Bhupinder Singh v. State Of Haryana




    
    

 !"#"$%&%'() *+,%'#"-.%'/*  "0%&%'%&!

1"-&+& .! !" -2 '   "&,'#"'!

 (  34

 .
5 4
.


-"&"'!(6

-'+7 8% '9#0$ !"9--"0%&%'%&!

- : ' -/9 -2 '    ;*"!*"-!*" ",-!"-&8$ 8'":&, ,"-< 2=" 88:"#! &""!*"7+#/<"'!>  ="-""--"#!!*" ",-!"--'!  ;*"!*"-!*"7+#/<"'!&*+8#="-",-!"#%'!*"#%/"&!> 66 66 4
.
 *%&%&-"0%&%' / %'&!!*"7+#/<"'!# !"#)9, &&"#=2 !*"8" -'"#."&&%'&+#/"9 '$*?+8 9 %-<%'/!*"7+#/<"'!$'0%$!%' # !"#@  '#-#"-&"'!"'$"# !"#A@9, &&"#=2!*" 8" -'"#  +#%$% 8  /%&!- !"  &! 8 &&9   '$*?+8 9   0%#"  :*%$*  ,-"&"'!

-"0%&%'%&!: &$'0%$!"#+'#"-."$!%'&   '#A6
 '#: & &"'!"'$"#  !  +'#"-/  -%/-+&  %<,-%&'<"'!  -  !*-""  <'!*&   +'#"- ."$!%'
 '#-%/-+&%<,-%&'<"'!-'"2" - '#%'" & 9 69%'#" +8!!*"-"9!+-!*"-+'#"-/-%/-+&%<,-%&'<"'!-'" <'!*+'#"-."$!%'A6
*"%'": &, %#!*!*"&"'!"'$"& :"-"#%-"$!"#!-+'$'$+--"'!82 *",-&"$+!%'$ &"%&= &"#'!*"&! !"<"'! B 9< #"

=2 * '4 8 8% &.'+
!%&&! !"#!* !'@9 ! =+!@( @(

9 * '4 89:*="8'/&!0%88 /" -# ' 5*+-#9 8%$" .! !%'

'%9%&!-%$! '$*?+8 9: &/%'/'*%&<!-$2$8"

66 6A)A-<*%&%"8#&!*%&0%88 /"< '5+< - '# '? 7 &'& *%&+'$8"+? <* '#:"-" 8&/%'/ *" #*%<!: -#&0%88 /"

%,+-  '%  &%#"   '  !*"%-  <!-$2$8"     46@)   ;*"'  !*"2 &%/' 88"#!!+-'!: -#&0%88 /" -# ' 5*+-#9!*"' <!-$2$8"< ?" 3=+88"!3=" -%'/-"/%&!- !%' 6A$ <"-< '%&%#"9 :*%$*: &="%'/#-%0"'=2*+,%'#"-.%'/* $$+&"#6,-"&"'!-"0%&%'%&!9 *%!' !*" = $?&%#"  <!-$2$8" 46@)9="%'/#-%0"'=2 < '5+< -& -"&+8!!*" $$%#"'!9< ' '# '? 7"88#:''

!*"- # '#&+&! %'"#&"0"- 8%'7+-%"&< '-"$"%0"#*" #%'7+-2 '# ="$ <"  +'$'&$%+& '# '? 7: & 8&+'#"-&*$? *" =+88"!

<!-$2$8%&!9' <"829*+,%'#"-.%'/*9 8&-"$"%0"#%'7+-%"& * '4 8 8% &.'+ -- '/"# !*-"":*""8"- '#,+! 88!*"!*-""%'7+-"#%'%! '# -"<0"#!*"<!%0%8&,%! 89 '% -<!*"-"9< ' '# *+,%'#"-:"-"-""--"#! 9."$!-69* '#%/ -*+-%'/!*"

!-" !<"'!9< '5+< -&+$$+<="#!!*"%'7+-%"&*",&!<-!"<: & $'#+$!"# '#!*",8%$",-", -"#!*"%'C+"&!-",-! &:"88 &$-%<"-",-! #"! %89   :*%$*  %'$8+#"&  !*"  &%!"  ,8 '   !*  !*"  <!-$2$8"&  :"-"  /! <"$* '%$ 882"B <%'"#!"-$<,8"!%'%'0"&!%/ !%'9!*"$* 88 ': & ,-"&"'!"# / %'&! *+,%'#"-.%'/* *"!-% 8+-!$* -/"&*""!"#*%< +'#"-."$!%'&9A6

* 0"*" -#!*"8" -'"#$+'&"8--"0%&%'%&!9!*"8" -'"# .! !"$+'&"8 '#* 0" 8&$ -"+882/'"!*-+/*!*"%8" &:"88 &!*" 8:"-+-!%8" *"8" -'"#$+'&"8--"0%&%'%&!* & -/+"#!* !=!*!*" +-!&="8:* 0"/-&&82"--"#%'<%&-" #%'/!*""0%#"'$"*""0%#"'$" : &'!$-%!%$ 882"B <%'"#9:*%$** &-"&+8!"#%'<%&$ --% /"7+&!%$"
!

66 * &=""' -/+"#!* !!*",-"&"'$" * '4 8 8% &.'+ '# '? 7 !

!*"&,!%&'!,-0"# & '? 7: &'"0"-<"#%$8"/ 882"B <%'"# '#

* '4 8 8% &.'+="%'/-"8 !%':%!'"&&%& ,-$+-"#:%!'"&&
 <!*"0%":!* !& - & '? 7%&$'$"-'"#9*" : & -%#%'/  !*"  ,%88%'    !*"  <!-$2$8"  ="%'/  #-%0"'  =2  < '   5+< -

#"$" &"#*"-"-"9*": & 8&! ?"'!!*"*&,%! 8 8'/:%!*,-"&"'! $$+&"#6-"0%&%'%&!  
'  !*"  $-%<"  #"! %8  -",-!9  !*"  ' <"    '? 7  %& <"'!%'"# &'"!*"0%$!%<& *"-"-"9%!* &!=" $$",!"#!* !

'? 7: &-%#%'/!*",%88%'!*" <!-$2$8"="%'/#-%0"'=2< ' 5+< -9:*#%"#%'!*" $$%#"'!
 <!*"0%":!* !!*"!-% 8+-!* & %8"#! ,,-"$% !" $"-! %'< !"-% 8 $!&&,"-!*"&%!",8 ' B ;

9!*" $$%#"'!!?

,8 $"&8%/*!82!: -#&-%/*!&%#":*%8"/%'/!: -#& '% *"

,8 $" $$%#"'!%& $-&&%'/:*"-"!:- #&%'!"-&"$!" $*!*"-9'" -<-!*!.+!*  '#!*"!*"--<  &! !;"&! *",8 $" $$%#"'!%&-%/*!%'!*"<%##8"!*"$-&&%'/&8%/*!82!: -#&-%/*!&%#" ;*%8"/%'/!: -#&0%88 /" '%9!*"0%88 /"#"$" &"# &:"88 &!*"$<,8 %' '!9' <"829  -# ' 5*+-#%&'!*"8"!&%#" 
!%& $8 %<"#=2 * '4 8 8% &.'+ &:"88 & '? 7!* !!*" $$%#"'!!?

,8 $":*"'#"$" &"#< '5+< -/ 0" &%/' 8!!+-'!: -#&0%88 /"  -# ' 5*+-#9:*%$* &,"-!*"&%!",8 '%&'8"!&%#":*%8"/%'/!: -#& '%
!%&!*"$'&%&!"'!&! '#!*":%!'"&&"&!* ! $$+&"#6 -"0%&%'%&!: &#-%0%'/=+88"!  <!-$2$8" '#: &$<%'/-<0%88 /"

'%
!%&$8 %<"#!* !=+88"!<!-$2$8"="%'/#-%0"'=2 $$+&"#6 -"0%&%'%&!*%!!*"= $?&%#"<!-$2$8"="%'/#-%0"'=2#"$" &"#< ' 5+< -

6A6
 <!*"0%":!* !"0"'%!*"0"-&%'/%0"'=2 * '4 8 & :"88 & '? 7%& $$",!"# &&+$*!*"'%'$ &"<!-$2$8"$<%'/-< '%%"-!*!.+!**%!!*"<!-$2$8"$<%'/-<

+8% -<.+!*!-!*:*%$*: &!! ?"!+-'!;"&!&%#"!: -#& 0%88 /" -# ' 5*+-#9!*"'%!$ '="*" #'$88%&%'-%!*"<!-$2$8" !*"#"$" &"#* #! ?"' &8%/*!!+-'!: -#&8"!9!*"':+8#* 0"*%! !*"-%/*!&%#"<!-$2$8"#"$" &"# *"-",-!!*"<"$* '%$:%88*"8,! --%0" !!*"$'$8+&%' & ! :*%$* &%#"!*" <!-$2$8" : & *%! "$" &"#   : & #-%0%'/ <!-$2$8"=" -%'/-"/%&!- !%' 46@)*"# < /"-"$-#"#=2 !*"<"$* '%$%& &+'#"-(6  " #8%/*!&*"%&="'!

 .%#"<%---%&=-?"'

 4"!&%#"8"//+ -#%&="'!

A 4"0"-# < /"# ) !*!*"%'#%$ !-&8"!&%#"=-?"' *"# < /"-"$-#"#!!*"<!-$2$8" $$+&"# =" -%'/ -"/%&!- !%' 6A%& &+'#"-(6  " #8%/*!* 0%'/&$- !$* 

-'!<+#/+ -#%&="'!



%/*!&%#"!-"&!="'!

A .%#"<%---%&<%&&%'/
!/"&!&*:!* !!*"-'!&%#"!*"<!-$2$8" $$+&"# *%!!*"0"*%$8"$<%'/-<,,&%!"&%#" '#=!*!*"0"*%$8"&"88#:' *"-"-"9%!%& ,, -"'!!* !<!-$2$8"#"$" &"#"88'!*"8"!&%#" $ +&%'/# < /"!<!-$2$8"'!*"8"!&%#"*"-"%&'# < /"' '2

6)6 , -!!*"-%/*!&%#"<!-$2$8"#"$" &"#=" -%'/-"/%&!- !%' 46@)
'!*%&: 29* #!*"<!-$2$8"$<%'/-<0%88 /" %,+-

'%*%!!*"<!-$2$8"$<%'/-<,,&%!"&%#"9%!$+8#"%!*"-*%!'!*" -'!&%#"-'!*"-%/*!&%#"9:*%$*< 2="'!*"-'!&%#"-'!*"-" - -%/*!&%#"9=+!$"-! %'82$ ''!*%!!*"= $?&%#"!*"<!-$2$8"  #"$" &"# 
!%&$8 %<"#=2=!*!*":%!'"&&"&!* ! !"- $$%#"'!9< ' '# '? 7"88#:' '# $$+&"#*+,%'#"-.%'/* 8&"88#:' '# &+&! %'"#&"0"- 8%'7+-%"& '# 88!*"!*-"":"-"-"<0"#!!*"*&,%! 8 *%&+-!%&!&""!* ! :*"!*"-!*" $$%#"'!!?,8 $" & $8 %<"#=2,-&"$+!%' '#:*"!*"-!*"& %# $!%&- &* '#'"/8%/"'! $!! !!- $!!*","' 8!2+'#"-."$!%'A6
>
 <!*"0%":!* !%!%&'!,-0"#!* !<!-$2$8" $$+&"#6 -"0%&%'%&!*%!!*"= $?&%#"<!-$2$8"#"$" &"# '#!* !-"0%&%'%&! : &#-%0%'/!*"<!-$2$8"- &*82 '#'"/8%/"'!82
!

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
!="%'/&9%!$ ''!="& %#!* !  -"0%&%'%&!: &#-%0%'/!*" <!-$2$8"- &*82 '#'"/8%/"'!82 '#*%!!*"<!

-$2$8"#"$" &"#< ' 5+< --<= $?

6@6 =2!*",-&"$+!%'
! ,," -&!* !%!: & $-&&%'/ '#-'"-!*" !*"--" &'9=!*!*"<!-$2$8"&&8%/*!82$88%#"#:%!*+!$ +&%'/< 7- # < /"!"%!*"-!*"<!-$2$8".%'$"!*"*" #< '5+< -*%! !*"- #9*"#%"#9:*"-" &%'7+-%"&! '? 7:"-"&'"/8%/%=8"!* !*": & '!-"$-#"#!* 0"=""'"B <%'"#=2 '2#$!-*"8<"!: &+'#=2 !*"%'0"&!%/ !%'/%$"-*"-"-"9%! ,," -&!* !=!*!*", -!%"&:"-"'! :" -%'/!*"*"8<"!& !!*"!%<"!*" $$%#"'! '# !"- 88%'/ -< <!-$2$8"&'- #9*" ##"$" &"#< '5+< -*%! / %'&!!*"- #9 :*%$*-"&+8!"#%'*%&+'!%<"82#" !*

-<!*"-"/%'/#%&$+&&%'9
$<"!!*"$'$8+&%'!* ! - &* '#'"/8%/"'!#-%0%'/=2-"0%&%'%&!%&'!,-0"#="2'# 88-" &' =8" #+=!&$$-#%'/829*"%&/- '!"#="'"%!#+=! '#%& $C+%!!"#!*" $* -/"&- <"# / %'&!*%<*"7+#/<"'!# !"#)9, &&"#=2!*" 8" -'"#."&&%'&+#/"9 '$*?+8 9 '#!*"7+#/<"'!$'0%$!%'# !"# @ '#-#"-&"'!"'$"# !"#A@9, &&"# =2!*"8" -'"# +#%$% 8 /%&!- !"&!8 &&9 '$*?+8 9 -"*"-"=2&"! &%#" "0%&%'%&!

="&"! !8%="-!29%'!-"C+%-"#%' '2!*"-$ &"*"%'" 8-" #2, %#=" -"+'#"#!-"0%&%'%&! 

4
.
   ) &7?& ;*"!*"-&," ?%'/ -" &'"# ( "& ;*"!*"- ",-! =8"

( "&