B()&3' .- !'2

'+ () &3' ( 8<2' 9-64'1'

 &3' * +' () # $ % #+-64 %/

*4'1'

&( &())-&-4'64(+6'*&+ &&3'4 &'() D# "% + ))(4!'!/ + &3' !'*' +'! B + " >' 4+ (2! & &3' & 1' () ** !  .(:'4 1'

'162(>''/ B3 *3 & ='+

*(1' () &3' !'*' +'! &( +5//C" 6'4

-15  'B()&3'.- !'2

'+2 !!(B <>&3'( 8<2'9-64'1'

* +'()

 

       





 

 #% #

2%/ D!'!-*& +&(<' 662 '! +&3'!'*' +'!B + < *3'2(4 &&3'& 1'()&3' ** &#3 +1 44 .'3 :

.<''

!

++(2:'!&34(-.3 !'*4''() :(4*' ! &'!
"5 5

/ &3'4'<> 4'

!'4

.

*(1' () &3' !'*' +'! &( <' +5
/
/
"#C"


"%5-2& '4()C3 +<''

*(44'*&2> 662 '! +&3' + 1' 3 + &( <' 662 '! B &3 4')'4'

*' &( &3' .' () &3' !'*' +'! (& 3 6 4'

&+53-+/ 662>

. 1-2& '4()
"/!'6'

*>()&3'*2 + ++'++'! ++5
//CC#


"E
"%53'*2 &+ 4' 2+('

&2'!&(+5
/

' *3 )(4)- '4 2'E6'

+'+ !2(++()'+& &'5 &'41+()&3'?-!.1'

&()&3'( 8<2' 9-64'1'

+  ,   



   

(


%% (



- (
(  !!'* () &3'( @<2'9-64'1'

. ! 

/ !/ $!



* $)!

 *

&'

(
( 2 66'22 &+ 4' 3'2!'

&2'!&(+5"

/

' *3( &()2(++()) 2*( +(4& -15 4'/&3-+/'

&2'!&(&(& 2*(16'

()+5
//CC!'& 2'! +- !'4, 7(++()!'6'

*>#


"E
"%
+5
//CC 7(++()) 2*( +(4& -1 +5C /

 7(++()'+& &' +5
/

 - '4 2'E6'

+'+ +5
/

3 4 +5
//CC

3' 1(- &()*(16'

 24' !> B 4!'!&(&3' 66'22 &+/ ''!2'++ &( + >/ +3 22 +& ! !'!-*&'! )4(1 &3' 1(- & * 2*-2 &'! + <(:'5 66'22 &+ 4' '

&2'!&(

&'4'+& &&3'4 &'()D6'4

-1( &3''

*'! 1(- &)4(1&3'! &' ())

.()&3'6'& & 224' 2 F & 5 66(4& 1'

&() 1(- &()*(16'

 1( .+&*2 &++3 22<'

&3'+ 1'4 & ( +) E'!<>&3'2' 4 '!4 25 4'*& +()&3'4 2

4'+6'*& &(1

'4()!

+<-4+'1'

&()*(16'

 1(- &&(&3'*2 &++3 22'

-4'5 &3&3' <(:'+ !1(!

)

&3' 1(- &()*(16'

/64'+'

66' 2 +!

+6(+'!()5 #7 + 

22% -.-+&"/ 











-!.' rts G3'&3'4+6' =

.4' +( '!, '+( G3'&3'44'6(4& <2' , '+(