Union Of India And Others v. Ex Naik Sarup Chand And Another
+,-.-./,0102'3) "!#$ $%00%*" 4&0102 5$$%'
) 6 !
3
7%*%'
)
,
-./(
&' () 0 &3 &' '%''
!"#
$ %& &% '%&3
2 %$% " %*$ %*
#3 3
1 & (#
)
*+
$
2 %$%"%*$ %*
# 4- 45$6 '.
.'. . # 7).% %#$ 5"68 #&. $%%). ! "#$ %&'# "(( )* # . ,."' 5#2.(/. 0 #&%6 $ + +)"($ ,$ - %.'/$. ' -'" # * *. %$ # 0.01.'% #&. .
. . .)'$#, '*% 2& &"/ /. ,."'% ' 0'. %.'/$. % %#" !% )((,%.##(.!"%*.'("2!.("
"'.!1, %#$#)#$ "()'#% " !$ #.'*'.#"#$ '. !.'.!1,#&$% % '$1) "(8"0 -%##&.'%$
+,-.-./,0102 2'3) 80". &"##"' "( 1, #&. 91(. ) )*'.0. )'# 2&.'.$ #&.
.%* !. #% #&.0%.(/.% &"/. "
.*#.! #&. "**($"1$($#, ! "#$ )* # . ,."' ' *.
.'% .( .
. . .)'$#, '*%8 1, #&. 91(. $-& )'#% .(&$ " ! ) :"1 ;
;
"'," "$ <"!" $ -&" !<"
" $ "0'.%*.#$/.(," !"(% 1, #&$% #'$1) "( $ =&" $ ./$ "
! <&" " 5%)*'"6 &. - -. .'"("**($"1$($#, ! "#$ %&'# "(()*# .,."' 1, :)!$$"( $ #.'/. #$ &"% "(% 1.. %.##(.! 1, #&. 91(.
)*'.0.)'#$ )'. !.' $ -& "'0"'5%)*'"6 &.'.
'.8 ! "#$ %&'# "(($ +)"($ ,$ $ -%.'/$.)*#9 .,."'9 ' - -'" # *. %$ %&"(("(%1."/"
"$("1(.##&.*.'% .( #&. .
. . .)'$#,'*%5 6 5$$6()11$ -*$ # '.
.'.
.516" !568$#$%&.(!#&"# 2$!2% !.
. . *.'% .( &"/.
. #&. '$-&# # "**'"& #&$% '$1) "(#("$0*. %$ ' "0$ (,*. %$ $ %.+). .# # &.("$0 *. %$ +)"!.."%.! .0*(,..%2&$& "((%2$#&$ # &.!.
$ $#$ 4%.'/$.0"##.'4) ) !.'#&.#" !#&$%'$-&#$% * *'/$!.! 1, .#$ 6 #&. '0.! '.% '$1) "( #8
&)-&#&.'.$% "**($"1$( ($#, ($0$#"#$ $ #$ )$ - 2' -%" !'.)''$ -")%.% "
#$ 8#&."''."'% *. %$ 8 $ #&.%*.$ $"%.% ! "#$ %&'# "((82)(!&2./.' & &"/. # 1. '.%#'$#.! '0
"% "('."!, !$'.#.! $ "'"-'"*& )'. !.' $ -& & "'0"' 5%)*'"6 2&$& $% 1$ !$ - )% )'#&.'8 #&. ("$0 0% !)"( "0$(, *. %$ 5$ "!!$#$ ##&. $'%# "0$(,*. %$ 6 62)(!&"/.#1.'.%#'$#.!
'0 8 "% "('."!, *'/ /$!.! 1, <$ $%#', .
. . .##.'!"#.! 5%)*'"6 5$$$6 '.
.'. .#$ #5!6 !68$#$%&.(!#&"##&.("21.$ -
)((, %.##(.!8 $ ()!$ - 1, %#$ $#)#$ "( )'#%8 #&.'. $% % %*. ' "%$ # !)1# #&.
. ''.# .%% #&. ."'($.' !
!.$%$ #&$% '$1) "($ =&" $ ./$9%"%.##&)%(",%!2 # &.''.#(.-"(*'*%$#$ ("2 2>
5
6 ,
% %$%"%*$ %*%2
+,-.-./,0102 2'3) 8.". %* $% %8 9 5 6
7&8
&8
*
(
':& ) *
1 &#
( *#
0
#
##
%* $% %8 , " + * # * &8 (*#
*
0
*$ $
*
"# $ $%## & %# &
!
%%", ?
?
?&.#&.'%*."@$ -A'."% .! ?&.#&.' .*'#"1(. C.% A C.% A