Amita Joshi v. Sandeep Kumar
! "# $%&' () *+!+%&,-,!). /+)(!0+ 122 33(%) 4! 5(%$ 26,/(" 1 !2%$ %) & 78 55 78 5 5 5
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
!" #$" %& '" !!( )*.
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
3,)+% /(""+(- :;$ *" $+#"* <+)0)0 /,),(3*%! %))0 2(")+ !.(3%- <+)0(%(223+*()+%"<(+#+%-)0 !)(),)";)+/ 2 "+$!+B/%)0!" )0 +%(3 ! ))3 / %) )0 2(")+ ! +% #+ < )0 2"3%- $ /()"+/%+(3 $+!2,) B+!)+%-: )< %)0 2(")+ !0 !(+$(223+*()+%<(!
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
B(/+% $%,3; . 0 (22 33(%) 0($ : % 2"! *,)+%- 0 " (223+*()+% " ! ))+%- (!
+ )+!(22(" %)"/)0 " *"$)0())0 " !2%$ %)0,!:(%$0($ +3 $(%(223+*()+%,%$ "5 *)+%> "$+!/+!!(3)0 (223+*()+% )0 (22 33(%)%)0 -",%$)0())0 (223+*()+%<(!%)/(+%)(+%(:3 +% #+ < 5 *)+% ' )0 *) +% )0 3+-0) )0 C,$-/ %) +%
!"
#$",& *(! !,2"(4+$ "$ "$() $,-,!)@. .)0 3 ("% $+!)"+*) ,$- $+!/+!! $ )0 (223+*()+% )0 (22 33(%) <+ :; (33<+%- )0 (223+*()+% ,%$ " 5 *)+% > )0 " !2%$ %) 03$+%- )0() )0 " / $;)0 (22 33(%)<(!)+3 (%(22 (3: " )0 +-0,")(-(+%!) )0 C,$-/ %)(%$$ *" (%$%):; <(; (22"(*0+%-)0 ,") :; (% (223+*()+%,%$ "5 *)+%> "! ))+%-(!+$ )0 !(/ +%)0 B "*+! +%0 " %)2< "!)0 ,")0 2 "()+# 2("))0 C,$-/ %)2(!! $ :;50,"$ #5+%-0.)0 )0 %+!)"+*),$- .(3(%$0("." ($!(!33<!&
! "# $ %
%$&' ! (
' )
)*('
) ) * )* ' )* + )
' ) ) '
)
& , % , *
'
)*
)#
) - ) )
-
.
# *
' *
. # + *
) / 0)
&' ! / ,.
1
%2 (
' '
'
.3 ' )
)*
.
' )
'
)* )
' +/ 0)/
* '
+
' ))(' )* / 0)
/
' # # '
* 4 ' ) + /
* 5
' ) ) 6 / 0)
*
,
. ) ) )* + * ' ) / 0)/
#
'
7 . '
+ '
7 )
9 * ' *
, : *)*'*
% , )
$ ) ,
*$ )* ;
)*
)*
7 # %% )* / ' $
6)
8
<3= > ?@%2 > 1 $1 F 2 ",!(3)0 (:# !(+$"$ "+%$+*() !)0())0 (223+*()+% )0 (22 33(%)"! ))+%-(!+$ )0 $ *" ,%$ "5 *)+%)0 *)% )0 :(!+!"(,$.* "*+%(%$,%$, +%3, %* 0(!: %$+!/+!! $G() " !0 0($!2 %)A; ("!+%2"$,*+%- #+$ %* :; %) ")(+%+%-(%(223+*()+% ,%$ " 5 *)+% > )0 " !2%$ %)0,!:(%$ :; 03$+%- )0() )0 " / $;)0 (22 33(%)<+ <(!)+3 (%(22 (3: " )0 +-0,") 0 (22 33(%)+%)0 !(+$*+"*,/!)(%* !0(!+3 $)0 2" ! %)(22 (3,%$ " )0 :! "#()+%! )0 +!)"+*) ,$- (%$ !,-0) )0 ! ))+%- (!+$ )0 $ *" $() $ :",(";.
,%! 3")0 " !2%$ %)"(39 )5+%-00(!# 0 / %)3; *%) %$ $)0())0 +!)"+*),$- 0(!"+-0)3;$+!/+!! $)0 (223+*()+%)0 (22 33(%) +% )0 B "*+! C,"+!$+*)+% # !) $ +% +) *3(+/! )0() )0 " / $;(#(+3(:3 ))0 (22 33(%)"+3+%-(22 (3,%$ "5 *)+%')0 *) 0($ %) : % (#(+3 $ <+)0+% ( 2 "+$ 3+/+)()+% (%$ )0 $ *" $+#"* 0(#+%-: */ +%(3.)0 2" ! %)(22 (3$ ! "# !): $+!/+!! $ )+!2 ")+% %)):! "# 0 " )0())0 $ *" $+#"* ,%$ " 5 *)+%)0 *)<(!-"(%) $% :",(";.:;50 ,2)(. )0 )0 %+!)"+*),$- .(3(%$0("0 2 )+)+%<(!$() $(%,(";'. (%$ )0 !(/ 0($ : % (33< $ % :",("; . :; %) ")(+%+%- )0 !(/ :; $+!2 %!+%- <+)0 )0 !)(),)"; 2 "+$ !+B /%)0! + <+)0,) -+#+%-(" (!%(:3 )+/ ()3 (!)!+B/%)0!))0 2(")+ !)" )0+%9(%$ 2%$ "# ")0 +"$ *+!+%)$+!!3# )0 /(""+(- :;)0 $ *" $+#"* :;/,),(3*%! %)0 2 B,")+%
#$/" %& 0 .
?5A>(%$ &* 1 !
%& 2 *
!
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
3 "(,$.)0 !(+$$ *" *,3$: *0(33 %- $: " )0 !(/ ,")<0 " )0 $ *" :;/,),(3*%! %)0($: %:)(+% $%)0+!*%) B)." 3+(%* 0($ : %23(* $%)<C,$-/ %)!<0+*00(# : %" "" $)+%2("(')0 C,$-/ %)$() $,-,!)@.? :,))0 3 ("% $,$- 0(!:! "# $)0() )0 "()+)0 ",3+%-!<,3$%): (223+*(:3 ))0 (*)!)0 *(! (!+)+! %)(*(! <0 " $ *" <(!:)(+% $+%*+#+3!,+):,)+)0($: %:)(+% $+% (2 )+)+%,%$ "5 *)+%)0 *)(%$5 *)+%')0 *)<0+*0 2"#+$ ! )0() (33 $ *" ! /($ :; )0 ,") !0(33 : (22 (3(:3 5,"2"+!+%-3;." 3;+%-,2%)0 C,$-/ %)+%
!" #$",& *(! !,2"( +)<(!0 3$)0()(22 (3<,3$3+ (-(+%!)(%;$ *" 2(!! $,%$ ")0 +%$, (""+(- *)+%*3,$+%-($ *" (33 - $)0(# : %:)(+% $:;"(,$) <(!0 3$:;)0 3 ("% $+!)"+*),$- .(3(%$0(")0())0 " / $;3+ !<+)0 )0 (22 33(%))+3 (%(22 (3(-(+%!))0 C,$-/ %)(%$$ *" ,%$ "5 *)+% )0 *) E 0(# *(" ,33;(%(3;D $)0 !(+$:! "#()+%!)0 3 ("% $ +!)"+*),$- +%*%) B)))0 (*)!(%$*+"*,/!)(%* !)0
!"
#$",& *(! !,2"(%)0 !(+$*(! )0 <+ <(!/($ )- )(% B2(") $ *" $+#"* (-(+%!) 0 " 0,!:(%$ <0+3 !0 % +)0 " +%) %$ $ ) - ) $+#"* %" !0 #3,%)("+3; +3 $ $+#"* 2 )+)+% (-(+%!) 0 " 0,!:(%$ :; +3+%-(2 )+)+%$+#"* %5 2) /: "A.??>50 *3(+/ $)0()("(,$ 0($: %23(; $%0 ":;0 "0,!:(%$(!< 33(!%)0 ,")(!!0 <(! $,2 $)+3 (2 )+)+%"$+#"* 50 0($23 ($ $)0()(*/2"/+! 0($ : % *) $+% 3+* 5)()+%. (C2,"(%,3;.??>(%$0 "0,!:(%$ 0($<+)0$"(<%(2 )+)+%% :",(";A.??@+3 $,%$ "5 *)+%?)0 *)%,3;A.??> "0,!:(%$0($(3!(** 2) $)0()0 % # "<(%) $
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
!" #$",& *(! !,2"(" ($!(!33<!& H7 (
$ /
* &*
. '
, %%2
+/
)
) > 1 '
'
) ' )+
' * @ ,
' )* 9 $ )*
$'
'
# '
) 9 > 1 2 ,
*$ ' $ # ) %2$ @ /
' > 1 > )A$7 +' ) 9 > 1 *
'
'' ,
* # ) > $ 8 *
> )2$ 2F ) " -+%- )0",-0 )0 (:# !(+$ C,$-/ %) < (+3 ) ,%$ "!)(%$(!)0<)0 3 ("% $+!)"+*),$- 0(!(""+# $()(*%*3,!+% +%2("(?0+!"$ "$() $,-,!)@. )0())0 " / $;)0 (22 33(%). (!2 ")0 "()+)0 ",3+%-)0 !(+$C,$-/ %)<(!)+3 (%(22 (3: " )0 +-0,")(%$%):;<(;(223+*()+%,%$ "5 *)+%> " ! ))+%-(!+$ )0 !(/ 0 2 B,")+%
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
+!)"+*) ,$- 0(! /+!*%!)", $ )0 C,$-/ %) )0 2 B ,") (%$ <"%-3;(33< $)0 (223+*()+%)0 " !2%$ %)(!!,*0)0 "$ "$() $ ,-,!)@. +!(22(" %)3;+33 -(3(%$+/2"2 "<0+*0$ ! "# !): ! ) (!+$ % 5 %& 2 2/
& 'A .($ *" ,%$ "5 *)+%)0 *)0($: %:)(+% $ % )0 !2,! !0($ *0(33 %- $)0 !(/ *3(+/+%-)0())0 "(,$0($: %23(; $%)0 ,")) <(!0 3$)0()+"(,$+!23(; $%)0 2(");.(! 2("() !,+)0(!): +3 $ :,) <0 % "(,$ +! 23(; $ % )0 ,"). )0 % )0 " #+ < 2 )+)+% +! /(+%)(+%(:3 0 (22 33(%)0(!!2 *++*(33;23 ($ $)0())0 "(,$0(!: % 23(; $ % )0 ,") (! < 33 (! % 0 " (9+%- +%) *%!+$ "()+% )0 :! "#()+%!
!" #$",& *(! !,2"(. )0 23 ( "(,$ " ! 9+%-" #+ <)0 "$ "2(!! $,%$ "5 *)+%)0 *)<(!): *%!+$ " $:;)0 +!)"+*),$- 0 3 ("% $+!)"+*),$- 0(!<"%-3; $+!*("$ $)0 *(! 3(<2"$,* $: " 0+/+%!,22"))0 *%) %)+%)0() <0 %(*%! %)$ *" 0(!: %:)(+% $:;"(,$23(; $%)0 ,").)0 2"2 " *,"! " )0 2("); <(! ) /# )0 ,") )0() 0($ " %$ " $ )0 $ *+!+%%)0+!*%) B).)0 33<+%-C,$-/ %)!(" " 3 #(%)& H
(C(%%(4!5 4 %9()(!<(/+. >5
@G "+34!6 !0(#(%$(%)0 ". 5@G 5(%)!0 ,"+4!%+3 ,"+. A +#+3 ?AG
A ,-(3 6+!0" 5/(%+ 4! (C( (/. ? >
+#+3@ G > E(!!(% 5+%-0 (%$ "! 4! 8(90( 5+%-0 (%$ (%)0 ".> +#+3 ?G @ ("% :,:(*9 " 6(!(/ 4! 50(%)0+3(3 (:,3(3 (+%. 6' 0 (:# !(+$C,$-/ %)!0(# : %" %$ " $+%*%) B)))0 */2"/+! $ *" ! :; )0 +#+3 ,")! :,) )0 2"+%*+23 3(< 3(+$ +! I,(33; (223+*(:3 ) )0 2"* $+%-! ,%$ " +%$, (""+(- *) (%$ )0 $ *" $+#"* ,%$ "5 *)+%)0 *)%"67 5 )* %& 1$"( #$". >." 3;+%-,2% 8 %& 9& 50/ 6!"& :;5 <5 . ??@ 5 >?. +) <(! 0 3$ (! 33<!& *$ *
)
$
) ' ) )*
*$'
)* *
9 ' # *$
' +
' )
)
)*
) )* B E (" )0 *%!+$ " $2+%+%)0()(!)0 +!)"+*),$- 0($ 2) $)!)2)0 2"* $+%-!() ")0 #+$ %* 0($(3" ($;: %*/23 ) $ :;)0 (22 33(%)+%0 "(223+*()+%"! 9+%-)0 ! ))+%-(!+$ )0 $ *" ,%$ "5 *)+%)0 *)%)0 23 ("(,$)<+33.)0 " " .:
2",$ %)(%$+%)0 +%) " !)C,!)+* )" 3 -() )0 2(")+ !)(22"(*0)0 +!)"+*),$- .(3(%$0(""($C,$+*()+%)0 (223+*()+%+%(**"$(%* <+)03(<
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
5 ,-,!). 5 5 !(%C(; E0 )0 "!2 (9+%-J" (!% $& !J E0 )0 "" 2")(:3 & !J