M/S Be Office Automation Products P Ltd v. Commissioner Of Customs & Central Excise
! " # "
$%&'
"
( )**+,-./
&, 0!1& 2 2! "1 0!1& 2 " 2 2"
+, &3"
4 5(6)
+ &3+7 +7 3 5(6) +( +
7!*+(
7
7 *
3
**+97
:*+9 ;
*+
: 3**+97 3( (-5 ;=5>)* %2 36*) >
5 :"
7*$3 73507
0'*+
?@-?.A$"!', B$ 3* **+*+
=*8** (:7 9(*+< *+:
+3 3*) ((3*+97 3*(*+ < *+D $;'
3 * 9+ ( 3( 3 ( ;= 1( 3*;+
*
3 +()+3 3=*
* 33( 3D $)'
31(3*;+
( +7 *+ +(
=*+7
7
+D $('
3 + *+ +(
= 7
( ;= 1( 3*;+
(:7 +*+*( +*)
) +7
+;
=3 () (D $ 3* **+*+
=*8** (*+7
+) DE
3+ ()+
+;* 6*( (//.5 *+**+ 3$'
6* (3 *+*+ 55?A+( 32 )*+F7 )5G/$373507 )0'
= .55?A+( 32 )*+$ '7 )993*
*+ 7 *( 3( 35 7
+ 3 (
;
3 7
**+ 3 +3
>)* $
'5:76*( 3( (...5 () (3 *+*+ 55?A
= 55?A7
+ 3 (37 3
;
3 7
7 (
3
*
(
;
3*+9
?@G?.A 2 $"!' 7
3*;+
5 3 7
3*+9 7 3* 5 (** ( 7
*
( ;= 7
3 +:
35*+7
*
+57 + *+*+ :
*+)3
(355?A-55?A
= 355?A-55?A5:7*)7:
=:*783*(*)*+5 *+7
*
+57 +
= ( 3*+ (;=
73*=) (+7 ;
+*+)3
7 7
) (7 ;
+(** (5 )*
=:7 +7
*
3 +7 (;
+(** - +7 7 37 +(5
3+ ()+
;* 9( +(6
*(3
+7 ;
+ *9+
:7*
*+)3
*+93 *+*+
=7 3( +)
3 +=
- *+ 3 ;=7*)3 ) (+(* 7 )7 7
*
;=7 (
3 +:
(**
3(
3+ ()+
3* 3
;4 F +3 *+*+57 ;
*+
:5:7*)7 3* 3 )+*( *+;=7*)3*+7 3
5*, 3 3 *+*+
=5 ( 3*+
*3
73*=5 ) + ;
*+)3
( 37 3 ;= 7
3*;+
*+7
*
5 )*
=:7
*
( ;=7 (
3 + *+ 7 3(
73*=7 (;
+(** (D / 7 )7 ) 7
(=;
++*) ;6 7 + = * :7*)73 <*3 )+*( *+* :7 37 3
3*;+
*+)3
*+97 +3 *+*+
=*+7
*
*+7 )*3) 5:7 +7
*
*+7 3
73*=5 3 ()*+9 7
= * ( ;=7 *+ **+ $'7 (;
+(**
*+ =*+7
*
;=7 (
3 +7 7 +
=) (;
*+)3
+(37
*
7 (;
(** (! *+7 ) *+ +(5 7 ) 7 3:* 7
*
( ;= 7 3 :
)**)
=(** (+7
*
57 3 ;=7
73*=:
*( +3 *+ *+
=:
*+)3
(7 )3 :
+ *;
*+7
*
5 )*
=:7 +7
*
(
3 +7
+(**
@
37
+ +*+ ;6 57
*
:
(7
;
*+
:5 3 (*+ F ;6 5* +:
(*+ 637
*+7 )+ < 57
* *( 7
73*=* 3 $
7!*+(
(9 $ 3*+( 32*+972*(7'
(9 -./ 4 3
4*+9?3
+ (, # ?
33 3
, # ?