High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-CW/184/2020allowed

Empire Real Tech Private Ltd. v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2024-04-18Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Lalit Batra15 pages

! !"

# $

% "! !"

!"#"

$%&'(( %$ ") "

((%((&

!"#"

$%&'(( %$ ") "

% $

!"#"

$%&'(( %$ ") "

% $

!"#"

$%&'(( %$ ") "

+ % $

!"#"

$%&'(( %$ ") "

& '(& ) )

)* +

'(& ) (( !,# -./ !0#!12132!.45 !$#!-5, 2 32!. ( ))16") !7"8 )! 6

," 9)!

: ! ! ** ;;;;

)

)* +

& - %.- - - -- -/- -- *! ! " !,5 :122, !

" "2"<

") 6:

))16 7"825#" 9)1,5 )) " 1. = ."2 = !

25 ))16 7"8!

11 4

1. = ."=1,5 : 4))16 7"85

") 6:

4!) 7"82"6 &01 $0 * "!

: 4))16 7"85 ") 6:

4! ) 7"8!

"# 5 "6 =5 ") $ $6

115 : 4) 7"8 < =! <6 << 6" < -. 5" #!2 #)

2 2 6 456"

"5 = !

2115 : 4))16 7"8!

1-1 -

") "

=5! #,56 << ! ! & !5 "0 =-!

:.25 =6" =

- ,0 5 = !<0,>#6 #) 5 " !

") " ))16" 7) !" 5 4! ) 7"88 5 ""

5" #! 5! #,5 =1, 4! ) 7"8 7"#)!8- = !

5" #!45 "5 .61< 5 66 !, 5 < =5 5 = ! 9!6 !

1 ="

# !!61 "

=5 "# == !5 ""#6 = ))! )! 4! ! ! ! !

6 5 #!

= <<#" !

6, 5

") " )! : 5 =61. = !1 :

1 )< 4 !0"$ 6 !+ 7:11, #1-8 = 5 3#!#,!< "! @!- <)1 9 = ! 5 3! #) #", 1 . :

! !

< "#!, * 6!

" 5 < "

6 <)1 # !5 9 !1

1 )< !0"45< - #< !2 ! &#!5 != !""#6 ="#65 5 !4!2 ! ! !!

6 5 #!

=<<#"

6,5 ") " !

""5 65!, "!

6 :

-.5 ") "

4!" !1 :

1 )< 4 !0" !6"

= 5 < # ! #1

7878 <, ).< = )! ) ! :

1 )< 65!, " !

45 $ 6 *7*8 =5 !.

1 )< ,#1 =@!-!

"62 4!!,

!< =)! ) ! :

1 )< 65!, "=#!5 !") < # !#1 =!.

1 )< ,#1 =@!- !

" #1 "2 +2 4565 -1, " 5 !

6 ! "6 ! 45 ! 6 ! < "6- < :1-1 5 1 61. ! 5 -""5 = < =.5 # !0, ).5 )! ) ! :

1 )< 65!, " 5 =!"!#6#!1-"6< "1,55 =2 !

&#!5 != !""#6 ="#65 5 !4!2 ! ! !!

6 5 #!

=<<#"

6,5 ") " >#"5 "" !1 :

1 )< 65!, ) 4!"1-1 " - "65!, -.5 ) !1 ,45 ""65!, -.5 ") 45!

") 6 16 6 "))1 = !-.5 6 <). !

=# ""65!, "2=.2)-.5 ) ! 4!"5 !1 :

1 )< 65!, &#!5 != !5 ""#6 =4!5 #!

=6 ! !! 61!,5 6 =5

") 6 #, 65!, !1 :

1 )< 65!, " "2) 1 "5 #) =! <5 ) !45 ## !0,. :

1 )< 4 !0 5 6 6 ! !

&#!5 != !5 ""#6 =4!5 #!

=<<#"

6,5 ") #5 ! " !

=# 5 < #65!, " !1 :

1 )< 65!, "1 ,45 " 5 ) !=#!5 !!

6,5

") " ,!"6 "!

41" =B ,2-#1,)1"!

4116 "

=#!5 ! " ). 5 !4 !0= !4 = 45",5

).< =-16 < # = =#!5 != !5 ""#6 =4!5 #!

=<<#"!

6,5 ") #5 ! " "65!, 5 -0,#!

=5 ) !2 + ,!:< =5 1 ="7"#)!8"61< 5 4! ) 7"8- 6< )!

5 ,! #25 ") 5 5 =

9!6 ).< "- 6 <,< -.5 ) !7"825#" 5

") $ 2" 9) "

" 4!" !1 :

1 )< 165!, "

1 )< 14 !0"- 6 <,6!! 5 :" " "11< ( #6, -16 16"

!6)1 < # 16 " 16" 1 "11< " #

+* *

* *+

+* *

+* + *

+ * +

* *

+* + *

+ + * +

* **

+* +* * + +

+* + **

+* *

+ +

+ 4 :

!2< # = 4" ) " -.5 ) !") !"65 #1 1" =5 ).< "< -.5 ) ! 66 # = !

# !/ 02 34056 0106 # 271 80$9

= !

2 5" #! = ! <0, 6 << ! !2 :)!,!)5" =5 " ! !- 6 < 9!6 5 = !25#"

6 61# 2 5 5 !

") " =1 "61 "

. "#==6 ""=6 !. !

" " = ! 6!!., # 5 :

1 )< 1 4 !0"2 ") 5 !"!

:,5 9) "

" 4!" 6# =5 )) "

!1 :

1 )< 14 !0"&#!5 !< !

25" #!1" 6 61# 5 5 !

") " 5:

5 < " -. 5

) !7"8 4!" !1 :

1 )< 165!, "25#"= !1 , ") 11 = < 5 = !

2 5" #! < !

6 7"8 5 5

1 )< 14 !0"- 6!! #45) ! = ,5< 5"

=! <5 <0, =5 6 << ! !5 4!) 7"87"#)!8 5" #!=#!5 !!

55 ") "4 #1-

1- !. <0 ))16 - = !

5" #!" 45 !" <

1"#<"!

C#!

- ) 5 ") $ -.5

) !7"8 - " " !

5 5 ).< " < -. 5

) !7"8 5 ") "4 #1- "#-> 6 :

!=6 -.5

$ = !5 6 <)1 = :

1 )< 14 !0")! "4 1 = 1- !. 965, 5 66 #"45 65 5 !

& '

(

)

+ $

- .

' 0

)

# = !

)! 6

, 61!

5 : 4) 7"8 -

<-1 2" ""!. 6#11 #5 )!6)1 "!

1, 5

:1 !6", =!

: 4>#!"6 -.5" #! )!6)1 "!

1, 5 :1 !6", =!

: >#!"6 -.5" #!!

6)"#1 >#,< < -.5

E-1 ) 9 #!6"

1 "E !"

!# $%&

' "E!

) !

() ### ( * ) +5 ")!6)1 "

9!6 5 = !

4 5#3

* 4 53 6

7 53

$ , "

"""

--"

. .

""7 53

! 8

)) + 9

#(+

: ;

< 1

+ < ; # = &

:..3

%+ .

*# 1 2"

$ 3 0"

'" 5# '"#6

() -7 823 (##8#) 9 8:

()

1 +#

4 53

) 53

< 0

53 +

) 53

53 !

)

53 !

5'3

1 ! 1 : 6 3 !12 !. "#-<"55 6 << >#,< 7"8"!:

- : 2 9=6

"#== ! =! < < !1 = 6 5 "2 !

! 45 !! ! !

<"0 "))!

5 =6 =!

6 !2""#6525 6 "55

: 4) 7"8!

<-1 - = !

5" #!

1 ! 1: 6 3 !15"11# = 6 "< -.5" #!5 6 << :

!67"#)!825#" -1 2-1 45 =5"-

9!6 - :

245)#!) !

65 ,"

:"F:"5 ) !7"8<0,").< " 5 ") $

4!" !1 :

1 )< 165!, "245 "2"6 5 "-1 "< ! ==6!5 !!6#1 5 "65 #1 = ).< " 4!" !1 :

1 )< 165!, "45654 =6 - )-.5 ") 6:

) !7"8 * 1 ! 1: 6 3 !12!.5"

1" =#!5 !6 55" #!451 <0,!

= 6 2 ! !< 245 "24" -"

5) !6 =5 < < #5"-

)25#""#-"

C# 1.!

65 =#!5 !# -1 6 61#" 55 !1 :

1 )< 165!, "

< )"#-"11. 1 ! 1 : 6 3 !12 !. "#-<"55 - :

!: 7"8!

=6#11.6 !!

6"5

") $ 25< ") 6=6)1 ,), ( 2 !4! " < 255 ) !5 :

) " 5

=!""11< 2") !5 "65 #1 !5 ! 1."#< =" +16"

4" ) " 5 2= !." =5 # =#!5 "11< 4")#1 4" 1. " ++ 16" 4" ) " < # = " * + 16" .

#"," 1" 6 55 "), " =5 4! " < 4") 1." 55 ) !5 1. ) " "6! !

5=1 ) "5 # < # 4!" 2 - " "" =#1 ="* + 16"2""#652"6 5

=6 -"

!: " G =5 5:

=6#11.6 !!

6 + 1" 6 55 -"

!: 7"8< -.5"

#!5< # =" 6! !

"5!

< 1 60 245 ") ""6 *2""#655 )! 1 , !

"< #"5 45 #. !1 :

1 )< 14 !0"

- ,< 25#"- ,)!5 !1" " -"

!: 4565" =!<1.!

5 =6"")1 5 4! " < 5 = !

6 "55 " -"

!: 7"84"4 !! !))!

=6 =5 6 !5 :

!67"#)!822""#655 : ) 7"8!

C#!

- 11 4 <0,5 - :

"#-<"" 25 "#-<"5)! ( , + =5 4! " < 24"") 6=611.)1 5 " ** $

5 6#!!

9) #!

= " ** 6! !

"2 6# =9 !1

1 )< !0"2 3#!#,!<,"5 1!

) =" *6! !

"5 = !

""< # =" 6! !

"4"") 5!

# = 1 ! 1: 6 3 !12!.=#!5 6 " 5 5 -"

!: < -. 5" #!2 5 11 5

1 )< 4 !0"!

6!! #25 ") $ "!

"! =! <!",.< #5" -

< 25#"45 #!

= !!, $ 6 *7*87878 = 62 #1 = +#1 "- " " 5

!<" = ,!

< 6# -. ) ! &#!5 ! 5

!: "!

6 !!. 5 14"

1 "

( D#1 65 ::$ =!. 5 !"- !,(

( = +5 1,"= 11 4"/

8 +

353 8 8 +

353

! 8 8 ' '

: %

2 ""%

2 .

&", ;2 "- ;

% ;

&"6 ",

-% -"-" *- "3

& " &", <" ;< 2 "2 ;% =*"

% "

2 "

;

2 "2 ;% =*"

% "

2 "

%# !

$ #

: ",

"."6 --

""- * .

& "

&", " ""

2 "

;

% -% * > "

# : ",

;

- & # 6 - "6

..6 , ; " * .

3# :

- .

*- &",6

% * 6

;* - " .

;

% -% >###?

1 ! 1: 6 3 !12!.5"

1" ) #5 !1 !4!) - !,(

1" - 6< =1 -#5 :

!< "< 5 "4!) 6 "

-. @ 2 5! #,5 " <0, 5 !

)1.2 ==: 5 !

: )! = 5 " !

)1. " 9!6 = ! 8 .

' '

AB6#

4> A @

;

@ % '

AB6#

% 4> 53 1"

+4 % ; +

/ 5% 3

0 ! +

, 0 *

% ; +

53 1"

4 9 ; +

# %

, '

0 <

9 ; +

% "

$ =

, ,

AB6#

* !

;

% !

;

@ *

! ;

53 A @

% -.

C !

0 AB6# % A

/ 0 AB6#

-.",

, 2

$ <

AB6#

;

# ;

D ! ; B C 8

&#!5 !< !

2 5 1 ! 1 : 6 3 !1 !.1" "#-<"5 1==:1" - 6< "# 2 25 "4!) 25#"-.5 15 = ,

!2 45 "!0 6 5 2 5 5 !1 :

1 )< 1 4 !0" 1!

. " 6 <)1

3#!#,!< @!- " H!1= !5:,"#-< 5 1 !

)1 "25

) !7"8

+ =1 <"6 11 #"))16 C# ", 11 45 < 45!45 4!) 451- !. =1 5 "< 45-

!)!6#1!"25#"1 , 5 45!41 = "4!)

"#11. 5 1 : 6 3 !1 !. "#-<"55 -"

!: 7"8"< -.5" #!255 4" )! ,!

"" 5 6# = !1 :

1 )< 1 4 !0" 5

"6 = 5 6#, , 6.2 .

5 !

") 6 6 ! 2 ,5 ) " "#<" = !1 :

1 )< 165!, "25#"

1" "<"< ! !! !))!

5 =6 =5 6 !

$6 25 - :

)! > !! !"-.5 1 ! 1 : 6 3 !12 !. !

""!1. 9 =6 <= ", <"

"2 5 =6 =5 6 !- " "45 5 " !! !"!

-# !! !"))!

5 =6 =5 6 !"25 6 << :

!6 7"#)!82< -.5" #! "#11.5" #!" =5 =!<: 55 :

!67"#)!8< -.5" #!5"-

< ,! ""

)!#!

= 5 )! > 6 " " < 5 !

)1 "2 ==:2 =#!"5 5 !1 !22 5 "4!) 7"825#"-.5

") $

* !

!25 6 << >#,< 7"#)!8"< -.5"

#!"!

"4565!

6 <)1

1.6 =16455

#6 ! :

=6"2")! > 5 )1 "2 ==:2=#!"5 5 4!) 7"8-.5 ") $

)1 "2 ==:245 ""#65!

<# 6 ! :

2 5 -. 5 . )!< =6 2 6C#!

#! = !#5 "#11.5 6 4"!

C#!

- <

5 -.5 1 ! ! D 65 =5" #!24565< 5 6 << :

!6 7"#)!8 5 4! ) 7"8 7"#)!8 !!1.2 5" #! <" ="5 ":

!6 <")! > 6 "- 6 <,< - = !

#!-.5 ) !7"8

5 " <.2 ") 5 !

)1 "2 ==:2 - 6 <,=#!"5 -.5 ") $ 4!) (

4561 !6)! > 6 "5 25"#-"1 ) ! " = 5 !1 :

1 )< 1 4 !0" !5 ! 5:

6 <)1

25 " "6 6 ! 2- " "45 10 )! > 6 "!

< 5 1==:2)) 454!) (

+ 2""#652)!<=6 25 4" 66" = !5" #!

6 61# 55 4" "#-"1)! ,!

""5 6# = !1 :

1 )< 1 4 !0" ! )!< =6 2 5" #! 4"

C#!

- <0,. -"

!: 5 ") 5 ) !7"8 )#!) !

1.).,5 !1 :

1 )< 165!, "2.

5 " < #" !

<, #") -. 5 6#, , 6.2 5#" = ! "

6#,5 !1 :

1 )< 14 !0" (

)

+ = !<525" #!="< !5 : 4) 7"8 7"#)!82455 - :

!: 7"825 "< !

11 4 5

6 << :

!6< -.5" #! #) 5 4! ) 7"87"#)!8"!

611 5 4!) 7"87"#)!8!

" !

5 !!

") 6:

!,1#<- !"5 "< - 1"

= !5 !,2 ") !! "

$6 5 < !

: 4 ))16 7"8 "

1= 5:

6 2 5#"2 11 5 ) , ))16 7"82 = .2 1" "7"8 ") "

!: 7"8< !

1.= !") "111 4, = : 4))16 7"8-#"511 == 65 < !" =5 6"

- !!:

5 " !

4!) 7"8 7)

)* +

7(( 9 % "! !"

",5

!") 0,!

" / '

) !-1

/ '