High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14505/2022allowed

Sumit v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-09-03Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri27 pages

!"#"

$% &'& () &&&

$ * +(( ( (

&&& #, $ $ # )% -. )& ( ( (

$$$$ ( (

/ & 0*12 %

& ' ( ##)*##+ ,( -

! (

' ( .( /(

/ ! ' 01( %+2 /

, 5

( / 5 (

* ( 6) 6+ 01( %72

(

/ / !

/ 5 /

( ( #

5/ 05 2 ((

/ %%*#6%8 6+ #6%8 01( %2

( (/

/ #9 6+ #6%8 ( 1 6# #6#6

' ( %:

%% #6#%

1( 8 ( %;

%# #6#%

((

, ( # :

0" :2

/ /

314/

</ <

& 314/

(

5/ 05 2

' !(

(

( * 34,

, # #% ,

& "34 *34 34

9):

:)6 8% %7 4, #)% ### #) %7 , #68 %+) #) +

, %:7 8;

) 3=4 %76 %76

1 6 7

0 *# $

"#8"1"

"4*! "

* 9# :

/ 1( : '

/ > ?

(

314/

/ ( ' .(

314/ ,

1( 7 @A , %6+;)9;

31 <A "

4 ;

,B 0C2D

( A E - /

(

314/

A , 01( 72

' 1 /

(

1( %% ' .(

(/ 1 6#

4( ,//

& ( ' 1 /

1( 8 '

(

(/ ( ( '

1 .(

(

' '

(/ (/

314/

1( 7

4( ,// (

/ (

(

314/

& (/ 3 , (

= E 4 %6 6# 01( %#2 4( ,// ,// 1

%% 6# %):8

/ /

) '

)

/ '

6# #6## ' ( 4( ,// (

A , 01( 72 1 ( (

314/

4 4 ,// (/

314/ , ( G

(

314/

= E 4 (

= E 4 ( %6 6# / 1( %# (/ 4( ,// ,// %% 6# %):8

)

' ' ( 1( %7 (

314/ (

%6 6# 01( %#2 (

, ( ( .( /

& (

314/ ( #) / ! ' ( / !

& ( / !

( (

, ( / /( '

(

, ( / (

9 314/ ( (

314/ (

/ ( (/

( 9) 1( %#

() (( ( . (.

5 ( (/

/ ( ( , ( # :

" %9

, ( (

(

! " #

$ # " #

% # & '

( $#

#" " #

)

% " !

& '

( * # ('

$# +", ;

" %9 ( (/

314/

/ /( (/

' ( 3 , / G

' (

4 4 ,//

/ '

( (/

(

01( 72

/ ( ' ( ' 1 / 1( 8

(

4 4 ,// ' / 6% 6# 6+ 6#

(/ -

( ( '

5 (

(/ ((

" %9

6# 4( ,// (

(

4( ,// (

314/ ( 01( 72

4( ,//

4 4 ,//

%6 6#

(

= E 4 1( %#

%% 6# #6## (/ 4( ,//

( (/ (/

4( ,// 4( ,// (

(

4( ,// F

( .( ( %%

( (/

( 6;

(

4 4 ,// (

(

!"#$%&$'$ () *+, -... /0+1 2 3 2 ,+

,, * ,

4+4, 56 6",+54 "7 , 56, 8,+,, + 7529 6/+, 40,$$:

$; , $ )

- .//0/ 010//0//2

$## # % $ "

" 00//0// 030//0// ! $ 4

050//0// # 6 7

(4-72

6 6 - 9/052 % - / :# %

$ "

$$%

, 4+4, . 6 7+ 4* ,56 6",+5 3 "7 ,

4+4, .+, 4+6

,+ 5 <*# "=* 4 6+/ "6,+57# 7 56 6",+5 3 "7 ,$$%

+, 77++55+

564 "7 , 6+5+ ,++6 8

,5*0 +48,#/.+, , 4+6

,+ 5<*# +/ "6, ; :# 0500 6

# %

2 < #'" :#

' " 2 " 2 ) <

:# - !

% > ?! $$$# , - @#

- # 5"6, 6

.+##* /+0 , 5, 6

< #'"2 < #'"

#2 /0// %6

5 ( ( (/

( ( ' '

' '

' " #

( ' 1 / 01( 82

4 4 ,//

( ( ' ( ( ( ' '

(

/ ( .(

6# (/ ( (/ .( ,//

,// //

= E 4

314/ ( / %6 6# 01( %#2

(/ 4( ,// ,// %% 6#

/ ' (/

4( ,//

5 ( ( (/ /

) ' '

! ,// (/

(/ %% 6# %):8

,// ' ,//

( (/ '

/ /

/ ,//

%% 6# %):8

! ,// ( ,//

( ,//

( (

314/

( (/ (

314/ '( ' /

5/ ( ( / ! ' (

314/ ( #) / !

5 (

F( / ,(

)$>>

+#?"760 6",, 56 4, 6 $' & / (/ ,( ' ( F( /

? 4(/ ,(

' '

</ <

/ ( (

F( / ,(

( (/

/ (F /

+#?"76@ ("861

( ,//

/ (

314/ /

# (

( (/ ' / ( ,( %% 6+ #6##

(/ '

(

34 !

() (( ( . ( (.

E 4 (

4 4 ,// (/

314/

/ '

/ ( (

/ (

314/

( 9) ( ( ( .(

/ / (

" %9 , ( # :

/ (/ ( (

/ ,// ' ' (

314/

5 4 (

(

F( / ,( +#?"76@ ("861 ( '

(

</ <

( (/

(/ ,(

' ' (

/ (/ (/ (/ ( (

(

314/

/ (

/ /

) ' ( %% 6# %):8 ( /

= E 4 %6 6# 1( %#

F( / ,( +#?"76@ ("861 () (( ( . (.

(

& %9

5 ( #" / (/

(( ,( %% 6+

! (

( (/

4 4 ,//

' //

4 4 ,//

(

.( ( () (( ( %)

- (

' ( 01( %#2

314/ (

= E 4 %6 6# #6##

( (

(

/ /

) '

) ' (

( 1 :# "! # # #

# " #

$ '

# - 9/05

/ (4-7

1/0/ #$#

" <9. :# #

# $ ' B # " # $

/.//0/ !

$#"

# !A

# :#

"! # $ "

# " "

# $

2 #2 # # # $

# " /.//0/ #$#

" <95 ) "! # # #

/.//0/2 # +" # "

030/0// $

$ 2 #

# " #

# "

//0// /./0//

#$#

" <90 :# # "

" # "

# ! :#

# " # #" # "

" ! # //0// 3//0// :# # #" "

# " #$#

" <9 6

# #

# "

" //0// # " $ "

# $

' # $ "

! # .

6, 0 6+ 4,

,+, ,, *+5 #,+ +8

6,+5+ , ,

,+,+ 6 "#4, +4 4"4 6, 3 , /6 , 56 .!

4*, 55+ +#5, 6 84 ,

77++,"*7+,, 3

6,+5+ , +"

4*,

A+#++!64,/ ,, * 5+,56 60,+"4 , /6 56 , 8 ,+,+ 6886

3+,,++!464 ++!) #56 55+

6+8,, +"

, 3 #+/+*+#+,

6,+5+ , 4 , +4 B"

,5, 8 ,+,+ 6, 3+,,++!464 ++!

) #56 55+

6+8, +"

4, 3 #+/+*+#+,

6,+5+ , 4, 4 $

+ # 4 .+, C"6 :$ 5, 6, 8 ,+,+ 6 4"*7+,, 4,

6,+5+ , + , 6 84 , 77++ 4, $$

0+4 4+6$&;7+,+ 4*, 6 84 ,

77++, C# "D %8

(

'( '

) ' 6#

' (

F 4(

9 ,// ,// A ,

1( 7 ( (

314/

! ,// (/

314/ ( G

(

314/

= E 4 ( ( / %6 6# 1( %#

(/ 4( ,// ,// %% 6# %):8 / ,//

' ' ,//

& ! ( ,//

4 (

1 A , 01( 72

%6 6# 01( %#2 (

( 4( ,//

(

314/

& (/ (/

(

' F(

( (F

- " 80 6"

6 D0 67 , 53 # +4, 6 $'&:

>+)( ;$$ :

4 "( ( E,

( (/

/ #% 6% #6%;

(

E, ( (

(

" 8@ ("861

,( (

(

- 3## 40 6" +67E

'(;1

;

? 4(/ ,( ' (

(

314/

/ / < (

(

- ( ( @ *! *D

( ' ( ( ( @/

? 4(/ ,( '

( '

* /( .( 1 ( ( (

/ (

/ (/

/ (

( (/ ( F (

- ' '( F ! /(

(

F( /

(

( 3 :# " # $#

" "

" # !

# "# " #

!#"

2 #

!2 "

# :#

# #

# +" !

# :# # ! ! # !

2 ' #

# !

$ #

# ! " :# "

" #

" +"

" !

# 2 #

# "!

# "

5 :# "

) #

#"! !' "

2 # # $

# ' $## # !

# & '

( $# "

# /51/00; ("

# # #" ! # " $#

# " # "

:# $# " $ #

# #

$ '

# "#

# $#

A" , ##

- 6,55 #

,+ 77++0 6""* 4 4, 6 $$;;5 $;

/ (F / (

,( 5 ' (

F ( ( ( (/

& / ! 3 ,

( = 4( ,

/ (

(

,( / '

( .( ( ( / / ( (/ (

3 / ( (

F( / 4(/ ,( 7?"76D+=60 6"3 # +"*64+, 60+

,+644, 6 $(&1

6# ?!6+4 , 60 6"36 , .4, 6$;>( 1

F( /

? 4(/ ,( 3## 4@

("861

& F( /

,( 5 (

( :#"

# #

# $# !

#" ! !

# " 2

! !

! "! !

" ! " 2 #

! # !

! )

7?"76D+=6< ("8612 # # " # # -" "

# @(% !" # $

"! $# #

"! #

# :# $ #

# "

2 !" # " %" # # # " # 2 $# ! 2 "

! A

:# " %" # # # " ! # "# !

# # # !

# ! "# # !

# ) $

# #

# " # #

+" # "

# " # ) # #

! " # "

$" !

!A " # ! # )

5*1 # ;& (3*" $

*# +#& *& & ) $

*#2 # " %" # # # $#

#" # #

# # #

# $# # "

# #

< E" #

# ! # 2 !" # "! # $# ) ! # # +"

$##

# " ! #

# " # # #

! ) # # # # #" !

# # # "! # "

) # # $# #

# ! #

# # +" : ' # +"

# +"

! #

' (" #$

# # +"

# !

+" ! # 2

# !" $ " $

2 $"

! ,

F( /

4 4 ,//

? 4(/ ,(

/ 7% 6% #6#:

- 7?"76D+=6@ ("861

? 4(/ ,(

(

1 / ( E,

/ ( E,

F( /

,( " 8@ ("861

F( / =#+/ F, 6 6"D0,5 53 # +

$3 # + ;>

? 4(/ ,( " 8@

("861 / '

? 4(/ ,(

F( / 7?"76D+=6@

("861

/ (

H 4(/ ,( ?6+/ 400 6"D0 67 ,5 3 # ++ $&;&>5 $

(

F( /

/ ( '

(

H 4(/ ,( '

/ 7?"76D+=6@ ("861 (

H 4(/ ,( /

(

H 4(/ ,(

( 7 ?"76 D+=6@ ("861

H 4(/ ,( ( (

( /

(

H 4(/ ,( #;

(

:# # # A" 030/0/;

# %" #

? <

C%D - /0;

$# #

;00./003 # 6, E -" 2

# :# # # "

@# ('$ %

" $ 2 #$ 2 A !

# 6"#

# "

# # "

# ! !

# "

! # "

:# # !

# "# A

" #

# %" !

# A # $

) " ! # #

! # %"

7?"76 D+=603 # +"*64+, 60+

,+64F , 6( $1&

'&2 $#

# %" "

" # :# #"

$ 2 " !

# # "

# "2 # $

# #

2 $

! !

"! #

:#2 # $#

, #+

5 (

,( 1

1( %%

( / 1 5/ 05 2

4 01( 72

/ /

) ' (( ,//

! 4( ,// (/

4( ,// %% 6# #6##

(

= E 4 %6 6# 01( %#2

& %%

! 4 (

(.( ( (

( (/

' (

( ' (

4( ,//

' 1

( %% (

/ ( .(

(/ 01( %#2 %% 6# %):8

(( /( 1

%% #6## ( ,// ( / (

314/

(/ ( ,// 1 / ( ' /

(

( (

01( %#2

( 9) (

! ,// '( (

& '(

/ ' /

<(/

? 4(/ ,(

,( +#?"76@ ("861 (/ /

/ (

F ! /(

/ (

F( / +#?"76@ ("861

( ( (/

' '

' ( 01( %#2 %% 6#

( ' ! ( %%

& 1 /

(

9 (/

( 9)

%% 6# '(

/ ' / ) '

(

( %% 6# %):8 ((

( (/ %% 6# 4( ,// ,// '

- '

(/ '

& /( 01( %+2 1 (

4 4 ,// ! %6 6# 01( %#2 (

314/ /

314/

(

- ( /

4 4 ,// //

(

' ' 1(

/ ' / ( '

6 7%

1 / '

/ /

0( (

&'&

$ 534* = ! * I*" = I*"