High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12501/2013allowed

Sohan Lal v. Union Of India And ORS

2015-06-30Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan22 pages

GIANENDER KUMAR 2015.07.01 17:38

!"#

$ %&

' ''

"# $%

! & & '(

! & )* ++++ '' # , -

& ) !. / )0 '230 4% .

'22)

#'220 % % "

5 #

# )66' % . 78

9 % .

#)66* # )663 % . : 78

, ; . %

! " "

# 78

9 7

< =9 ,

. / " )6')

. "

. %

-"# !

.8 "

: 5

; .

% " . . :..

'3 %

> )6'1 % " .

% ! #

" 5 "

% ":

'6 )6')

@ . & 1) & **

, ": '?

'6 )6')

$% . / 5 # %

. .. '3 . '0#" ! . % " 8

! ..

. ') '6 )6') %

" . !

% ..

4 @"

!! "

# !

7/,9

.. .'?

'22)7

;'9 % ! " "# .. . )* '6 )66? "

5 .. .) ') )6')

! " #

. "#:

! . !

C .

"#:

;

! % % . "

& )* " % " "# . # )3 ') )6'' %

. .

: '?

'6 )6') "

4 @".:

!(! !)(*+,-".*/- 0*1*!)23"1,# 44'5 !(!

!)(**!)*!23"1+, ''3*10* 5'45 %

" 8 :

! " D "

& 0 .. . '?

'22) % # .

) .. .

.. : "" . %"

!"#:

! . ! ". .# ;

! " .!"

: !

5 "8

! " %

" ;

% !

% .

! %

8 %

! "

% ! :

5 #

% "

)3 ') )6''

4%! ! % % " % .! "

. .

4%!

% ." #

* )6') % !

.. . #

!! % %

# ! )0 ') )6') 4%!

! .! !

)6'1 % %

"# %

# '0 * )6'1

% !"#: 16 * )6'1 %

> )6'1

% 8 .

% ! :

.#!

: %

. %

. % '?

'6 )6') ,

. )'

> )6'1 "

" % %

" )3 ') )6''

! .

'22) ,! ) 0% !" "%

!#$"

% %&! '( !" )

* +,"%- .'"+ '

0112 03'4 5#$6%/ ! * *

.+ % ("

%# (% * ( * .+ %#% # * !%# *# "

$"". )+# * %+'( !"&)

*0 78

+ 9 # 77 #$:# #% # + $#$6% + +(%# *# "

$"". + ( 5 *

.+ % ("

2# (% * ( * .+ %#% # * + $ . #"" + " %+6#* ;7

+5#(2#

<=<9 - %3

52 #"+ . #( ""+ "

#% + #$6% + * )+(%#$"". + * $ + #+ %% "

. +#$:# ( + 0+ *# % >>> >>> >>> %&% '& &( %& (% ( )* %&+& ,&

- ,&.

& )++ /& --+,/+&?+ % +% * ( "

" * +

% @ ( ""

* # + "".

*% * +#"$(% "" $#*++ %+'( "! 2 / ##( A

(%.+

%+ * ++ $ # + % ("

(% * ( *A

(% .+ (%# % "%+ * ( * >>> >>> >>> 0 #&+& ,&

- ,&.

& --+,/+& ( ,& ,'

,+. *+'

1 /.( /& & - (? * .+ %( $ +'( "! 2 $# .+%

+% %# % !

+ % + '!2 % $# $+ %# "" ( .

""$% + + $("

% "%$ +'!2B + ""$(# "+%%"# % ("

% "(% * +( %

+ ".

""$ (("

$" + % "C , :

. "# :

'6 )6')

)

/ '?

'22)%

;

.# %

4 @".:

2% ,%& #(

4 .

%" !

% !

/ '?

'22)

%"#4 @".:

"! .

":%"

5 :

0 / #

)

: ! ""

# .

! "

!"#: %

#E .

4 @".:

-".*/ - 0*1*!)23"1, ''3*10*7 9 .#!

5# !"#

4 @".:

2% ,%& #( 4 @".:

F ! @C .#C '

. % "

#E .

.#H ) G

"% .#

H , % " .# %

.% H

5 % "

! 6$ 0 + :# @ .+ + (#( + " % (%# + % ("

% " (% * % $

+ %% +1#"",%++) $# "+ +"+

" .+ %+ * % ("

(% * %+ * + % "(%#

#+(" + % $

+ + ( "(% * % "(%#

+(" )+ "%(%# $" +%+ * %+ * +

#)+(% ("

* ( + *.

""$# $"+ #+ ( + " % (%# D

++) $# "+ ( )+%

% $ + " %#" + ((""

#+ + .++ # ""* - %""%% %((

#%+ * %+ * + .#"$ +

+ (# .

+ (" .

+ ( % %

( # )+ %%( % + % .#" #" 6# %+(" % + $ + >( % + ("

* - " "* ( %#"

" .++

+ %+

( + -(( *"

$ "

+ #" + # %+ *

%+ * ++ ""* # + #+ - * *+ " +#" - #%+ %""% + "

% "

+%+ *D+ #+ + %+ * + # + #+ + +(. #(+(" #+" #" +#( $ "( + " %(%#)+ #+ +# .

+ % $+ " +

#+ + %%"# + 1#""

,%++) $# " % .

+ %++ )+%%"# ""./)2( ( E % ( "% *

% *+ % $ + *+% "( % $ .

++" " + *# (%

% ("

% "(% * *

"A E + "%(%#% $"

%+ * +%%

+%+ * + "$+% "%# $AC 0 )+ #$ + + * % % $. + . %%"# ,# + #"

+ .+ + 1#"" ,%+ +

+ . %%"# % $ %% " .

+ %++)+%%"# +#"$ + + ( % % $ .

++" "

$% # % ("

% " (% * ( * *

+(" ) +

+ #$ +" ( * + * .+ %+ * %+ * + + " $

# + (" )+# +

% % +.%%"# C !

! , "

! "

% . "# : ! .

. .

.. -

% . , , "

5 "

.% ,

" %"# 4 @".:

!(!!)(*+' )3*'*/3*! 1

!!3

# !"#*27*8"49$ 6$)+:# +. %%"#$ +

9#*% + 2# 4

=< - .+ %++ .+ $ -D

(%#" *.

++ $% D

"+( + + .+ %++ ( % $ + '( "

! 2 ( + *+ (

#%+( +##( + ( "(% *$

+ + + # # # $" + $ $#*+ + "% "

+ " %C (%#% $ ()+% +'( "! 2 % $("

"%C" + % + ( +( "(% *+ $

.( * %%"# "

+ $( $ + (((

#+ $ # + + % *

.+ + ( " (% * .

#" "

> + " % %

* + % + '( " ! 2 .#"$( +% .#"$* %C *!:!)(*+"8*/*' 1;*!*1*;*!*

!!! # 0$#*2

7*8"<94$ B. + (

* +6#* + B *+ 2# + $#

)+ "%(%# .

.""

+%%( %6# (#%)+ (%# ( .+ (" # ( % % $# % ("

% "

(% * ( * *

+ +% + * + "+ %$ ( %% -( "%$ ( +(% * :# 4

=<9 - 522 ((

G/ 3 (E 78+" (% * ( * *

+ ( . + % "

(% *.+ %+ %:# "+( .

( * # .

+ (% % + %:#% ".

*+(% + )+( ":# (% *.

+ +"

+%+ * +E

+ 7;.++($% #(

.++! 2 +" (% *

+.( ":# (% *( *

+ ( )+ " % (%# %#"+ $%#"+(

+ 7;$.

++"+'

(% *

+ *+

)+B *+2# .

+ *+ % *+( $* %.+ %++(.

# " 78+ % % %# %+% + (# + +

G % ( +(+$ +( 78= ,% "# :

% #%

/ I #') '233!

%% . # .

/ '?

'22)%

% "

I 8 .

9 ) / ') '

'233 ! % "!

" 8

: 7 !9 ) %

" "#

"#:$ # # . %

,! )

/ ') '

'233

"% 2 .+H5 "2!%#I (("

$"?

+ % +% * (

"* + % @ ( ""

*#+ "".

*% * +#"$(% "" $#*++ %+'( "! 2 / * ##( A

* (%.+ % ("

(% * ( * % + $ -

% ("

(% *A

* (%.+(%# % " %+ * ( * % (%# + $ # % + $ - %% % (%# A * *

.+ *

# ""* %#( $ $ "

* %#% (* +$ 2,

*% ( "+.

C , !&)+ . 2% ,%& #( %

:. &!.")1 '232

. .

$ &!.")6 '232

. .

.- #"

8 "# . # ,

% 8 "

D . 7D9

."16 '233"#: $ ! 7:$9 % % ! "# . #1' '232 J!

% 8 &!.")6 '232 "

D. . % #

' '226

;4 @". :"

! >>>>>>>> % "

-+( .++1 3(.

* $ +2 ",# # * + $ +% + $ -$ +%( #+

% ("

(% * ( 6 ( " + ( ( + * + '!2 +

(("

$ "

+ " % (%# % $ #$ )+ #"

+ %+ * :#

(" *+% +%( #+

+ % ("

(% * #%+

$ +% *+1 3($ + 2 " ,# # * .+ %+ % +

""* *

+ ( ( + $ % ("

(% * )+ :# #"

+%+ * #%+ % "* $#"# $ * % ""

+ 13 "

+ + %+ * + .

# $ ( %++(#$:#+ * +'!2 + % "% $ +( " )+:# > %+% /D++

+ % ("

(% *+ $ - ( % " (%#

$+ .+ %++'!2 +"% J )+ % .#"( + % + %

-( * . + $6% #*+ $ %+ $

( * + " % (%# .#" $

%*#+"+ % "

-+( .+ + 2, + % + 13A + + #( #+ + ( - * % % A +%( #+ + - + % + $ + 13

% ("

(% * *

+ (

( 6( " +% $ #$+ + " % (%# % ( *+ ( #"> + %+ *)+ % .+ %+"+ ( + "%(%# ##$"

6#* + # $ "

( (

+ *+ ( % "". + " % (%# +% %# %% + $ #"C :#

/') '

'233 % "

! *27*8"<$

<8D " + (%+ % ( + % # 78

9 # 77 #$ +'( !" )

* !"

!#$"

% !

+ #$6%(%# *# "

$"". #%+% *+ # .+ %++ " %(%# $"". %"

# (%

+ % * 2"

# "

H *

.+ * #

""* %#( $ $ "

* %#% (* +$ +2, +

*% ( "+.

I)+ %+ +13 .

* $ +2, %# + +( "#( % + $ -

% ("

(% * (

6( " *

+( +( $ *+ % :# " .

+ + $ %"

# +*# "

+C 4# #* 2% ,%& #( # % % :% 1 ?

'22' ..

."#:$

4 :! %

% 7 9 / ') '

'233

$ 1'0'22' / .& ))6''E'E2'J 9 . 7 9% . <:! = 4%!

% ."# ! .

./ #+%"

+ ?

""% -( "%+ + 0 %%#% $

$" ( + 0 77.

""$(+

"+ $# %$ '!2 + .

"" $ "" ( + +

6# + $()+( ++ *+(.#" %# $ $" " #( %# "

%+ * .+( 1# "3#" ; 5 % "

* * %#" $ *

+ %

$"$% #%

"$ * "% + $

%#" *

* *

% * *( #%+%

% "% %%# ++% (

+ 0 +% .

""% #$ + "%

0( *+ "%$% #" ( % # + $ % H# I$ '!2#+ % .#" $% C

! "# :$

! 20'22'

,.% !

:..

7::9

. .

! 162'22'

,4 @" :

# 20'22' ..

:. .

!"#!

9 :! "

! 7 9 1'0'22'"#

, 4 @" . :

I .

% .

,! "

*27*8"4=$ 5$ K %#" + ( #%+ +"

*++% + 2# 4

=< 9 - + 5 "2!%#% $" %+ * % %+ * + " + #"#%+ + + (( +" +*(" % $ + ( + +.

" K %#" " #$ + 9 - .

% "". 4

'5#+ 5 "+ , -

'* "

)+%"

#+ %( +5 "2!%#%

9 - .+ " +( +% + %

" + ( + + . % + % .

(("

+ %

- )+ % +.% .

+ +(#$"

% %%+ $> + %+ * $ + % " %# + (% +( "" *

" # % +%+ # C

,"! % "#4 @". :

6+ .

# $

I .

% "

! "(!

# + % + * ( +"".

+ % @ ( ""

* + * +#"$(% "" $#*+ + % + '!2 @ # #( A

+ $ .

+ %+ * + + % ("

(% * ( *A

*(%# % " %+ * +

(% * ( * *+" $$ +B *+ 2# + $%

$" + + + '!2 + ((" + " % (%C+% + (#+ + "

E .+ + (I $ %+ .( " + + (.

##( %+ * + .

#(+ .

+ * % "

(%# #%+% %# % !

$ +% +'!2+ $ +# + :# (("

* "%(%C + 9

" 5#$ + !

+ $ "* .

+ !

; + 0 % #

D + " > %!

;+ #.+ %+ - %" + * .+ % ( $ +'!2 +% %# %

+% +'!2 % $# $+ %# "" ( .

""$% + % + $("

% "%$ +'!2 > % *!

. " + *+"

*+++ % (% $+ )+#*+ +" 5 + + #%+ * +. # + ( :# . %(" +.

# % + " $ + ( + " "

.+ + $ %+ . ( + % .

> % + % + ( "

+(.

% ##( %+ * ++ $ #" E E " + % ("

(% *.

.( *

E#%+% %# % . + .+ + *+2# #"" 6# # *+ % $ !

+ ##$ +" 5+ " "

( !

;+ #.+ %+ #/ B + "" $ ( # " + %%"# % ("

% % "(% * +( %

+ ".

""$ (("

$" + % "C #%+ +% %# %.

> %

E "

%("

%+"

( !

;% $ %%($ (("

$" +"

*++ $ %# .+ %# "( + *+"

*+ + "

( . +"+ + "

. 9 - % #""

(("

$" + % + +% .

++#" % +B *+2# 2:#"

+ (( " "$ +4

+ B. +.

""$

% #

' '3*10* 7 9 %

! 5 )+" 5 $ .

*# + % + 2# 4

355+

#$ + ( +% + 2# - % . !

; + 0 % # +"

*++ %+ (% * .

$+% " ( "

+B *+ 2#% $ "- *!

;+ "%(% %+ + %

#$ % $#

D+ % #"" * +#*++ %# "( +#" "

.$ + 2# 355+ % +#*+ +

% + 2# + *# + + % 9 - % +"+ + (("

$" % +"

*++% !

."" !

; +0 % #

+ % * "

*+ +% + + $#" "" . + .+ +% 35 5+ % +"(#"+% + ((""

C !

%"!

. !

! .% :% '?

'6 )6') .

)/ '?

'22)% - # ! ,.

" 8

" )3 ') )6'' % "

% 5 .

/ ! . !"

. "

! %. %

"# % ! % ! #

# )'

> )6'1 "

: '?

'6 )6')% @ " % #

! 4

.#!

%0% "

!" % . "#: '?

'6 )6') " ! .

.. -

% . , % "

5 "

!"# ''