Alok Shandiliya And Another v. Devender Bhardwaj
*+, -./0 !1
%2* -./0 31
4-5,6,5 * 8** +,5,9:
*., ( ;<(
- =
* > ( (*5-1,+2%5.*
( =/=/(1,+2%5*.,
=
1
2/2/. !!
%
!3,* ?+, 5,9:+ 4-5,6,5*@159.*5+0 2+2,,-2! A%5B0*/*21!AA! &5%%,*C5 2D)1+,:,B/,, "
!# .**,06,,2(B*!***1B/ 8,*. ,,,
!#105%5/9*2,,B*/. /.*/%.,%!/525 ,,5*/156 9*,,.6,0%525F/52/. *2/.*5/
/ .. "
%
!# %, 06 5 .* B*5%*,2+2,*25*0,*/**,065 %,,,-***,B1B/1+,:,B/ ,, "
#
!"
B*5%*,22%,B*%2+2, *215*+*5*0%, 52,9*2,
5*/5*0.*, +,2%*1.**50%, *.5**0%5
22,B 5 2/.>+, 5,9: &9 *.,)1 5 9 22*,1 /61 4 -5,6 , -505 -5,6&.*5)B*26*+25/ ,*6% <E-26-+2* </, /.9* /.6 95 5 22*, 9* B, 5 22*, 5, **, ₹ 25F*
"
"$E%/% "1EE G>, "
"# %/ ₹ % !
1#E#G>105,,
!3,9H*41-2$31 B/1 9,* 5 9B*1 5 2/. 9+1 .*105525F*9,*.,955/4* ?.6/*..,065,9@1 +,04//,, $
!3
/.*B2,,
!35B5B*,.* *4B522*,.6525F/95!$,6*%/5 ,%2.%52 9*B,555*29* 2+,024*,+,*.,,,5*122*,%, /4.6/%525F/*12/.B52/. ..25506%B52/. #
!3
$
% 2,B ./6 +,21 9 22*, 9 *//,%2.*2,-2! A%5 21+, ,,,!
#
!3 ..21522*,9*+,2 %22*,-2! A%5 21952556.,, B6,2/, /...,*I!.+5 B* #
5*.2+*/*2,,,-2 !
15922*,45*/*,5%%2525F* 9**,065/9,**6%52/.10%**2
%E.B*
%5*/1562/4905%,2//,065 2/.9552/.61*/25*52/.9*%, 094B52/.6,BB*6%/55 2/.6195*+B52/.6%522*,,5*956 5 .6/ % 5 25F* 9* *.., , 5 9* B B*,B*52/.12.6%95259*H
56* ,.%**,0652/.6*H !
5 922*,%5,/,5+2+,B206*B5 565,.,5*/!$
!3,2.6%5.6* H ># 5,%215922*,.,2,99***
"
%5B055*,*,.*B5+,2 2,1,9*2+2,955,%2.,, 06522*,,2+2,05%5/*.,*B+
..B*5*,2+2,*25*0,*/**,
*2,,06,2*%5.*5 055*%,..25,%2.,,0622*,> .*195259*9.+,2,1*/25*5.6/ %525F*9**..,065.*22%5%, 5+B02//,0652/. 52/.*, ,*0*5*6%B,*%52/.6 ,5*606 %BB*B*%*/%5B,* *,*12/.,, 22%5/B+5/%5.25*%*5*%5 B,* 65*159*%,5+0/.6,5 2/.61/61-464-2* *2+/01
! , 22%5*%2*1 #,,!3
!$5,0 B*,B*52/. 2--2!"G!A1, -2*3 #13
13#"13#A,3"!%
%E.B*
<, 2* % 5 .* * ,9 9,*52**>H/%I!>2/.+,5,9:1 955,/,5 B*5/,555,02, F6 22*,,,5+*+,-464-2* 10 ,/,5H !9***,065*,2/.6 <,2*% 5.*5*%5,99,**/6%I! -,,+195*5
&,)%-464-2*
,95*%,552/.5,:,52/.6* .(B%/+/01
! ,95*.+,5 *6*.*H > >$ *2,,5*,,%25,0 406522*,5+6%*..619556.,5 B206*,BH
># ,*,99,*5 %2 55 5 2/. 5* */61 2/. %,05.6,,!$
!3&H
#)5B21 95259**06522*,15B52/.5/*%.2,5 *,.62,
I550+*0/***1.6*/,%*B *,5/.B,:,B/%2+2,,%*206 22.B5.*.
!!
%B5%*,2*1*B,06, 2*%5*.,>2/.55B,*%-2 ! A%5 2,6%%,1*/25*.*,, ,*. 5 *B* 5 25F* F* 5 5 *, 25F*5,0**,%/522,55*/9**, 9,*9B*%52/.,2**15*.*/. ,-2! E%5 2B,BB,%2006 ,5.*>22*,%,05*,.*/. <,
3%E.B*
2*,%,,5/.B,:,B/%2+2,,% *2,.6,%,*/**%5.*+*.
5+2*,,*0/***%055*,*,5+ .*,52,2%6
*,*.52/.>*.,*,0 5/.6% <E-26-+2* 19,0659 .*>22*, **,*.55925F*9 **,06522*,9,*9B*%52/.,055 25F*.*5+0,*5,22%5%2 5.6/5%9**..,065,9 !3
9+1 5 5 2/. 5* %%,+ H I!G12/.,*2*,*5.,%59B*% 9525525F*F*9**, *>22*,5+ ,*.,5562+,5B2,,
!3&H
>3)
9+1*5*.2%2*,%522*,5565,*.6 ,,!$
!35*,B219525*+05 2,*H
>#
!$
*B615B552/.5%,5* 2/.05*,.6,,!$
!35+02+,06 5/ %/ 5 22*, %, 0 5 */ 5* %%,+ H
I!G#10*5,%5*,.* $
$
!35 2/.5/*%.2,2,*H
>#
!#
5%*,.6H
>#,*2**52*,406 522*,15+.%9525**, > ?!
565+94,52/.6%/6%%2, *,/,%2,565+,9*6%/5 */10*./5569B+ *.*06%/BB2*5 ,*.
$%E.B*
%6*.*0665+,*0*9B**25 /5,/B,6,6%%*%5***
5%.,%B* !
!3169B+ 2*5%,*0*/%9B**%%%,1%9525 6 5+ 22, % , / % $!AA#G>,/62*1B9569* /% *
#!!G>196>95*,*H5,,, + % .25* % *5* % 5 B,*1 9525 5, 5 0 22, % 5 *5* ,*0, B,*
5 ** % %/* 95 2* % ..H/6 * 92*5,04066 5* 5,22,%066,
5/62*5+2+,92/.*%/# /.6**%9B*61B,B2+B% 5/569B*,565+/*...,5 /%5*695259*B+606/62 ,565+%B,5*B**6*5, ,,5/%B,**6/62* 2+,065/
$ 5**./5565+ 02/B%%2B61+*B/62 ,*2+,565+:,52/.6 !* 20
5*/165+025B/6 21*6994B%9/.6*5*/ /1*2/%%2,5%2/B49 050+*,%2//62*5+6 *..,5.6/%625F*1*60 %5*/
.6 9* HHHHHHHH
55*.%2*,22H10 *./5565+:,5 2/.6 !
! , 5D* 956 /6 2 5+ *..,5.6/%0+*,25F*1%2/B 49 0 6 B 0*2 5 %%2 ,B
#%E.B*
+/0,2/01
! 1*5//62* 9+B,5*%2%60*29*5 49,B%/62*,,+6565+**, 525F%5*6%+'21
! %95256 0@ !"
5*1*.5.65B2*06522*,1 525F*9**,%5*6%2/.%5.,% +/0,2/01
5,0B,52/.5, ₹ 22,%,/% $!1AA#G>9,*9B*% ₹ 5*%%B+5/%,*0*/5,22,%
1#!!G> B+5/%.25*%*5*%5B,*5,22,% ₹
**%%/*2*B%..H/6 2* .%/5*1 5,0B,52/.9*%,094B955 2/.6*2 !
!A
5 * 0*6 5B 2, *59 5 2/.+*.,,50+*,.6%5B2 %5B*2,5B*5/
!E
B5*2**>H/1I!2/.+, 5,9:5B56,,5*.5*:0.%15*, ,*0*5*6%5*%%10,/,5292155, ,*0,5*6%5*%% ,/,,BB%5 H
B* 5/ , 5 5 5, :, 5 F6 2,2, 06 5 2/2 %%2*IB 5B515,/,5+2+,5 ../H !%/-464-2* 10*, 55,,22.5%% %6,,5+94,% -464-2* *,,5++2+,6 .6/
! %/-464-2*
5*/6%52/.50+%%2*
"%E.B*
%*%,065*9*,2/6+,2.,2,065 22*,>.* I!>-, ,+ * 5 / *2* &,)%-464-2* 1956.+,5% &H !) **, 06 5* 2/.6 5 2/. +, 5,9:10%5*%,5*,+,5,9:5,:, 5*2/.6+/01
! *% *.+,2,5 *6*.*H $ B2**>H/1I!,*2*,5 2/.5,2*6,:05*2/.6+*2!* +/01
! ,,B5/159**+B65 2/.6 I -.9*5+*BB %%2%5 # ,,!3
! &H )B*,B*52/.,*%, 5*.5+*B2,2,065/12/.5,%B, 52.*%*6%2B,*B,B,*0*/%5 *6,5,/0JJ,5/ .+,2,5*/ %%*25B,*(4
5*/6%I!-,,+15%%2%5 -464-2* <,10,95*6*.*H $ .+06,,05*.,>2/.9**+B5 *,-464-2* +*2+/01
*.5 ,%2.,,06522*,1525F*F*5,0**, %5*6%52/.%5.,+/0,2/01
! ,*%2/B4905%252/.9* *+B52/.6,9*0*B%/52/.6%5 22*,>.*55.6/%525F*9**..,
+9%5+95/B+,2.,2,2,06 522*,>.*152+25.%5, .5,B%5*/065..*0*6:*%,
A%E.B*
,01.*/.,-2! E%5 29*+0 %+% 52/. 2 5*B* 5 25F* 9 ,/,,5525F*9**,%B,%20 ,00610522*,>.*9:*%,52 %*..B5.6/1*/25*525F*9**,9,* *6 % 5 .,1 % 9525 5 2/. ,, *+ 5 2/.6%522*,>.*,51*+,52/.6 -464-2* *,*12/.9*%,5+ /0JJ,5/.60%5*6%5B,*B,B 9525 H 9*,B,B*5/
+9%5,*2***0+15/.B, :,B/%2+2,,%*2*2,,065* 09**, 5.**,2F,%525B* 5 ₹ .*+*.*5069, 5/%
G>., 065.*5*.,>2/.5B55*2*1* %2,5,,,
!"%5*21*,2,0 %,,065*.,>2/.5.*95!$,6* %/,6 -./0 31
& =
) * I55*,G*.4B *G I55.0 *G
E%E.B*