← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4447/2006allowed

Amandeep Singh v. Vijay Kumar And Others

2019-02-27Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan12 pages

 

     

 

  !

 

 

  !

"

 

  !



 #

  !

#

 $

   %&' '()*)+, 



- 

         ,  ./  010          !" #     $%&'

 (  )))) 102 3%4,   +    ,-,-.,,/    0       ( *   1 0

2 23

(* ($.,,*4.5,6.,,%.,7*4.5,6.,,% 0   0

   

  +     

  !

  *   $+  '

 (8" *90



 $:&,;:&6<-- 

  2 

23 0   $5%



                      5-,/.,,%  

=    +      >  

       ?

(   

@ 2

2

   + 2 

2

0 +!



  2

"A+ 

   (  0

 

  $  (=&,5:&.5;;  1 

   223B +09    + 0  



 

                      

  

  

=         +9 (

=    +   +       (

  =   C          (   +(

=  C  +  

+  =  C  D' $-/ 5-,/.,,%+

   

 +    5//    5<;;1 0

2 230

9

                    

 

0 *   

   



    +

             

  

       

* +  

 

   

+



   0   

 

,   (*($.,5*4.5,6.,,% +

0 0

9



+   5//          

=   -,'



+  ++9

 

8 (

  0  0   (     =     +      .5 ,5/4& *   +0 *  5 ,,,4&  

  

D E&   

 / ,,,4&++    E (  5 -, ,,,4&

+++         0  +

+  

+

+  0 

F<G

       /G 

     H     8         & + .5 ,5/4& 

'

 *E 7 <,,4&      0      0     

D =      (

      

      

 =        0

+   +  

      +     *          

  



 8           '

  +    

  +    

           0               *  +0  

       ++9

8

(   0+ 

   

  E  0  *     ( 

       &   

            

 

 !

"#$   

"%!&'

 (& & &  )(&( '  )*&  '

 +   &')



 &)

& )& ! '

&  &!(    !&   '&   &  '

&  )  & (&'& &((&( '    & ! '& )'& (&( '    ( ,-.!)&

'&/ &  &/&

)!

 &' 

!( +&&*'!

(&()

&'

&& (&( '     (  '

&  *0

' &  !

&  

!(  +& '

 (& &( 

 &&&'

& )&(&'& &(1    

 E+ .5 ,5/4&* +

    -,&/,       5-G        +>  54%

   &E      25%2   '

+     (

 

!

"#$" %& '#

 %

(!) * ++*   , ")-& .  !

"# $% /'$)/    5- ,,,4&    E     '

+ 0  

 &  &

%3&)(54%3* 65+&)+     

   .5 ,5/4& 5-GD % 5-.4& 0* .7 5/;4& 54%   E  ;

,-/4&  #  5/ 55.4& 

#  <% %774& 

   25%2

#2"2 D IE  #2

8 I #2

 *

#2"2   +    ,-,-.,,/   

 (*  ( $.,5*4.5,6.,,%    

       E          5 -, ,,,4&+0  

.- 7% 76.4&  +

  



 

,          (*  (  $ .,.*4.5,6.,,%+

0 0

9

   +   5// 

       '



+  +7;     + &+ * + -, ,,,4&J

    2   0 2 8                      * 

+

 0

     8           '

  +    

  +           

   =         + &+  + &

0

  *  

          0              *   9

 0      

   0

  9

  *    



'

     

      

      (

 %0 " 1 %%

 & 0" %0"2 %

2 .,5-!7" ((.%6

+ 

+   223 & 4 +&4&(   &(  &!)&/!

&(( &+

(& (!



5& )' &  & 

&)&( & 5& 6  (  &7&&( & '

5( &+   

&   & &  & '&  )  &   & 0)&    !+!&  #  

 (  &  ( &   &  & &  )*&(

  & &'

 &(&'

 +  (&+& )& &

&   !

+!&(' +& '

/ &(&   ) &8

&)&0 &95& ( &     

5  +  &  '!

'5  (  &    '

  &('& )&)!



( ' & '&

&(& &(+& &5&   +&&'&  !5&/  &!&'!'

!&!

)(&/&(&'22 =

  

+      

    .

7,,4&   

 0

    &E  0* (

'"-

3  %  

  &   23  3     433  % 

'$)/  & 22:  8)&  &  (&'      ;  <(2  ' & 

/    &  !'

& )&

&)& & &(''

( & &  &    !  '

&  )  &  

&)&    5&  +& 09/&  ) &(+&&+&&&&&

/ ) # :=&& )''(&& ! ((!&'  +& ! &( +    && 0

('

 

!(+&//!&( &  !

'

&

 >& &   ?

&   '

'&(& )

& (&* '&(/  / )&@ (& );<(2 ' &

/   ' && / &&

  & ')

 (&   !'

& )&

&)&   &  '

&+  &(&  !)

 & '& !&!!

&'

&  )&)!'& ' && &&

  & '

)

&(&  !'

& )&

&)& ''



)&  !)

 & '& '  !'!

(&  & & '!( &+ !

/& )

!!  ! +!  

'

 (& &( &&(&( '  )0

(

 )&   !'

&   

&(22

!

      +7;

        25%2      0    

     +      (

 & "%

&

%

56   '

+     (

'#

       5- ,,,4&      E     '

+    0    

    &  &

%3&)(54%3* 65+&)+     

   .

7,,4& 

#  .;

;,,4& 

   25%2 "22

D IE  #2

8 I #2

 * 2 2

  +    ,-,-.,,/   

 (*  ( $.,.*4.5,6.,,%    

       E          -, ,,,4&+0  

7 ,7 7,,4& "

 %+9#

,   +         (*  ( $.,%*4.5,6.,,%     .,7*4.5,6.,,%     0  

 0

 

                      +   .- .5     (       

"

0  + &  + 8       

   9  + + + #  + +  #

 $

,     (* ( $.,,*4.5,6.,,%   0   

 9

    

 

0 '+    +.%     =++9

*



9:

 #D( : 9#C



K&7 0               =   C      * (   '+    +

(   

    

         5-,/.,,%   .6,6.,,%'+   + 

0     +9

  '+      +

  .-,/.,,%=  

     

  0 * +  (% (7 (-

  0    *   +       % ,, ,,,4&  +

 .

,, ,,,4&   0  -, ,,,4&    E  

? 

 8                      0    0 0=  0

 +    D            +     

   

# 0 (

+0  * 

K&7





  

 

0  K E

 

       09        



  

   *   0 0    0 &       

     

    0             

+0  

+

 

*   ( 

   !

   $%  &  0  4 %%

 *  & 

&' 

)&8' '

& / ( &' " )&A&8' '

)& ( '

&  & + !

 (& & & & & +&&*& ' &(' & & &&'!''!& & & ) 6 &+ &+'5

(  +&@ (&(&&  / ! )

& & )& & ' & )(&) !'+&/ &(+ & + !'&&( '

&  +&&&*& ' &(+& + !     (  /!&  & &     &  

  ) '

/&   +& (&(/ '

! &()

 / '

!  (&  & &      '

/&  )

&

/&' & &'&&  )

 (&) !    /&  )  '

/&    A

&*/ & 

/!&(/ &   & ('+&'

!!&(

)

&' 

)&8'

&' " )&&8'

 '( &' & ()

&

/&' &&'&&

)& & )

(&) !/& )&'

/&   && & & /+!&& &   !!

  / 

)/&!'   

!&  &((/ & '

+&(6  & &)

&( &'&(& & )& &   (&(+ &B

 !!!

&+&//!'+!&!!/&

& / ! )

& & )& & +&&)

'&( && ( &'&(+& + ! '

0      0+

+ 



  

565  *  (

" %

& 7 '   )%/ /    % 8 /& &' " )&C

&'!& 8'  =%% & &)& &)&

&(    28'2  & &  & '!)

'

/&  (& (& &' !!

&( +& !  + !& + !( &' ((  &

 )'

/&   /!&& &  !!!

+&/(  ' & )

 '(& & !& &(& )5'! = 6 

    

  

!! ""#

  $  %&  

    &!(    & /

    &?

&/& )& & (( 

'

/&    !

&(  (&& &(  3 &  

  & &*/ &  1  &((  !( & + !

'

 (& &?

&   )& &  &/ &!( &

& ( &)' (' '

 '&  )&' &6  '!& !&!(& ((&'  &/

 

)/& )& &  ( '

&  (  ( ' +&+

(+

!& 

 6& &  '

/&  )

)

+& '&

(&&  ) &'

  &+&&/(  &  '!  A &  )  & &     )*&(  (& &' " )&8'(&(  +&&+&  &(

/ &'

 (&& & ' & )& & 1 

+ + + 0  ( 0 92 

         +                  

+

F6-G

   

     H     :10;

 

'<35%3= 2

-  /5@+&@