← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO(FC)/282/2016dismissed

Ravinder Yadav @ Ravi v. Vandana And ANR

2018-08-10Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi13 pages





        

 

  



  !"# $"!

% ! &# '# '" (#

)"     

  

&# #

&* + *#

"!

# -.. +

"!

)#

# */

#,+

"!

#)"

 # & $"!

"!

))+  001 

 ))+  0 3 44444444   



5( #.+ #!

71 .+8  #



71 #"

*

" #.+ &#"

# # (# 9#&9 : (++ ;

". )"

.+8  ""

0 

++, #)".)+ ,(#68 "#"

)8 .

22 = .(

, 2 = .(

.#  " + ) #(# "# +# ++ ###

 ,( )#"

> .( )8  # # 6#

( !#8 .( 6:



 ? 6#   # .## +.@"

6, )#!"# $"!

.)+

*.'"

1  1

5( (#"

.## 6( )#   ,"+:

.+ (+"

6#

0

 1

? ++"

.)+

(## ###"

9( #)"9 .## ""

#!! +   "."

",#8 ++ #. ."

  (#  (" .(# ? "

)# ++ #. !+!"

(# +"8

*(

+.+8  #"

  (# .#.+ (. 3  + .# (+"

-! ")"  # . 6( #)" )

2 #& +. ++ # + # )# "  "+ # 

 (   # 2 = .( (

 ( 

0 ) #)" "

+ ,# . ++ ++ ,# ""

1 )"

))#"

, 6>  (#+ >."

&A

,(+ >. *;8 + &A /  &A0 B!# *( /8+ &A1 *;8

## &A2 &#:( ("

&A

-#( # &A3

 . C>&

C>&00

#:

#: ,# #+"

) + "   . (#

A(# +8

0 >."

(.+ A

2

# (# 6( " #  (# ( ##"

 # " .+8  .) "

;

". ""

0  (+"

, +"

22 = .(

.#  +"

2 = .( ,#" .

#

&* + *#

"! # -.. +

"!

+ ))# 6(+ " . "

((+8 >! ? # "

6 ##"

)#+ ?"

#.8 +8 ) ))# (.+ (+"# 6#   ,"+:

# .## ? 6."

#"

& +.#8 6# +  D#( "

 "(#"

"+ D#"

 3 7 .# "6+8 ) ("

(#  >)  (#

# + #

? #(# # "

 6# # .## #"

. (+"

("

"

#( ("

+ (## ("

. (+"

! ( ( .;# #"

,

# (,!# (  "

.6(! .)++"

+! .#.+ (. ! )

-"

##

 "."

,("#, (## )

*

0   6 -"

##

  .)+#)"

# "

# +8 "# . )" ? 6."

("

) #("

+ .

1 .)+#)"

+ ""

> "

3 

3 &# # # */

#,+ +#"

+ ))# 6(+ #)".)+ 6. . 6+ . "

# )"8 )# #.+ #! ("

#"

##

# +"

# ! # .#  #)"

 (# ,(

 8# +"

") "E  . "

 >

8# (,!# +"=. !# ###"

? # "

. ))# .# (+"# 6# # .## )+8 +  (+"# ,# 6 6# (

) .#+

#")# " (# ("

  .##" ? 6."

" . )#"

"

##"

, +"

+#+8 #+  . )8 .

 ?

(! (#"

+#"

+ )# )#  ##"

 (# 

7 5(# ")  6   .## +.@"

6,

1  1   ,"+:

.# (+"

.+8

(8#)"



6#

0

 1

+  # "#  

 

     

 



# " .+8  .) "

2 ;

". ))# !" " . )#"

"

##"

. (+"

.)+#)"

+"

22 = .(

.# (+"

+"

2 = .( " + )

++ # .  #"

6# ,# #"

6# #+ . ,# "

+8 "#"

#+ #

# " .+8   )#  6#!"

+.

)#( 6"

#!! .#+8 ) )+8 +

? "

) 

)#"

"

##"

C>&1 ""

#+

+ ,("#,+

 

)#+  +"

"

 (.+ (+"# # .## )

#+ "

") ,++ )+" "

6( (+"# ,( # , "

+ # +! (# .#+ #"

)# (,!#  . # . "

: . (.

"

 #+ 6#!"

. ( (+"# #+ 6#!"

#>. "."

" (#  ""

8 *(+ <#+ 

;.# (,!# +.

:

.8 6#(# .: )8. "6+!"

+"

+"

8 !" ##"

 #+ )+"

#+

) # C>&   "

*;8 + (##"

  &A ,(

. 8# 

 (!

(, 6 ,#( 3 0 101= 6:

 "+ C>& C>&0 C>&2 C>&7 ,# # @"

#+ .8 ("

#!"

(# # (  .  ("

,("#, (   ,# +"

# + ) #+ #(# :

  (# +# ". +"

  ???

D:

& * :(#+ *D?

(# + "

*D&  * # + )

#+ "

.)+ .!"

))+

#& : )#"

 6:

 "+ . (,!#

""

(! 8 6:

 #  (# ( )  ,(+ +. ,"

(# >)

# +"

'++ D":(#  #(#.# #+ 6#!"

("

!#8 +#+8 #"

+ .#+  6! +8 ")#! .)+ (# #( + +.

+ #  . 

0

++

++ #"

+ #

# +8  (" # ++

#"

+

##" # +8 # ,((# (! # # ,( ) #!, )#"

2 #&  )

-"

## # "

# +8 "# "

6 )" 6, )#

5(  + (  ( )#"  ##"  .

6 "+ (## 8 .. # 6#!  

3 ##"

6! ++ , +"

++ +:+("

)#;

" ."

6+, ,(# )

-"

##

 )"

1 * # # . #"

+ ##"

) #( . .)+

#"

. ""

.)+ ,(+ ))# , 6> &A

#+"

) C> , +"

#+ # ,("#,+ + (

)#( 6"

""

+"

8 !" #6  "

, *  )#( 6"

6+

2 (# , >."

#)" 6# #+ 6+"

"

)#( 6"

 # . >) )

&A *;8 + )#!"

##"

#  "

(.

#+ +  )#( 6"

 3 0 101 3 8# 

&A0 /  ( # & ;6 *"

D:

.

F+ <# "

)#!"

##"

 . = # C #.

)#!"# )##

&A1 B!# *( /8+ *# # ???

D:

*#

6# ( ##"

" . #+ 6:

 (! ) 6+   201

 0 *.+#+8 &A2 *;8

## +#:

& ;6

+ D:

* :(#+ 6# ( ##"

" . #+ 6:

 (! ) 6+

72

  (# ,("#,+  ++ . +"



7  2

&A

&#:( ("

.#

 * D:

?" (# + "

6# ( ##"

" . )# )  (, )#"



10

,("#,+ ("

  &A3

-#( # *+ A", )## *D&  * )#!"

##"

" . (, .

+ ,("#,   ;+8 !"# . .+#+8 .

+ ,("#,

  2



  .

+ ,("#, (# ( (E  .

 # # #>. ,(+ ))# , 6> A

"."

" (#

  "8 8 <#+ *(+

;.# ("

)8 (#  # +#+8

- "."

" #+  

. 8+ # C *+:(# # *# B+!8

'(# ("

 ##"

#.

## #. C>&0 

- "."

(+"# ))#  6#"

(#

- "

 8 (# (# - "."

("

"

+  .6# &#+. 8#

777

3  # # )"8  #.+ #!

+."

,# ! )#)# ("

) #("

..!6+ )#)# . #

+ )#)# #("

# * -#8 "#"

"

 !# (# ( ?! #  !#8 . ("

7 ."

 #)# !"# ,# # (#(+"# ++, )#)#G

 ,# )

=1( (# /++

01= = 01= =0  <#  .: )+ 6# #!   '++ *+:(# !+  "

6  ## #( !+ # *( 5# *( /(+ )#)#8 ."

 *#

+ +"G

 (! =02 (# + #:6

:+

.#+ . 1 :+

.#+ ,( #!   !++ :

6"

+ D":(# 5(+ *( # # #.

)#)#8 ."

 *#

3 + +"

  #(#  #)# * -#8 .+8 . ! ,#  D66#:

*(( D6 # !++ /") # # #.

!+  (  "



2 ## *( 5# *( /(+

#( )#)#8 ."

 *#

1 + +"

*( ,# - 

20

*#

# #.

!+  (  "

6 

2 ## )#)#8 ."

 *#

 + +"

)# :( $"!

# ,# +

C *#

2??

# #.

!+ "

6  + )#)#8 ."

 *#

3 + +" ( ,# ..#+ (! # 02 E 8#" !++ /") # ++# # . "

6  7 = E 8#" 8# 

)#)#8 ."

 *#

7 + +" A(# )#)# ."

 *#

0

+ ""

6+ # .+8 ..6#

7

2 #& "

. # +   # , .# (+"

# +" )# # ."

6;"

!#8 "  <# )#!"

. # +  #  ++ ,(  + ,)

#+

0 ##"

#+   ?"

D8 )#!" .)+ )"8  +."

#+ ++ :  # +"

, (+"# # + "  (#68 "#! + !#8 ..#+8 #. (# 6

  #.

#" !" +"

" . )#"

"

##"

 #)#  6 "+8 +# ")" +8 ) +."

(.



,("#,+ (!   ? 6 "+8 +# )# ")" . (! 6+ (# . (## ")"

) )#

. (##"

  ("

..!6+  ,#( 3 0 101=

) 

+@"

"!  ("

(# " !##6+ (.

. "#   "# 6:  " "

6! (,!# +"

. "

# )"8 )# + .) (" + ,#(

" #+  

. 8+ # C # ? #"# !"

+6+8 . #)" ""

"+ 

") ))+

#&

5( +#+8 #+ 6# ! ? 6:# "

( "# 6#! #+  

          





       

  

    #)" # , .# (+"

, +"

"+8 6 +"

+."

(. C>) #)" " (! 8 (# +6+8  " (# # .## # #" (8 # #" (# .#+ #"

)# . (. " (#   .##"

5(##  +8 + " ,( ,# #."

)#)# .G (! !"

6#"

(#G "

+ .6# &#+. 8#

777G ,( " (# ("

 ""

8 <#+ *(+

;.#  #) "

+8 (+G ,( (.+  



((8 "."

*(# .

*(+

#!+ 8#   8 #( . 6 6 )# .# . # >!  ? , +"

6 )# . ,(+ ") ) +8 ""

# ## +"

: # .#9 "

 >  8#  ""

# 8  # + #)" )#. ) #(  (. # ,# 6# ( #( ,# ++8

)6+



 .+8

6  #."

+

= !#8 (6 #("

# + .)+ "

 + (,"

.) 6 "+8 )#"

0

)# 6! "

# )"8  #.+ #! #.+ .++ ))+ ""

1 2 6#

 0 )###"

;!

$"!

6#(# .)+" (.

0 ++ 6( )# # ++  ( (# #8 # .)+  (8 .8 ># .8 ))+ .+8 5(## #.+ .++ ))+ ""

2 2  6#



001  . 6 . ! .)+" (#

1 #(# )#8# ".+ ))+ )#)"

0;!

$"!

++ ))+ ;!

$"!

("

+!

(#

1 5( " ".

 #8   ++ #"

#"

))+ . 6 # #)"*  #)# 2 1 #) + )#)# 6."

.)+#)"

? 6( ))+ (! 8 #! ##" (# #( 8 (8  !+ (#

#."8 #" +,

))+ # #8 )# +

)#

)#" "

2 #&

2 ? !, # "  "#"

!, (# .#  #.+ #!

0 . (#68 "."

 0 =

"#"

+# ### ,( )#"

(# .( "8

#"

#+ 6  6:

  



!"#$#"%     A((# ):=#"

$=  A((# #)#6+ $=