← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10365/2014dismissed

Ram Partap & ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2017-01-10Mr. Justice Arun Monga6 pages

   

            !" #$% &

' #( ) !* !(+,# - ,(.(.!,#/ 0,#/"/

( (, #$ !  !*(+,#/ - ,/)!*,!(/  12 341 

1 4

#,/,!( 1# "# 01+"!( %*05 (,#(+,),(.(.!,#/ 1#6+ !! %**7% #$ !  1#/+89,#' %*05 (,##,/)!*,!(/ (& 1 4% +, ),(.(.!,#/ + 0, ))# 5+,* (+./ "#( :$ .!08.!;(+,)#0./.!/#(.57,

<

&(+,!/(.("(.! #=" /+.!;(+,#*,#* (,* % ) //,* :$ #,/)!*,!(  "),#.!(,!*,!(  ! 7 .5,# 0.*,@+.5+#*,#* (,* >&%!!,?"#,  %) //,*:$ #,/)!*,!( 2.0./.! 7  ! 7 .5,# @+,#,:$ (+, @ (,#5"#/,  / !5(.!,* #' ).!(   @ / /,( /.*, !*'*..,*@ (,#5"#/, /+ *:,,!/ !5(.!,*

2 1# "# 01+"!( %7, #!,*5"!/,7 )), #.!;# (+,),(.(.!,#//":'.(/(+ (.!)"#/" !5,((+, ))7.5 (.!% + 0.!;:,,!/":'.((,*(#,/)!*,!(2.0./.! 7 ! 7 .5,# # 7.;!',!(  (+, @ (,#5"#/,% (+, / ', @ / +, #* !*"7(.' (,7$0.*,#*,#* (,* >&%!!,?"#,

 % (+, @ (,#5"#/,   @ / / !5(.!,*  ,,7.!; ;;#.,0,*  (+, / ',%  (+" '2)#,*,5,//#2.!2.!(,#,/(  #,/)!*,!( / ( & 5+ 77,!;,* (+, / ', !* (+, #,/)!*,!(  "),#.!(,!*,!(  ! 7 .5,# 0.*, #*,# * (,* %'*..,*(+,@ (,#5"#/, /+, #,',!(.!,**,5./.!@ /5+ 77,!;,*:$ .7.!;  5.0.7 /".(  +, / ', @ / *,5#,,* :$ (+, A"*;',!( !**,5#,,* (,* >&>%!!,?"#,  +, )), 7% ( (+, .!/( !5,  )#.0 (, #,/)!*,!(/% @ / 7/ *./'.//,* @,0,#%.!#,;"7 #/,5!* )), 7:, #.!;>B% &%.!(,#.')#(,5(.!/( ("/="@ /;# !(,* +, / .* )), 7 @ / 77@,* 0.*, A"*;',!( * (,*  % !!,?"#, % :$ +7*.!; (+ ( (+, .0.7 "#( *.* !( + 0, (+, A"#./*.5(.!  ! (+./ : 58;#"!*% (+, )#,/,!( @#.( ),(.(.!

 + / :,,! .7,*  :$ 5+ 77,!;.!; (+, / !5(.!,*  #*,# 5 !!( :, / .* ( :, +.( :$ (+, *5(#.!, 8.! ( C,7 $ !* 4 5+,/D  , /":'.(/ (+ ( *"#.!; (+, ),!*,!5$  @#.( ),(.(.!% (+, ),(.(.!,#/ #, .##.; (.!; (+, /".(7 !*!(+, #,',!(.!,* 7.;!',!( !*(+,/5+7.!

22  (+,! ',+ "*+ #$+ ;+ !*1,,7*"5 (.! 5.,($% .7. (,* ( (+,  #$ !  5+7 *"5 (.!  #*% ./ :,.!; #"!  , "#(+,# /":'.(/ (+ ( (+, #*,# "!*,# 5+ 77,!;, ./ !( /"/( .! :7, /  #,/)!*,!(/  ( & + 0, !( :,,! /,#."/7$ ,5(,*  !* (+, ),(.(.!,#/ #, .##.; (.!; (+,.# @! 7 !* $ 0.#(",  ,7"?  (.',% (+, #*,# * (,*

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

% (+,#,#,% ! ,=".($  7.,/ .!  0"#(+,),(.(.!,#/  + 0, +, #* 7, #!,* 5"!/,7 # (+, ) #(.,/ !* '  (+, 0.,@ (+ ( (+,#, ./ ! #5, .! (+, #;"',!(/  7, #!,*5"!/,7#(+,),(.(.!,#/ / !(.5,* :0,% (+, A"*;',!(/ !*  *,5#,,  (+,"#(/:,7@@,#,"7(.' (,7$/,( /.*,0.*,*,5#,,* (,*  % !!,?"#, &  ; .! !(+,# #"!*  7.(.; (.!% .,%  (+, )#,/,!(  @#.( ),(.(.! + / :,,! .7,*% (+,#,#,%(+./"#(@+.7,;# !(.!;.!(,#.'/( $%*.#,5(,*

22 (+, ),(.(.!,#/ ( *,)/.( ! '"!(  /7 5/%@+.5+./ !( *./)"(,*  ! '$ ).!.!% (+, #*,# * (,* >& ) //,* :$  "),#.!(,!*,!(  ! 7 .5,# ./ 7,; 7 !* A"/(.. :7, /(+,@ (,#5"#/,)#0.*,*(+,#,.! !**,).5(,* .!(+,/.(,)7 !? <./(+,:,/(#"(,.##.; (.!#(+, )#.0 (,#,/)!*,!(/0,!(+,),(.(.!,#/+ 0,5+/,!!( (.7, ! .* 0.(.!)"#/" !5,(+,#*,#* (,* &  @+.5+#, */ /"!*,# C              

   

          

         

  



              

                    

  

     

       

D +,),(.(.!,#/+ *5+/,!(+,) (+@+.5+./!( )//.:7,  ( ./ !( 5')#,+,!/.:7, / ( +@ !* .! @+ ( ' !!,#%7 !*+ /:,,! 5=".#,*%$,((+,5!/(#"5(.!(+, /5+7@ /# ./,*(./ ! ((,')((*,7 $<:/(#"5(.!(+, .')7,',!( (.!  (+, #*,# * (,* 

%@+.5+./.!'$).!.!./*,)7# :7,

22 ! 0.,@  (+, #,/ .**./5"//.!%  * !( .!* !$ ',#.( .! (+, )#,/,!( @#.( ),(.(.! !* (+, #*,# * (,*

%*,/!( 77@.(+.!(+,/5), .!(,#,#,!5, !**5(#.!,A"*.5. 7#,0.,@ !* )) #,!(7$ 5 !!( :, / .* ( :, ! .77,; 7 !* #:.(# #$  55#*.!;7$% (+,#*,#* (,* >&!!,?"#, ./")+,7* +,5/(/ /7 5/./#*,#,*(:,#,7, /,*.!  0"#  (+, )#.0 (, #,/)!*,!(/  ( &  @+ + 0, :,,! *,)#.0,*  (+, #".(/  (+, #*,# * (,* >&% %., 7'/('#,(+ !#($$, #/ 55#*.!;7$%(+,@#.(),(.(.!./*./'.//,*  !" #$% &  E1 4F 6   +,(+,#/), 8.!;<#, /!,*,/< +,(+,##,)#( :7, ,/<