Narinder Paul v. Sukhbir And Others





  
 
 

 

 
 
Date of Decision: 04.03.2025






((!

'






 




3("
  " 
 !


 



#
!.!2
3!!
"4!
 #
3
#!.
"4!
 



!((! #
2!
5! !
"4!

("
*

#
3!2
6'%!
-!!%

("
* "4!

88888

 

#
!
$%&
&
(
!((!
!
 
("
!/!

!+!"
"!

!"




(!"


!%
(
 "
'"
0



# 










!"
#
"

"
$!%
& &'!
0(!


9 
&'!9
4"
+

!

!%
(
 "


!((!)!%!
+ +!
"%"





 
!
-
!


!
!
!


;

!%!

! *!"
!'
+
//

!
 
 
'((
+


(.( (
+!"
, ,!
-!+!
$+.
"

 
%


!"



'"/
 
0!
-!.

1"!
0(! 
!"
!"
!./
+

5 5'
$!"
+ 
("
*

0'.
+ 
"4/

% 
*
:

:3

$

!
!
/
("
!%

 %

((
"
!"
'.

/
%  
!/!

/
/


 !%!

'/



+

"

!

!
'


!"

!% %!

"+
!"
'!"
4! '
2'
 '"/
!
%('"
!'
 

/
/
:
+!
%4 4"
%

(!

!"

,!
:(!
0(!
+

+ +!
%"!
<!%"
!"
!"

&
% %!
+!
("


 
+'( 
>13
*

"!"

;
'"
0
 )77
1$
+ +!
/"

"
!

0!
$
0(!
!

!/!
("
*

?(



!%
( 
("
!((!"
 "

+ 
(


" /

!'% %

!")%(! ;

>%

(!"/


(!

&'!
!%"
+/ /
'

@

!%!
'!"
2'
"'

!
!

!"
//
"4/

%  
*
:3 $

("
*

A 1
'
*


(4"

"

!%!4
+!
%(! 

!%!

"

!"

"
%
+%B
A 3 = 
!./

"! 

(!"/
!"

4" 

"

"

!"
&'!
"% "

!% (
: !%!)!

!((!
"

(
!((!

!

/!

%(!




















 C!"
'


!(( (!
"
!
4
>13
+ +!
/"

"
!/!

("
*

'.


!%
(
+ +!
"%"

"


!"
&'!



/'"
!
!%!)!

!((!
!"


(4

4 44%


("
*

0'.


!"
&
 
(! 
!

(
!((!


!+"
!

!"
%(!

/!"

 
!((!)!%!
!
(
 "
!+


!
!"
' 


("
*

!
4% 
!/'"
!

(" 
*

+!
!D'"


> >13

/"

"
!/!
%


(
!
!"
!%
(
!
/

"%"

"

&

(! 

"% !


!((! C!"
'


 ("
* 7 1'!
$%(!

!
"
!

1'!
$%(!
+!

!
4
!
(!


! "
&'!
!"

!

%!"
!
(!


$'
!
!((!
!

!/
!"
!
' 

1'!
$%(!

 
!

(!
!
%(!   1
!4

!"
!"
'

'


(!
!"
('"
+
 "


!

&
4!
(


!+ +!"

("'"
!
'"
'









 

 




 +

 


 



 


 
 
!"
# $
 
% 
&
# $
!  
 

 

#'
( ( 
!  


$ $


)
# 

  







(

 


" 




 
 




%
& &
# $

' 
 
(*+ #+,



 
 
$

 


 
 
 










 
 -

 



'

 


'
" 

"$ 
(
 
 



 
 


 

.

/


 


 
 
"


0*
 


12 

 

3


"


'

' 
!$"
  





*+
 
 









 
(*+ #+ +, 


$ 
' 
 


 

 
"
' 
  



4


 
 

 

 


 






#'
( 
!  


$ 
 
)
#




 
(*+  #+ , 


 
$
 

 


 







 
 



"$ 
&

 




 




'


 


 
 
4
 
$
 

 


"



4
 


 






 


"
 
 
 

, 5




'




0*
12
 
4
"

  

"
'


0*




"

 


  

+
"

 

 


'
 

 


"

 '


0*


 
 
"

 
4 4
 


 
 




  
 



' 


  




 




 

*+
!$"
  

 + 2  

 



"
 
 
 


 
 


2

' 
 


#
6
7 
!  
&
 
" 
  


"  



"




 ' 
 


 


 
  



' 

 


 


 





'


 





0*





 

 
 

+ 




  "


    

!$"

 


'

 
,/
 
"


4 


 
 


##


"  


4
 ' 
8 


 
  





  



2 
 

 





2 

 

 





  



'


  
!


" 

 ' 





   



'



 
(*+ #+,




 

 


  



 
"







 
 


 


 





'


 



 
4

 
 
 

"
 
  



 '


 
 

 


+
  

 


 + 2 


 


$

'


 



  
"




'


" 
/



 
!$"
  

 



*+
" 



.


 

 

"





4
 


  
 '

 
 

"






*+






 

 





$
'

' 

 




' 

' 
 

' 

 
 

'





2 
"

4" 

*+
 
 





 

"
 " 

 

 
"



 









 
"



&

 
 

 






'


! 
" 
  





"

$ 

 '

 




"





' 
 

 

9




 

 

 
" 
 
"

 








  





 '




'


0*
 
  

2 





  



'


 


' 



  
 

,/
#
#











' 
8

  

  


 
'


 


2 

 
  
"

 
  



'

!

 


 
(*+ #+,




 ''





 

 



 -
"



'
 
  



 '


 
!
 



 


 :


('!


%('/"
!+ +!"
4!


C!"
&'

'!
!
 
2"

!%
(
 

!%!
!

!%!
!
!"

 !
!
("
* 
0'.
+!
"4/

"

"/
%  
!/
/!
*
:

:3 $

!

%

!" &
!"
&'!
!
"'
!

!((!"

4"
"
 

!"
!
!4"
!
!
+ !"
 '

&
!%!
*!"
!

!'
@


"("
!



E!'! 


;
!
!'


( % 
+

+!
!"/
!

"
$ $4
:(!
0(!
4/
+

5'
$!"
!
% 
! /
/! 
*
:3 $


!%
 %
,!
-!+!
$+.
!

!"
'.
!/!

!
%

!
'

'! "
2'
'"/
!
!' 


/
( (4

:+4
!
!
 !"/

>13
F<


4!
 !

+!
"

"/"


!%
"!
!
!'

 =
( % 
+

/! 
'%
 

"/
% 

%"


!
('

'
!

!
%


"4  
" 


!%


"( 
0%! 

!%!)!(( (!
*!"
!'
"'/

"( 
!
@ 
""

"

"

"4


% 

""

"

"
!

!
"(
!
'"
! 

"


"4

"/ /
% 

>'

("
*

0'.
+
!((!/

+
<
!
3@ 
!
""
 44%


!" :
"
 !


+

%  

.+
+

"4
 :
'
" "
!

+!

"4/

% 
!

%

!" &
!
!
0'.

!/
 !
!"
+!
!!"


( 


! "

'

! 
!

+!

"4

"/ /
% 
!

4!
%
1

"
((


 !+
!
% 
/

!
!!
!/!
 ("
*



!
!
(
!4 4
(""
+
!
!
"
 
!
'4
(

 
44% 


!"

;

1
#
"
$!%
& &'!

("/

!"

"!"

(

(("!


(!

 
!"

%
<
 
!
!!
+ +'
!4
4" 

'

!
!

= &
&'!
!(
"
 !

!%!
!"

(4
"
 

"4


>13

"' /

%
#4
(
( (
'"
0

7


$ $  $ 
+
+'"
'"!
4/!  
"/
!"

!! 

%(!/
("
*

0'.
+!

("'"
!
4"
&
14/!/
A
+ +
('%!


""
("
*

0 0'.
!

"4
+!
!

!"

 
+
+'"
!4

!

!
("  
44%


!"

 &
!'

("'
 

(

4"
+
 '"
!4
!

"
!
"

+ +
("
*

0'.
!

!"

!"

"
!4

!%! 
! 
"4"


!
'!
!

!"
' 

%

D'
!"!"

(

1
/


!4


 !
!

!%!
!
!"

"

!


(("!

( !
!
("
*

0'.
+ +!

"4


% 
44"


!"
& &
&'!
 !

!"

! 
4+"

4"
!"
'

'"
!

"

"


"4
%!
'( 4

$D' 
1
"

 %


!+!"
""

C!"
& &'!
&
(
!((!

 
"%"
/
"4"

"

!
% 
!"

%('/"
!+!"

'( "

 >'
1'!
$%(!

""

"'

' 
"'


#
3!2
6'%!
-!!% %
"4!
+
!
("

"

+
"!

! 
%

"!

(

 (


"

4+

 "
"!"

;
(!"


$'

> >A  

20.

Pending application(s), if any y, also stand disposed of.


 









!(! 

@
(!./)!"

@
(!

G)*
G)*