High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/28701/2023allowed

Sushil Kumar Singla v. State Of Ut Chandigar

2024-09-24Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil11 pages

!

!"#$%&%$

' ()*% + *+ ** ) ****

!"#

$ !

!

+,#!

-".!/ 01 % %&'

()* + ,- ./)0 &/&**1&2 (*13(4&3(5)3(4&-%# *1&6&*17- ' # # &4

# &4/ &(1**1*/%!

8 /'

&/1(*1*/%!

8 (' 9

# + #

%*' # 9 #

:"

;8# 6 <# !

$3 !"

= 3!

> #

"

#9 # =

?!#*1&4 ?*1&4

-?!#*1&4!

# ?

=

9 @> A #

B;8#

- # = &(1*&2

*01&&2 = #"> = . &51 C

# =" #

>$

8 >

# > = =

- 2 - *& 5) 2* 25/37

9 = 8 ?" >$ + > !

: + > 9#

8 &&1)*1&1 => # # %/' $ " # #

# ! =

9 8# 1)15*1&) =9

>

!

A # 9# 9 = = ?-. . = -9

?

: + > 9# 9 9 A

9 3!

>

A

# >#

, !

9 3!

>99A 9 -9

! + > # 9 !

3!

>6 %(' D

# #

##

!##

9 #

,- "

8 =>

!

9 9 > = #A >

*1&2

>

9

:

> #

" 9" 14&**1** 9 >

-= 9 !

#

>

> 9

" #

# #>9 # #

%0'

,- #" > 8

> # = ?!#

- 3 - ?!#

#

,-= 9 # !# " #

>

- #?!#

?!#

# 9#9 "

-

# = ="7 # # >

7 #

#

9# 8"

%5'

" ># # &/*? !#99 #

7# =

= =8# #

=7# %0'# &/* !#

# &/*%5' !# = = = # #

## , "

# (60

# # 9 A ?

? !#

# # = 9 "

"

="

-

-

# = #

!!

%4' <

!

= #A

?9

?"

>=>

A79 >= ## # 9

9 39 >

=

# = #A

#

# 9 = #

> " #

#7 ###

= " #7 ##

> C E #A> ,D

- 4 - %)'

!

9# # F

A

78 3!

#"

A A79 >= 9 #

"

"

>9 9 = # = # "#

#7 ###A>C

"

# #

>" #

> + >

9 9 #7

## # 9 A

= = = "#

#

# - 8 $

9 ># "

> # 8 "#9 = 9

# - %2' !

=>

! "

3!

9 8

> &&/ #

>

## ,- .&11 1*14*1*& (*13(543(5)3(4&3&*17 -

# # &4

= " $ #

;

# "

3!

9 #

D! *11* %&1' !

G# - 9 >

# = # ! = : " # $

%&

'

& ()*) +*# /110*1&29 9 =

- 5 - ? 99#9 " - # ?

?!#

>

"

= # =>

# # =

# = # !8 # ,,-&

.+*) + + # # # # "9 = A > 9 # # # > # > %&&'

#

# %&*' ! > &4/ " #> = == #

>" #

>" #9##

= " 9#

A => > ,D " = =

# 9 %&/' -

= 9

A

= # # F=> 9 " #

=>

>< >=# #7 ##

#

# #> "" #

= # ## # #

=

=> # " # 9#

>

# 9

"" %&(' !

#9##

= "# 9# #> "

89#

- 6 - ,- !

3!=

3!

=> = A

?!# ?!#

-?!#=>

# %&0' ! = # 3# ? !# *1&4 +

# => =

# " => !#. 7#

#9 #

>

3

# --- "" # 4&&?!# " ">

## 8H " "

8 # H - = = %' "

? 9H -- " 8 "# =

# H ---= = %'

=A ## H -I =

= %' # #

H I = = %' > 8

" = #3## 8 #

9 "

. 7#

#9

>#

> "> 3

>

= %&5' I-I %# &**7&/)'? !# *1&4 9&5*? "

#

> 3

"# 9

-

?

"# 8!# *1&4 I-I? !# *1&4 # F = # 7%&'-

# A

# "#H%*' 8"

7 > H%/',

>

- 7 - "#H%(' #

# &***&## =

> #

> > 3 "#

3 > 8 # " &**%*'H

>

= # # &**%/'

"

?

> # 9#

> " !# 3

> 9# = # = &*0 ?!# %&4' +

9 ,- #

= 9 ? ""

#"

=" -

J %&)' - /

01 2 34./+*52

((++ = !8# 9 9 # # *& **

#

%$"

'!# &204%

$!#'

=

9 = #

9 /42 -J !8 #

#

# 9#

$!#8#=> ## # ##

= > # #=> # # 9"

# #9##

# -

$!#

9 > # =>-

# # #

= # - 9 9 9 #

$!# %&2' - #

6 ,, ./+*2

!)5 !8 =

> 9

!##

!#

- 8 - &2(2 - # 9

!##

8

= 9 =

G -

!## > = - 8 $

#

>

8!# = 9

> "

= # #

# # + = =>

!##

=>

=>

!##

9 ## > #

#

9

# (&2 (5) (4&

(4* - # => " # /24 !

C

# # 9 # #9

#

#

# (&2 (5) (4&

(4/ - 9# *(

*5!!#!

#

9 =

> #

-

# F

# # # *(

*5!!##

= A =# # = => #=

9

# * ( 0

# &20%&' = # #

9 #

#

"9# #

# !!# " # *( *(!

*5 !# #

= # -K

>#

9 # #

: 9

7

- 9 -

!" " ! " ! !!

! "

# ! !

$

%

& '$

" ! !

()( *++++++++++++

# ! , -)( ! !" " ! $./$0/0/0()( ! # $.()( 1 " + ! ! " ! -! #+ 2!

3")##+$.. ! " ! ! * $./%0()(

4 ! " " ( $. *

- 10 - %*1' - # 7 1 -,

"

0 1 +*( !* # 9 - # 9#

A # F

# $ # #

> # = # *2*

*2(-

# 54- !# - 9 # = #A 9 "9 # 54 9# 54!

54-!#9 # #

# *2*-#

= "A %*&' !# ="## 99 > # # # = ? !#3? !# 9#

#

#

"9 # #

# I-I ? !# 9# #

> " #

" &** 6 &/* !# #

= #

-# > "9 # ,- =

> = A #" > 8 => 8

> # #

? = # #

-

=:# # 9

= :

> !

# *1%*' - ,

7#

#

> # &/*%5'?!# "

#

= A

- 11 - %**' - "9 ="# 9

,- ./)0 &/&**1&2 (*13(543(5)3(4& - %# *1& 6 &*17 - ' # &4

# &4/ &(1**1*/%!

8 /'

&/1(*1*/ %!

8 (' 9 # + #

+ $%&%$ +,#!

-".!/ 0

.!/

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No