← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16011/2019disposed of

Ravinder Singh And Others v. All India Council For Technical Education And ANR

2021-04-08Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill25 pages



       

 

 !

"#$%&#&

'

!(

)* *!

  +!

 "" , "!*

",  *!  & 

 (* (

)* *!

    +!

 "" , "!*

", *!

 -   

 !.(

)* *!

    +!

 "" , "!*

", *!

  /0  12/ ( (2(22

!  /!!

*))!3"%'!*   /! '

(*!4%'!!  /!

*+!4%'!! & /! 5,!(*!4%(

! ",

"!

 

7 0&898:0&#; 7 0&;-;&0&#;< === 2(22% *

4!

>

)5 , !*!

)*!,)*'

 !

,,>!5*  4 % +0; *

!! *""

7  ?#%&;-;&@&898:&#; *>' 3!

 

!5 , !*!

))*! ! >

)

>A44 !!  !

4!AB,

'"'

""* 3!

 

3**!*  %3*!  ,!

)* !* ,!

 3 * !  C 

,   *

" 

!

)  !* 

,%D,!,5 *!! "

, !* !

4/

!(  " (*"!

(*46! *!CE /(((F<!* 44, D *4 !

!4 

&#?0&#8

7 0?#0&#; 4 

&#80 &#$

7 0&;-;&0&#; 7 0&898:0&#; ,!

,  ,>4

G  !*H !!, !4," .> " !*(44, D *4 !I% /(((3 !4,"

!! >, "  A,*44, D *4 ! >"*4  J* ! 4   "   ,!

  !, '  '

 >

 !'

)   !,

A  *4 

! 3 * * ! , ! !  "

3*!%  .

 * 4

!4   >4  !   F  )!3* !A     &:#;&#&3

,>A*(44, D *4 !% !4  )*! ,  ! 4 "4    * /((( ! * 4  A! &#0& (*"!

3  !'

4*H  ,!3! , %* "%  >5 *!

"*!) !*"

>"

*4!

 9###

 3! "!  > !'

 ,  3* * :9##

3,">!) !")!,!

%&9#!

!

) &9#! 4 "  +!

, "

> A

",

)** *'

 "

 &* ! B, '"  H4

  *!,)* * ( !  (*" ,  44,   D *4 ! ! *  !" !  ( !A , 6(<   *"

 44,   D *4 ! 

4 

) 

:9 "5*  ! 

,4 3  !'

 ""   , " ! *

" ,  6!

*!CEF<3  !, *!

> A 4 "4  * *4  !"  

  "" ,* "

>"   *!! (  " (*"!

(*43  ! ,> B, A!

 !



***!3!

 

! !

>  !"A !* 5 '

*, 3'!%

 !

 *

)**!



,!)!

) 

""*3!

 

," ""

*"

> A

 ! !

>

*!  ' *4 ""*  * ,!* !#K&!   *!!4@D!!(*!,)**

  *"

44, D *4 ! 4!

!



"

," "">A"" *  *!

,!*! 

,!)!

)! C

,>

* ! !

>

,

!4  /((( !)

>A* ""  5

*

!

!4 

  *!

 *"" ) !!L44,

   #9#&#$ 6

H,! ?<

,>A !!! &3*!>A!B, !!"  ""*  * > !.  ,"A  "

!!)

! 3 *3 *""!B,

,4

/A%&#? /!

 "

% 3* *

", 4   *   3  !3  ,  889- >A  6

H,! :< 3 * " ,4>! 

  > !" % >

9### 4

  3

, >A    3>



 , % &#?% 3*!

 !  !,

)!4

, ! /(((3 ) ' 

 ""A4 

 *

*4!

"

!4:## 9### 3," >

!'

3   #&#$&#?   !4 9##  3!   "" * "

,4>!

 * 4!

 "

   #-#$&#?   !   *' )  ! 

) * ,

)   #-#$&#? * ! !

> "

 44,  D *4 !>,*,*!

"")!, "*4 ! 

,

 * !H **A ! >"3 * 4!   :9## *,

 " 4 *   3!  '  4!5 !  ! ,

)  *!   #$#$&#?3

,!,

)>*" -#$&#?,

3  ! !

 ,  :9## 4!5 ! 

!

!4    * )!*



%3  * ,

) 3"">,*A3!

4!5 !   %-%$%%&%-%: ?

3!

 !4  ! 

*,

)

* *!   &-#$&#?6

H,! 8<3

,!)!

)"

> A !

, ! /((( ""3

) ! >"

>"0

G   ""   *!,)* *  !"

J ,

!

!*4 A!&#?08 & "" * !'

""A "

>"   ! /((( &#?08 3* 4 !

* 2/ 2( *'5 4

, !)!,,!

!4 !&#"?0"8 * !3

A*""3

))!A

, ,

* (@D   !""A  

,  6"

5 " %      !"

'!

< >  !'

  

 !'>A , !  &  (,  5

) 4

 , ! /2 ( /



  !' >A !  ' !),"!A ,*!

A 6/ " , "    / @  " , "    <I



%54

3 *! &>

* 

" 4!

 "

   3 *

 * ,"  4 *,"  >! 9#$&#?   "  3  >A *  F>" (, !4 ,!

 



  !

"  # $%& "

  ' (6

H,!

;< 4

*  ,"%*3'!% >, " * !"  !A  ( *

" ,  ( A >A !   &    ,"  > *A

""A !

 * 

, ! * ! > 4!

"*,)*  *,"A ,>4 * ! "



3 *! & *

 4 & "7 0#8;;0&#8*""

)!. * !   F ,!>A*!A (*

", ( A% D,!,5 *!

'!

A%D,!,5 *!3* *3 ""3>A* '

 * *

,! &8&#$6

H,! $</,** ! ,! !

% 

% ! ' "!  &9#-&#$ !4 !   &

4

) *  '

  "!  #9#&#$ *  "

  )!  , !

/(((% *!!%   *," >  

 >A *  B,   * !  C

,  !"  *  3  !. >A  

!"

!!#9#&#$%

H,! ?% *)!, *,&9

% "A9 ,

)%*, %#>  3!,!

)*"A

"

>" #  * 9  3* ! 

 ,

) 3! *"

"

>","3!

)9* 3*3!"""")  "

,>4  * !  !    !

! 6! *! C EF<  "



   !"% ,"A'!

>A*""""),*!

%*, %3! 

!!)!     :% 9% ?% 8  9 ! *  3* *> ""*!"") ))!

'*!!4%7 0?#0&#;* >  " 



 *

 3!

   " 4  ! * 4 

&#80$*,)*



*3!

  * "

A3 * !)!4

, ! /(((*H *   !4 * * )* ! !

>""

,

"")"% 3 ,>4 * 4 *!),4 *!

)* /((( 3*"

 >!* ) *""

>A* * *4

5 !*

, 3*! *'5 4



,  * !3 



 *

 3!

   " 4  ! * 4 

&#80$*A "

!*

!4  /(((>

),""A "

>"  !*!

!

 !'



&#80$ *4*!



,**  !)

!, !* 4 !!"

*4!

"

 

,>4 %3!""!,

) *A3!""

, ! ", ) " 3*! 3  

>"!*4 ,!

,* ! ,  ! 

4   !  ;% 3* 3 ""

,

4"A

!

A!

*

"")  

!

)% ) ,!

 * (  /*! *!

 !;!

)!

' **"""")

 >"* 4  * * 3," 5 4

  !   &  D,!,5 *! (  ! 3 *

 * ,"  4 ,)* 4

  !   & 

!B, *! !* )

*"")""*! 

,>4 % "

   

 '!

,  "")  ""  *4  > >" ! ,!

) * ! ,    !!!  .

 !   &  

 * !   &

!)

 >A % ""

* ! !

> "

, !* (*4   4

 3! 3 *

 !4

>"  

5  F !B,  3      *   3 "

  * )!,  * *A *  , " * ! .

) ! !

 * 4 

&#80$))!

'*!!4%*

3!

  3  "   

  *!

5  ! * 4  A! &#80$



*

 ,"A!)

!

!4 &#80$ /(((" 4!

 "

  ;8#9 3  !3  *,)*  

 * " ,4>! 

9### 

*

 %

,>4 ,"  ! 

 * ,

)  "" ,  

,!> 

 * (  @D 

,>4 ** F>"(, !4,!*"

H *,0! 4

!49#$&#8-##;&#8%  "

 4'>A*(  44,   D *4 ! ! 

 4      -#;&#8 6

H,! -<

, >A * '!

4   44,   D *4 !%  )*! ,   !4 % 3*!

!4 *

 '

3  !!  &#;&#8* F>"(, !4,!

$;;9&#8

/$?-  &#8

  '

"  "  ;#:$  &#&% ""   3* *' ! ' !'

" 4

 "!

 !4  , ! /(((   3! A  ) 4

*"""") *,".

* !!  '"") >A!>! -##;&#8 

% ,"  ! 

 * *," ,

,

,!>

*( "

!*! *

 3* * ! 

 * ,

) 3!  >

) ""% *

,    

  * ! * 

 

!

)   & C

,3 , > >"!!B, !4 *  *A ,)*  3! )!  4

 3"" >! * ,    -##;&#8  !

   "

  , ! *

)*   !4  %   4  3* "A-#

3!!"  >,;##3! ""' ">" !*4 

&#80$ 

,>4 % ,)*

! * ! ,!!* >, ' " ))!

'%7 &;-;&0&#;* >  " 2!

,

"!* 

""*3!

 

,>4 * !  C ,*!

 *' )!

"A !!

 !.

) * )!  

*  

,>4 * *  ," ""* "

> A!

!

 ""3 *

* !4!

* /(((%*!

B,  

  *4 /!"A >,  *   *' 5 4

 * !3 %

>)!,  A *42!

 ,

"

!  * 

 7 0?#0&#;%  !

 !!

  /((( &#?08  ,>4  *   ! "

> A !

!

  3* *' ,! 4

 * !3  

3* * ! !44  >A % ! " !  

,>4 %   ""

  A  * )!

* 3*!  ""AH",

,>4 *4!"A >, * *  ! 

*,

)

>)!,  A *3* * 3 !> !!

"A ""3 !      ,  )!,   >

) "3!

 4!

% 3*  *   3! 4 "A' ">" 

  *

3! )"A4 

!!#9#&#$ *  

* !

"L

!

)"") 3!"" *A B,"

A

*4!

"

,* !"3!

)

,>4 * *!

 >

 ! * 4   * !  4 "A   ) >A

"  :9## (*"!

 ! '!A 4,* ' ">"% *!!% *!



.,  !

)* 4*  %3*>

),""A"

>"!

5

) * 4 

    *

/((( &#?08 *!

*

) 

** %3**  ! 

*,

)

> )!  * !>. !



* 4 ,) !!#9#&#$

* '* %3*3!""*"") , !) !",!

 " ,>4 * ! "



 * !","A'!

>A*"" ""),*!

*  *.



 ! * * ""% *"") 

""3!  >"

,>4 * , A *!4

) * !*

%*  

>*" !

>"/!'!%*

, >

)* "">A*,*!

A%



!A ," >, " * !"2!

,

" ,>4  *! * 

>,!

""*' ">"

3* *3!

 !*

!

 *! A ,*>. !)!

' "> A

>

)!

2!

,

"!!

4

,  8* 4

)   !0/

!

" 44   (  " (*"!

 (*4  44,   D *4 ! *"   &9#&&#?

 !   * 4*")A  >  !3! !*4 A!&#?086

H,! ;<

4 *!

** %3*!

*4!

"

%*'*  *!54

 * !3 *

%3* *!!)

J>A  !  !' >A  , ! (  &6<   &6< ! !  '

),"!A>A! 54

*!,)*,

)! , !

,4!!A  

,>4 >A"!

,

"!*  *,

)3,">

0 B,0 ! , !

,4!!A   "A !**!

!

'"'

* !  

 2!

 ,

" 3 * !!   * 

 "" * 3!



,>4  * * !  C ,*!

 !  ., 

 5

) 

 *'  ! ,"!

,""* 

 >"!

* !  *  4 )* >

 ! ", ) ! !

 *!3

   ! * !B, !4 * %*  *'!

)*

 *! *5 4

 *!

,*

3 "

) > A

**!

,>

),"A!)

J>A ""

)3 *

*

 ! !

>

, 2!

,

"!*  !!

*/

,  #9#9&#8  &#* 4

)  *  !0/

!

" 44  6

H,!

9< ,>4 ** 44 3 

, *)!, !"

A3*

 > !' * G

'!

% 3*   * ! 3 % *'   4  *  @ D

 , ! * *4 4A >  ! >A *   

,! 4* 4 " * !,!

I

"

> !'*!4*4 A!&#80 $ "A* 3**'5 4

*""

!3* *' 5

  !"

'!

 ! / "L

!

) "")  >   '!

4   ,  " "'" H4

 % 3," > 

!  *!3

"

>""

!!

 /(((&#80$ A*  ,*>!

!*, %5

)4

 * !3 >A* L!4! ! 

,

)%

!),% *," >)!, !.*" 4 *  2!

,

"!"

,  .,)4 44, D *4 !  )*,!

 7 8#&#9, *"

2 6 7<0&0&#$'

!! &?#-&#$6

H,! $<6

7 0?#0&#;<

%*, % !A*"" * 3!

 

>""3 2!

 ,

" ! * !  C  *  !

 * 3!



!),* ! 

*,



0B,0 ! !"     *   

,>4  *

   ,

4

!! !'  A5

4

! B, !

)*

 4,     

,! * 4,

 B,  !*  * !) )!,  2!

 ,

" !* ! C  ,>4  *

!  *

/(((&#80$

 !

%

 ""A !'

*"

>"

!* *4! !* ,!

!4*

L,

'!

*"

  3* *



"A   * 3>

    *  3,">   3*54

A*!

,!,

'!

A  * ""   ! '!*"

 !B, !    * !  * ,

"

)  !   *

 3," > 

>,!

 *!,)*  ! .

) *

   , "

) * .

) ! !   !" 

,>4 *  /(((

 "

4 ! '**>  *!, ! >

>,!

 !

"A

! 3 ** !'

*!

"" 

**!3!

 

,>4 % ""3 *

* !4!

 /((( !"

 *.,)4 *44, D *4 ! )*,!

 ,  *  3   4 

!*  *!

* *)!,  ,"

! !,4   %3* **!

*!



%*, % !A** 3!

 

>



  & C

, *  5       * "" *  3!,"A4 >A % !

"A3 *

 !4!

 /(((&#?08 &#80$!  '"A

* ,!*  ,"  >, " *3>

>,   * > ""*

, *!,)* ,

) (4  * 

 7 0?#0&#;%

 * >  !,  ! 

 * ,

) 

 !  >A ! &*""*  3!,"A4 

*! C

,3 *

* ," !

 3 *

 "



 !4* ""* 

7 0?#0&#;*'4 "*,!

3 *!B,

 4!5  

 *! 3 3!

 

 *' !"A 4 " *  ! ,!



 "A*

" 4 !3* *

"(   !

** ! , *!* > >!5

,  A* 

""**!3!

 



!"!

,

"!* ! *') *!,)** " ** !>"

  

4!!!* /(((3 !4,"3 *'

3 !'

  >  * 44, D *4 !

!! >" *4>

* )*!, 

,!* !

)!

*4

!4 

 ""A 4 

 * ! ! * H !)!,  ,!

,   3* *

/(((3 !4,"%*A,*

*(*"

'3 *

!, 

* ! , %3* **' 4 * !> A4  *!" '"A>!0  !

 3! >"   * ! * "!  >!   3""    ! ,

 3 *

 * , !A% >, *  3 * "

 4

   *' ,*  

 *!!%

 !!   >" * A,*   

 * ! ,"" 4   " ,!

 !, ' '

3 !44 **

*4 > " ! '!

,  ,!

 "" '!

4  "")

'!



!

% / " "")    !

 !

'

  >

 >A * '!

4    * >

  >. ' !

!

 

  ",>">.3* *

,)*>* '>A*

/((("!* !

4

&#& *!!! ,

'4 A!

(4*

 * A! &#:09 3* ,"  ! 

 * ,

)3! 



*A !** )*,!44, D *4 !>A3A   8#  &#9% 3* * 3  ""3   #8#?&#8% 3* " > !'

)  !0 G8 7*  ,!

) ,

)% ,!

   "")  * *  

>""%*!,"> *!  !,"

 ""3

)*   ,!

,*,!

!3* **A*5 4

!

'!

A $

)>A* HM

!

)

, M  ! !44 

*H !!, %3* ** >  %*



 B,  '

>" * 4 "4    *

*4 *   > !)4    ! ," !

 *  "  

 * >5)!,   *  "  !,4   % 4, !*  *  !'

) !  

)% "H >"  !* !*! * !

A *"" >

05

) 3 * * >. '  > * ' * *

"

 !

'

" ,! 

 >""3 !' "    

) * ",>" >.  > * ' !,

 * )!  

* >!),"%*3 * >. ''

A4

! B, !

)* 3**' *3 * !J"   *,

4

 ,!

)  !' ,!

 *

,

 (  44,   D *4 !

 *  H  !44 

  * H ! !,  !">"  *

!



, %*

*>5)!, 3* * !

,* ! ,*!



!,(  "(*"!

(*4! 44, D *4 !%*'> ,!) !'!

 ' !* *A !*

")!, * >'  ; * !,H  *  !'!

A

    3**!   

"!"A

,  3* *' 5  4

 * !

'!

A !'

""A 3**' "A "

  !  ! ' >,*'  ! 

*,

)%," > 

 >    * *4 * >.   "A

) *!,)* 

 !"%  !,!" !B, !4     3!   A

* %

 

 >, * B,

 3* !'  *  *! !4 ! 

*,

)* > "!"A* )*"

)*>A* 

* !!.

!>A 

*

 * 4 *  ( 4>!% &#:% D *4 ! +""A 3

  '  ' " *   A   "" *!   3!

  >A * ,!A  ,!

! ,*  !,4    *

*' *3 * !,!) ) !'

"4

!

'!

A% ,*%! ,!

)*,!

% *A>  !

'*>  * *4***  *! *'5 4

*!

'!

A *A ! ,!

) * ,!

 

 * 

 * *

3**  "

*!,)*

 !"3 "" > "

*!

  A*>  * )

  3,"*'> !

 ! *

! * 4  A! &#&0-   &#-0:%  3* 5 4

3," *'> )!  , !* *4 *!

 "3A     ! 4 !'4  ! ! "

J

) )!  

 >, >.

'!   A >    * )

  &# *   !,4   % H  "

, * >  !' , !  ,""A *!

)  * 4   4*   "A

) ,

)%*!'"

! ,

 !3

(!

)! A3* *%

*4 *( 4>!%&#:% 4!%* ,>4!)' *,)*  *! 5 *5 4

 ,4>!3,"*'> 4!

/3!

'!

A%*A,"> *!

'!

! "")  >, 3

 /3!

'!

A%   ! ! 4

* 44*4%*!!%>A!"

% >. *4

 H3 * '*,,!  * % 3* *' >  ,!

) * ! ,!

 * !

'!

A%

  5 * ! >    ! ! !4 ,>%   A *4

  , * ! ,,!

 . !A% 3* *(  "(*"!

(*43 * ",>">. '

 !4 

 3 **>. '%*!

., , !

))!  I (, 4 >A*! C

,3! !  4H  >!)

!! >!" 

* !',!% , ! G  *

" "A

 !%>A3A  4H  ! * 4 

 &#:09% *  3* *' > 4 >A*! - *"">!)

!! *"" > !" 

 * ! ',! *!,)* !  '

   "

 ! ,> B,  A!

  "" *A 4 " * ! ,!

I (  

 3  , *"

 2  6 7<0&0&#$ '

 !!  &?#-&#$6

H,! $<6

7 0?#0&#;< 

!"'  *

""* ! 3!

 

%  3!,"A!)

! *A ),!

*4!

"

%3* *3 !3 , >A*

! C*A*'> 



 !

4!

"A *)!, **A.



, ""*4*!,)*,

) L!*A  ! 

*,

)

! 3!

 

!" *4 !*4 

 &#?08   &#80$   * (*4 &#?08%

 !'

 * "

,4>!9###

3,"> !'

%:9##  !) !")!% >

&9# * ! 

!

/ "L(

!'



!* )> A " 4 )/ " 

!

!4 ,>.*

'

!,

)!4* *!""

* ,4>!) !")!

 !'



* *!

 *!""

) !" !4

5%* *!"" ,4>! 3,"> '!  B, '" 

!

!46 !" !4

B,"  #9$ 

!

!4% #-&9/ " (!4<  * " ,4>! 

 !'

% 4A !,

 *  !

 3*  "

 *  :9##

!  !) !" !4"

> A

*&#?0 8(*4! !'

 , !0  (,  *'

) 4 "  44,   D *4 !   3* !  4  A! &#90L&#:0"9 !4 @D ! ! (  

*"

"

@D & '

)  !

!*" "  "+ "

 " +) 

)",- !

.

$%& " //" !

.

01 !

)"  2 !

 3 "

/ )

".

"!.

!5 4

*

,"" *!,)*,

)! , 4,4!!A 64 *

< - '

)4 "A

4"

*

?" !

,4 : (,  *'  4 ,"

!

"A  "A 

 ! !)

!     7> !"* LL333 0.50 *!

)'

H",

!"

 , !0  )!

(,  "

>", !* *4!  (, 3**' 

"

& !

!*4 A!&#:09  (,  ,!

),!

*!,)* 

'!



 (, '

)>  *! *4   (, )

)4

*!,)*/ )4 N,  (,  ,!

) ,!

,*    "4 ,!

 "

)  3!)!  (,  ,!

!,"'" ,

A

  (, *'

)4 "A

4'!

?"5*  !

,4  (, 4 

3* *

*! !', !&  !!>A!  '!),"!A>A 

 ""A !'



*  ! !



!)

! **

!B, !) ' !!  3**!*L *3 5 4

 *

L*!3 !*!,)*,

) !)!

),

) 4 

/(((&#?08%! , !0 " 

,  ""4  ! * , 4,4!!A   3 "" >   *!,)* ,

) "A!*

*4!

"

3**' ' * !  ,

)   ,

) 3 "" >   ! / "   &9# (*"!

3,">3!!4 " !4 4!

 * 3**'5 4

 * !3  ! * ! !

>4

 !,!

 !'>A *!),"!A>A  $

*

"2 )" 

,

 !

 +"







!



4 !*" "  "+ 

5  !

"

*

/""2 "2 !*"64 *

<  *  3* !

* 4!

 "

    " ,>4  * !  4

 ! ! 

 ,

) !

 ! ""4  , 4,4!!A  % * *,",

3 "" >

!, !* *4   A *!""

 * ,4>! 

 * 4!

 "

  &#"90"?3 "">44>A*

*4!

"

&#:09 ! 4!

3 "">4





 (, !!B, '

*""3

 ! 

 *

!4 

 5   *  4  ,

) 

  !' * 333,)

L" L"") L2

! &$   O&#O&#"") O&# O&# O&#-  "&&#"9  

* LL333 0  !' >A

!)L *>!L ) L *>! 6 ",

*!4A  *  " / )4 !

* ")A<    * *4   >    C * LL333 0.50

0)'

 (" (, !* 3 ""> !

"A>  /!

   !* !' !,!!&#?08(*"! "">(

(*  "A3**'5 4 

*4 (

&#?08 2 (*"!

 3 "" > 

>,!

 *!,)*   "A ! .

) *

,   , "

) * .

) ! ! " )3 * *! !B, ! ,4   !" (*4 ! * 4 

 &#80$ 3  "



, 3 * * "

> A

%3* *! , !0 &6%1%3%6%7  (,  *'

) 4 "  44,   D *4 !   *'

 & H4

  !4 @D ! ! (  

*"

 "

 @D

 4  A! &#"?0"8 ! &#90"? "A  44 4!

"

3 ""> ! !! &#?08L &#90?% 3* !)

! *4 "'    !"   !

""4   ,!

),

)!4 A!&#80 $  '

)4 "A

4

?##25*!"

 !

,4  4

3 "">!*

" " 3""

L"") L,

'!

%3* *!>A!  !' >A  , ! (  &6< ! !  '

),"!A    '!

4      "A% 3* * ! ," ""

)""3

) "!

!

  "", 4, "")   "") 3 *!  !)!44   "") 3 *

 &##"

 "")

 * !*   !*07 !

 ( 6 4*" ! *% .>%* )!*%!A %"*

. * ! ! *  !5* < 3 * " 9#O !"4   "") 3 *" $#O!4! !"4 4

*! *, !A  ! 4

5 >A*  *

!*!3

!'

 , !0 /((  (  7  (,  

!,   5

) 4

   *

L*! 3

"") ,

 ! !

>"

"") 3 "">' ">"! 4

  !""AL(  

 3*!

4

!4 "A!B,"

A

) ! H4

  ,>A !"L('!

4 >4"

>"!

 !'

*A*' "

 0"

!  * ! ,4  ! '!

 >A '  @D *

3 """

>!B, ! ,

) 4!5 * !  ,!

)*,

  (, 5

) 4

 /(L( !

 "!

 ' 4

 ,!

 4A 5 4

   3  * !  "A

,>."!

)  (, *'4 ,"

!

"A "A

!!)

!  7> !"C* LL 0.50 

L

!'

!)!

)H",

!* 4

*(*4&#?0 8H *!

H",

>  A!4 "

)"



"' !'

!)!

),

)!! !, *!, !0  (22  $

"*  "2 

)"

/ +

!"

" ,

)" 

, " .64 *

< Xxx xxx xxx  2

  

L

'!

 3*! 4

 ! 3,"> ! ! 3 "">

"A 3>

 "

>" , !*(*4! !* * ,!

 !4 *  

L

'!

  "A  4A >

*  3 "">  * 3*5 4

 *! *  * "

  

'!

' ">" * !"H /(L(!""

 4

" ,!

 ! 3* * , !

,4!!A B,

 ' ">"3'!%""* !!B, ! *

! L* ,

) !   2

  "" !)

!  3," > ! !   3 "" >

"A 3>

!

!4 *  

!"'  *

* ! 4!

3 

,>A "!

,

"!* 4!),4 *!B,



! ' ">"

* *! *""' ">"

*'> H*, *!

,!*! 

,*""*  ," ""* "

> A!

!



",

)**

" *4 "A

4>

"

 *

? "5*  ! 

,4    *   "" , !  A  * H",

", 4 

/(((&#?08!&#80$"

 A%

  !'

* > 4! ! 

,

)>A*

!!

,!**!

4

*

A4

!!*

 !"      !'

) !  "

>"  * 4 

 !

", !"A

)*!

**! *,">  B, !

)4

* >  %3* * *,"!**!))!, 

> * * >  !4   ,! 4

   * ! 3  

 3* * !

!)

J>A"

> A",  /(((&#?08  ""A!!

 %3**' ,!4

 * !3 

%3* *! !)

J >A  "  !' >A  , ! (  &6<   &6>< " !  ' ),"!A >A " 5  4

 *

, "" *!,)* ,

) ! , !

,4!!A      * 3!

 

 " 3 * *

, !

,4!!A     * /((( &#80&#$% *!

    !'

!4 

) 54

 !""AL( 

 '

 * ! !

> "

 3*!

 4

 ! 4  "A ! B,"

A

! H4

  ,>A !"L('!

4 >4"

>" !  !'

 *A *'  "

  0"

 !    * ! ,4 !'!

>A'@D ,>"

"A%

4 *"" !!B, ! ,

)* ! * ,

"

) !(   * 

 7 0?#0&#;

 * 

 >

) !  ! ,

) *A 3!  !4   !  *!

 *!

   

"  * 4 3* "



)*"" 

*

!

!43!H*, *! 5-8#-% *!!%! * 3! 

!!4



 !



*

)*

! "A7 0?#0&#;%

4 * 3!) ' * 54

 *

!*!3  !*"

"") ' ">" * !"(, %3**5 4

 * !3 3! ,>4 .

)! !%4!5   3 >) '  ! *! *  ,>.  4!

  *  4  ,

)      * ""4  "! 3! *  '!  *    *  3'!%

  !H "4

!

"

 * ,">)!  "A*

3*3!"" *!,)**,

"

) !

 

 !

 ** 4!),4 %"!

,

"! * !    

, * * 

 7 0?#0&#; *'

,

,""A4 ">

)* !,!



,!*!'!

** 

3*!3!

 

*'4 "*,!

H !*" 4 !% 3* **A! 3 ,!

)

 !4**!3 >!5

* ,!

4 ,!

>A A*  

/((( 3

!,

 !!  >   3* ,"  ' " ! !, ,

,!>

*(

 ""A 4 

 ! ! >A * H ! )!,   G  !  * H ! )!,   !4,".> " !*(44, D *4 !I* 3 

!A "* *4  >"*A,* 

* !,""4   " ,!

* !, ' '



!*

",>" ,!  **

*4 3! !,",>"

"A%*,*!

!3""3 *

* !!

)* 

4  !

! !



!),"

!!

,!**!

4

 * !'

    

,! *

 !* * !) )!, 

! 

,

)%, "

)*!4 

!A,4 >A *

B,

"!"A  

*

 ! 2!

,

"! * !  * ,>4  * *! 3     !'  * 4

 

/((( **   *

   3""  % *!!% *

   !    

 * !

  ,

)   7 0?#0&#;% *!



"*  '!4 *  **A*4 !     * ,

) >, *A !  !4     

4 

 44,

   #9#&#$ 6

H,! ?<

 *  3!

  *    *  !4

 >  >, )

 *!

  

"*'!4

*3!

  " 4 *! * * > 

 *)!, **A3! , *! 5-8#-%*!!% *A3! ' 

!

'*  6  :%9%?%8 9<3!"""") >,*A " ,>4 * ! "



 * !" ,"A '!

 >A * "" "") ,*!

 (    *

5 4

"")*!* * ""*!!* ! ,"

>, "

)7 0#8;;0&#8>A* !  *!! &8&#$ 

*!

4!!!&#80$ *4  !'

 A  4*

4!* )*

, 4A>"" * *!

   !'

!!

' *

3*!

!, 5

)4

 * !3

"") %3* *! ,

* ! !

>"

"") %*,)*

 !'**

*,"> !""A!(, 

%3*!4

!4 "A ! B,"

A

) *  !  H4

   , >A *  !"L( )'!

4    * *   *," *'  "

 

   * ,4 '!

>A*)'!

4 44, D *4 !* !"

!B, ! ,

) 4!5* !   2!

,

"!*! * 

,4

, &#*  !0/

!

"44  

,*!44 A!&#80$% "A *  3," > 

! "

>"% 3* * 5  4

  * ""

* %3*3

** )* !"")3,"> !B, ! ,>4 * !!B, !* )*!,)*  !, "  *  /

,   4

) !'" *  A

 

! '!)*(*4 

,!**!))!, ! ' * >  , !*(*4

 ""A4 

* 4

, **

%3*3

** )*"""") 3,">!B, ! ,>4 * !!B, !* )*!,)*3'!%

 * >



  *  >  5  >A  *  * )

 * ""

!4

>" * 

 54

 * !3

"") * !* *!

 ",

>"H "  !*!!. !B, !* )

>A 4*  



7 &;-;&0&#;*'5     * *!3!

,!>

*44, D *4 !*!"'  4 *A,"  *,

),*

! 3"" ! * "

 >  4  * !!  *  F>" (, !4 ,! 3*! ,0  ! 4

*  >  H  !4 9#$&#8-##;&#8      "

 4'>A*(44, D *4 !*!



"* 4

"A 4  * *  !!

 ,   !  A >    *   

!   *  !      !,4    !'" *  *'> 

*>   /((( !

4!

"A *)!, * *!*A*'  *,

)!*A*'5 4

 * ! 3

*



""4 *!"") !*!3



3*!4

5

 !4>

* ! !

>"

, !*(*4 ' "> A*

% 

*!)

) ! %3  !4 '!

>A"!

,

"!*! C 7* " !4

) !"

  *  %     4 4 ,!% )* ,!44, D *4 !

!!#8#?&#8* !

)*"A> !'*

4 "4   * > !)4  ! ,"!

2,>" >. ,)*>* '>A*(*4 *," > ,">A

"H >"  !

  !* ),"

 *' >  ,

 "  !'  4

 

B, !

)>, * ,!  *(*4*

)%

, ,"  !! * .,)4   *  F>" (, !4 ,!

 '

" 8"

"** )

, 9 '"  

: +. !

"   

';;:;

 9 8.

< 9 <  = )

'



2

$")" !

"

  ' /

"   (;* F>"(, !4,!

*  3 "

)3 *! 3""

  *"



*"!

!,

4"" 

!, L.,  ""

, !*! "3A  !

!&## ! 3 4! "

-$*

 % ! ' !

"( "

A3* *! !0 G(;

'

"

) 

 ")

"!

2"

/"*"" "2

+

2

"2

/ "/

P 6< * ( *"" !

'  !4 * 3"!*  ">A ,!

)  !

)  '"A 4A   " !!

 3* * ., %  "%  4    "

"%

*""

!4""*

*  ""

 6&< * ( *""%

 ! ,"!% !

'  4

 *

B,"

4%    ',!  "



B,"

, %  !,

 "A4

'

,"

>, "

4 )!,   "!

 ! ! ! ))

 ! '

I  F>"(, !4,!*"*

*,A'!A3"!(  ) ! 4 "A4     

,! *

  ',"

!>" 

H "  ! 3 4 !"

!

'! * 3

 



  '4

 (  ' 3*!

> !'* G *!

 !

,"

 !4," !  A 4) " *!4

 *      " .,  "" *  4

 *   >3  3 ! "

43 *  !A3 *, , !

4  **!%* *,!3,""

',!*35!   *  A%( "., 

*!)

)!!)"!)!

,4>! 3 *,  !

'   !, ")" !

)*    A>A 

,**

) > *

  "., 4,  !' "'! A*

"!,"

!

*" 

 4

,

!!)!!)"!)! ,4>!' *,)* )*!!4 4*

"!,"

',! !AI !

  A * !),"

 3* * ! ,

 " !   >

!   >   , ! * (*4 *   > !% 5

 '

3 *

  !'

 ,

 "%>,* 4 4  !

%>

 ,

"'

3* *4!"A"  ,"

)*'!A ,!  !3* ** (*4

!4,"

., 

*,A*! 

,!

!" *>  *!))!,  *  !,4    * !  % .,  *"">4>A!

! *  F  >A*,*!

%  ""A5

'

3*""3

)0 < ""*  4 "A," """* ! !

>"

> A 

",

)*

"!

!



<

  *' 

,!!  A  * 

B,"



4 

*(*4

< ""   3! ,"A !)

!   ! !"

 * 4!

"

 ! ! '< * * (*4  ""A !'

 ! 4

 >A *

 * !3 % !'

*

,

* ! !

>

%!)

>A 6'< 

, 3*!   *' 5  4

 ,"A !)

 >A %

 * ! !

> "

 , ! * (*4   *   ,  >A * 



,! >A *  "

 6'

< *!

 "")    A 4

 ! B, !

) >A  A B,!! 6'

< (*"!

!*!"' A!

!4 "A' ">"    H*,  6'

< 

,!>

 "

! 4 

&#80&#$!   ""A

 H<

,4  

 7 0?#0&#; *'

) 4 " * ! ,!

,

,""A   *

 7 0&898:0&#;  7 0&;-;&0&#; 4 "

* ! ,!

H  * ," 4 4 ! 63* * *A ! ,!

)< 3 *,  A >!5

4 

*, % 4   ,*!

A

  !  !

! * )!  

  *  % 5

 '

3 * !  !

   5



!A      %  A *!  " ,4 < ! !B, !  * 

4  *! > ) '   *4 3 *

 3 35   !   !  A*

!!( ,4 > ,>4 >A*  3 *

3 35  *!!   

" 

 ! !

!   *  F  >5 3 *

,!35 

!A >5 *!! ""*>' *!3!

 

!%!

)"A%

 62

 ""<  !

"#$%&#& ,) rts 7**! 5

)L!   L 7**!! !>"   L