Jagdev Singh Bhatoa v. State Of Punjab And Others
!"# $%$ & ' !'( "& & )*
% &$ +" +,- !
"# # ## !
"# $
' ' ./0 /1 -21
'/,' ' +/(0+3,01 --0 1(45- ' 6%(7'1
1(45 8888 # ##%&'( &/,',/5 0-9/,':'//, !'-9 00-
/1/(' /3(,0: 9// :'5(- '3/--1-.,729 /- 1 91/3(,0:/3,0-- :' '31 5( 001 / ',- /2 0'-: (- --
' /0-7 / 0 / (,0 (01 '-1 9//'9/-(0-5/0- ;'-(0,': //0(- '(,0(01'-5-0'- 2- 001 :' '3 3,0- '7 '3 235'1 9'-19//9005235'1< ' - ,'2 '07 / -(' / 3(,0:-5- '/'',,' /( /-
&/0 /(,0(01'-9'/0-5:/ " = - (, 3,0 / ,' 01 / '>('- (35' (,0 (00' 9' 0-
' 0 ,' 7 0(--1 / (,0 (00' ' 5 -3'- /
- / 3 -: / 0 / , '-?! '- ' 5 (-'. ,' (45 (,0 '- - ! '- 0 +(01 @@= ' /'1 / @@= +(09///25 '3-(-'/(45(,0 1
' /'1A/
B = #/,'1.,729/ /9',
0-5 '/('57CD C 19/''3'-'9 ,- '/0-7/0/, '- /(,0 (01 '-1 9 (- ' /0-7 / ' 37 ' / ,(', -3'7 / / / 90: 0- (,0 (00'19//9-= &/,'079//'(,0(00'./ -(-/3(,0: &/' '1'3'-'9,- ''7 / -(7 / 0 ' / , '-1 ,9(7/9//'1/, !'-5 00-(,' - '77/-(, '3/'>('-''10 /, !'-9-(-
&/(,0(01'-(-,'001/ " (45(-
-'7//E 0>((,0(01'-19005/0- / 7'(-//-3(,0:/0'-:3,0-'3 :' 27-(-'/09= < )0777'2-7/- --
1
/ ,' / ,,'/- / (' 5: ,07 '0 (, / ,'2 09//(' :'5 '3/-9/ 37 '/0/, '-'!'-/0-- /,'1(/3790:/0-235'11- ,'- :'5(- '3/--19//(': 5 3,0- - /' '1 / ' / " / / (,0 (01'-/0'-:3,0-'35:.7/- ' 37 = '' - '': / ,'2 / (45(,0 1
;'-(0 '/,'(53/ --
''/0-7 0 (,0(01 3:.-0:5-/7'(-/3(,0:(00 235'1< 39(- &/',-/2 0-/',0: 9/'1/53-/,'/091 '0 90: 0- (00' 0(--1 ' 37 5 /0- - - 371/5-3'-90:0-(00'-0 5/0- '/, '--!'-5(/,' 1/'9''7'-',-CD C '/0-7/ 0 / , '-1 / 37 9 0: 00- ' -3'7 / 3,0: 9/ / -' 72 5: / 3,(' 09 ,'/',-1-37-3' / / 9 /0- = - / ,' 07 9/ / /' 0-(,0(00'9'-3'-//-/: '3- /3(,0:27-(-'"
/ 3- ;'-(0 '/',-(53/ :''3 /(00'?(,0:/0'-:3-1.,729/
'379//9-3'-1/1/'/.,7 29/ '37/0- '0/, !
'- 235'11/-(' :'' '3/-- ''1/7' -,':'90020//','2 09 0(-7 '0= * /( #-//'3 (,0(00'53'/ :' ,'/',-1 /'3'- '3= 9'-10':/0-(,0 (00'57,-'7 '3= -1/'7(3 '-5:/0'-(0 '/,',-1/:900'3 (00' ','- 3'/ :'-9005,-0': ' 3' / < :' /(7/1 (-' 09 72'7 2' - , /: /0-/, (,0(00' ','- 3'/ :' - /1 ,':' ,' ,-1 3 9(0- 0- 20 /','2 091/'3(-'/ '(072.
/2/'-/0'-(0 '/,'-/27 /'(7//''-9//'50 &/'(09//72'/(9/'7'-/(' 3(,0:-50.- ,'" 9//-09// 3, 3(,0:1"
(-'CC
!"
"
# "
$ "
"
"
"
"
""
"
% &'
"
!
( "
"
) '
*
"
%
" !
+
&/3(,0(0/00 0-335'900 / 335' / 0702 350: / ' (-' 9// - (,0(00' 00 "
9//-09/ /-(' /3(,0:1/3(-'
,'
'
!
'
*#
'
"
"
,- $ .
+ "
+ "
"
!
/
0 * *
- ""
""
"
% '
1 *"
"
*#22#
-
'
% ) *
"
#
-
(
- -"
"
$ '
!
"
!
'
!
'
- "
#
" 3
*
""
"
4
*"
"
*223#
! - "
5 ,
!
- ""
""
"
4
*"
"
* 223#
! -"
"
""
"
6 *
-
"
!
'
!
'
'
7
5' ,'(0 / 52 9(0- /9 / '3 2': 3(,0:( ','- :' '3/- ' 37-07'1-9/9005'(- '37/5 E,0-3/37/0- '0 /'--! '-(-'"
= #3:5-/(-'"
12': 3(,0:/0 '30-335''--! '-/3:55(1/'- E- '0 (/ 335' )('/'1(-'"=
10-335' '/
00/-3'--2/0/ , '-?! '- (0- 5 (-'. 001 / / -3'- #'-''30// 90:0-335'-/ 0 / , '-1 / 2'3 9-31 5: E'7 / 4('- (-' /
1 / '3- / (45 (,0'--!'- 0+(01 @@= " / @@=+(0(-'C
8 ""
"
'
#! 9
:
"
"
!
# -# '
'
"
"
#
'
"
"
"
"
#
!
"
"
"
/
/
"
#
$ 9'
; "
'
/
/
"
#
'
'
: .
#
"
"
<
;
!
#
!
!
<
; "
" <
"
&'
"
.
"
"
<
#
!
"
"
#
7
<
5' ,'(0 / 52 9(0- /9 / / ,(: 33'/5(/'F-00/ '37 '0( /0'-'-3'//90:0-(00' --(/0 '/, '--!'- /-37
#3:5-/ ','3(07 @@=+(01/' 357(:>(/ '375/0-/3/ '37
' -3' / - ' -(7 0 ' / ,
'- -! '- 5 00- (-' " @@= +(0 $1/E,072(-'"
>( '37/5 '-/'3(0:9/" @@='(019//'(0-'5/
'37 /(,0(0
#3:5-/(-'"
1/ ,'3': 3,/ / ' 37 3 / (' /3(,0: #/5 : '37 E-(-' /
1/E,09---"
'(/ '37 $1 '00-,(',1 --,//-(' /3(,0:9' '3/ -G '37H5/0- $1+(0 @@=+(010'0: - / '379///5-3'-/90: 0-(00'-0/, '--!'- 5/0-1/35'- '37(/ 3(,0:-'(' 2 1/ '37//-3'-(00' 5(0, '--!'-.,0 ': '15-//3(,0:/5(- '('5:,07'0(,/E,072"
&/E,015'-9//(5>( +(0 @@= '(01 9// 0' 5:- -(5 / / ' 37 9/00- '-3'7//-/0/, '- - ! '- . ,0 $1 2 / / -3'-/- '375(0/, '- '!'-.,0 ':'1/-375'- '37 '39//-/(' /3(,0(05 (- ','- :'-5:-/
,'" @@=+(01(,0( 01 (/ '37500-5:/,(:33''- ' -3'7///(00'0-- '/0-7/0 /, '--!'-/3- 5','(0 /52','-(9(0-/9//53-3-': /0-/0/, '--!'-/ '- 0 9///72//' 059" 1 "
-/E,072/'//'3 / 3(,0: ' ,'- :' - / - '3 900 33 '3/-/37 '0/, '-- !'-00- ' /0,,0:7/,'2
-/ @@='(0 / ,' 1 3: 5 - / (, 0( 0 (,0(01'-1/ '37900-= ' -3'7 / / &/(7/1 ,' @@= '(0 72'7 2 / 0'5/0- '/, '--!'-/ 3-://5-3'-5(1.,729/''7 '-',-5:/('CD C 1-0/, '- (0- 5 /0- $1 / >( 9// ' ' -' 9//'1 (/ ' 37 9// 9 E- ' -3'7 / / 5 0- (00' = 5 '- '37'3 "
3,0 :''32 /0/, '--! '- (0- 5 /0- -( '3 '-' ,- 5: / (' 1 / ' 37 /0- '-3' /5( 5 '-/ '37 1/,,-- '(7/-(' /'3 3(,0:1900'-,':>(//','2
09 1(00'-3'-/-,' 3(,0: (-'"
-0'270':'7
'3/--1/--19//= /,' 1./- '37 ',(', (7 -(' '31(/(00'900(5-, ','- 3' / :'1 9// '': / E- -(' / 3(,0:9// ','- :' 0:/1/3900 5 '': '0 = * / ( #- 0 9// ,'2- / / -(' '3 3(,0: (00' 900 5 ,'- :'-G;7'H $1 '00-,(',1 2 /,'1-('3'-',-5:/3, (' 09 ' ''7 / /0-7 / 0 / , '- / ' 37 00- 9/' (00' 9' -3'- /= 9/'5:/:53/,' /3(,0:1/ ,'- :'900' '3/--- '3/-9/ (00/, !'-9'/0-235'1
;'-(0 '/,'/'7(-//'3 ' 3(,0:19//-
'//'3 E- '(,0(00' - /1 / (00' 0- 5 '- ,' / 3(,0: - /' '1 /: ( (00' 2 5:- ,'- :' #3:5-/"
/ 0'-: 5 ','-(- /'5 ' - / - '3 G3(,0:H 0(- 0- (00'1 /1 / '7(3 / / (00''-
':/3(,0:''-5 ,- ( 3(,0:,'"
0'0:0(-(,0(00'1/1/'3 /(00'- 3(,0:'0--3 ' :'9//-('5
(- '3/-/(00'.//'/3
'37 )('/'1/E,0"
57'0-(,5:/0'-(0 '/,'-//
' 37 3- "
/
5 / 379///0 /'-/0- &/-E,0 7','-(-(-'C
------- ,- $ .
+ "
+ "
"
!
/
0 * ------7 = #1-E,072"
5 '- 727 37 / - 2''- / (52 ,'2
- @@= +(0 &/(52,'2 "
,'2--/-('' '3A ' 37B &/' '1 / ',' 9// / 5 72 >( ' 375:/'3('-7 '0= * /( #-1"
-" @@=+(0-3 / 3 / 9/ ' 37 /0- ' -3'7 / / (00'19//3712/0/, '-- !'-5/0-1 0 '-5:-/'0 / ,(: 33' -( / 3 / - / -3'-1/C/0-7 (/0900E-/(' 3(,0: - / ' 37 900 5 / - 9/ - 37 -3'//90:0-(00'/0-2 0' /0-/--
&/-(/-05'-5 '/(''0' 0 #
! " # $ % &' #( ) * 1 '- %/ / (' /0- / / ' 37 9// / 5 /0- ' -3'7//(00'0-5'-/'02 - ' / ,(', (7 / -(' :' 2 1 / 0/, '-'/0-/-- &/30' 2997.+ ), , , & "
# $ % &' #( - , &/ 291 9// 9 . '0' 91 9 ''- 5: /'C'-%/ /('9/0--7+*
( .
/# %0# %# # $ % &' #(
;'- (0 ' / ,' (53 / /(7/1 / - 29''5(153-,,050/,'19/0 007/ '37/,'1/'9 '/0-7 /09///-
'7 /,' < #3:5-//,'1/37 '/0-7 / 0 '- - ! '- / (,0 (01 '-/ '-9///95-3'-(0-5 /0-/'907,-79/'(-'.79725: -,'3'-//0 '/, '-9(0-5 /0-1/571007/37 '07/'-/-: 9/ / / 9 -3'- = 9(0- /2 5 3,((/,' /"-/1/-37/5 '-/20-375'- '37 '(7/ -(' /'3 (,0(0,'"
'00-,(', D # '37--= 9////972 ./ '371/-(' :' -3(,0:/ 0'-:53,0- @
91/0/-(0/0'-:5,(50/-- 2 / 3 /2 0'-: 5 00- ' / 0 5 -(- 2/'91/71/0 '0'-:,'1'0 57'-/,'
I,729/0: /'(313- ( '/7' '0 ,':- '5:/,'-/,'9' ,'-70:-3- # ## $
) )
%
//'",.7?+- 6 //'+,'50 6