High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15869/2012disposed of

Jatinder Pal Singh S/O Ranjit Singh Wahniwal v. High Court Of Pb. & Hry., Chd Thru Reg. Gen.& ANR

2015-08-26Ms. Justice Navita Singh,Mr Justice Jaswant Singh29 pages

!"#$#%&&'(

)( '*+,#)- ."&%#/.-0!1!'"

'*+,#)- ."&%# !2!'"3-&

% & '

( )

(' & *

) ('

& ( + )

(' & * + ) (' * ,,, !2!'"3-& 4

' .

/ 0 121233")

1212334

(

$'0)

& '

$'0 151#333) 316"114 &) "117 '

."0

8 '

$'0) 9 : ; 1312"113

.#0 (

"11<"1

' 8

8 = )

* 4623 "1" - )

"715"1"

( '

* 2##3 "1"

.50 9 ) ' ' 8 ( "11<"1 .40 ( > (

"11< "1 %<

! "

% # $ "

%&'(')&'((*) +),, (- .%

# $ /0 1

# $ "

""!-

/0 .%

&- . %

# $ 4

"" (565-7

! '(-'8-&'('

&9-'&-&'(( #" !"

- 61!"% :

!: : !

% !

! #- 4

" # !

# - 8- , !

! # $

# 7-

<- +

(-8-&'(' 6(-6-&'(( 5- , %

! "

" # !!

% ! - !

" ## -, % - 93 )

* 4

! !

" " %

" % # % "

- =- 3

) 1), % +) ,,, $ 4

" # !!

: !

## -> .20 (

) 8

? 8

) ? ( ' ;

( = 512"1

' ' 8 ' )

= ) = $ @

) ;

( "11<"1

.70 $ @

) ; '

"512"1

)

) '

' '

( >

%< A&

*11 ""12"1)

' A4

% !"

% :

":#"

! &'(' &6'((/! 6(-'6-&'((0: #

- "

! "

" :

% !! "

!- %:

": "

% % #

"- "

%: % %

! -

" "

1 "-# ##

(=-'7-&'('-> .60 - )

1517"1

> ' 8 ( = ' .30 B "17"1) ?

B ( 8

? %< 4"

*) ;;

;;

,4-6* +

:1 /

0: -

8-5-&'(( %

" !"

# $ "

% &'(')&'(( %

- " -- ?:

.10 9 ) 6 9

1416"1

8% A;" ! "

(9 @

%&'((:

@%:7%

:&'((8-(7+-- ;;

;;

&'- 4

(&-'5-&'((

" 1

% "

+ 2 1 " /" A "0 # "

3 # :

! " #! $" % & % "

'( ) * " **+"

, ! "

$" #! - "

' ) )'. " "

)/ .0 =

? ) 1616"1

216"1 -C

C B )

$ @

) ; =

' =

412"113 1416"1

"#16"1 '

*4623 "1"

= 316"1 1517"1 > 8 ( "11< "1

= ' 1616"1

."0 $

* 4623 "1")

.' * 57 "1 (

%< 01 ,

" #$- +"

2"#&

"* 0

" !"

: "

! #" 1 5 + -57

" %, !"

! "

# # #$ %-

" $! "

!""

# "!

"(6:&'(&- 2-# 2"#&

"* 03 "

# ""

% # B+

1 - &- B:""

%:!

*) /0 4 "

B+

/10 -8(5

&'((

# , " % !!"

B +

/10 -(=9

&'(&

# , " % !!"

+ 2 % 1

#- /0 "!

:+ 2 % - /0 4!

B+

/10 -(=9

&'(&

1 # #$

%-4!

% 2 #

#$ - /0 BD 1 "# B +

;! %%!

! %

" 6(:&'(&- .#0 C ') '

.50 ;

( "11<

% A 8

' ' D ? ( ' ) = AED

= 8)

"" (565-7

! '(-'8-&'(' &9-'&-&'((#" !"

D A 8D A D

C ' ) 8

? 8

' '

8 = 8 =

8 A % D

' A

! "

"#!!

# %! - !

" ## -> C )

' ( ' $ @

C )

-C '

' ) $ @

C )

)

A 8

.40 C

! ,

" " %

"% # %"

) B

) =

= 8 = ) 8 <

C () 1), % > C

8 ( ' )

"#!!

- ""

## >

)

C )

8 '

) ? ( ' ) ' 8

C )

8 8

.20

1 ' 8 =)

? "17"1 A

6 9

? .70 C ? 9

) '

.60

"116<"113 "113<"11

? ( ' 9

) 8 ' ?' ? -)

"11 "11<"1 ' '

.30

? ( ' 8

614"11) 8 ' ( ' ' C

? 8

$ @

' 8

."10 ;

( "11< "1 '

( >

.' * 57 "1

#1"1

& +

) ; ( '

)

& $

) (' ) / 9 ) ; 1#1#"11 1#1#"1 B

8 ) ; ? (

$'0) ;

> ' "15"1 #114"1 8

( > "15"1 #114"1 %< "

D*A -> '=-'6-&'('/@ 10-":

! %"

" "

%-> ."0

= ' 8 ( "11<"1 > ??

< (

) & +

)

> ( )

' 8

( >

%< 74 "

- !? #- 4 ! "!

2":D%:D% !% !

- ! ? # "" "- :B %+ "! $;!

$ !

! "

); 2"

- 84 %!

! -8!

- "

! ? # % !

" : "

!? #:

4',!'. # " "

/ $

# $ "

%&'(')&'((

! "

! # !!- 74

! -7

: "

# " "

- ! ? #

" -, '.# " "

/ #"

# $ "

%&'(')&'((-, 1

:# %

6 5./ "

& !"

& ! 4

( !!

6 1

, 2 !

& & ! 8

& & !-, # "

% +,,,

& " " 0 "

" &

""! &&

B: "

- !

5 ? #:

54',!'.# " "

/ $

# $ "

%&'(')&'((

! - D %:! "

! # !!- $ %"

1/;"!"

-5-- , % 0#"

@ E!

% &'(')&'((- 4: !! %""

- !? #-> .""0

' ' (

5 2

."#0 ;

) ) ' ( "11<"1 ? ( ' ) ' '

' 8) )

( ' G(

' >

' 8

??<

' (

)

' 8 ( ;

' '

4 8 ? ( '

( "11<"1)

."50 H

%< ' 8

( "11<"1 ' ' !

" E'

)

E' ) !

."20 ( '

)

8 (

8 # $ "

""!-

' 8) ) = ??

= 8 ?

7#74

115"11 "61""1

8 ?

)

C )

#1I

2 ; $'

- ) 8 '

)

."70

) ' )

' 8

- 8

' ? ( '

= )

.0 ? ( '

)

' $ @

F') E

) '

C '

8 A

."60 ' = ??

= 8

) > 8 .0

) .0 )

) ')

8 ? ( '

C ? ( ' ; $' &) "11

614"11 -

' - ) 8 ? ( '

."30 '

1#1#"11) #1"1 @ 1#1#"1

? ( ' C

? ?

) 8

8 A

D C 8 '

- )

8 > 8

) ' 8

.#10

( > *

#9 $:"2-+"

."11304

"" C AC

> ) )

D .#0 C

&6 !2-(

6 ."1130 7

771) > ' 8 ?

' 8

)

C > 8 ' 8 ( > %< 7- @ (=9& (==7 (==5:!! :

% :

% ! # !

" %- %

"- @ % (==6: !

" # " #

$#;!

-> C

> - >

.#"0 ( )

% 0 2-: #; "$20 !$"< ! 6 ;

$ !

&='

9(-""

! % "

- "

# ;"

2"!

-4

% %;!" %

-, " !

-4

2""" "

" "

% # %- (=&- %: % "

#"#

! " % !%

-4 !"!

% 2"

2" #- : !

! %

:% "

! % !" - 4 % "

!! ! % "

-, %

" :"

-B ""

1 : %2"#

%# " ""!"

"% !%1

- B !! ! %

! %

" !" : #1 "&&< 1 " 6&#

# -> .0

2!( ) (

"-( < "1"

.50 #25

( C > ( '

"1 9

' C

( - ' .

< %6 #> "2!

( < "15 .0

(

' ) ? ?

' '

(

' (

( .##0 ( '

8 (

> % 33"

<33#

- "11<"1

" 33 "< 33 # 33 #< 33 33 5< 33 334< 332 332<37 337<36 336 < 333 333< "111 "111< "11 "11<"11"

"11"< "11# "11 #< "11 "115< "114 "114<"112 +

E E E (' = ' 8

E E

E E E E " C

' 8!

C J J J J ' 8

J J J

' 8 J)

E J J # (

> !

': (

) (< E) /

.E0) / (' G ) </ (' 0

/ .

0 J /K .E 0 J /

.E 0 (< E ; /

.0 / K .E0 /< ('

J /K .E0 E

(< E /

.E E J (< E J (< E 5 C '

) !

.9 $ @

& 0 E *( *( *( *( *( *( J E

J *

E *( J 4 C

B !

J J J J J E (' J J

J J J J 2

* J J J *

' *

J J

J F J J J J *

7 8 )

& E E

' E

E E

E (

6 /' /

E E E

' E *

E E E E E E E *

)

> !

* - '

1 * % /.

0 E /K /

(< E /

.E0 /

.E0 /< (' KKK /

.E 0 / K .E0 / K .E 0 (< E /

.E /

.E 0 ( . E0 ( . E0

&''<)&''5 &''5)&''9 &''9)&''= &''=) &'('

&'(')&'(( (- .%

# $ /0 1

# $ "

""!-

/0 .%

&- . %

# $ " %

" F%

" " (565-7

'(-'8-&'(' &9-'&-&'(( #" !"

- 61!"% :

!: : !

4 "

!#-4

- 8- , !

! # $

<- +

(-'8-&''<

6(-'6-&''5 %: &''5 ":

&''9 ! &''9 ":

&''= &''=) &'('

(-8-&'(' 6(-6-&'(( 5- , % 4 # "

"" %

D - ;"! :

"- 2"

!" "

! - #"

- !

- !" "

! - $! "

! "

"#!!

# %! - !

" ## - , % - 93 )

* !" "

" 4

! !

" " %

"% # %"

- =- 3

) AG/3

0 + /3

0 A +

1), % + ,,, $

" 4

"#!!

: !

## ->

"# .#50 - 8

' )

$ )

115"14 $B

* CGG G"15<4 #1"15 L C

%< A0 4"

! $

"% #

: ""

! %%#

0 , "

" "

D "%: "%

! #%" !

% "

! %

% 1 "

1 H 0 , D

!#: "

! # C # $

% !

-> .#40 - 8

( =

' ) '

)

' ) ? ( '

= ' )

) 8 '

' G '

"5 '

8 >

C ' ( G

8 =

( >

= )

()

C ' '

' ) '

.#20 ?

(

"!" <- "3".#0 - #56) (

8 ) '

)

' .0

( > %< (9-

#2 :# "% $

"-B ! %

!-;! " # " #%:

% "

# $:

"4 "

" !

""$2"%

-4 % "

2""

! !

" ! " "

1 2"%-4! "

" "

! :

" % :1"

"% %

/ " ;!%

% ! #"0: "

- ,

" "

%/0

2"#

, !"

/0: #"

"- %:1!%

" :

":!"%:

"! % "

"-41

" ! !

" "

" % # " "

-B

2":

2"% E

- (=- .4& :

4 >0&''(/(0 -1-4-6&9*/&''(0& 116'7 (

"->( ; "2<!.&

>,:(===/&0 -1-4-676*/(===/8 11 75=:

1:1 !

# $" :#"

"2 !

": "

$!#" !

2"%-41

! ""

% "

- B "

1 "

%-> .#70 ?

: +"

( <"1#.20 "3# %< &6- B % % 2

# #

* --- !

# "

;""

- "

# #$ %" ) ;"

#$# -, # ::%

%-> .#60 C

? :"2") .36605 43)

%< , :$2:-: #:*/ 11 !-('8:!9<0 9<---- 4 ;"

# # # ;"

# ;"

# %%- %: !

# ;"

)

"7 !!"

" ;"

## %

-, !

# /# 0 ;"

"#"

; #"! %

:";"

# # -> .#30 ( > 2! @& 4 !" #

2 ) ."1"05

%< I69- , ! !

" !

!!$

- 6=-, $F%-

-+-:"

/ 11!-&86:!6<0 I6<---%"

# "

:%-4

"%#

% : # "!"

-, # % % :# % - 4# !

#:#%-> 8(-,

B-A--? #: * / 11!-8&(:!50 I5--- 3

2"-

! !

2"#I8&-, --$2-

, : 2" %

! "

2" " !%

-4;!

! "!

2"!

D "

! "!

2":

# ";"! " #D "

;!% % "%!"

! #: % "

- I85---

$# :

- 4%#

$ #" "

; %# ""

"- # %:

"(8

! "

"&(- .510 C '

) = ' 8

"11<"1 = -) 316"1 ' (>

<7 '

*4623 "1"

= .50 = )

.5"0 " = E'

)

E' ) )

? -

"517"1"

' (>

0 '

* 2##3 "1"

)

"3 8

( (

)

5/ 1 6 5