← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16029/2019dismissed

Simran v. Central Board For School Education

2019-09-23Mr. Justice B.S. Walia6 pages

  

             



 !"#"$%  &"'( ) *(#+#

,"$ -

"!(. - ( &!/- +!

"$0 &1&!

(2.   ) #4$ $  

   (#$ % 5(6 /+,/. 7!

"$( 5( 7$ /4( . 7!

/(#4$ $  888        ( 9("$ /:("

4 "$"# /"##+ $! :("

"( (" ( ;+ #/"$, !''+$"!

"$ $$<+( =>

2. :/(?9 / (;+# ( !/ $,   /(

/:

#(@!

 ( 9("# -# /"##+ $! :("

'+# ( "(!

"$, /(#4$ $ !((!

"$(A#

 ('BC B  ("

#  / !

# - "$, "-"$,  / :("

(

"$(4 ## /(> /!- ##<

('  &  #4/# &!/-. '?

 "$ / 9 ( . :/(

( #/ 3

'"##"$ "$ * +?-"! &!/-. '?

. $ / ?

#"#  $#

"##+ ?9& #4/#+?-"!&!/-.'?

."$:/"!//(

/"##

?(!(   #B

(4 ##"$,

[2]

!- ##<

('*+?-"!&!/-.'?

."$ /9 (.

3 '"##"$"$/ . :/( "$(4 ## /('

"$<

"$"$ /9 / "#

"-"

"$(:

#"##+ '

"# #/:"$,/(

#BC  ($ !+$#-!$ $ #

/'"#

3"$

/

"$( (!(   "$ / '

"$ !(

 !

' $ "! "$(:/$#/4- $$  , ?( . ##/, /( ##4( "##+ "$ /9 ($ /?

#"# -

/" B?#" #/( ("7"$,-"!$#:

-#"##+ $ /?

#"# /(

/ " B / 4 "$( '

 (;+# !((!

/(

#(!(  "$ / /!- ##<

/ (#4$ $  7"  $$<+( =C

  B :7(. / # ' :

# (@!

  7"  !''+$"!

"$ $$<+( =>

 2$ /,(+$ 

44-"!

(!((!

"$/ $ ?$#+?'"

 "$ "'"$ ('# +-0"71 &9E :#.2 +-0"71 :#"#(4( +!  +$ (%E F/ 44-"!

( !((!

"$ "$

/ +-9

(  ?9 / &!/- -$,:"

/ !+'$ '$ "$ "$?9- :#0"""1#/ --?$

"$ ?9  ( $-9:"

:9 (#

 !-

(#+- ##G<

"$!((!

"$:/

#7( #/ -- ? '

 $ 44-"!

"$ #+?'"

/ #

[3]

4("   : 9 (# /"# :"-- ?

"7 <

?/- "$5 (!/.2H B  4(+# -  / ?9 - :# (7 -#

44-"!

!((!

/"# ? (  ?9 / /&!/-

-$,:"

/ !+'$ #'$ "$ "$9ED :0"""1:"

: (#

 !-

(#+- ## /<

$!((!

"$:/

#7("#4('"

 $ 44-"!

"$#+?'"

/ <4"(9 

('$ "$  4("   : 9 (#  '"

 -9.

44-"!

( !/ $, 

/ "$  / !- ## <

# #+?'"

  ?9

( #7$ 9 (#  !-

"$   /( (#+-  "$ (,

"$   9 D :  0"71 

:# 2

($!"# -#'

/ !"#"$ "7"#"$$!/

/"# +(  "$ '?"3  6 +- 7# $   /(# 2 01 & 

-7 < /# '"#(4( +!  #+$ (%I    

   

   

  

       





   



  

 

  

  

        



       



  

        

       

    !

    "

   #   

  $   %   &

             

  



    !

         '

  (



 

      

 

   

  

 



 !

    

[4]

 

   

 ( 

 "        

           



 )  





    

  



 !

     '

 





  

    

    $      

           (    

   

 

        

    (   



        

 

       



    (   

 



 !

    '

    





    

  







*  



 

( (       

    



+   (

     ,  (     (     

 

       

    



  





 

   



 

       



       

  

    



  # # 

&      

   

 $  - . /0-1      









  



    

2    

      



        

     









  2            





[5]

  4(+# -  / (-7  < / !"#"$ "$ '?"3 6 +-A#!

#0#+4( 1(7 -#

'"##"$ #!/-"# ? ?

# +4$

,"7$?9 /!

$ "

.:/"!/

!$ "$+# ? -!

 "$ / '

"$ !(

. /( (.$!.  !

$ "

#!'4-  /"#=/( +!

"$$ /?

#"# ##+' 

."$ !$ -"!

:"

/?"( /!(

"##+ ?9 ,"# ( "( /#

/#./=#/"## 44  ('(-9"$,+4$ /?"( /!(

(#

, -"

+( /(

#'$ "$ "$ '

!

$? --:  ?!((!

?# :"

4("  /(9 (# --, 

"$"$, , '

@("

9  '"

 -9.

# ( -!

  "$ / '

 "##+  ?9 & :

# ?

#  $ / (!(  # :

#+?'"

// "#!/- (':/(

"$( !- (  /( '

"$ <

"$ !(  :"

(, ( 

/  "$( :

# #+?'"

  ?9 / *" 9 "#$ /?

#"# (!(  '

"- ?-  "

 :/"!/ "$!-+   / #!/- - 7"$, !(

"##+  ?9 * +?-"! &!/-. '?

. :/( "$( :

# + 9"$,4("( # + 9"$,"$/ ."$:/"!/

/  "$( :

# ( -!

# BC /

 "##+ ?9 * +?-"! &!/-. '?

##+?'"

$$ -# /$ "$(=/( ,+ ( "

$#  / $ *" 9 . "# / (!(  # (!"7  ?9 "$(=/( ,+ ( "

$# ('*+?-"!&!/-.'?

'$ "$#

 #BC/#

/:

#$ ( "$

[6]

/ #!/- (!(    / $ *" 9 .  $  "

# #

/:/"!/:

(  ?9/

"#

"' #$ "$, "$(A#$ ' ?"$, --:  ("$ /'

"$<

"$!$ +!

&4( # :/

#7(:

#( "# ?9

4"$ "'$(

'

(:

4( # ( "# ?9

, $+'?( 9 (# $ "$ /"$ (7$"$,4("  "'. "$(, /(4 ##4( $  ("7"$,-"!$#"##+ '$ "$"$,/(

#B/4 "$(/ ##+,/ !((!

/(

/"$ /'

"$<

"##+ ?9

&"$ /9 (.$-9"$ /9 (. /+#. /# '"#!- (-9 ?

(( ?9 :0"71.2 #:-- / !"#"$ $A?-. / "7"#"$ $!/  /"# +(  "$ '?"3  6 +-A# !

# 0#+4( 1 C $ / -",/ / 4#"

# $ ?7. / :("

"$?"$,?(

'("

"# "#'"##  0& -"

1 + ,  @#/33/+( / /(#4 3"$,=( #$  % #= / /((4(

?- % #=