High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18196/2011dismissed

M/S H.M.M. Coaches Ltd. v. Employees Fund Appellate Tribunal And ORS

2015-03-10Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

"!# $%&'(!)*#+&&'',!-#'! .&

! !

#01+)

!&!

! 2&3('1+)

!!& 4 "#$%&'

,&!&&!#!6&!(! !

# 6!#! !!! !7#8 !! 9+:#! ; 9+:#! <;

&-(!& $%&'(!)*# +&&'',!-#'+!)*#%%!#! 2 <= 4 >? &'( ! $%&'( !)*# ''#!)+1 9! !

-! !!@+@;

A%! !!&!6 #' !

&8 !-# ! %! : % !8'(1 &!% !& ! % #!

2 <= >? %& &'( -( 6( %86''!:8%# !!! &!)% !+ $%&'(!)*#2%1 &!)!)!( %8 ! #'&(% !-# &!!%% A1!6 #' %!:

%1! %8!')& %6>B &!2>?1%&'(!'-'&(%&'! ! B& !#8!!& % %## !%%#!+ !%6%# -%#'' #'&(% ,+&&''+#!( !8 &!' #%&(6 #'&8 !!-#-#!!%&(&!0

'&!-'% #!6 !%(!! + !) *# %%!1 6!-( %# %8!# <11

< -!!- &!&)#'86%&'! ! B&

#01'!#'&&!8-'

&!%&(6 86 '

&!-'%! !#'&! %&'(

%! ! #'66''

#'-##'

! 2&3('1'!#'&&!8-' !& %&( # - #' &8 !-# #!' 7# &'(6''!6#'!(

''6 A)!'!#' !&!&&! !! 9+:#!<;&-(%& #!(!! 9+:#! ;&-( +&&'',!-#' !%8 8!!-(%& #!(% )6#

! !%(''8'(1%# '1&!)!( A% )6#!)#!!'(' %&( #'&8!-#6 6:8%!:%!8'(!)!( %8&(% !#!2<=>? +6)-' , #! 6' #8 % ( &! %&#8 !! #-0 ! &!&B %#6%

#01'!#' !&!

!%#!&!%&(%&'6 !%!! > 2&! %&( #'&8!-#6#!(&!1

< #!(0#4'8'%&8%8 !)!%-(6( %84! #'- #6 8!!-( %&#!(6''-(+&&'',!-#' +!8'(1 %&#8 !! 9+:#! ;4 9+:#!<;!#&' ,&!6!& ''6!'% 0#'!)61! !1%1!8'(1% ( ) # '