High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/151/2007dismissed

Naveen Thakran v. Sanjay Thakran

2015-02-04Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri,Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta9 pages

!!"#$#%&'(( )!!%*+,%-#!.*,#.%/0*+,% ((((11!22% ( 3!,$4$ .%/0*+,%$%.*,# 5*%6!,*+,% ((( !$1%6!% (

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

% -$6#%8@@(%6 0!, *)#,@-22!8!7#14,%6-$ *!%20$%*#$1,!% $( %! 5.#%8*8 !!" 6 *!5,,#8!90" #%8$5#662!5%( *!1,1$2 *!5,,#8!-$""!1 !6%6,+"!,!5%0-$ 1!,,5!6( %;('('7 *!5,,#8!-$$2!5%#>!6( % *!)!

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

$0"*# ,#$ #$*!9!*)!$#%$5!$*#%8#%(.*!6#6% +! *! 1,!$",#9!65!6#"#%!%6$*! + *!5!6#"#%!,5 *!,!$1%6!% %6 *,-% *!5-0%6 ,% *!1,!$",#1 #%$2#1( *!9, *!, *! ,!$1%6!% *!%#%,5!6 *!1,!% $ *!11!22% -*"5!% :(('%6 +*!,-0( %'(('7 *!1,!% $ *!11!22% "22!6 *! *!, *!,!$1%6!% %6,!B4!$ !6*#5 $!%6 *! ,!$1%6!% +! *!11!22% -# **#5$$*!-$1!,!" 20%,52( *!,!$1%6!% -!% *!*4$!*#$#%2-$%:(('%6 9,48* *!11!22% 9"+ *!,5 ,#5%#2*5!( !,"5#%8 *! *4$!7 *!11!22% 8#%" !6#%5$ 4%9!"5#%85%%!,%6 2+!6%%$!%$!(.*!-$ +!% ,(*#%6!,6%7 $0"*# ,#$ 7 4,8%%C(('-*65#%#$ !,!6"412!#%/!" #%$(*!% 8#%$*!-$ +!% *!6" ,( %(('7 *!11!22% 9!"5! )#2!% %6$ , !6$*4 #%8 * $*!$*4269! +!% 80%!"28#$ ,

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

2*#,(:(:(% *!5!% #5!7 *! *!, *!11!22% 2%8-# **#$04%8!,9, *!,%6"4$#% +*!,-# * *!5 *!#, *4$!(*!08 *!,65# !6#%*! %!4, $0"*# ,0%6,48! 66#" #%7!-!2*#%(:('-*!,!$*!,!5#%!665# !

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

22% -$ $4!,#%8 ,5 5!% 2 6#$,6!, 1!,5%!% % 4,!7 *! ,!$1%6!% #2!6 1! # #% , %%422#%8 *! 5,,#8!906!",!!6#),"!(*!$#61! # #%-$"% !$ !690 *! 11!22% 90 #2#%8 -,# !% $ !5!% ( !$#6!$ ,#$#%8 ),#4$ 1,!2#5#%,0 9/!" #%$7 # -$ 12!6!6 * *! 11!22% -$ % #%"192!8#)#%8)2#6"%$!% F$*!-$% 4%$4%65#%6%6-$ % $4!,#%8,55!% 26#$,6!,(.*!-$% 4%# ,5,,#8!%6 1,!",! #%"*#26,!%(*!,!$1%6!% %6*#$5#205!59!,$*6 "5!%,+"!,!5%0%6*6$!!% *!11!22% (.4#"#!% 54% -$$1!% %*!,5,,#8!94 *!,!$1%6!% 6!5%6!6$45( 2"$%6$% ,",#% *!6-,0(*!,!$1%6!% -% !6 !A5#%! *!,1!,$%220 *!"512! 960%61,#) !1, $-# *%+!6!

0!$90 4$#%8 ,"*2#8* %#8* #5!-*!%9 *-!,!%%!9!694 $*! 9/!" 6 *!$5!( 4! *#$4%#," *!,!$1%6!% 7 *! 11!22% 9!"5!1,)+!6(*!11!22% $!% !2!1*%#"5!$$8! *!,1,!% $ * *!,*4$9%6%6#%2-$-!,!*,$$#%8*!

6!5%66-,0741%-*#"**!,9, *!,"5! $!! *!$# 4 #% -*!,!#%*!4%6 * $*!-$$4!,#%8,5!)!,%6-$%,52( *! *!,)!,5!% $56!#% *!1! # #%-!,!6!%#!6%61,0!,, 6#$5#$$2 *!$5!-$56!( *!,!$1%6!% #2!6,!12#" #% "% ,)!, *!)!,5!% $56!#% *!-,# !%$ !5!% %6,!# !, !6 * 56!#% *!1! # #%( ,5 *!12!6#%8$ *!1, #!$7 *! ,#2 "4, ,5!6 *!22-#%8#$$4!$& <( E*! *!, *!5,,#8! *!1, #!$-$2#92! 9!%%422!6% *!8,4%6$5!% #%!6#% *! 1! # #%G

( E*! *!, *!1! # #%#$ #5!9,,!6G

D( E*! *!, *! 1! # #%!, *$ 8 % "4$! " #%,#2#%8 *!1! # #%G

!2#!( D( %$411, *#$"$!7 *!,!$1%6!% 9!$#6!$!A5#%#%8 *#5$!2$ E;2$!A5#%!6 E.#,#%7 E8#%6!, .#%8*7 ED?,#$*%?45,%$ 92!7 E',(,*5!!1.#%6*47

E,(*#%6!,6%7 E:,(,#$* #7 E.,41.#%8*7

EC*!%6!,.#%8*7 E 5*%6!,%6 E.% ,!)#( % *! *!,*%67 *!11!22% 9!$#6!$!A5#%#%8*!,$!2$ ED2$ !A5#%!6 ,6!!1 %$ E%6/0?45, %$ E( '( *! ,#2 "4, % 11,!"# #% !)#6!%"! 2!6 90 *! 1, #!$76!"#6!6#$$4!(#%)4, *!,!$1%6!% *26#%8 * *#$ "%$!% -$9 #%!690,46%6$$4"**!-$!% # 2!6 8! *#$ 5,,#8! %%422!6( $$4!( -$6!"#6!6 8#%$ *! 11!22% *26#%8 *!1! # #% 9!-# *#%2#5# #%( $$4!(D-$6!"#6!6 8#%$ *!11!22% 9!#%8% 1,!$$!6("",6#%8207 *! ,#2"4, )#6!

# /4685!% %66!",!!6 !6(:(22-!6 *!1! # #%%61$$!6 6!",!!%422# 0#%)4, *!,!$1%6!% %68#%$ *!11!22% 6!"2,#%8 *!#,5,,#8!$#22!82%6)#6(!%"!7 *!1,!$!% 11!2( '( @!,%!6"4%$!2, *!11!22% $495# !6 * *!#22%!$$ *!11!22% -$% 1,#, *!5,,#8!( -$4, *!,$495# !6 * *!,!-$%!)#6!%"! $*- * *!"%$!% *!,!$1%6!% -$9 #%!690,46( -$4,8!6 * *!2$!22!8 #%$-!,! 2!)!22!690 *!,!$1%6!% ( ( % *! *!, *%67 2!,%!6 "4%$!2 , *! ,!$1%6!% 9!$#6!$$411, #%8 *!/4685!% %66!",!!7$495# !6 * *! ,#2 "4, %11,!"# #% *!!)#6!%"!2!690 *!1, #!$*6,#8* 20 1$$!66!",!!%422# 04%6!,.!" #%

*!" $ *!

11!22% *6120!6,46#%9 #%#%8 *!"%$!% *!,!$1%6!% , $2!5%#> #%5,,#8!( :( !,*!,#%82!,%!6"4%$!2, *!1, #!$%61!,4$#%8 *!,!",67-!6% #%6%05!,# #% *!"% !% #%$ *!2!,%!6 "4%$!2, *!11!22% ( ( .!" #% *! " 6!2$ -# * H)#692! 5,,#8!$H( 24$! "

$49$!" #% .!" #%2%8-# *"24$!

$49 $!" #% .!" #% *!" -*#"*,!,!2!)% , *!14,1$!$ 6/46#" #% *!1,!$!% 11!27,!6 *4$& < $ %&'()* +',,%'-*. %0 5,,#8!

$2!5%#>!67 -*! *!, 9!,! , !, *! "55!%"!5!% *#$" 7$*229!)#692!%650 9! %%422!6 90 6!",!! %422# 0 % %0 *! 22-#%88,4%6$7%5!20&

II II II

* *!"%$!% *!1! # #%!,7,-*!,! *! "%$!% *! 84,6#% #% 5,,#8! *! 1! # #%!,-$,!B4#,!64%6!,$!" #%$# $ 6#55!6# !209!,! *!"55!%"!5!% *!*#26,,#8! !$ ,#% 5!%65!%

" 7 ;C ;C 7 *! "%$!% $4"* 84,6#%-$9 #%!690,"!,90,46$ *! % 4,! *! "!,!5%0 , $ %0 5 !,#2 " , "#,"45$ %"! "%"!,%#%8 *! ,!$1%6!% F,

II II II

-# *$ %6#%8 %0 *#%8 "% #%!6 #% $49 $!" #% 7%1! # #%,%%422#%85,,#8! % *!8,4%6$1!"##!6#%"24$! "

$49 $!" #% $*229!!% !, #%!6#

*!1! # #%#$1,!$!% !65,! *%%!

0!, !, *! ,"! *6 "!$!6 1!, !,7$ *!"$!509!7 *!,46 *69!!%6#$")!,!6F,

*! 1! # #%!, *$7 -# * *#$ , *!, 422 "%$!% 72#)!6-# * *! *!,1, 0 *!

5,,#8! $ *4$9%6 , -#! !, *! ,"!*6"!$!6 1!, !,7$ *!

"$! 50 9!7 *! ,46 *6 9!!% 6#$")!,!6F

II II II= "",6#%8 "24$! "

$49$!" #% .!" #%

/ *!" 75,,#8!#$)#692!-*!,! *!"%$!% *!1! # #%!,, *! 84,6#%*$9!!%9 #%!690,"!,,46(*!-,6$<,"!=%6 <,46=*$% 9!!%6!#%!6#% *!" ( ,6207,465!%$%6 #%"246!$" $"55# !6901, 0-# * *!#% !% #% 6!"!#)!, #%64"! *! *!,1, 0 6"!, #%" $( *!"%"!25!% " %!"!$$,#2048* 9!$4"*% 4,!$$ !" *!6!"#$#% *!1, #!$( 6!1!%6$41%" $!"*"$!( C( .!" #%

# 1,!$",#9!$ #5! 2#5# , 1,!$!% #%8 1! # #% )#65,,#8!% *!8,4%6,"!,,46("",6#%8 *!$#61,)#$#%7$4"*1! # #%*$ 9!#2!6-# *#%%!0!, !, *! ,"!*$"!$!6 1!, !,,46*$9!!%6#$")!,!6(*!$!"%6 "%6# #%, *!5#% #%9#2# 01! # #%*$9!!%1,!$",#9!64%6!, .!" #%

## *!" ( $ #142 !$ * *!1! # #%!,$*426% *)!"*9# !6-# **#$,*!,422"%$!% -# * *! *!,1, 0 *! 5,,#8!$*4$9%6,-#! !, *!,"!*6"!$!6 1!, !, *! ,46*69!!%6! !" !6( ;( 6)!, #%8 *!" $#%)2)!6*!,!#%7# #$ 9!% #"!6 * *!,!$1%6!% *6!A5#%!6 E:,(,#$* #-*-*#2!6!1$#%8 *6" !8,#"220$ !6 * *!5!6#"2#22%!$$ *!11!22% -#!-$ *!,!6# ,0( !6#8%$!6*!,"$! 9!"4 !1$0"*$#$-*#"*#$ "55%20+%-%$!/ 8*%(*#$-# %!$$*64, *!,$ !6 * *!5!6#"#%!$ +!%90 *!1 #!% 50!!" *!5!% 2%61*0$#"2 6!)!215!% *! "*#26 #% "$! "%"!1 #%( )#6!%"! ,( *#%6!, 6%

E 7 .,41 .#%8*

E %6 *!%6!, .#%8*

EC *)! 4220 $411, !6 *! "$! *! ,!$1%6!% *4$9%6 ,!8,6#%8 *!#25!% *!11!22% ( !$#6!$ *!,2 !$ #5%0 *!$!-# %!$$!$76"45!% ,0!)#6!%"!7A( A( '7#(!(112#" #%

0 *!.41!,#% !%6!% 2#"!%6 *!12#"!!% ,0#$2$5 !,#2(

4, *!,A( A( ;*$2$9!!%1,64"!690 *!,!$1%6!% *4$9%6,!2 #%8 5!6#"2 ,! 5!% *!11!22% -*#"*#$"2!, 1#% !, -,6$ *! 5!% 2 "%6# #% *! 11!22% ( % $4"* "#,"45$ %"!$7# "426% 9!$#6 * $*!-$% $4!,#%81,#, *! "% ," #%8 *!5,,#8!( 4, *!,7# -$1,)!6%,!",6 * *!

11!22% -$*)#%85!% 26#$,6!,%6-$% %,52 *! #5! 5,,#8!%6!)% !, *!5,,#8!(*!,!$1%6!% 2-0$,!5#%!6 4%6!,11,!*!%$#%7$ ,!$$%6 !%$#%9!"4$! *!11!22% "426 "+ %0 #5!-*!%*!,5!% 26#$,6!,"426*)!88,) !6( *!5!6#"2!)#6!%"!664"!690 *!,!$1%6!% *6% 9!!%,!94 !6 90 *!11!22% $$*!*6#2!6 1,64"!%06" ,,!8,6#%8*!, 5!% 2"%6# #%( *!#,,!$#$ #92!"%"24$#%#$ * *!11!22% -$ % %,52%6 * "%$!% *!11!22% -$9 #%!690,46( ?!!1#%8#%)#!- *!" $%6"#,"45$ %"!$ *!"$!%6!)#6!%"! %,!",67 *! ,#2"4, *6,#8* 209$!,)!6 * *!,!$1%6!% -$ !% # 2!6 8! *#$5,,#8!%%422!6$*#$"%$!% -$9 #%!690 ,46( ( %)#!- *!#%6#%8$,!",6!690 *! ,#2"4, -*#"*"426 % 9!6!

5%$ , !6 9!1!,)!,$!,!,,%!4$#%%05%%!,9!#%8 9$!6%5#$11,!"# #%,5#$,!6#%8 *!!)#6!%"!%,!",67% #% !,!,!%"!#$"22!6,90 *#$4, (%$!B4!% 207#%6#%8%5!,# #% *!#%$ % 11!27 *!$5!#$*!,!906#$5#$$!

12 89$ 34