Jagtar Singh v. State Of Punjab


 

                 

       

 


   


     

     



 



   

  

      

  ! "#"#$% &  '(  !& ) && *  "#(  +&#,#%'-  & .#(#$%  ! "#"#$% +'-- %/#%/" !! --'"  $0&"10*/, %"*'" *2  !'(( *34"

- '&% ***-  ((#$%(0*/ $'-#5 & 34"  &#,#%'-!! '-$


6*'" *7   2'/'#%("" 10*/, %"$)+$%.#+"#$%*'" *7 

 2 !'(( *34" 0*#+#'-'/#("&'" (" -'(($'-##%+'(  $ 8*'" *   90%* & +"#$%#262 8
82 $-#+ "'"#$%'(  $'-#5'(*#(,#(( *'%*" $&* &$)( %" %+ *'" *7 

 2#,!$( * 34" "&#'- $0&"5'(,$*#)# *$%-4"$" -#,#" * :" %"$)& *0+#%/" ( %" %+ 0%* & +"#$% 8
 "$$% 4 '&

 )'+"(- '*#%/"$" & .#(#$%! "#"#$%'& %$"#+ *3 -$5

%  9'"'3$0"9 9!

, '-1 "#%/'%*'&#%* & #%/#%*('')" &)#%#(#%/$))" #&$))#+ - )")$&" #&$, $%" ,$"$&+4+- 3 '&#%/ /#("&'"#$%$ 
;9

;;82 "'3$0"9 !

,  5 %" 45 & 10("

(< 4'&*('5'4)&$,'&'"0*#$ $5=$% . #+- 3 '&#%/& /#("&'"#$%$ 

>
8783 #%/*&#. %#%'. &4#/


(! *+', )&$,3 #%*5#"$0"3-$5#%/'%4$&%'%*#"" ,$"$&+4+- )&$,3 #%*'%*+$%( <0 %"-4'-1 "#%/) --$%" &$'*5 & '( '&#%* & #%/'-$%/5#"" ,$"$&+4+- 5'(*&'// *34" ')$& ('#*

'%" &"$'*#("'%+ %" '++#* %"'-1 "#%/& + #. *,0-"#!- #%10&# ( 5 & '('&#%* &#%/*# *$%" (!$"'%*" ,$"$&+4+- 5'('-($ *','/ * '=#%/'*.'%"'/ $)" +&$5*/'" & *$. &" & " *&#. &$) "  '%" &)- *'5'4)&$," (!$"

 %" 3'(#($)('#*("'" , %" 5'( & /#(" & *

)" &+$,!- "#$%$)#%. ("#/'"#$%)#%'-& !$&"0%* & +"#$%2

&

5'()#- *3 )$& " "&#'- $0&"'%*0!$%+$%(#* &'"#$%+'&/ (5 & )&', *'/'#%("" '++0( *?! "#"#$% &5$!- '* *%$"/0#-"4'%*+-'#, * "&#'-  %$&* & "$*#(+'&/ " $%0( " !&$( +0"#$% :',#% * - . % 5#"% (( (  & ')" &("'" , %"$)'++0( *5'(& +$&* *0%* & +"#$%

&

5$!- '* *)'-( #,!-#+'"#$%$5 . &%$ .#* %+ 5'(- *34#, #%#(* ) %+

 "&#'- $0&"')" & :',#%#%/"  .#* %+ $%& +$&*)$0%*" '++0( */0#-"4)$&+$,,#((#$%$)$)) %+ (!0%#('3- 0%* & +"#$%26  82 '%*'++$&*#%/-4 5'(+$%.#+" *'%*)$--$5#%/( %" %+ ( 5 & #,!$( *0!$%#, 

 !"

 "

"

#$#%& & 26

#,!- ,!&#($%, %" )$&;  ,$%"( '-$%/5#" )#%  $)


?
'%*#%* )'0-"$)!'4, %"$))#% "$0%* &/$ )0&" &! &#$*$)#,!- ,!&#($%, %")$&2*'4(

 8


#,!-  ,!&#($%, %"  )$&    4 '&(  '-$%/5#"  )#%  $)
79

?
'%*#%* )'0-"$)!'4, %"$))#% "$0%* &/$ )0&" &! &#$*$)#,!- ,!&#($%, %")$&$% ,$%"

2

#,!- ,!&#($%, %" )$&;  ,$%"( '-$%/5#" )#%  $)
9

?
'%*#%* )'0-"$)!'4, %"$))#% "$0%* &/$ )0&" &! &#$*$)#,!- ,!&#($%, %")$&2*'4(


//&# . *'/'#%("" ('#*10*/ , %"$)+$%.#+"#$%'%*$&* &$) ( %" %+ *'" *7   2!'(( *34" "&#'- $0&"'%'!! '-5'()#- *34 " +$%.#+"3 )$& " **-  ((#$%(0*/ '/'&$'-#5$.#* #,!0/% *10*/ , %"*'" *2  *#(,#(( *" '!! '-'%*'))#&, *"

"&#'- $0&". &*#+"

$5 . &" ( %" %+ #%)-#+" *0!$%" ! "#"#$% &0%* &  +"#$% 8
5'(& *0+ *"$(#,!- #,!&#($%, %")$&$% 4 '&'%*& ("$) " ( %" %+ !'&"5'(,'#%"'#% *

#(('"#()# *5#"" '!! --'"  $0&"10*/ , %"" +$%.#+"'( !& ) && *"#(& .#(#$%! "#"#$%

@ '&% *+$0%( -)$&" ! "#"#$% &'('&/0 *"'"" '-- / * '++#* %""$$=!-'+ '"'&$0%*9 !

, '%*" "&'))#+'""'""#, 5'('"#"( ! '=" & )$& " & 5'(%$$++'(#$%)$&" ! "#"#$% &"$*&#. " '-- / * $)) %*#%/. #+- &'(-4'%*% /-#/ %"-4  (03,#"("'"" '++#* %""$$= !-'+ 10("3 )$& " &$0%*'3$0"'%*" "&'))#+5'('-& '*4(-$5'%*#"5'( " )'0-"$)" ,$"$&+4+- *&#. &5$"0&% *#(,$"$&+4+- $%" - )"(#*  " & )$& " ! "#"#$% &A(. #+- ("&0+=" ,$"$&+4+- )&$,3 #%*  '( )0&" && ) && *"$" " ("#,$%4$)'&* .#%/@$%/#'BC9D5$'* :',#% *" ,$"$&+4+- 3 '&#%/& /#("&'"#$%$ 
;9

;;82'%*"

$)) %*#%/. #+-  '%" &3 '&#%/& /#("&'"#$%$ 

>
878'%*/'.

#(, +'%#+'-& !$&":

9?'%*:

9?& (! +"#. -4

@ '&% *  +$0%( -  (03,#"(  "'"  "  &#,  5#"  "4& (  $)  " ,$"$&+4+- 5 & #%"'+"'%*%$"*','/ *" & )$& " #,!'+"*$ (%$" (0// ("&'('%*% /-#/ %"*&#.#%/$%" !'&"$)" ! "#"#$% & ++$&*#%/"$ #," +'( $)" !&$( +0"#$%(0)) &()&$,,'" &#'-* ) +"(" & )$&  3 % )#"$)*$03"* ( &. ("$3  :" %* *"$" ! "#"#$% &'%*" #,!0/% *

8
10*/ , %"$)+$%.#+"#$%5'&&'%"(#%" &) & %+

)" & '&#%/" - '&% *+$0%( -'%*+$%(#* &#%/" +'( )#- +'& )0--4"#( $0&")#%*("'"" !&$( +0"#$%+'( '(3 %!&$. *34C '-1#"#%/5$5'('!#--#$%&#* &5#"*&#. &'&#%* &#%/B* + '( *D#% " ('#*'++#* %"

 '(+- '&-4("'" *"'"" $)) %*#%/. #+- 5'(*&#. % 34" ! "#"#$% &'%*5 % ("&0+=" ,$"$&+4+- )&$,3 #%* ) --$% " /&$0%*5 & '(" *&#. &$)" ,$"$&+4+- '-$%/5#"" ,$"$&+4+- 5'(*&'// *0!"$ ) "5$'-($(0)) & *#%10&# ('%*'*#* %"#)# *" ! "#"#$% &    '&/0, %"  $)  "  - '&% *  +$0%( -  "'"  "  *&#. &  $)  " ,$"$&+4+- 5'('")'0-"5$(0** %-4+', #%)&$%"$)" "&0+=*$ (%$" ( ,"$3 !&$3'3- +$%(#* &#%/" (#" !-'%5 & #%!$#%"AA#(" !-'+ 5 & " '++#* %""$$=!-'+ $%'$% 5'4&$'* 0&" &" ("'%*$)"

- '&% *+$0%( -"'"'"" "#, $)" '++#* %"" & 5'(-$"$)"&'))#+'%*" ! "#"#$% &5'(%$"*&#.#%/" . #+- &'(-4'%*% /-#/ %"-4#('-($5#"$0" '%4, &#"'(" (! *$)" $)) %*#%/. #+- *$ (%$"* )#% &'(% (('%* % /-#/ %+ $%" !'&"$)" *&#. & "#(" *0 +'& 5#+5'(& <0#& *"$ 3 "'= %'""'""#, 34" *&#. &#("$3 ( %5#+#(,#((#%/#%" !& ( %" +'( '(#"5'()$&#,"$3 +'& )0-"$+$%"&$-" (! *$)#(. #+- #%$&* & "$'.$#*" #,!'+"

0&" &"  .#* %+ $)C9#%*#+'" ("'"" & '&"'#- -',!$)" ,$"$&+4+- 5'(3&$= %'%*" . #+- 5'('-($3 %"  ! &0('-$)" #,!0/% *10*/ , %"$)+$%.#+"#$%!'(( *34 " "&#'- $0&"'%*0! -*34" '!! --'"  $0&"& . '-("'""  %"#& ,'" &#'- .#* %+ $)" !'&"# ('(3 %+$%(#* & *+'& )0--43 )$& $-*#%/ " ! "#"#$% &/0#-"4  )#%*#%/($)" "&#'- $0&"'(5 --'(" '!! --'"

$0&"'& 3'( *$%+$&& +"'!!& +#'"#$%$) .#* %+ $%& +$&*5#+($5(

9
"'"" !&$( +0"#$%'(!&$. *" +'( 3 4$%*& '($%'3- *$03"

(0-"'%"-4%$/&$0%*#(,'* $0")$& : &+#( $)& .#(#$%'- 10&#(*#+"#$%

 "#"#$%#(*#(,#(( *

$. ,3 &  

   

0-'"# '( C " & !$&"'3-   (?$ C " &! '=#%/?

'($% *   (?$