Smita Gupta v. Joginder Pal Arora



 
    
   

  

!"#$%&%"% %

 

  
   #  !"#$%%!&'(!") *&!+,
 (

( 

'(

)*+,--.  /



.

( ''')

'12 '! '

.

3

-

  .045(124( - (  6 '(

7

 0


)(#. 

 0  4

*

(48( 9,'5 (  +(  -'  :  0- 

-$ 
#+#$./01/2!23/!+4$ 

2!2!$#5!&!2  .3 )  6* ,  
  *
&/1/2!+,   )   

'1

' 0  /

  

) ')*+, --4 

''((/ 0( .(



)--1(- 

% / (

 <
(

(1/'

 

 '  1 1' 

5

24(/ 0 00 (/ 1

.( 

5( ( 

1

1'

12 2   ' 

  4/


)( 4 4 2((  (6 

5(( '(   (  00 '12 5(

 (.'(  4 0 24( '45(  (6 (

(  '   24( .(/ 0 00 1

 ' 5 (( .( '5((

'  45(4 0 .(  

)+(--

' 0( .( 

)+ 0 .( ' 1

1; '     2 

  

24    / 0   

04  5(/  1  (       (  04

20 (/ .( 

 ( 24

(

 ((

0 ( .(  

(

 ) ( 0 '

2   ' 1

12  (  / 0       4  5( (  =

 

.  / '  '/ 5(  

 "

(  24 .

' 6  (4( .(( 1

    

/ ( 0

'   (

4( .(  (

(( / (  :5/4

 52  

2(  0

 

> 5( 0      / 0?

.(        

4  (

)

 @

.

/

0( :

.(-  )*+,(--5 '1 25((

''12(

0 12

 (

  )(-- 3 ( 24(

0 ( 0 '' 

)

1(/ 0?

.( 

;

( (.' 0

(

"

((( '4(

0 (

'(

  )  

.

 .((/ 0   

 (. 0 '(

 0 '  0

 ( 24(

/ /0 (

   
)( 

 

12 1 (

1  ( 0



(

 

/ 0

  (-- '  
+)(  12 =



( --

(0  ('0' '

 (4( 0

4 5(

(/ 0'

(   (6 0 1

 '1/ 0

0 (

 

)' 5 ( ('

/ 0 '  

*5,(--A )  3 (4  

.  (  ' 

   

/  /

.4 :  0- 

/&#3.7&!.#78#4#20# 2.#++/9#23#4$ !"

:01!&&7&!/2
&/1/2!+;;#!+  <8 (/.%
&/1/2!+ ;;#!+ =78 >'#3/'#'72 = > 6) 5(

2

.( (

1



/ 24( ( ' 7 <B
('    '

.5 ( /

+

.( 412( .

 4

 

''1

/

 

 =

2    12   

2 

 0'    (/ 

/  ( . 0= 0C#/-

  3 

30 0 14# 

C

( 5 5 .(.

5(



5 ' (

4  (  

2 '(

. 

2 ' 

(  2

(5  12    =

 (         ( 

2 

 (5

  '

  ( .(   

2

  (

 1    (     5 '  (/  (

6   

./ ' .( 4 51 '



  =

.  1

.

  :5/4  5(    '



.'

 

6  2/ '12('

 . 1 (4( 

6  (/

.

@ 2'

 '12' 4

/%/$/$?#3!0$#/./$$#..+#'+!( .%!..%#+!('#3+!&#'?@.%/$
70&./$&#.&7$;#3./4#!2'/$ 27&1!++@!$$01#'.7?#.%#+!(8&71.%#/23#;./72 B(   5 2  '   0 1 '  5 (  (         ; '.0    "0'91#2.  7& '#3/$/72  (%/3%  /2.#&;&#.$  !  $.!.0.#  7&  ;&74/$/72  .%#&#78 '#3+!&#$.%#1#!2/2978.%#$.!.0.#!$/.$%70+'?#372$.&0#' 8&71  .%#  '!.#  78  /.$  #2!3.1#2.

 2  7.%#&  (7&'$)  .%# "0'91#2.'#3+!&#$(%!..%#+#9/$+!.0&#%!'$!/'!..%#./1# (%#2  .%#  +!(  (!$  ;&710+9!.#'  !2'  .%#&#87&#)  /.  %!$ &#.&7$;#3./4##88#3.

"

(  24

 ( 5( (

0'1

/

=

20' 

/D(

5 0( 04

('

 

.

 5



/( . 21'

  0

5(( 

'

(0

.(

55( (=

'0(

(   

 

D(( ' '1( 5( 1( '(/ 52 5( '(

 0 0( ((' 2(  

C  5 51 0

= '( ' C*0 (

''', + (4

/ 5(; '.0 ''12(:  0  -  


#+#$./01  /2!23/!+ *

,   ' /&#3.7&!.#  78 #4#20#  2.#++/9#23# *

,4  '  

 ! '.4   '4 

 '( /



)-- ' ( 0(

-  '

0   %.

2

'

 ' '( 0

 1@ '(  '(   '

! '.4  '4(5 ( E 

'4 '

2

4  24

''

' * , =

6 
  D(( @

.F% G F# D((% 1 G F#