High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/27614/2024dismissed

Abhishek Tiwari And ORS v. State Of Ut Chd And ANR

2024-08-22Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat17 pages

!"#"

$%& '&

%()&*&*&*+,

$ $" "

"&$

&*&*+, -&./ ' ! $

" ()*

+ , -.%'/0 *''/*/*1 " ('2 (*/ (30 (3) (0'

'*/4#.

$" + & " '0

6 4'7 "& &5

6 4*7 * -. "

"&$ &!+% ! %*

& "$

!" !!

#$ %" & ' ( )* %" & +,-&

./0 12 $"**(*#'3+343/5+3+ -- -,-/"!**06!1 "!"1 !' !* $7 !1 !'54,,&!!' !* ! -- -,-/ 7 * '1!189!

! -' *

$/8*' 2:$ !2*" !54,,&;2 1 ;2 0& -,,+/334/ 0 7 **7 *! !

0 * # ! !) ;1# 2<;21

0 # /-4,.,,,,3-/ 2=

;6),,,/-4 0 !'54,,&0* ""2$"$-

-,-/ !8!

!' $ " ** " #'3+,.55+,,

" ** 0> ( ) 2$7 -+&5&-/*$!?-+&5&-/@ 2$7 -3&5&-/ 8 - /, ( A *"7!3+,.55+,,* 7 !89 4'?0> ()@'

?0> ( ) 7 *

!8'' !

$!*/,&5&-/!13 (

"*!@!1" !'.+ 5.,&&#'-,,+/334/?;2@ $!&#'/-4,.,,,,3-/?2<;2@'0 * ! ! $ 0 6!1

2 ?'1!18!

!'@ /,&5&-/' 0 * *!$!$*B !"!!' ! *-,-/

$ * 0 6!1 7 * ?'1!189!

!-' 1 " ! $ "!! ! +.

5+,& 2<;2 1 0& #'

/-4,.,,,,3-/'!7!**7"* ! ! ?!8!

!'@ " 7!;20& -,,+/334/ 1 0& /-4,.,,,,3-/ ?2<;2@' / *

0> (*?!8'@ 7***!*$! !

?!8!

!'@ /&&-/ ! !'+.-,,&7!*! 0**( "!;20& 0& 7*!!

0& * ! !) ;1 # <= ;1 0&# 4,,,5--3-.43/ 2=

<= ,,,353**7" **!

" 7! 0 6!1 7 ( #'+343/5+3+' . *-,-/*$ ! ! ?!8!

!'@ ! ! !' 3-+,.& 7! ""

!* *!" @ $ !('#'+34,-5,4+'07!! ;20& <= 0& 4,,,5--3-.43/2=

<= ,,,353' 2$ " ! $! !.&&-,-/' ,4 *-,-/ >(* $ 0> ( )' * !8C 4' ! !' +-.,,& 7! " "*

' 7!!;20& <

0& 4,,,5--3-.43/'0"**7!

*!$(' $%"7(+.4++ ,.,/47 !" ! 0> ( *'0**7"**06!1+34/ 5+3+"!!B1"' 4 * -,-/ *72 !8'$ 0)" .5 ,,,&2 !"' !;2 0& <= 0& #'4,,,5--3-.43/'A!

" **! 7 $ $ %" 0> ()(*+.4++,.,/4 06!1! !!(*#'+343/ 5+3+'2"* !'5 .4 --.&! !! ! $'DB!!! ! ! ! *" $ 1* ""$ * 0 * ?!8'@""!

!' 2 $ "* !8#1' *1' *! *** $ $%#0A2#/8 (02)''D!

* ' #$ %" < ; /&,3&- ( 3+++..,*$/8*'<, ,-,-/'99999E'

1 8

" $ " "

+ %*

" !

$+ !$!+$" "

$$ -. &

" %* 3(9$ " 6 ! & &$+& & "&

$$+ !$!+

$"8

" $

" ! " $ "+ & "& &

% *:"&$

! "& & '(/9*/*(5

6 4*7;! %* $$

6 417" "!

& & " "&$

-.$ $ , + "& &

( <

" $ !& $+ & & +$

" $ "

+ $+

%* !

$ $& ! $$ + ;! + "&

& !

! $ "+ $

$$+"+""

$ $ &+ 8

" $ & " ! -= $$:

&$ & )/(3030)// )292'*3/9)

)(9))/(/19

&" "

!" ! -&$ &

)/(3030)//

- &$ & )29213)2)0

& &$

%2 $$

?)292'*3/9)

& $ :

%*3 %

A+"$

)(9))/(/19

&> &$ 8 &:B'*

&8 %*

$ >C $:

= & : % '1*9'/(////20*01 .

#. #

:" % 9/'//3**2*(921 D - #

: % **''*1*2(**23'09 & $$ -

" #

: %2**/'//9/*39*3/6#

:%''/'*/21(*'/

$+"" %'1*9'/(////20*01 5.

#.7

& + !D%''''2:(

+ 57=:"% 9/'//3**2*(921 -#

:%**''*1*2(**23'09& $$-

: % 2**/'//9/*39*3/ 6 #

: % ''/'*/21(*'/

& >

%* @

%*3

A+"$

& DE

5 7- !4& "" ! "

E $ &

"" -#

#.#

"" - $ & ,

"" % **''*1*2(**23'09 5 & $$ -

" $ #

7 ""

%2**/'//9/*39*3/56#

7="" %''/'*/21(*'/ 5

& >

%* @

%*3

A+"$

& DE

5 7 #

& "&$

F#.#

:"%*//')122901

$ " 39#;! "" "

, ! $ " &$ & $$

$$ & $

& G&H"& "" G&H"& G& A<"& "" G6 4&H4"* "&

G "&"& - " ! & $"&$

& "&$

! " "

: 39# ;! "" 9 8

" $ & >

*1''*/*1

"$ &

"! &

% ' >C $:

= &

$ 4 : 394# ;! " " "

"" %'1*9'/(////20*01.

#.#

"" %9/'//3**2*(921 D -#

"" %**''*1*2(**23'09& $$-

" #

"" % 2**/'//9/*39*3/ 6 #

"" % ''/'*/21(*'/

$+E "" %'1*9'/(////20*015.

#.7

' + !D%''''2:(

+ 57

"" % 9/'//3**2*(921 D - #

"" % **''*1*2(**23'09 & $$ -

" #

"" %2**/'//9/*39*3/6#

"" %''/'*/21(*'/

& >

%* @

%*3

A+"$

& DE

5 7$&" &

! "" - ! "

& $ $%& 209*'1(1()5 "

"" %2**/'//9/*39*3/6#

"" %''/'*/21(*'/

& +

" 3 8

" $ & >

!$!

+ "

!$! $$ "

=2 #'-4-,-/!-3.

/-/ /-4

/-5 4,5/.2

! * "6* <!( !'E 0 $$ !

$ " & "

$ "

" $ & ! !"

$$ "+ $

!&+ ) <

" $

$ %*& H" "

-. , "& &

D & !

A" $

"&$

" *2/9*/*( +

-.& + , "& & 2 . !

" $

" '/ D I$ & $ &

!"#"# $!%&

'"( # ) & $$ 2#?!"@ < !061

!"17* !!

!$ !" ! ! ! !!"!' 2 !B "$! * "!' $7! !* $7$7** "$*!!!! !* "! ! !*' ! ** 7

* $**77*$ $7'2 !! " !* 7 "! 7* * *!77*!*$! "$!"'!$ !*!!7

!.+-!*C! -3'F!!!7!*!$ ***!! !!**$! **"!*B! *"!&$!'2!! !!!$!!!** $!!*')17! ! !!7!$! !$!!**!

!7$*C!!"7! $* " !!!! !!&*$' 7 "! $ ! *! "**!$ !! **

!*C!!"7 .+- !!!!* 7*"!!** !FE ! * 7**7 /, * **7 !!77B!=! 2 "

G//'H$=2 !7**77! !! ! "*&$' 2 $! "* 7! 1 *** ! "!!!!"$!!"7 "!

!"'!! *' 7$ $"!""! $I'

G!"*"!!$ "!"**7 7**IG'

!!"!"'2""! $!!"!7*! ""1!"*'2 !C77*!$**

*" $ "!$ *$ *$"** !! "!'$!* ' 2 ! $ !' 2 $7 "!7"!

!* 7!!! 7 !"" "!!'>$ ! !**!*!"!7!! 7*C *"$!7!! !' !$ ""'2 7* !! ! "!'''E -2* +, -

!"#"# $!&) .

!"/ (0 12 " 1!&)3

! %##4 7* !! C"**

!! ""*! 7!$ 7 * " $*$ "*!*B!'2 ! !"!7**$ )! 1$!

!' ! $*$ ! !.,5 .-, .5 .5+ .7 -,; * ';!"!

7**$! **!'(' !<"1(!?!*

! 7!@ "!! ! $*$**J7! *7!"*!7! 71 $*!7E'

*7)!

7!!!7!" **7

F$**I1 !**$! $$* C"!!!*" 7 *'

!"!! ""$* "!*7'2!!*7!! !*"'2!"""** 7$ ! "* *$*$$$*!1 ! ! ! $ $7**"*$*' *$!**$'2!I *!!'$

2 !!" 'E B! * "! 7! ! ! !

E' '' $$ D I$ $D $ @5873)9*/*1$ J /$" +5#6 -$7 $$ '2** +

##%)7!!$ K*0"C

7* B! =2 ! * .,52

!B!=2 !! !* 7 !"! "* "!*!*' *$!$!!

G5'H"!!!""!$!* !"! 7 B! $*$ ! "* "!* !* * "!"!$* "! ! 1" *$ 7 "!!*!*$"!! *C7!

!!*$! !!$ *! $ * *' ! ! !! "" !*! *!*7'G ?>"!!!""*@ -')!*"*! =2 B!"!*

.-,2

!!"77 "$"!!!!* =2 B!'2! ! 1! !$! K* 0"C ! +

!4##8 77**7""*!B!=2 !!!* **7""*!

*$ "!! 7*!*7

G5'+' * !! $*$ ! 7 ! * * * "!" !*!!7!!**$**$ """!!**B!7"! $!*!"' 5'3'2!! B! * " $7 "! 7!"!

"!!*$!

*" 7*!""!!" J 5','!C"""*! ""!!5'+'5'3'$'>! $*$*7** $"*!7* !"7"$!"!' 7* ! * B! 7 !$*$$1* !'!B! "*"* !!7**7*FG ?>"!!!""*@ 4'0=2 *!7$ * !!! " ""!

3 "$*!!!& 77!!"!* 1 "*7*7! $ $! 7 $* "! !*!!C$ 7** "* * ' 2 ! !"!!7 "*K!1<*! 7 1 * " 0 % '2!*!! "717"! 7!!"$!!!7 '

5'2K!* !"* * *$*$! 71'#*!!! ! ** !$!

** !!!! ! 7** ! $!**!"'!B! ! $* !

"!!!"$!'0! 17* ! ! !

$!!!$* ** !'-+'!!

1"!" !$!7!*!! !****! 7$!!' $!**!

!* "I*!

! $*! * " 7!&"*!

*! "** C"! "*!*!E' '* .

& $$ $!$$+ %*:"&$

%* "!!

$$ $$ 4& $ &

$ &

& & !&&$+& &"&

+;! "&$

$ & 3 (9 **(:4

: ""

! %*:"&$

;! &

! +$"

" "&

+ ! "

"$$"+$" "&$"+ "

&;!

"& & "

! & "

$ 6 &

& $$ " " + "& ! +"$

6 + $&& !

" ! $

$$ !" + "

$ & " -. "

"&& "+

$+ &

& !"& $$ + " "+

! " "+$"

$ , -.! "& &

'1 , $+ & & & '& & .&*&*+,1

@ :

C:% @ $ C:%