Bahal Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS

   

       

!"# $#%&'&()
*
 !+!,-&(.+ #"&"&(#/ '

0#/'1'

-"!"# 1(2!3!($"+#/'

#'4($#(" '

)  56  - 7 6-  /#'#(")8 /--&$+19$:%!"#9 /"+#4#"&"&(#/ /-!"+!(&!9#41"; 1(2!3 / 14"!9$:%!"#9 //#'4($#("'
!($<  +#"+#/"+##4/"#/' ,%!,(#='4!4#/>!;3#!,,=#$" '##"+#21$.>#("?#'
 3#/# #//#$""+##4/"#//("#' < +#"+#/"+#21$.>#("'+1,$3#/#4/"#$&("+#$&.#'"?#' 88 88 6- 

6 +#  4#"&"&(#/  +!$  /#"&/#$  !'  1%"&(  #%/$#/  />  "+# !/"@#" >>&""##9!('!+#4#"&"&(#/+!'&>41.(#$"+#/$#/$!"#$ 
A  ((#B1/#88 9  4!''#$  3;  /#'4($#("    <  &#  "+# $>&(&'"/!"/9!/@#" >>&""##9!('!9!($"+#/$#/$!"#$
C


((#B1/#88
94!''#$3;/#'4($#("9$&'!,,=&(."+#!44#!, "+# 4#"&"&(#/  ($13"#$,;9"+#4#"&"&(#/9=+=!'=/@&(.!'!(1%"&( #%/$#/9  +!$  /#"&/#$  />  "+#  '#/:&%#  (  <

   #  +!$  3##( '1'4#($#$ />'#/:&%#(
C($!"#$*=!' /#.&'"#/#$1($#/-#%"&('A A A* !.!&('""+#4#"&"&(#/!"- !('!("+#'!&$%!'#9"+#4#"&"&(#/=!'!%D1&""#$ "+#%+!/.#' /!>#$ !.!&('"+&>9:&$#21$.>#("$!"#$A* ((#B1/#88< 94!''#$3;"+# ,#!/(#$ +&# 1$&%&!,!.&'"/!"#9!('!+#4#"&"&(#//#82&(#$"+#$1"; (
$1/&(."+#4#($#(%; "+#$#4!/">#("!,&(D1&/;+#

8
8 $#4!/">#("!,&(D1&/;=!'%($1%"#$9&(=+&%+"+#4#"&"&(#/=!'+#,$.1&,"; !($/$#/$!"#$
 ((#B1/#88A =!'4!''#$+#/#,#:!("#B"/!%"

/>"+#'!&$/$#/&'/#4/$1%#$!'1($#/)8 +!"!

"#/"+&'%!'# #>4,;##-+!+!,-(.+=!'

!(!,;'#$  &(  $#"!&,  !($  $#%&'&(  =!' >!$#  "+!"  (#  !((1!, &(%/#>#(" 

/(#;#!/(,;  -+ !+!, -&(.+ 1%"&( #%/$#/=!''"44#$"#>4/!/&,;!($#>3#FF,#$!>1("&' /$#/#$"3#/#%:#/#$!($"+#$#%&'&(=!'!,'"!@#("+!""+# 4#/&$'4#("3;#>4,;##1($#/'1'4#('&('+1,$3#"/#!"#$ !'$1";4#/&$ /!,,3#(# &"',&@#4#('&(9&(%/#>#("9./!"1&";

#"%G "  %>#'  1"  "+!"  !

"#/  "+#  &>4'&"&(    '!&$  4#(!,";9 /#'4($#("<4!''#$!("+#//$#/$!"#$
A ((#B1/#88 =+#/#3;&(4,!%# "+##!/,&#/41(&'+>#("!=!/$#$""+#4#"&"&(#/9"+# 41(&'+>#("  =!'  #(+!(%#$  !($  &(  4,!%#$    '"44!.#    (#  !((1!, &(%/#>#(""#>4/!/&,; /(#;#!/9(#!((1!,&(%/#>#("=!''"44#$=&"+ %1>1,!"&:##

#%"!($"+#/#%:#/&#'=#/#/$#/#$"3##

#%"#$ />+&'

4#('&(!/;  3#(# &"'   (  "+#  /$#/  $!"#$  
  ((#B1/#88A 9  "+# '1'4#('&(4#/&$=!'/$#/#$"3#"/#!"#$!'$1";4#/&$ /!,,3#(# &"'

,&@#4#('&(9&(%/#>#("9./!"1&";#"%931"&("+#&>41.(#$/$#/$!"#$ 
A  ((#B1/#88 9  "+#  '1'4#('&(  4#/&$  =!'  /$#/#$  "  3#

/ #&"#$!($"+#'!>#3#"/#!"#$!'(($1"; /!,,41/4'#'+#'!&$ /$#/&'/#4/$1%#$3#,=)8 +!"  -+/&  !+!,  -&(.+  1%"&(  #%/$#/  !/@#"

>>&""##9  !('!9  =!'  .&:#(  41(&'+>#("  /  

#(%#  

#>3#FF,#>#(" %#'' ##>!/@#"%>>&""##/#',1"&( $!"#$
!($"+!"=!'.&:#("#>4,;##3;&''1&(. 

&%&!,/$#/,#""#/AC$!"#$
31"&("&/#%"/

 !($&!/$ +!($&.!/+:&$#+&',#""#/ )

8<8
 <C$!"#$*
<"!/@#" >>&""##!('!+#,$"+!"

"+&'41(&'+>#("=!'/&.+"!%%/$&(."1,#' -:&$#"+&' ,#""#/!

"#//#%('&$#/&(. >>&""##5'#',1"&($!"#$ 
9    -  -!+"!9   - $>&(&'"/!"/9  !/@#"

>>&""##!('!/#%('&$#/#$"+#41(&'+>#(".&:#(""+# #>4,;##!%%/$&(." -08!/"8* < !($&'4!''&(."+# /$#/ 3#,=>#("&(#$41(&'+>#("!%%/$&(.""+#1,#A   1(2!3  -"!"#  ./&%1,"1/!,  !/@#"&(.  !/$ !/@#"

>>&""##9 ,!''8-#/:&%#1,#'99=+&%+&'!'1($#/)8 

(#  !((1!  &(%/#>#("    #>4,;##  &'  '"44#$  =&"+ %1>1,!"&:##

#%"  !($ &' /$#/#$ " 3# /#%:#/#$  /> +&'

4#('&(!/;3#(# &"'
 -1'4#('&(4#/&$ #>4,;##&'

/ #&"#$ "/#!"#$!'

(($1"; /!,,41/4'#' -$ 8$>&(&'"/!"/ !/@#" >>&""##G +#4#"&"&(#/+!'%+!,,#(.#$"+#'!&$/$#/&(!44#!,3# /# "+#-#%/#"!/;91(2!3!($&!/$9 +!($&.!/+9=+$&'>'&'#$"+#!44#!,9 :&$#/$#/$!"#$
C
 ((#B1/#88
 +!:#+#!/$"+#,#!/(#$%1('#, /"+#4#"&"&(#/9"+#,#!/(#$ -"!"#%1('#,9"+#,#!/(#$%1('#, //#'4($#("'
!($<!($+!:#!,' %!/# 1,,;.(#"+/1.+"+# &,# +#'+/" D1#'"&(!/&'&(. /%('&$#/!"&(&'=+#"+#/"+# 41(&'+>#("/$#/(%#4!''#$%1,$3#/#:&#=#$!($#(+!(%#$41(&'+>#(" %1,$3#!=!/$#$!'=!'$(#3;/#'4($#("
9"+!""! "#/"+# /#"&/#>#(" "+#4#"&"&(#/(<

?

+#,#!/(#$%1('#, //#'4($#("'
!($<+!'!/.1#$ "+!""+#4/#'#("4#"&"&(&'(">!&("!&(!3,#!'"+#/#:&'&(%1,$3# &,#$ 1($#/-#%"&(A
 "+#1(2!3./&%1,"1/#!/@#"&(.!/$%"9 3# /#"+#-"!"# :#/(>#("+#/#,#:!("1,#'!44,&%!3,#""+#

8A8 #>4,;##'    "+#  /#'4($#("'  !/#  1(2!3  -"!"#  ./&%1,"1/!,  !/@#"&(. -#/:&%# 1(&'+>#("!($44#!, 1,#'9

/'+/"5"+#1,#'5 +#'# /1,#'4/:&$# /"+#$#4!/">#("!,&(D1&/;&(%,1$&(.&>4'&"&( >!2/ 4#(!,";("+#'!&$/1,#'9"+#/#&'(4/:&'&( //#:&#= 41(&'+>#("

(%#!=!/$#$!($#(+!(%#>#(" "+#41(&'+>#("!

"#/"+#/#"&/#>#(" !( #>4,;##!($"+!""=&"+1"+#!/&(.+&>$>&""#$,;9#:#(& "+#/#+!$ 3##('1%+4/:&'&(9(/$#/ /#(+!(%#>#(" 41(&'+>#("%1,$+!:# 3##(4!''#$3;"+#/#'4($#("'!

"#/"+#/#"&/#>#(" !(#>4,;##("+# !3'#(%# !(;4/:&'&(9"+#/$#/$!"#$
A ((#B1/#88 &'

4!"#(",;&,,#.!,!($!/3&"/!/;#B#/%&'# "+#4=#/'3;"+#$>&(&'"/!"/9 !/@#" >>&""##9!('! +#/$#/ "+#!44#,,!"#!1"+/&";$!"#$
C
 ((#B1/#88
&'!,'+#,$"3#&,,#.!,  ('#D1#(",;9"+# '!&$&>41.(#$/$#/'$!"#$
A!($
C
 ((#B1/#'88!($ 8
/#'4#%"&:#,; !/#D1!'+#$+#4#"&"&(#/&'!%%/$&(.,;/$#/#$"3# ./!("#$  /#:&'#$  4#('&(!/;  3#(# &"'9  &.(/&(.  "+#  &>41.(#$  /$#/'9 !,(.=&"+H4#/!((1>&("#/#'" +#/#'4($#("<+!:&(.4!''#$ 4!"#(",;&,,#.!,/$#/&'!,'31/$#(#$=&"+%'"' 'C9 894!;!3,#" "+#  4#"&"&(#/   +#  /#'4($#("'  !/#  $&/#%"#$  "  /#,#!'#  "+#  /#:&'#$ 4#('&(!/;3#(# &"'""+#4#"&"&(#/=&"+&(!4#/&$ "+/##>("+' /> "+#$!"# /#%#&4" %4; "+&'/$#/ +#4/#'#("4#"&"&(&'!%%/$&(.,;!,,=#$

6-   

*
 '2@'