← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15602/2021dismissed

Shivam Gandhi v. Haryana Shehari Vikas Pradhikaran And Others

2022-02-02Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa,Mr. Justice Lalit Batra9 pages

 

 

    

   !" "#$%$&'(

    

             

 

   ') *+++

) *+* *



 

   !

  "

   

$$$$$ ++   #   

 % %

 # !&' ()  *+               %

    %         

  ,  ! % !

  - 

-.

 / %

 0! 5667

8  0  %

!#     % !   9  %

&##

  %

 #    &#  5    3+  !    :   # 7%  , ; ).  # % 

0  %

#

 ##    !

#

&  #  %                %   

  0     0  

      :  # 7%  



; )  # 0    0    /  %    !     7 0 #  



%

! 

        &' ()  *+  

    !*<

 )) +3 )667! %  

    *) )4 5667 

   :       )2 )6)6  

0 !  

! # 9  0% ! 5667   % ! *) )4 5667  

0 9 

36<! #%   # %#        :  # 7%   0 0 #  !

0 =  !8  !   9  0    



0 !

%  %    65 3) )6)6  =    #     #

0  ##                    :  # 7%  

 ! 

!   9  >#  =  !8   

      

%  # ! ##

#   # %

#  &# )5! :   # 7%  0  0#   

 !   !#%

, ;

3.0% !

%      ##    #  !         



 ?

 !3% 0%  %      0  2  0   !    :   8   #  

        0

,  )2 )6)6 

7   !#   

 ?

 % ! 0  #  ! !2  ! 



  #        #

   #      % 0

    

   &' ()  *+

  8!    

 9  ! # #  %  %  % ! %# %  !#0 



!#        

  !            % 0

  #  0 0@ 



 ##

&# 5 3+! :  # 7%  , ; ). 

   #    #  ##

#    #   %#    %# #     # # #  !          %       0  

!

! 

 %  #

       #    #

          #   

8   !  :    0     0  % :  # 7%   ; )

&    !:  # 0#      



-             

  

   

  !

  



"#$"%&"'

"($") (("* (+** +$* & ,,'"

*&"$+"*$,,"$* *")*& * "

)*& *) $ , "

)-"

'

 *$*,,"$*)*& *( *$+, (("* $,+  *&") $*) . 

)" +$* & ,, * *)/*&"'

"($".0"1"

*&"'

"($" *"$"

, *&""

"1"($") (("* .

2*3----- ----- ----- 4.

% /"

  "**")*"*&$&  

+"

**&"

+$$"

)+,' "/  *&"(

/"*)567)*&"'  /+*.

----- ----- ----- 8.

"

"1"#$"%&""

"1"($" & ,,'" "$ "

'

*&"

//**""$ **+*"

)*&" (+( ". &""

"1"($" & ,, "/ $) "* ,   & ,,'"+ "

"1 ,+ * *&"& &"

*'

9) $$"(* ":"$*  ' ;.

.

, ',*    * )# *$( * <  56.

------ ----- ----- 55.

&"*"  '

" & ,,'""=+"

* "( * "

"

* /"

"=+1 ,"**3791"("$"*;)$ * *'

"($")"

$& (("*  "( *", 9)&$&*&"'

"*"

*( *$( *""

+$*;  '")"  ( *$( *    *&"  "+$*.   &+

  "

*"  *' )/"*& "(("*  & ,,'""=+"

*

"( **&")/+,*(,"(("*"

&"

&" &"

*' '")"

( *$( * +$*.*&"

,,& 1"*'"

"( *"

 "( *",  )  "

$&  (("*  )  &$&    *" 

  '

" * *( *$( *".

52*5> ----- ----- ----- 53.

&"$/("*"* +*&* )0?#"

"1"

*&" &** $$"(* ":"$*  ' *&    ,,*&"(("*"

)/"

+$*$ $",( *("*&"" +$* *&+*

   

"

.

54.

&"'

 ,, * *)/*&"

"#$".&""

"1"($"

& ,,  "/   $) "* ,    & ,,  '"  + "

 )  "1 ,+ *  *&"

& &"

*' '

*&"$/("*"* +*&*

5.

*&""1"*) ") +,*'"

$&$/(, $")  ) *&"*"/   $ * 

 $ *"

 '1"))+ &  

 $"$*)/ * *  (*)*/")+$*

  )*"

*&"/("*"* +*&*  & ,,& 1"*&" &** $ $",*&"'   ))"*&," /+*) "( *"

'

*&"

'

".

58*2--------- 28.&" "

*"

9;)*&"+ +$$"

)+,'

" 9"-$"(* 05    "

$&  (("* ;  ,,  '"  ")+ "

 '

 *&"  

*"/

+*/ *$ ,,    *&"  $,   )  *&"  +$*.   "



$$"(* $"  ":"$*)05' $/("*"*+*&*  & ,, * "*&" "$ *& "1" 

 )*"

*")"

+$*.@   ?  !     

 % 0#  #! % ! %    0#   &##  ! !   !  # / % 0#  

#% !

   / %

 % 

  ! 

> 

0   !

# 0   ! #

/ % ! # 9  !0  %  %



0 *) )4 5667

% ! 5667

  0#  %   %#  !    !!   !  

  

  %

#   

%

!  % # %   0    0! #0

&  # %

%#    

 :   #   0   0#  %#      

        

/ 0#      0 /   

 # !  

  !  % % #  

 % &

 8  ! !     #!  #

              !  % 0

         

 /  !

%#   %

;     #  %     ;  &    #    &        0   0   %  %  0     ! # 3)! &   %  

  !

 

% 



 !  -%#  &     

! "" #!

$

! "!!

  %&'(

) ) ""!* $

) " + *,- ./01 2$1  3

* ! "" 4* $

"

. )) #. -567&/.0 8

+) ) ""!*#   00 %C "

!& 9:1 63 %&. );;

$"$ " ##* /        %    #    

   

 !   % !  #

        ! 0

 

  # !&# )5! :  #   0 ##!

 !   

 0   ! #!

%#   9  0   !  0   %#   %  !

    ! %#    #%# %#      ! ;

!!

%#     # D % # # )5!

:  # %#    ?

 ! 3% %   0   !20 !  !

  # !   9  0    %     0#



    ! #   %?

 %  

B #   ! #        

    0 #0 %?

   

#   !     ! #

 &# )5  ! !2 #    %  %  

  !  #

     #! #!

%#    %          #      :    #  0 0#    %#   

8  ! !      %

! 

  7 #   !#      !    %  %  %  

/    !       #

        %

8 0091.68<0$ <  91.  .    );

*  *3  ""  + +     -%#  &    !

 

    !       ?

 % !

  %#  #!

   / , ) " 

!

= 0   !

   0#  % 0   # 0    !    % # & #     0    %#    %#    0#0 #   

8  0 

   

  #  %          #  !#        

 

!   ! !              %    %

 

   0   0#  ##  !   !

#    ;        

  #  

#!&# 5 3+! :  # 7" 

 B    0!   :  # 7%         0  %#   B       # % 

 ## 

 ! :  #  # &# 5 3+ 

!     :   

    %   %

   %      ##



0         :    0     0  



E  

# !&# 5 3+! :   # 7%   ; )  

>   

%

0  !      0

C

++   * *

 

( B   7  F 7 B  %# F 7