← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4128/2006allowed

Raju Khan @ Sarfraj Khan v. Man Pal Singh And Others

2024-11-27Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma13 pages



            





!"

 #$%$!&'

!( )* + ,-    



 .%/     

  '

 01

2/ 2  2

2   

   

  

      

     !"# $$$$ 2

2

/

&"  # '(()*   *     !"# '

  #   %+ (, '('-./0 %)+' '((,  !  #     !" 

#  "  

! 1 2

"1   !" 1 !  "  . 

      !"1    * 

   *#!  

"  / ! 

      

  *      !"# - 4      # 

*1             !"#

  1   %+ (, '('-./0 %)+'

'((,    !"#  * 

   

        *#!  

 

 &         *    

      1    ''

(+ '((5 "   %)) 

6  %7++*#  

!"& * . *8 

 9& *:;   " "    '7 +'5< 

  

 *# "   

 

') (, '((3 '

   "    2" "1 *# & * 



          *  # 2

  1   21    2 &           "     

"1 *# & *1 

 *      &            *  1       

"*1  1 -         1 

"# 1  #*" "  *# & * #*  &     # 

"          1

     )                     

   "*#= -(>  ?=3- 1 1#  

*#@,A

*  .  1#'-#  " 

11 1<?     %,

. * B   #    ?=3) 

 1   1 #  '+((< " & #    1   *#@7"

    *    21 14 

  2 

, B:*   "  !         1        

"1  *# &=!    67) + .%/ 5 67) +

&9 &!: +  

 27;+ ) !7+ % % 33                

 

!" "# $%&   

%  %    %'%(  $)  *  +)  '   $%  %

$%) (,* )

-%(%(.)% - 

%$%%

(*+  %'%(/(%$%/$%&/( )(%%)  '/(%%%$- %(%%%%* %( .)%* $% )*)% %

%% (%$%/*+  -%(,

)($ (%%- ) % % -)/$ + )' %) (%* -%( .) %*  - * $%(- +)-*)%  '  )(%%) ) +)-$%%*

$%(%* - %(%)

%* -+- $% %$' ') (%+-(*) +)%(%* -%%$) %)(% ) ( %%(!0120)*%$%3-2)&)%%34

0)$1)65478%%/%(91 !3(%# :( ! #011 %(;%&<

)/*- 5 15#  %()('  $%%'%((%

+)- %%

'/=       !#  >,   %/    %$  % ?%  $(  %%)/(%($

%),() !#:%/!%(/%#' +)(') (% $%(%(*+)( $/= !%#:%/()/(%$@ !*#:))%/%

)$%(%* - !#  ))  $(  ,    )%-  (%$%/  !A%

7%$%/# !#7%$%/%)/%(%)$%%% .)  +) !#:%$!%(B  $%%/# !#:, % !/$% /-# 3)% +)- % $%'

*%'%(( - )(%(!#!#!%#%(!#3 -) %+)- '  $( (  *%/( 

%$%% $%'

*/%()(%- %(!#!*#!#!#%(!# %/ ))%/

)$%(%* - ))$( ,  %$  !%(B           $%%/#  %(     , %  ,,, ,,, ,,, ,,,     

   



 !

< !#

+)!$%(%* %/$+)#( )  %/ %% - !# %/$%(%* -'  ' *(-% %*%)$(* %/

%/ %% -)( - %/  %/ %% -%$% %/$% (%* -!, %' %'*)% *% (  

)(% %/ %/ %% - %$% %/$%(%* -# !#( '%(%+)(

%$%',%$($ )*.) -%,$%(%* - %/ (  -/%(,$%(%* -  %/ %% -$/%'

%*%(*- *)% ' ( - !#%$$%(%* -$%-) ( %/  %/ %% -(((/) %)

)%+*%/() %%( % 

%$ ))%/, %(* ''  

'/ "

 #$# =+)(%'&$%'%%/(6 -%%( %/46

$%$%

(7 " ( $%(%* - $*%% .)  +)-'% C%( .)% $%(%* -   '%  .)%(  %  6 C        %/  %% -   '%(*-*)% % C*%(

* %)

%$% )($ -$*)% ' /%(1%

) % $%'

*%

'= %#)%  $*%

(=46

 *#:))%/%)$ ! C%)%  $#= 4



#)  %  %* ' %/= 5 (#:))%/=!

, 5#= 4

"

 #%#=+)('%%(%/(6 -%%/4

$8%(%$)%(%($%(%* - %(% C8'%$%($+*% ) (

/(8 % //%-$ -$'%* %& %(/%-+*% %-'% & -*%%  *)% %( ))%/ %% -% 5C1%

) % $%'

*%

'= %#)%  $%

(=46

 *#:))%/%)$ !5C%)%  $# =4



#)  %  %* ' %/= 5 (#:))%/=!

, 5#=4

"

   #&# =    +)(  '%    -%  %(  %  %  -% >//)(%) %

('% $% '$/%('%%$)%(%('%% ( $%(%* $'%%(%5 C+)('%  %% %())  %%(%.)( %% %%)/)  ))%/

%% -'%% %(%5 C

) % $% '

*%

'= %#$)$%)%  $') (

, %/%(*$ -(%% >/ =4

*#:))%/%)$ !5 C, (%)%  $#=4

#)  %  %* !

-%#  = (#:))%/=!

, # =45

D  =    /)  %((    

)%  !#  %(  !;#  % - /)3

)%!1#'%*%( )% %&$( (2)$%%!)%#E + B:*  "!   ' "  & ( ) 

*+ = ,



2  >   1

 %)) %)3%)+  6  %7++  1   8;

A             =     " " C 8D;

  "   C 8!;

  *  #" 8A;

*            "#    

   "  = 1 C 8?;

.           

  1 "*C "# = # &    "     '&$ -,%%* )$3 $)%%%* /) % %( %$ - %  )$%()% , ) ( * 4 

 4

 %(4 

   -   /%(%(%%

%*   ;)) (*% 

 .)%)$



 <&%') (* (/%%$)% '%.)%() (*% ( %/*% --%%(% $) (*%%

C%%-% <%(( ( * %)  %  '

 */     -          %(F B:*  "!    ,  )  ,-

.&( /0/0$&1/23  G5%% ' %.)(*,%$(*-)= 

 4  4#5# 

4#6#@ %%( %$)  )/*% %/%

%% 6-% -/+)(/$%%

3)% 1$%-:$(9%%-0%(

51H

!01#3%%%(+)(/$1);    -%$($)  $(*)(%$( %*  %0% % $%!0$#%(7  %1%%(

1H

!01#3%/ /)    

  -%    $)    %    *  "

"  % /  ' % /,(%* - %%(%

-()(*- %( )

  ( 0% 1% %( ) ' $  



)  %    $)      *  % (      %     %

%%*"

"%(" 5"   (

 4     

  4 

   

 

   478 3         %%(    %

%  % 

%$(

$%'%%(* (  )

?

H%/(   %I 

1H !01#  %( 0%( 2%)+%) 7%(I

51H 5 !01#<,%  * '  )H%/(!)%#%% = J 3%/ $%%-%*  (   (**$( $')%$% $%-(%* -

%(*-%%

( ( %'%( $%%'%( $%$)

%$/

'/% = !# 9%)/%(%)$%) /$%

(@ 8;

: $

)(/)) $@ !# %* - $ %(%$% / '%$@ !# ( ,

)(/% $$%-* .)()(%&))@%( !# :, % J D$%) (E %%(  %% *$%?(%%  +)(/$0%(2%)+% %!)%#/% $)  $('% /

-)(%( /%

-'

%* ( .)%-         $  %  %  )     (%    $% (%* -)(%%

( 3% )% ) %',%$ (%* -   %    '    %($B% ?%   



%%))$*(%- K-%$)/)

H%)%-

6%)+)%(*)% )(= J' 4 =

 !#

$)(% )% )$) !# % )** %$ !#

$)(% )**/%$ !# % )6(I$% %% /%( !# )* % % )/$) !# % )%$) !# % )**  / <%% )(/%%,( '/ )- %%

% )/%(*- %( ) (0% 1%%%$'% (% ) ;%%$%-%%$%( %)+) ',)% *(%% 60%(2%)+% %!)%#% '   % -/    $)    $(  ))      %(% $      %(  %  %  %     *  %&  

(% <%)).)

-'%$  %

%%(%%(   '/%()) $)% *% ( % %

%%&/$%(%* -%6  C .)% %%$*%+)(/$ %% 3)% 1:( %!)%#$ 

- %% !# (/%/%

%') (*  C% )% % %- %  .







 

 

  

   

/8

 3 %%(%

%%'%( ('%()/ )%/ C '+)( % ) $

)(/H%/(L

%!)%#%  %/%'%) ()%(*- %( ) ( 

%$'% ( C '% % (*-1) &+'&(9"+'

) %%(% -/ (   

) % $%*-%

%% )%%-') (%*%((% 

'= :

$  :    %/  ' !4  , ,6  B

4

))     !  

%((# 4

( ,

)(/ %

%/ )$  4  B

:    $%$%

  4

:    $     %$  %(  $%

%/- 4 

9%%()/ 4

%

4  6 B

%

%') ()* ( $% 4  6 B %

%$(% /'$ %% C%)$$(%%  %

(%%-$

 ;,(",< %(  1 *   11  ''

(+ '((5"  

 #     1 1*#B:*  "! "*   "  ""  *1  "  '+((< " 4 .   -(>  %%'(<8'+((F-(>;

  "  -, (-(<837'(F%';

4   

 -(> *#  %+ +%)<8-(> -,(-(;

  %+  3+ )++<8%++%)F%+;

 ?=  )7+'5< 

   +( (((< !   3( (((< &  !   '5 (((< 4 "    (( (((<

 A  3( (((< !

@ #!); &% $!&

+9 9' %/ -,3-<3 )!7&

+9 9 *8 +$*7& @ %/-?-<B &:

&# 9

)!7& !"

#!); &% $!& %/<-3- B %%

       *#B:*  " !  

= %)   

) ?

 3,

;) +

 ). ' .  &   

< 27;+ ) !7+ % %  ,-

"  

#  7>  "

"   "  G %'

  0 3     !"#              "1 1& *1  1 "

"   # " && *  

3 * " "*

 &

"   *

& * %3 B1 

0 3   !"#   

 " "

" 0 %'  1  ''

(+ '((5           

    *  %- .       !"#          *    

   

       1  #

"

      #  

%5 D   1" ! =   

        * !   "

%) A 

 # %,    # 

2

2



 0 "* ', '('- H    @ <I<0 @  *  I