Ram Vtar v. Theunion Territory Chandigarh Andors
! " #$ %&' && (
) * & '& +, -& ) !.%/+ &( ) (0,& + )1 /2 *//+ & ( 333 && ( //(( %4//-& ."'
5 $4 & ( 567, && &."'
&"/4 ( &'5 333
- ( % 8"& & 9
:
;" <=+ 4% & 7 >
: (=+ -&&&( -&//'4/ // /(/?
:
;" = @
:
;" = -& 4% & ((/ / & ( ( 4% & ( ' & :
;" <=+/'&/ +- / A" & + ( % & ( " / // 8"&8"&(
4 && /&( & " ' -"/ 4 ;( / &"' & // / - / 4% & &' &
& % 9@@ + ((/ -& 4/' /- ' "( '/%+ & ( "4 ((/ // / + " '
/+ 9@ :
;" = B- + & "" "/& - /-" &% 9@ & 9@ $&& -4 &% 9@@@A +& && & % 9@9+ & ( - % & (+ &-//-//' // +4"" ( C D ( 8 % + -&& & 4% " &'
9@9 E + & 7 >
/ < <9<+0&( "4
& ( 4 ( "
+9 D 4% -% B- +&/ - 4% + -&- '& &"-//% / &( F&"4-/
-& - "
' / " '' / + " ( & & &"4 '& & ((/ // & % 9@ + -& & - // /+ ( & / < <9<+ (( 4 & "& ,& (( & ( & / & &"4+ - ( ( & 8" " /" & &"4F & -&-&/ 9<A +& - "" "/+(/ " ' /+4 ' < ,
+&' &-//& ,"48"/%+
(( 4 (
9< + 8" 4%&"& +"4
& &"4+ -& & - 4 >0 )/ + &
- " 4 -& '/ ((/ "4 4%&( +-& &-(" ( 4 ) . "& +4'"(" &/ / + @9<<+ <9<9+ . & /
// $& // // - / 4% & ( 99 :
;" =+ & ((// "& % //- & ((/ & $& - & 7 >
B- + ' & ( - &/4/'4/ // " && &/ - . 4% & 7 >
<99 :
;" = + '+ & ((// "& % 99<:
;" =+& & - &7>
$&7>
"
& %( " &
@999 :
;" @= ' "( & / // " &( "//%+&7>
+
@ 999 :
;" <= ( & / B- + - >
. 7 >
+ &
:
;" =+ ' . & / &( + " & "&- /%' -& & > '+ ((/ /4%&( +& -4%&
((//"& %+
:
;" =G -4 &+ @ 999+&/ & ( - ( & - // ;+-(&7>
(%& $& +-/"&& @ 999 // 2"+ ( & 4' + ( - " &/ // & + (- 0"((" 8"&%&-0 " & ""
G (/+( " &&! G + '/, "&+&/ " &
:
;" @=+;"4%& + -&& & & (
) .
&&0-& 9< &-"'&+ ('+( @ 999:
;" <=
:
;" =+ 4% & ((// "& %+' .&/ &( 9
:
;" <= 2' '' + & (
((/ 4 & "
A "
G+ &' &+ -&& - 9
< $& ((/ ( '& - -& -+
< :
;" 9=+ -& /4 % & ( (" "& % 4//-A-&& "+ & ( / & 9
:
;" <= ((/4 &((//"& %+-&& -
:
;" =$& ( ( '& -/ 4%&
&
: ( =+
@
:
;" = $& &-+ 4 + & ( 4 &" E "/ & ( "4 &
@ 999:
;" <=+/ &( -(+ &- "/// + & &4 /+-(&"& & /'4/% & ( ( & B"4 &"48" - / /% 4% &( (/ ."A" & +&& & ( -/"&-" -+-&&-&% & - "'& /" & & "48" -&/ 9<+-&&&-&&/'4/%- "G +&"4 +&&"& & ' "& ( /'4//"& & -+& +- /' (& (8"&/ + & & " & -+ // " & & G &% &( +&& ! G + '//" /%( &&&((4& '/((/
) . +/ "/ & ("4 &&( -& /'4/ / // " && G+& & & & 4'4%&"& "(( & & 4'/G +(4%&
"
A "
+ 9
<+ & "4 & & -/"'&( & &4 /A +((/'& - -& - & & / "/ & ( ( "& >"&"'& "/ & "+ - & - & & ( -&//% +&"+/4/4 & & 4' & /%+ & (
) .&((/ // /" & / &"'& 9@ B "" "/- " -&- &/&% 9@ & 9@ A +&& - &% 9@9+ & ( - "'&+ & - // -//' // " ( +&( %&-//'& ' ,"48"/%+ / < <9<+( - 0 " &
."/ ((( + ( 4 +"/%4%&)' G/+ ( "
+9 D 4% -% + & & "/4/"& -/%+( :
= & ( & / (/ -& & & G+ +-&&(( 4 & - 2 & *"( >0 )/ - //% /&( +(( &&
@ ( / & / 4 -
:( = ( &"& (-&& 8"
" &'
4% & &"4+ &-"
'
/ -(';"% "
,&-0"4 ( & /// "
&-' & & - " '' *G+ ( (" 4% 2"+ & / 4 ' %&' & ' B- +&-//( ( & 8" " 99<+ "/ & //' &"4 :
= - /" & - //' H
I ' " "/ & - - -& & H//' &"4I - // (/ <+ ,
+&' &+" // // +& " &
& H//' &"4I :
=+
;" + 8" 4%&"& ,' /%+H//'
I- 4 >0 )/&
& +& '/((/+ -&&&( & ((/ // &% 9@ +&- 4 ) . / 4%&"+ (0 ( "& //'&"4:
= @9< A -&&+ +-&-- 2 &+ & ! F G% :
;" G!=+ & %
A G! ' 4%&A,"((/ ( +/-//'"
+&' &+& "(+ -&& - // 2 & *"(
< >0 )/+ < 9@<+ & & &"4 //'
+&(-% A" & +'& -&& '/((/
:( = & "
+ "/ 4 ( " 4% & "& + & &-+ & ( (( -& 4 ( @9< -&'+" 4/%+& ' %& -& %/ '&"+ & / & & & &"4 - 2 & /
-" & (+&(" " & ( // '+ &' - (/ -&& "/ /% "4 "& (/ + ;(/%+ & //% ' "( & / 4% " &'
:
;" @= " &(
(( /%+ & "/ /% 4 " & - "4" -&&&( & / &( // ?:= / < <9<+-& & "& 0
" &
( 4 "/% 4% & )' G / /' -& +9 D+&-/' &' & - / /-& := B & / % 8" (/ &" & & ( /% 4 &' & - &" /'4/ // " & & )'& 4%+&-( " && 8"
4" & "/ / ' & (( "% 0 &// & $&&-+ -4 "'&-&
9 % & &"4 :
=+ -& & & + / + / $& "4 & & 4 4% / "/ & ( + & & @ 999 :
;" <=+ -&& & ( - &/ / // +&4 /+& 4'/ - 4%&( (/ ."+/0 4"G-"/4((&'+ &/" 4% (+"(( @ 999+-&& &"
! " #$% ! " %&' $ ( ) * " $ + ,)&$( * '
"'" -# "$+ %)$ ! )&%! ! ,) + ) ! ,"( '"+ "-"#*".* # ,)' ( )& !"
" *# ) ! )
#, !"( / , + ! 0& ( ) ! "11*#,"$ ) ! "**) ' $ ) 2 '" *" 1*) "$+ ! "11*#,"$ %)$ #$ "11 "*.
) "$+ ! ,"( #( '"$+ +.",3.4 ! ",! #'
%)#$% ! )&%! ! $ # !#( ) 4)
! ,"( "') ! -# 5 !"
! ,*"#') "11*#,"$ !"( . $ / , +.4 ! )
#, +& ) ! )./ , #)$( #* +.4 '
"'" -# .& $)5 '
"'" -# !"( #* + "$ "
#+"-# !"
(! !"($),*"#' ) ! "**) ' $ ) 1*) 5!#,!!"(. $1*", +)$ ,) + !
) ! ,*"#')
! "11*#,"$ ) ! "**) ' $ ) (#+ $ #"* (# . ,)$(#+ + (&./ , ) ! "-"#*".#*# 4 ) 1*) "$+
&* #**' $ ) ) ! 0&#(# '( "$+ ,)$+# #)$( "11*#,".* &$+ ! (,! ' ) ! "**) ' $ ) 1*) &$+ )+ * ,! ' "$+ ! 6 . #$ #'"
+ ",,) +#$%*47 7; + & + 4 + & 8" &/ &( 4 "4. "/ // & 8" // " &&
A +&/ - / .4%&"& -'& 4. /4% +-&/ ' "(& 0G- /"+ / /" /%+ & & ( - /'4/ / // " && B '&+/'4/% / - % 4 & -& ( /% & "& + & ( + & " $& + & & 4' / / -& & @ 999 :
;" <=
:
;" =+ 4" 8"/ & $&"+&( (/ ."-"/ / &/ G & 8" /'4/% & ( " && +-"/4 "/ /" := & & :
;" =+ -& &( &//% ((/&% 9@ +-&& &" 89 ! )**)5#$% ,"
%) # ( ) 1 ()$( " ) . ,)$(#+ + ) "**) ' $ ) (#+ $ #"* (# ( * "( :!)*+ ."(#(: ":, ;;; ;;; +
()$( %" +#$%#$!"$+#%" ! ) ! *"( ! 4 " ( $+#$%)$8( , '. 8<=87
(( /%+ ( 4 / 0 & / // +&- 8" 4 '&' &
&/& % ' 9@)'& 4%+ ( &( - 9< 9@ - ( 8" /%+ ( / (/ %' 4/ /& ' /"(
:
;" ' =+& /% % 8"+ & - (( -& & '/ ((/ & % 9@ + & + & & - 4,' /%+&'4 "'& &- -& 4 & G% + & & - 9@9+ ( - 0 ((/%
& +&"+&/'4/%&4 & A" & + &- & & ( ' ' " 4& & ' ' & & & - " & & "+ /%+ *&&%
&-&&( -
&& . " &/ +4"& - /"& $& '/&&&( " 4 &"& -"4%&'/$ ( >
+ 2 //% :#= @99+ -& & - 4 & 2 //%
/4+ ( & 9
<+ 4% "
A "
G+&' &+/ & ( - / 4" & + ( &(+ -"/& 4 '((/&((//"& %//- &( -& -& (// -&/4 % / & % %4 4//- 2& %+&( ."F" &( " /+/%& (/ < <9< (/ -& & 8" / '& +-&/ & / 4&-
//'
+ ( & "& /" & & /'&"4& -(& 8" " ,& (" " & ( // 4&/ &( & %2" & ( +& & //' &"4 :
= -"/ & 4 /" & - ,& - 2 & & //'&"4:
=+-& -/" & -+- "%6+//'
" & - & ( + & ((/ // (" " / < <9< (/ -& & 8" / $&"+ & "/ / / // 8"&-// "% G&-0 &(+0&"4 +- " -& & ; 4% & "& " / &" G 4' '/% ( S.J. VAZIFDAR ) ( ARUN PALLI ) ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE JUDGE 16.03.2016 Rajan