← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/242/2007dismissed

(O&M) Nidhi Goyal v. Vinod Goyal

2015-05-07Bench- 4,Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik16 pages

 

     

   !

"

#" $# %& '

"""""(('' ) "

) & '

"""""* (   

 

  



 

 

 

  "*+,- 

((''"

 "). /',0 "- 1  "0+0 ,- 

  ( "

22222  

 ((''1% ' (('  +(    + "

"

,  

"0-0 +,  '   3  ,.

',1 ,-

( ' ) 1 (+

 1 (  1  '-  -





'"

/     '. 4(  1 +



5"

6"$775   "8+

 1  +('+

 1  ' ++" 1- , '1 

 1'

." (

 (  ,+ . 1++' +

  ((''1   

+  -( "9 

+  ((''1,+'  1   

+ 

   

+

 1    +

+&" (  (  ,

    ((''11   '

 + 

+ +

 "1 ''     ((''1 

'  

+":-

   (   - ;

' '  1 " +  

. ' <

.  

1

  "0 '

1 ; +  '-   " 

.( '

1 1 

    (  ,  1    1

" 

    ((''1-   . 1 + 

' . "

++   ,     

  



+  ,1  -   + .  1   

++'

 1    +

+ &"1 -



+& & 

   

-'   +<   ((''1"

1 

-

((''1''  

( ( 

 '-    (  ,1-  - +"0 (' ' 1

'  

 '1

."

0 '

1 (      +'++      '-   +' "= 

(' +(' 

-

((''1  (  

<>+  ,  9   (   ((''1, 1   

"+, .1'' -'

'  '

   

+ "  8   (       9  

 1

+ (  + " .    & 

  +    -

   "   >"5"

>,  ?  @   1  -"       ((''1  - 

   +'++ ((''1 1 +('' "."

+    

'1'' '

+ + ' +" 

, .(('' 1  

 ,  ,1  

+ +   +(    ' '1 ?@- (

 +'.    -+

"01 . & '

 (',0

6,.

',1 

' '+   1   

+(  - '   "'

+  (     ' ',-   ( 

9    (   

"8 - 

, 1 +& ' (',0

6.

' 6"

#"

" - , (  -   (' .  + 1

'.  ((''  ('" , 9  ,    

" 1- , ;,1+.  (',1 

(   . 1  

((''1    

+ ('

. 

1



+ +"0, ((''1    1 (  " A  -+ 

+ ,1 (' '    +''   ((    +      '-11   1,  + ( '

  , ,    '" '

''     '

    ((''1+ +

 , +  +'"B ',('   

  

' ((''1,( 

-

1   "

 ((''1       ( "  0     ''   " 1- , + +

 1 +" 1 +

 1  +(' " ,' 

 1    ( ' '

3"/ +' .1    "  /     (   +      -

 +'   1 9 +' 1 " ,((

 (  +  3 $775

+

   

  

""(  C D1 "   1      (    +

  

'. (' 

#   11  '' $ 3 ',$775,  +

 1  '  5"

6"$775" (    (    ,+

  + 1  ' '



)1,0

$ ,   41 ( +(  1, +

 1 ' " 

  ((''1 + +

 , 1    /"$& - +

'' 

& ' ,0

$$   "89       +

+& 

  +

           "    1  (''       

 

+  "0 ( '

+'"01 1

.     '



+(1    "0 ' -' - ' - "0 



."/ 

+-   + ('  

       1  

+(' 



 '  +

 " 1- , 1 +

 , '    (+.

  '"    9    ,    -  - -  (' "   1- ,   -

  1       '- 

  , 1  +

 +   '   "8 +((''1(  

1  

+ &,   "0- 

. ' 

8")"0"*    .   , ;('  -  "      -   +'(' 1  -   1 .(,

(( 1

. ( "1

('  1''1  +   ' . "

0- -   

  ++ "1 ('

   ,1  1 

  

 ; + "

=      ' 1 ''

1 + "   , + -1 

 +'++ "0  - 

 '

1  (     

 +' ++ "''

+  '  + + ' +"1 ('  1-  ( +   . 1  "

8 1  9   

, '' "1 ('' -     ' '"   1  +-, 

, -1

  & ' (',0

6,.

',+    '  (

"=, ( , +1    &, 1 1  

 0

6 (',.

'"+ 

+   

  1 1

 1 

(   ', 

 '    +    -  

(

"01 . (' 6"

#"

, 6 ,( 1 '"=(   ((''1+ . 1

  + (' ,

((''1.

+"8++(   .  + + ' +   +(    ''"1 

(' -   +  1 

'   -    , +  -   % '0-  +

  * " ,

<'

+ 1 1* "$,>#,

<

+  - 

'   % '/.,0

$,.

'"/   '   ,         1 1    

   +

"  A   

+   + ' ( 1 1 ( "



+('  (  , ''

1   1  +! 





     



  

  



  

 



  

     

  

 

!    . 

' 1'' 

+ -   (       ,-

(     ) 1 (  -

1   -

 ( 

'"

=  -      "  *+  ,  - ,  

  (('' "). /',0 "- 

  (   ((    + '- + 

"

8+

 1-

'+   

'"  , (' 

 +'''

((''1,  +' ") C=D  - -:;"/     +  ( "0

( ,   - '

  -(   + '

+  -"8  '+'- '    '  ((''1 ( 0E ( "

0   

++'



 .    -

 '((   +   ,'- 11, '1

'  "

 ',1 

' 

 '

    1       

+   - (   -  

  +

 "8 1 - ' +(   (('' 1 

+ +

 "% ' , -

 ( + - ;

' '  1 "  ,((''1   +'

'  "

 ,1 

' 

 '

 ((''1(

+

 , 1   

+ . +'

 ":' 

 ,1   ((''F  '

3"/ +' 1 . 1  "/  (  + -

+'   " .    C

 D 

+ + ' '   ((''11 ) ,(   ((''1   +

  1 ' 1 ( +(  1"8((''11    /"$& - +

'' 

& ' ,0

$$   "0'

  - ' 1

.     '



+(":- +

   -

('  

    " ''      1 1 -  (

'+

+

 "8  ,1 +

 ,((''1'     (+.    '"   

      11  +,  -- - (' "

 1- , ++       ' 

    ' 1 +

 +   '  "8 1

   '+((''1 (  '  

 1 (  -  

+&,

  "8  (

 '

((''1,  ' ,1   (    +''' " 

+ -

+  ' 

 '

(('' 1, -1 +

 ,((''1'    (+.    '111

. 1  

 +, -- - (' "8       

 ''  1, 1  ( + - . 1      "(( ',11      ,  -- - (' "

'--'' '""



+& 1''  + 

0"

.

 C=>D, '   '     ((''1  1    

+  0E (  (

    +

 "

"0"

.

 C=>D(

-(

( 

 '

 ((''1, :;"5"%   

5"

$"$777 1 ='. '

+, ( +   ,&:*, 1 

 ''  ((''1 6+   $ " -  '

+, 

  + " "

 +  6 +    -"   ((''16+   ' 5"

$"$777,

 1

'-'' '

+ ""

'

+ "#,  

 6+   $ "

 8+

  (  

.(' 5"

6"$775"8 , 5"

$"$777,   ((''1 +  6+   $  ', - 1   

+   (

 +

        (  '

      ((''1"

"0"

.

 C=>D, -(  

 ( :;"5"=

  

 (1 .

, + 1 (  " '

+ 

+(   +  + " (   

,

++ 1(('' 11 +

''  (

'+   '' '

,

' +;

1

 '' 1

'.  

  +      '' "1 

(

 1 +  +''$7751G 1 +

  + 411   +   +

 1   0 " +

 ,(1

' ''

1 

 "=;('+'++ ,     F - +

 1  ++

' 

$# H"8 

    1+'  +

((''11 1  '' 

++ +

  $#   

'

 "8 ((''1,-

' ''  +

"0  ' ' 1 

<> 16+    +

 

8

 (.  +'  ((''1" + 



"0"

.

 C=>D((''1   1

' (  

 

   "0'

 ((''   ' 

+  + - 

"8+ ((''

'

  ((''

'  '  -

1 1 

  ( ' +

+ ('

 ,     1''"''     1(('' +'++ 1 1''1 +'  ((''     . +, ((''

'  ' 

+  

   

":- (

:;"5  1 1' - +' 

 (, +     1    /"

+$ ,    

 ((

1 "01

' +.

("B.1 ,



,1 +  '

 (,+. "0C((''D  "+ + 1   

     : ' + + 

' (('''

 '  + 1  

   "8  + .

 -

 :;"5"% ' -,- 

"0"

.

 C=>D,1  

+&,   ,+ ' (

:;"5(  

 +' ((''1    ! # $

  

%&    

 



    

      

'

 '

 (   

  

)* +

)* !, -'

.'

/ '

  '

* 

'

  

  0

)* !1 -'

.'

" 

 '

 

2

)* , -'

/ 3   '

  

4 

  5

   

/ 

)* 6 -'

&7  '

 '

8 

   5

 &  



   

  

 9:

*;'

  





   

)*

 



    

 '

   



  <4   

'

:

 :  

          5   

   5 

 



5  $





 

         

 

'

   

'

 

  '

  





   

 '

  

    

  

  

 

    

       

       

     

     



 



    

  

 

2&=  

'

   5 



5



  

> /5  ":)*   

   !

'



 

 

 '

    



      

    

    

  

 '

  

 

  

  



  



'

       5

 

  

     

  

 



   

< 

    

'



   5    

   5

'



   

 



       

  



 



#

    5  

 



      

 



'

      9

   ?

 

   "  2 

      '



       



  

: 

     

  5

   



 

    



3 

#

 



 0 ,;



 

 

    

?

 

     +  





 

 2 <





    

  



:  

  

 

 



@       

 6 



    

  

 '

 

 

 

    

  "



    

      

'



 

5



 





    

( 

  8

   5 

 

'

  

(   ?

#

  >

 

(    

> 

 



  5

   

* A 

A!

 '



   







"

 

  

      5'





    $ B      

'





   

5     

  



 

   





 

  



 >

" 0

C=$D,' ,& ' (', 0

6,  .

',      

 1       ((''"   (  #"

"

,  ((''

 

 "( -    "

(   (

   .$  .

6"8 +1  -  ("

(     ,+  

 -  1( '+"8  - '  '

+1     

"    + +-     "8  ,((''

 - +

 ''

1 ( +" 6"

#"

, 1   

   (' (

  (

 +'.  ''.  ++  "0 +  ( ('1 - +"01 + (' ' ,  9     

 1     

+     ('"  8  

       ((''  

 

+0E ( ":- ( :;"5,&

'

       (    0E ( "    (

-    (      :;"$, + 

:;"( (  '( :;"> 6" 8 

+ +  

 1'' +'

--'' ',  '  '((''  ( 0E (    

++'

 "

 ,' 

 '

((''   ( 0 $>C$DCD  

 ,-

 '   (

 

'

+

 

  

'

 +'

++'

 .  ;(     ' ;(    '-  1    1"  :;('   FF      

+  (

-    '1 (. 

  1 G+'

 H" 

     +'  

  +  +'  '' ,  

  

  +(' -'

(+    +,  (  (  



    



 ' +'

 0E ( ":;(' F/F (. 

  ;(     G(  (  

 H  +    (    



 ' +C1

 '

  

+'

'' D 1 ' 

+''  -

 

'

 (  '  (  ( ,1

  9  

  ('

+' +"

  1  

  -





'""  0 $>C$DCD

 0 $>C$DCD4 - '   (('' 

  +''' "8  +

 (('' 

 

++'

 .  ;(   '-1((''"

 1 

' 

 '

 ((''=$=> 

( 

 



;+       0E (   (  .  (

( + ,'-

+''"=>( (1 0E ( ;  (   

+'



+'-

"  ,''  -  - (  ' '

+''"/

1 

+''  ''( '"8''  ((''C%& 'D   '"



   +""



    

1   0E (   ',+ '  ,1( ( 1(    "0E (    

  "

 

''

"

 

   +   !" #$ % !" &'1  +'

(

   1 +(

-++'9 ' ('

; 

+'9 +  '  (    ( '

(

 +'

  0 $>C$DCD 



 " 

-      -    

'    1''  +'

-,  ((''%,   '  ((     *=$"    

 ;+ , +  .  +

+&

 ''  $777"0

  .  ' $ + "

"0

( 1-   (  ,    ' 1 + "0

''    

+   (" 8 ,    +    +'  '' "  % 

   (   %((  1  ((

  -((''  

 ;+

1

' +(  -

    '' "

"0"

.

 C=>D,1  



+ &,  -.

,+' 

 

 ( ' ++ "8 

  -+( '- "  

+- (   

   '0 "$5"

>"$777,  

 -

1     11  ' + ( ', ) + I

+3"  

, +  1    +

":-"J1  -  5$"=>(  '' 1 '

1-  "8       -((''  (  





# 

+

""+;+ ++41  -   



 '1

.41  (( + '-     4

 '.  '



+4

.( '  

''4+ + 

. ' <

.  

4+ 8")" 1



 4   . 1 +  ' .     +1'(  '

4  ' 

 '1

.4+(    ' '1 1FF4(

 +'.       -  +

    -  +   +

  '  -   -    

0

6, (',.

',1  1   .FF1 1:;"$":-' 

 -  

' '( '' 11((''

     1  ,1

' '+. '-   1

+( ' 1

''1 - 

 ' 1'' ' ((''1  +  +



1 '"    , 

   ( )( #%" %(  !"

!

 

% % * # ( %+  !"

!

 ,,' '' ((

    ;((''1  

'  

1 '   -

"



     

   -,      +      ((', 

   + "

 ( ( 

 '"

  

 



 

 

!"!#$!%# &'()(