Simran v. Central Board For School Education
!"#"$% &"'( ) *(#+#
,"$ -
"!(. - ( &!/- +!
"$0 &1&!
(2. ) #4$ $
(#$ % 5(6 /+,/. 7!
"$( 5( 7$ /4( . 7!
/(#4$ $ 888 ( 9("$ /:("
4 "$"# /"##+ $! :("
"( (" ( ;+ #/"$, !''+$"!
"$ $$<+( =>
2. :/(?9 / (;+# ( !/ $, /(
/:
#(@!
( 9("# -# /"##+ $! :("
'+# ( "(!
"$, /(#4$ $ !((!
"$(A#
('BC B ("
# / !
# - "$, "-"$, / :("
(
"$(4 ## /(> /!- ##<
(' & #4/# &!/-. '?
"$ / 9 ( . :/(
( #/ 3
'"##"$ "$ * +?-"! &!/-. '?
. $ / ?
#"# $#
"##+ ?9& #4/#+?-"!&!/-.'?
."$:/"!//(
/"##
?(!( #B
(4 ##"$,
[2]
!- ##<
('*+?-"!&!/-.'?
."$ /9 (.
3 '"##"$"$/ . :/( "$(4 ## /('
"$<
"$"$ /9 / "#
"-"
"$(:
#"##+ '
"# #/:"$,/(
#BC ($ !+$#-!$ $ #
/'"#
3"$
/
"$( (!( "$ / '
"$ !(
!
' $ "! "$(:/$#/4- $$ , ?( . ##/, /( ##4( "##+ "$ /9 ($ /?
#"# -
/" B?#" #/( ("7"$,-"!$#:
-#"##+ $ /?
#"# /(
/ " B / 4 "$( '
(;+# !((!
/(
#(!( "$ / /!- ##<
/ (#4$ $ 7" $$<+( =C
B :7(. / # ' :
# (@!
7" !''+$"!
"$ $$<+( =>
2$ /,(+$
44-"!
(!((!
"$/ $ ?$#+?'"
"$ "'"$ ('# +-0"71 &9E :#.2 +-0"71 :#"#(4( +! +$ (%E F/ 44-"!
( !((!
"$ "$
/ +-9
( ?9 / &!/- -$,:"
/ !+'$ '$ "$ "$?9- :#0"""1#/ --?$
"$ ?9 ( $-9:"
:9 (#
!-
(#+- ##G<
"$!((!
"$:/
#7( #/ -- ? '
$ 44-"!
"$ #+?'"
/ #
[3]
4(" : 9 (# /"# :"-- ?
"7 <
?/- "$5 (!/.2H B 4(+# - / ?9 - :# (7 -#
44-"!
!((!
/"# ? ( ?9 / /&!/-
-$,:"
/ !+'$ #'$ "$ "$9ED :0"""1:"
: (#
!-
(#+- ## /<
$!((!
"$:/
#7("#4('"
$ 44-"!
"$#+?'"
/ <4"(9
('$ "$ 4(" : 9 (# '"
-9.
44-"!
( !/ $,
/ "$ / !- ## <
# #+?'"
?9
( #7$ 9 (# !-
"$ /( (#+- "$ (,
"$ 9 D : 0"71
:# 2
($!"# -#'
/ !"#"$ "7"#"$$!/
/"# +( "$ '?"3 6 +- 7# $ /(# 2 01 &
-7 < /# '"#(4( +! #+$ (%I
!
"
#
$ % &
!
'
(
!
[4]
(
"
)
!
'
$
(
(
(
!
'
*
( (
+ (
, ( (
# #
&
$ - . /0-1
2
2
[5]
4(+# - / (-7 < / !"#"$ "$ '?"3 6 +-A#!
#0#+4( 1(7 -#
'"##"$ #!/-"# ? ?
# +4$
,"7$?9 /!
$ "
.:/"!/
!$ "$+# ? -!
"$ / '
"$ !(
. /( (.$!. !
$ "
#!'4- /"#=/( +!
"$$ /?
#"# ##+'
."$ !$ -"!
:"
/?"( /!(
"##+ ?9 ,"# ( "( /#
/#./=#/"## 44 ('(-9"$,+4$ /?"( /!(
(#
, -"
+( /(
#'$ "$ "$ '
!
$? --: ?!((!
?# :"
4(" /(9 (# --,
"$"$, , '
@("
9 '"
-9.
# ( -!
"$ / '
"##+ ?9 & :
# ?
# $ / (!( # :
#+?'"
// "#!/- (':/(
"$( !- ( /( '
"$ <
"$ !( :"
(, (
/ "$( :
# #+?'"
?9 / *" 9 "#$ /?
#"# (!( '
"- ?- "
:/"!/ "$!-+ / #!/- - 7"$, !(
"##+ ?9 * +?-"! &!/-. '?
. :/( "$( :
# + 9"$,4("( # + 9"$,"$/ ."$:/"!/
/ "$( :
# ( -!
# BC /
"##+ ?9 * +?-"! &!/-. '?
##+?'"
$$ -# /$ "$(=/( ,+ ( "
$# / $ *" 9 . "# / (!( # (!"7 ?9 "$(=/( ,+ ( "
$# ('*+?-"!&!/-.'?
'$ "$#
#BC/#
/:
#$ ( "$
[6]
/ #!/- (!( / $ *" 9 . $ "
# #
/:/"!/:
( ?9/
"#
"' #$ "$, "$(A#$ ' ?"$, --: ("$ /'
"$<
"$!$ +!
&4( # :/
#7(:
#( "# ?9
4"$ "'$(
'
(:
4( # ( "# ?9
, $+'?( 9 (# $ "$ /"$ (7$"$,4(" "'. "$(, /(4 ##4( $ ("7"$,-"!$#"##+ '$ "$"$,/(
#B/4 "$(/ ##+,/ !((!
/(
/"$ /'
"$<
"##+ ?9
&"$ /9 (.$-9"$ /9 (. /+#. /# '"#!- (-9 ?
(( ?9 :0"71.2 #:-- / !"#"$ $A?-. / "7"#"$ $!/ /"# +( "$ '?"3 6 +-A# !
# 0#+4( 1 C $ / -",/ / 4#"
# $ ?7. / :("
"$?"$,?(
'("
"# "#'"## 0& -"
1 + , @#/33/+( / /(#4 3"$,=( #$ % #= / /((4(
?- % #=